A comparison of electricity and hydrogen production systems with CO 2 capture and storage. Part A: Review and selection of promising conversion and capture technologies

Progress in Energy and Combustion Science

Volumn 32, Issue 2, 2006, Pages 215-246

  Damen, Kay ^a   Troost, Martijn Van ^a   Faaij, André ^a   Turkenburg, Wim ^a  

^a UTRECHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

CO2 capture; Electricity; Hydrogen; Techno economic analysis; Technology overview

Indexed keywords

ABSORPTION; CARBON MONOXIDE; CHEMICAL ACTIVATION; COSTS; ENERGY CONSERVATION; FUEL CELLS; HYDROGEN; PRODUCTION CONTROL; TURBINES;

CO2 CAPTURE; HYDROGEN PRODUCTION; TECHNO-ECONOMIC ANALYSIS; TECHNOLOGY OVERVIEW;

ELECTRICITY;

EID: 32544433894     PISSN: 03601285     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.pecs.2005.11.005     Document Type: Review

References (112)

1. 2 capture, reuse, and storage technologies for mitigating global climate change: a white paper 1997 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Energy Laboratory Cambridge
2. IPCC Climate change 2001. Mitigation 2001 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
3. S. Pacala, and R. Socolow Stabilization wedges: solving the climate problem for the next 50 years with current technologies Science 305 2004 968 972
4. UNDP World energy assessment. Energy and the challenge of sustainability 2004 United Nations Development Programme New York
5. J. David, and H. Herzog The cost of carbon capture D. Williams B. Durie P. McMullan C. Paulson A. Smith Fifth international conference of greenhouse gas control technologies, Cairns, Australia 2001 CSIRO Collingwood 985 990
6. 2 capture, separation and R&D options B. Eliasson P. Riemer A. Wokaun International conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Interlaken, Switzerland 1999 Pergamon Amsterdam 119 124
7. Göttlicher G. The energetics of carbon dioxide capture in power plants. English translation of the original dissertation 'Energetik der Kohlendioxidruckhaltung in Kraftwerken', National Energy Technology Laboratory; 2004.
8. 2 removal systems for fossil-fuelled power plant processes Energy Convers Manage 38 1997 173 178
9. 2 capture and storage. In: Seventh international conference on greenhouse control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004. p. 1551-9.
10. E.L. Parsons, W.W. Shelton, and J.L. Lyons Advanced fossil power systems comparison study 2002 National Energy Technology Laboratory Morgantown
11. 2 capture project. Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam
12. G.H.G. IEA Decarbonisation of fossil fuels 1996 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
13. M.G. Klett, J.S. White, R.L. Schof, and T.L. Buchanan Hydrogen production facilities: plant performance and cost comparisons, final report, prepared for the national energy technology laboratory, US DOE 2002 Parsons Infrastructure and Technology Group, Inc Reading
14. National Research Council The hydrogen economy. Opportunities, costs, barriers, and R&D needs 2004 National Academic Press Washington
15. 2 and energy 2002 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
16. IMF World economic outlook 2004 International Monetary Fund Washington, DC
17. EPRI. TAG - technical assessment guide, electric supply, TR-102275, vol. 1, revision 7. Palo Alto: Electric Power Research Institute; 1993.
18. 2 removal 2000 Parsons Energy and Chemicals Group Inc. Reading, USA
19. DOE Market-based advanced coal power systems 1999 US Department of Energy Washington, DC
20. 2 emissions at power stations 2000 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
21. 2 2004 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
22. 2 separation and capture technologies 1999 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Energy Laboratory Cambridge
23. 2 from flue gasses: commercial trends. In: Canadian society of chemical engineers annual meeting, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan; 1999.
24. T. Mimura, K. Matsumoto, M. Iijima, and S. Mitsuoka Development and application of flue gas carbon dioxide recovery technology D. Williams B. Durie P. McMullan C. Paulson A. Smith Fifth international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Cairns, Australia 2001 CSIRO Collingwood 138 142
25. 2 capture from flue gas. Seventh international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004.
26. Falk-Petersen Gas treatment using membrane gas/liquid contactors D. Williams B. Durie P. McMullan C. Paulson A. Smith Fifth international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Cairns, Australia 2001 CSIRO Collingwood 115 120
27. 2 removal technology from flue gas of thermal power plant by physical adsorption method P. Riemer B. Eliasson A. Wokaun Fourth international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Interlaken, Switzerland 1998 Pergamon Amsterdam 95 100
28. P.H.M. Feron Membranes for carbon dioxide recovery from power plants J. Paul C.M. Pradier Carbon dioxide chemistry: environmental issues 1994 The Royal Society of Chemistry Cambridge, UK 236 249
