Deception, catholicism, and hope: Understanding problems in the communication of unfavorable prognoses in traditionally-catholic countries

American Journal of Bioethics

Volumn 6, Issue 1, 2006, Pages

  Toscani, Franco ^a  

^a KING'S COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Catholicism; Communication to terminal patients; Deception of prognosis; Hope; Medical deontology; Truth telling

Indexed keywords

HUMAN; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; ITALY; PHYSICIAN ATTITUDE; PROGNOSIS; RECUMBENCY; RELIGION; REVIEW; TERMINALLY ILL PATIENT;

CATHOLICISM; COMMUNICATION; DECEPTION; HUMANS; ITALY; PHYSICIAN'S ROLE; PROGNOSIS; RELIGION AND MEDICINE; TERMINALLY ILL; TRUTH DISCLOSURE;

EID: 31544461554     PISSN: 15265161     EISSN: 15360075     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/15265160500394994     Document Type: Review

References (105)

1. American College of Physicians. 1992. Manual of clinical ethics. Annals of Internal Medicine 117: 947-960.
2. Annunziata, M. A., R. Talamini, S. Tumolo, C. Rossi, and S. Monfardini. 1996. Physicians and death: Comments and behaviour of 605 doctors in the north-east of Italy. Supportive Care in Cancer 4(5): 334-340.
3. Antoninus of Florence. 1841. Summa theologica moralis, partibus IV distincta, Book 2, Pt 10, Chap. 1 (reprint), Florence, Italy: Mamachi & Remedelli.
4. Ashley, B. M., and K. D. O'Rourke. 1997. Health care ethics: A theological analysis (4th ed). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
5. Augustine of Hippo (St.). 1952a. Contra mendacium. (English trans. J. Jaffee and R. J. Deferrari). In The fathers of the Church: A new translation, vol. 16. New York: Fathers of the Church.
6. _ 1952b. De mendacio (English trans.) S. Muldowney and R. J. Deferrari. In The fathers of the Church: A new translation, vol. 16, New York: Fathers of the Church.
7. _ 1955. Enchiridion ad Laurentium (English trans. A. C. Outler), In Library of Christian Classics, vol. 7. Westminster, UK: John Knox.
8. Bentham, J. 1948. Division of offences. An introduction to the principles of morals and legislation (reprinted ed.). New York: Hafner Library of Classics.
9. Bible
10. Blackhall, L. J., S. T. Murphy, G. Frank, V. Michel, and S. Azen. 1995. Ethnicity and attitudes toward patient autonomy. Journal of American Medical Association 274(10): 820-825.
11. Bok, S. 1978. Lying: Moral choice in public and private life. Hassocks, UK: Harvester Press.
12. Calvin, J. 1863-1896. Petit Traicte Monstrant Que C'Est Doit Faire Un Homme Fidele Cognoissant La Verite Quand Il Est En tre Les Papistes. (Small treatise on what a believer knowing the truth must do when he is among Papists) (ed. F. M. Higman) In Opera. Brunswick: J. Baum, E. Cunitz, and E. Reuss Publ.
13. _ 1970. Three French treatises. (ed. F. M. Higman) London: Athlone Press.
14. Carrick, P. 1995. Medical ethics in antiquity. London, UK: Kluwer Academic.
15. Catechism of the Catholic Church. 1993. Città del Vaticano: Libreria Editrice Vaticana (an English translation, which includes the amendments promulgated by Pope John Paul II on 8 September 1997, available at http://www.christusrex.org)
16. Catholic encyclopedia.
17. n.d-a. Fathers of the Church (available at http://newadvent.org/cathen/ 06001a.htm)
18. n.d-b. Mental reservation (available at http://newadvent.org/cathen/ 10195b.htm)
19. Cuyas, M. 1987. L'accanimento terapeutico e l'eutanasia. (Overtreatment and euthanasia). Dolentium Hominum 6(2): 3.
