Cutting to the core? A reflection upon recent education policy debates within the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales

British Accounting Review

Volumn 38, Issue 1, 2006, Pages 31-61

  Paisey, Catriona ^a   Paisey, Nicholas J ^b  

^a GLASGOW CALEDONIAN UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b HERIOT WATT UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 33144473260     PISSN: 08908389     EISSN: 10958347     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bar.2005.08.002     Document Type: Article

References (134)

1. AAA, 1986. Future Accounting Education: Preparing for the Expanding Profession. The American Accounting Association Committee on the Future Structure, Content and Scope of Accounting Education, New York.
2. A. Abbott The System of Professions 1988 University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
3. ACCA, 2002. ACCA Professional Scheme Syllabus. ACCA website- http://www.accaglobal.com/prospectivestudents/ professional scheme.
4. Accountancy, 1993a. Chartered training: Limited and limiting? Accountancy, May, 14.
5. Accountancy, 1993b. Mixed feelings about core and options. Accountancy, December, 18.
6. Accountancy, 1994. EandT strategy gets go ahead in part. Accountancy, March, 19.
7. Accountancy, 1995. Member demands EGM. Accountancy, November, 11.
8. Accountancy, 1996a. Council opts for options. Accountancy, January, 13.
9. Accountancy, 1996b. E&T strategy to get full consultation. Accountancy, June, 18.
10. Accountancy, 1996c. E&T-what the members want. Accountancy, October, 14.
11. Accountancy, 1996d. Training revamp. Accountancy, November, 11.
12. Accountancy, 1997a. ICAEW to go back to members over E&T. Accountancy, March, 12.
13. Accountancy, 1997b. E&T forum to be introduced. Accountancy, June, 16.
14. Accountancy, 1997c. Council approves examinations. Accountancy, July, 21.
15. Accountancy, 1998a. Members still split over electives. Accountancy, September, 18.
16. Accountancy, 1998b. E&T consultation - the White Paper. Accountancy, December, 114.
17. Accountancy, 1999a. Cook takes on ICAEW again. Accountancy, April, 6.
18. Accountancy, 1999b. Government proposal boosts electives. Accountancy, June, 14.
19. Accountancy, 1999c. Impact of electives vote will hit in 2001. Accountancy, July, 6.
20. AECC, 1990. Position Statement Number One, Objectives of Education for Accountants. Accounting Education Change Commission, Tempe.
21. AICPA, 2003. AICPA Core Competency Framework for Entry into the Accounting Profession. AICPA, New York.
22. W.S. Albrecht R.J. Sack Accounting Education: Charting the Course through a Perilous Future Accounting Education Series vol. 16 2000 American Accounting Association Sarasota, FL
23. F. Anderson-Gough C. Grey K. Robson Making up accountants The Organizational and Professional Socialization of Trainee Chartered Accountants 1998 Ashgate/ICAEW Aldershot
24. F. Anderson-Gough C. Grey K. Robson Tests of time: Organizational time-reckoning and the making of accountants in two multi-national accounting firms Accounting, Organizations and Society 26 2001 99-122
25. F. Anderson-Gough C. Grey K. Robson Accounting professionals and the accounting profession: Linking conduct and context Accounting and Business Research 32 1 2002 41-56
26. F. Anderson-Gough C. Grey K. Robson 'Helping them to forget...': The organizational embedding of gender relations in public audit firms Accounting, Organizations and Society 30 2005 469-490
27. T. Awty Future view? Accountancy May 1999 117
28. D. Barnhizer The purposes of the university in the first quarter of the twenty-first century Seton Hall Law Review 22 4 1992 1124-1176
29. D. Barnhizer Freedom to do what? Institutional neutrality, academic freedom and academic responsibility Journal of Legal Education 43 3 1993 346-370
30. B. Barrett What should be conserved? The Law Teacher 20 1986 187-198
31. B.R. Bewley Reorganising medical education British Journal of Hospital Medicine 47 1992 40-43
32. P. Birks Examining the Law Syllabus. The Core 1992 Oxford University Press Oxford