29. Hendriks CA. Carbon dioxide removal from coal-fired power plants. PhD thesis. Utrecht: Department of Science, Technology and Society, Utrecht University; 1994.
30. 2 capture, transport & storage 2004 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
31. 2 capture from power plant 2005 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
32. 2 -fired power plant 2002 Chalmers University of Technology Sweden
33. 2 power plant 2002 Chalmers University of Technology Göteborg, Sweden
34. 2 capture and storage 2004 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
35. Matta RK, Mercer GD, Tuthill RS. Power systems for the 21st century - 'H' gas turbine combined-cycles. GE Power Systems, Schenectady, NY, Report No. GER-3935B; 2000.
36. A. Cohn, and J. Scheibel Current gas turbine developments and future projects. Advanced turbine systems annual program review meeting 1997 EPRI Morgantown
37. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 91 97
38. 2 abatement: gas turbines 2000 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
39. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 37 46
40. Chiesa P, Lozza G, Mazzocchi L. Using hydrogen as a gas turbine fuel. In: Proceedings of ASME turbo expo, Atlanta; 2003.
41. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 227 256
42. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 47 97
43. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 273 290
44. 2 capture Energy 29 2004 1269 1278
45. 2 retention. First international conference on industrial gas turbine technologies, Brussels, Belgium; 2003.
46. Anderson R, Brandt H, Doyle S, Pronske K, Viteri F. Power generation with 100% carbon capture and sequestration. Second annual conference on carbon sequestration, Alexandria, VA; 2003.
47. Marin O, Bourhis Y, Perrin N, Di Zanno P, Viteri F, Anderson R. High efficiency, zero emission power generation based on high-temperature steam cycle. 28th international technical conference on coal utilization & fuel systems, Clearwater, USA; 2003.
48. 2 capture options for natural gas-fired combined cycle plants Adv Environ Res 7 2003 901 911
49. Sundkvist SG, Klang A, Sjodin M, Wilhelmsen K, Asen K, Tintinelli A, et al. AZEP gas turbine combined cycle power plants - thermal optimisation and LCA analysis. Seventh international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004.
50. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 625 645
51. 2 capture using chemical looping combustion in a natural gas fired power cycle. ASME Paper No. GT-2002-30129 ASME J Eng Gas Turbines Power 126 2002 316 321
52. 2 capture Adv Environ Res 7 2 2003 335 345
53. 2 mitigation in advanced power cycles - chemical looping combustion and steam-based gasification. PhD thesis, Stockholm.
54. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 499 511
55. 2 capture. Seventh international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004.
56. Viteri F, Pronske K. Personal communication on water cycle (CES) performance. Clean energy systems.
57. Sundkvist SG, Griffin T, Thorshaug NP. AZEP - development of an integrated air separation membrane - gas turbine. Second nordic minisymposium on carbon dioxide capture and storage, Göteborg; 2001.
58. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 537 559
59. Möller BF, Torisson T, Assadi M, Sundkvist SG, Sjödin M, Klang A, et al., AZEP gas turbine combined cycle power plants - thermo-economic analysis. 18th international conference on efficiency, cost, optimization, simulation and environmental impact of energy systems, Trondheim; 2005.
60. 2 capture and storage. Energy technology analysis 2004 International Energy Agency Paris
61. 2 emission abatement from fossil fuel power plants by exhaust gas treatment. 2000 International joint power generation conference, Miami Beach, Florida; 2000.
62. 2 capture and sequestration. In: Fifth greenhouse gas technologies conference (GHGT5), Cairns, Australia. CSIRO: Collingwood; 2000.
63. G.H.G. IEA Precombustion decarbonisation 1998 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
64. 2 capture via partial oxidation of natural gas 2000 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
65. Martinez-Frias J, Aceves SM, Smith JR, Brandt H. Thermodynamic analysis of zero atmospheric emissions power plant. Second annual conference on carbon sequestration, Alexandria, VA; 2003.
66. Viteri F. Electricity cost comparison of CES versus gas turbine power plants. Internal document prepared by clean energy systems, 2004.
67. 2 separation system. First national conference on carbon sequestration, Washington; 2000. p. 23.
68. 2 injection into gas fields 2001 Shell Technology EP Rijswijk
69. Gas turbine world. Gas turbine world handbook, 1998-99; 1999.
70. Ploumen PJ. Personal communication on chemical looping combustion. KEMA.
71. NETL-DOE. Worldwide gasification database. Pittsburgh: National Energy Technology Laboratory, United States Department of Energy.
72. C. Hendriks, W. Graus, and F. van Bergen Power and heat production: plant developments and grid losses 2004 Ecofys Utrecht