20. Dalla-Vorgia, P., K. Katsouyanni, T. N. Garanis, G. Touloumi, P. Drogari, and A. Koutselinis. 1992. Attitudes of a Mediterranean population to the truth-telling issue. Journal of Medical Ethics 18(2): 67-74.
21. De'Liguori, A. (St.). 1926-1928. Theologia moralis, Tract. De VIII decalogi praeceptio. C.I, Art. 2. In The complete works of Saint Alphonsus de Liguori, doctor of the Church, Vol. 3 (Centenary edn. 2nd. ed. Brooklyn, St. Louis & Toronto: Redemptorist Fathers.
22. Demmer, K. 1983. Si deve dire la verità al malato? Il sacerdote cattolico. (The patient must be told the truth? The Catholic priest). Federazione Medica 1: 8.
23. Detienne, M. 1967. Les maîtres de vérité dans la Grèce archaïque. (The masters of truth in archaic Greece). Paris: Librairie François Maspero.
24. Dorszynski, J. 1948. Catholic teaching about the morality of falsehood. Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press.
25. Eco, U. 1993. The search for the perfect language: The making of Europe. Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell.
26. Encyclopaedia Judaica. 1971. Vol 15: "Truth." Jerusalem: Kefer Publishing House Ltd.
27. Engelhardt, H. T. Jr. 1986. The foundation of bioethics. New York: Oxford University Press.
28. Erasmus, D. R. 1961-1963. Responsio ad Albertum Pium. (Answer to Albert the Pius). In Opera omnia: Emendatiora et auctiora, ad optimas editiones praecipuae quas ipse Erasmus postremo curavit summa fide exacts, doctorumque virorum notis illustrata/recognovit Joannes Clericus. Vol. 9; cols. 1194-1996. Anastatic reproduction of the Lugduni Batavorum (Leiden 1703-1706) edition. Hildesheim: Olm.).
29. Estapé, J., H., Palombo, E. Hernàndez, M. Daniels, T. Estap é, J. J. Grau, N. Vinolas, and J. M. Mane. 1992. Cancer diagnosis disclosure in a Spanish hospital. Annals of Oncology 3: 451-454.
30. Feingold, A. F. 1994. Three Jewish physicians of the Renaissance. The marriage of science, and ethics. New York: American Friends of Beth Hatefutsoth.
31. F.N.O.M.C.e.O. (Federazione Nazionale degli Ordini dei Medici Chirurghi e Odontoiatri). 1989. Nuovo codice di deontologia medica. Approvato dal Consiglio Nazionale il 15 luglio 1989. (New code of medical ethics. Approved by the Board of Italian Medical Association on 15 July 1989) Pubblicazione a cura degli Ordini Provinciali dei Medici.
32. F.N.O.M.C.e.O. (Federazione Nazionale degli Ordini dei Medici Chirurghi e Odontoiatri).1998. Codice di deontologia medica. Approvato dal Comitato Centrale il 3 ottobre 1998. (Medical ethics Code. Approved by the Board of Italian Medical Association on 3 October 1998) Pubblicazione a cura degli Ordini Provinciali dei Medici.
33. Field, D. 1996. Awareness and the modern role of dying. Mortality 1: 255-265.
34. Field, D., and G. Copp, 1999. Communication and awareness about dying in the 1990s. Palliative Medicine 13: 459-468.
35. Fiori, A. 1993. Problemi attuali del consenso informato. (Current problem on informed consent). Medicina e Morale 6: 1123-1138.
36. Frank, G., L. J. Blackhall, V. Michel, S. T. Murphy, S. P. Azen, and K. Park. 1998. A discourse of relationships in bioethics: patient autonomy and end-of-life decision making among elderly Korean Americans. Medical Anthropology Quarterly 12(4): 403-423.
37. Friedenwald, H. 1917. The ethics and practice of medicine from the Jewish point of view. John Hopkins Hospital Bulletin 318(Aug.): 256-261.
38. G.I.V.I.O. Italy (Interdisciplinary Group for Cancer Care Evaluation). 1986. What doctors tell patients with breast cancer about diagnosis and treatment: Findings from a study in general hospitals. British Journal of Cancer 54: 319-326.