33. P. Birks A decade of turmoil in legal education P. Birks Examining the Law Syllabus. Beyond the Core 1993 Oxford University Press Oxford 9-17
34. T. Boreham Pushing a degree of ethics and history Business Review Weekly November 1992 102
35. L.M. Brown If I were Dean Journal of Legal Education 35 1985 117-132
36. J.H. Bryant Educating tomorrow's doctors World Health Forum 14 3 1993 217-252
37. J.P. Byrne Academic freedom and political neutrality in law schools: An essay on structure and ideology in professional education Journal of Legal Education 43 3 1993 315-339
38. G. Capalletto The evolution of the new-age accountant Australian Financial Review January 1994 14
39. E.E. Clark Legal education and professional development Legal Education Review 4 1993 201-221
40. J. Cook CAs of the future-a member's view Accountancy January 1996 65-66
41. J. Cook A question of semantics Accountancy September 1998 6
42. J. Cook Déjà vu? Accountancy May 1999 116
43. R.C. Cramton Professional education in medicine and law: Structural differences, common failings, possible opportunities Cleveland State Law Review 34 1986 349-362
44. B. Currie Surveys of members' views Accountancy August 1996 8
45. S.W. Davis W.R. Sherman The accounting education change commission: A critical perspective Critical Perspectives on Accounting 7 1996 159-189
46. M. Dawe New education proposals: A recipe for decline Accountancy January 1997 73
47. J.F. Dillard T. Tinker Commodifying business and accounting education: the implications of accreditation Critical Perspectives on Accounting 7 1996 215-225
48. R. Dixon Accounting Degrees-Where Next? 1989 The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants London
49. R.S. Downie B. Charlton The Making of a Doctor. Medical Education in Theory and Practice 1992 Oxford University Press Oxford
50. Evans, E., 2003. Professionalisation and the problematic of education: The case of accounting education in Australia 1945 to 1988. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of New South Wales, Sydney.
51. S. Fearnley Examinations, qualifications and a hoary old chestnut Accountancy November 1996 116
52. L. Fisher Training crisis hits profession Accountancy August 2004 48-49
53. L. Frederikson P. Bull An appraisal of the current status of communication skills training in British medical schools Social Science Medicine 34 5 1992 515-522
54. S.B. Geddes Training ACAs Accountancy May 1993 7
55. Geddes, S.B., 1995. The Development of Accountancy Education, Training and Research in England: A Study of the Relationships between Professional Education and Training, Academic Education and Research, and Professional Practice in English Chartered Accountancy. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Manchester, Manchester.
56. P. Gee E&T strategy proposals-time for a rethink Accountancy October 1994 78
57. GMC, 1993. Tomorrow's Doctors. Recommendations on Undergraduate Medical Education. General Medical Council, London.
58. GMC Education Committee, 1988. Report of a Survey of Medical Education. Practices in UK Medical Schools, General Medical Council, London.
59. O.F. Graves I.T. Nelson J.R. Davis Accounting student characteristics: A survey of accounting majors at Federation of Schools of Accountancy (FSA) Schools Journal of Accounting Education 10 1992 25-37
60. R. Gray D. Collison J. French K. McPhail L. Stevenson The Professional Accountancy Bodies and the Provision of Education and Training in Relation to Environmental Issues 2001 The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland Edinburgh
61. J.E. Guthrie L.D. Parker A quarter of a century of performance auditing in the Australian federal public sector: A malleable masque Abacus 35 3 1999 302-332
62. R.M. Harden S. Sowden W.R. Dunn Some educational strategies in curriculum development: The SPICES model Medical Education 18 1984 284-297
63. J.W. Hardy L.A. Deppe Competency-based, integrated approach to accounting education Accounting Education 4 1 1995 55-75