73. 2 sequestration. Fourth international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Interlaken, Switzerland; 1999.
74. 2 capture for sequestration. In: Gasification technologies conference, San Francisco; 2003.
75. 2 capture 2003 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Cheltenham
76. 2 from coal with commercially ready technology. Part B. Economic analysis Int J Hydrogen Energy 30 2005 769 784
77. 2 capture project Capture and separation of carbon dioxide from combustion sources vol. 1 2005 Elsevier Amsterdam 257 272
78. 2 control in IGCC systems: techno-economic feasibility study Energy Convers Manage 38 1997 159 162
79. 2 removal 2002 Parsons Energy and Chemicals Group Inc. Reading, USA
80. 2 from coal with commercially ready technology. Part A. Performance and emissions Int J Hydrogen Energy 30 7 2005 747 767
81. Armstrong PA, Bennet DL, Foster EP, Stein VE. Ceramic membrane development for oxygen supply to gasification applications. Gasification technologies conference, San Francisco; 2002.
82. 2 capturing solid oxide fuel cell J Power Sources 106 1-2 2002 377 380
83. D.R. Brown, and R. Jones An overview of stationary fuel cell technology 1999 Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Richland (WA), USA
84. EG&G Technical Services Inc. Fuel cell handbook. 6th ed. 2002.
85. S. Campanari Carbon dioxide separation from high temperature fuel cell power plants J Power Sources 112 2002 273 289
86. G.H.G. IEA Fuel cells with carbon dioxide removal 1998 International Energy Agency Greenhouse gas R&D technologies Cheltenham
87. 2 from gas turbine exhaust gases Energy 29 2004 1279 1284
88. 2 capture. Second nordic minisymposium on carbon dioxide capture and storage, Göteborg; 2001.
89. Haines MR. Producing electrical energy from natural gas using a solid oxide fuel cell. Patent WO 99/10945; 1999.
90. 2 capture with SOFC Energy 29 2004 1249 1257
91. Nawaz M, Ruby J. Zero emission coal alliance project. Conceptual design and economics. 26th international technical conference on coal utilization & fuel systems, Clearwater, USA; 2001.
92. 2 sequestration from solid oxide fuel cells: technical options and costs. Seventh international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004.
93. 2 capture. Seventh international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004.
94. 2 capture in SOFC-GT systems 2003 Energy research Centre of the Netherlands Petten
95. M. Appl Modern production technology - ammonia, methanol, hydrogen, carbon monoxide - a review 1996 CRU publishing Ltd London, England
96. D. Simbeck, and E. Chang Hydrogen supply: cost estimate for hydrogen pathways - scoping analysis 2002 National Renewable Energy Laboratory Golden
97. J.R. Rostrup-Nielsen, and T. Rostrup-Nielsen Large-scale hydrogen production Cattech 6 4 2002 150 159
98. 2 capture. Seventh international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004.
99. 2 capture using membrane reactors; 2003.
100. Sjardin M, Damen K, Faaij APC. Techno-economic prospects of membrane reactors in a future hydrogen-driven transportation sector. Submitted for publication.
101. J. Ogden Review of small stationary reformers for hydrogen production 2001 Centre for Energy and Environmental Studies (CEES) Princeton
102. 2 capture J. Gale Y. Kaya Sixth international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Kyoto, Japan 2003 Pergamon Amsterdam 141 147
103. C.N. Hamelinck, and A.P.C. Faaij Future prospects for production of methanol and hydrogen from biomass 2001 Department of Science, Technology and Society, Copernicus Institute for Sustainable Development and Innovation, Utrecht University Utrecht
104. A.W.N. van Dril, and H.E. Elzenga Reference projection 2005-2020 2005 Energy Research Centre of the Netherlands (ECN), National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM) Petten
105. Hufton J, Waldron W, Weigel S, Rao M, Nataraj S, Sircar S. Sorption enhanced reaction process (SERP) for the production of hydrogen. 2000 Hydrogen programme, Golden, USA; 2000.
106. Rojey A, Minkkinen A, Lebas E. Combined production of hydrogen, clean power and quality fuels. Seventh international conference on greenhouse gas control technologies, Vancouver, Canada; 2004.
107. L. Bromberg, D.R. Cohn, A. Rabinovich, and N. Alexeev Plasma catalytic reforming of methane Int J Hydrogen Energy 24 1999 1131 1137
108. 2 Abatement by the use of carbon-rejection processes 2001 International Energy Agency Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme Gloucestershire, UK
109. S.Y. Lin, Y. Suzuki, H. Hatano, and M. Harada Developing an innovative method, HyPr-RING, to produce hydrogen from hydrocarbons Energy Convers Manage 43 9-12 2002 1283 1290
110. ECN. Fuel prices. Energy in numbers. http://www.energie.nl. Petten: Energy Research Centre of the Netherlands; 2005 [in Dutch].
111. Williams RH. Decarbonized fossil energy carriers and their energy technological competitors. Prepared for IPCC workshop on carbon capture and storage, Regina, Canada; 2003.
112. 2 emissions Energy Policy 32 2004 367 382