39. Goldie, L. 1982. The ethics of telling the patient. Journal of Medical Ethics 8: 128-133.
40. Gordon, D. R. 1990. Embodying illness, embodying cancer. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 14(2): 275-297.
41. Gordon, D. R. 1994. The ethics of ambiguity and concealment around cancer: Interpretations through a local Italian world. In Interpretative phenomenology: Embodiment, caring and ethics in health and illness, ed. P. Benner, 279-322. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
42. Gordon, D. R., and E. Paci, 1997. Disclosure practices and cultural narratives: Understanding concealment and silence around cancer in Tuscany, Italy. Social Science and Medicine 10: 1433-1452.
43. Grassi, L., T. Giraldi, G. E. Messina, K. Magnani, E. Valle, and G. Cartei. 2000. Physicians' attitudes to and problems with truth-telling to cancer patients. Supportive Care in Cancer 8: 40-45.
44. Grotius, H. 1925. De jure belli et pacis. 1. III, c. I, 10-21 (English trans. F. W. Kelsey). In On the law of war and peace, Bk 3, Chap 1. Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill Co.).
45. Gum, A., and C. R. Snyder. 2002. Coping with terminal illness: the role of hopeful thinking Journal of Palliative Medicine 5(6): 883-894.
46. Häring, B. 1980. Liberi e fedeli in Cristo. (Free and faithful in Christ). Vol.I and II. Roma: Edizioni Paoline.
47. Henderson, L. 1935. Physician and patient as a social system. New England Journal of Medicine 212(5): 819-823.
48. Herth, K. 1990. Fostering hope in terminally-ill people. Journal of Advanced Nursing 18: 1250-1259.
49. Hofmann, J. C., N. S. Wenger, R. B. Davis, J. Teno, A. F. Connors, Jr., N. Desbiens, J. Lynn, and R. S. Phillips. 1997. Patient preferences for communication with physicians about end-of-life decisions. SUPPORT investigators (Study to Understand Prognoses and Preference for Outcomes and Risks of Treatment). Annals of Internal Medicine 127(1): 1-12.
50. Holland, J. C. 1989. Now we tell - but how well? Journal of Clinical Oncology 7: 557-559.
51. Holland, J. C., N. Geary, A. Marchini, and S. Tross. 1987. An international survey of physician attitudes and practice in regard to revealing the diagnosis of cancer. Cancer Investigations 5(2): 151-154.
52. Holmes, O. W. 1981. The young practitioner. In The writings of Oliver Wendell Holmes 13 vols. Medical essays 1842-1882, Boston: Riverside Editions, Hughton, Mifflin & Co. vol. 9: 388-398.
53. Huang, X., P. Butow, B. Meiser, and D. Goldstein. 1999. Attitudes and information needs of Chinese migrant cancer patients and their relatives. Australia and New Zeeland Journal of Medicine 29(2): 207-213.
54. Ignatius (of Anthiochia). n.d. Ad Ephesios. 7, PG 5:738 (available at the Christian Classics Ethereal Library at Calvin College: http://www.ccel.org/ fathers2/ANF01/anf01-16.htm#P1093_206499)
55. Jonsen, A. R., and S. Toulmin. 1988. The abuse of casuistry. A history of moral reasoning. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
56. Kant, E. 1949. On a supposed right to lie from benevolent motives. In Emanuel Kant's "The critique of practical reason" and other writings in moral philosophy, ed. and trans. L. White Beck, 346-350. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
57. Kegley, C. W. 1970. The philosophy and theology of Anders Nygren. Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press.