64. Harrison, S., 1992. On balance. Charter 63 April, 48.
65. K.W. Hoskin R.H. Macve Accounting and the examination: A genealogy of disciplinary power Accounting, Organizations and Society 11 2 1986 105-136
66. E. Hughes Men and Their Work 1958 Free Press Glencoe, IL
67. E. Hughes Professions K.S. Lynn The Professions in America, Beacon, Boston 1967 1-14
68. N. Hughes The pain and profit of training institute students Accountancy May 1993 79
69. D. Hunt A better future for our qualification Accountancy October 1993 73
70. R.L.C. Hunter Some reflections on the relevance of educational thought for Scottish law teaching Juridical Review 1971 1-19
71. ICAEW, 1993. Chartered Accountant-The Future of our Qualification. Accountancy, October, 131.
72. ICAEW, 1994. Progress Report from the E&T Directorate. The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, Milton Keynes.
73. ICAEW, 1996a. Education and Training: Survey of Members. Accountancy, October, 122.
74. ICAEW, 1996b. Safeguarding the Future. Accountancy, November, 118.
75. ICAEW, 1997. Safeguarding the Future. Education and Training Strategy Revised Proposals for the Initial Qualification. Accountancy, April, 111.
76. ICAEW, 1998. Creating the Added-Value Business Advisor. The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, Milton Keynes.
77. ICANZ, 2002. Becoming a member. ICANZ website- http://www.icanz.co.nz/StaticContent/Member/CAIndex.cfm.
78. ICAS Education Committee, 1995. Education Review 1994-95. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland, Edinburgh.
79. IFAC, 2004. Continuing Professional Development: A Programme of Lifelong and Continuing Development of Professional Competence. International Federation of Accountants, New York.
80. A. Iredale A curricular merger at a medical college Higher Education Quarterly 45 2 1991 167-175
81. J. Irvine Justifying the imperative of change Accountancy September 1993 20
82. P.A. Jennett S.M. Edworthy T.W. Rosenal W.R. Maes N. Yee P.G. Jardine Preparing doctors for tomorrow: Information management as a theme in undergraduate medical education Medical Education 25 2 1991 135-139
83. B. Jolly H. Ho-Ping-Kong Independent learning: An exploration of student grand rounds Medical Education 25 4 1991 334-342
84. M.R. Kapoor Accounting students' attributes and performance: Some empirical evidence on general education Issues in Accounting Education 3 1 1988 108-119
85. N. Kelleway The case for limited change Accountancy June 1998 125
86. N. Kelleway We're still accountants! Accountancy January 2000 111
87. M.S.L. Larson The Rise of Professionalism: A Sociological Analysis 1977 University of California Press Berkeley, CA
88. T. Lee The professionalization of accountancy. A history of protecting the public interest in a self-interested way Accounting, Auditing and Accountability 8 4 1995 48-69
89. Lord Chancellor's Advisory Committee, 1994. Review of Legal Education, Consultation Paper, The Initial Stage. Lord Chancellor's Advisory Committee, London.
90. S. Lowry Medical Education 1993 BMJ Publishing Group London
91. R. MacCrate A fresh look at lawyers' education University of Richmond Law Review 27 1992 21-32
92. S. Masters Streamlining training approval Accountancy April 1994 138
93. S. Masters The new ACA: Protecting the future Accountancy March 2000 104
94. Mathews, R., 1990. Accounting in Higher Education-Report of the Accounting Discipline in Higher Education. AGPS, Canberra.
95. P. McAuslan The coming crisis in legal education Journal of Law and Society 16 3 1989 310-318
96. C. Menkel-Meadow The legacy of clinical education Cleveland State Law Review 29 1980 555-574
97. B.D. Merino B.S. Koch K.L. MacRitchie Historical analysis-a diagnostic tool for 'events' studies: The impact of the Securities Act of 1933 The Accounting Review 62 4 1987 748-762
98. P.D. Montagna Certified Public Accountancy 1974 Scholars Book Company Houston
99. G.T. Moore The effect of compulsory participation of medical students in problem-based learning Medical Education 25 2 1991 140-143
100. G.G. Mueller J.K. Simmons Change in accounting education Issues in Accounting Education 4 2 1989 247-251
101. P.V. Murray The evaluation of clinical legal education Studies in Educational Evaluation 13 1987 153-158
102. A.T. Nelson An update on the 150-hour educational requirement Journal of Accounting Education 9 1991 53-62
103. C. Paisey N.J. Paisey A Comparative Study of Undergraduate and Professional Education in the Professions of Accountancy, Medicine, Law and Architecture 2000 The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland Edinburgh
104. A. Paliwala Transforming legal education Computers and Education 19 1/2 1992 113-124
105. R.J. Patten D.Z. Williams There's trouble-right here in our accounting programs: The challenge to accounting educators Issues in Accounting Education 5 2 1990 175-179
106. POBA, 2005. Key Facts and Trends in the Accountancy Profession. Professional Oversight Board for Accountancy, London.
107. D.H. Porter The Emergence of the Past: A Theory of Historical Explanation 1981 University of Chicago Press Chicago
108. C. Poullaos Making the Australian Chartered Accountant 1994 Garland Publishing New York
109. J.E. Rebele An examination of accounting students' perceptions of the importance of communication skills in public accounting Issues in Accounting Education 1985 41-50
110. G. Ridgeway Just the job! Accountancy April 1999 119
111. R.W. Sanson-Fisher S. Redman R. Walsh K. Mitchell A.L.A. Reid J.J. Perkins Training medical practitioners in information transfer skills: the new challenge Medical Education 25 4 1991 322-333
112. E. Scribner A glimpse into an accounting department in the year 2000 Issues in Accounting Education 5 1 1990 143-145
113. J.E. Sexton The preconditions of professionalism Montana Law Review 52 1991 331-343
114. K. Shackleton The evolution of education policy within the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland K. Anyane-Ntow International Handbook of Accounting Education and Certification 1992 Pergamon Press Oxford 417-444
115. C. Stanley Training for the hierarchy? Reflections on the British experience of legal education The Law Teacher 22 1988 78-86
116. C. Swinson Skills for the future Accountancy July 1998 6
117. C. Timms The ties that bind Accountancy August 1993 77
118. A. Towle Critical Thinking. The Future of Undergraduate Medical Education 1991 King's Fund Centre London
119. A. Towle Community-based Teaching: Change in Medical Education 1992 King's Fund Centre London
120. T. Usherwood H. Joesbury D. Hannay Student-directed, problem-based learning in general practice and public health medicine Medical Education 25 5 1991 421-429
121. M. Waterfield S. Furber Computers in teaching medicine Computers and Education 19 1/2 1992 145-151
122. H.H. Wellington Challenges to legal education: The two cultures phenomenon Journal of Legal Education 37 1987 327-330
123. C.R. Whitehouse The teaching of communication skills in UK medical schools Medical Education 25 4 1991 311-318
124. H.L. Wilensky The professionalization of everyone? American Journal of Sociology 70 1964 137-157
125. K. Woodley Special meeting on education and training Accountancy January 1996 8
126. P. Wyman Options will enhance the qualification Accountancy January 1996 66
127. P. Wyman The value of the qualification-a personal view Accountancy June 1996 85
128. P. Wyman Safeguarding the future Accountancy November 1996 117
129. P. Wyman Beyond the qualification Accountancy May 1997 108
130. P. Wyman No training, no future Accountancy October 1997 72
131. P. Wyman No training, no future-part II Accountancy November 1997 68
132. P. Wyman New training, new future Accountancy May 1998 100
133. P. Wyman The future is training Accountancy December 1998 123
134. S.A. Zeff Does accounting belong in the university curriculum? Issues in Accounting Education 4 1 1989 203-210