58. Klein, E. 1987. A comprehensive etymological dictionary of the Hebrew language for readers of English. New York: Macmillan.
59. Konishi, E., and A. J. Davis. 1999. Japanese nurses' perceptions about disclosure of information at the patients' end of life. Nursing Health Sciences 1(3): 179-187.
60. Laros, M. 1951. Seid Klug wie die Schlangen und einfältig wie die Tauben (Mt. 10, 16): Zwei Gewissensfragen in den Noten dieser Zeit. (Behold, I am sending you like sheep in the midst of wolves; so be shrewd as serpents and simple as doves (Mt. 16, 16): Two questions of presents time) Frankfurt a. M.: Carolus-Druckerei.
61. Ledrus, M. 1943. De mendacio. (On lying) Periodica de Re Morali 32: 5-58 & 123-171.
62. Ledrus, M. 1944. De mendacio. (On lying) Periodica de Re Morali 33: 5-60.
63. Lin, H. R., and S. M. Bauer-Wu. 2003. Psycho-spiritual well-being in patients with advanced cancer: An integrative review of the literature. Journal of Advanced Nursing 44(1): 69-80.
64. Lind, S. E., M. J. Del Vecchio-Good, S. Seidel, T. Csordas, and B. J. Good. 1985. Telling the diagnosis of cancer. Journal of Clinical Oncology 7: 583-589.
65. Link, H. G. 1989. "Verità." (Truth) In Dizionario dei concetti biblici del Nuovo Testamento, ed. L. Coenen, E. Beyreuther, and H. Bietenhard, 1966. Bologna: Centro Editoriale Dehoniano.
66. Lombard, P. 1880. Patrologia latina: Sententiarum libri quattuor, Vol 192. Paris: JP Migne.
67. Luther, M. 1880-1891. Briefwechsel Landgraf Philipp's des Grossmüthigen von Hessen mit Bucer. (Correspondence with Landgraf Philipp's des Grossmüthigen von Hessen with Bucer) Hrsg. und erläutert von Max Lenz. Veranlasst und unterstützt durch die K. Archiv-Verwaltung. Vol. 1. Leipzig: S. Hirzel.
68. Marañon, G. 1947. Vocacion y etica y otros ensayos. III Ed. revisada y aumentada. (Calling and Ethics. III ed. reviwed and augmented) Madrid: Espasa-Calpe.
69. Maritan, J. 1947. La personne et le bien commun. [the person and the common good.] Paris: Desclèe de Bouver. (English trans. J. J. Fitgerald). New York: Charles Schribner's Sons.
70. Martineau, J. 1898. Types of ethical theory (3rd ed., rev.). Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
71. Martini, C. M. 1987. Quale verità al malato: Chi, come, perché. (Which truth for the sick? Who, how and why) Anime e Corpi 24: 683.
72. McCormick, R. A. 1984. Health and medicine in the Catholic tradition: Tradition in transition. New York: Crossroad.
73. McFadden, C. J. 1967. Medical ethics (6th ed.). Philadelphia, PA: F. A. Davis.
74. Meyer, B. C. 1969. Truth and the physician. Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 45: 59-71.
75. Mitchell, J. L. 1998. Cross-cultural issues in the disclosure of cancer. Cancer Practice 6(3): 153-160.
76. Mosconi, P., B. E. Meyerowitz, C. M. Liberati, and A. Liberati. 1991. Disclosure of breast cancer diagnosis: Patient and physician report. Annals of Oncology 2: 273-280.
77. Mounier, E. 1949. Le personnalisme. (The personalism) Paris: PUF.
78. Munthe, A. 2002. The story of San Michele. New York: Carroll and Graf.
79. Mystakidou, K., C. Liossi, L. Vlachos, and J. Papardimitriou. 1996. Disclosure of diagnostic information to cancer patients in Greece. Palliative Medicine 10: 195-200.
80. Novack, P. H., R. Plummer, R. L. Smith, et al. 1979. Changes in physicians' attitudes toward telling the cancer patient. Journal of the American Medical Association 242: 897-900.
81. P.C.C.U. (Pontifical Council Cor Unum). 1981. Question of ethics regarding the fatally ill and the dying. Città del Vaticano: Vatican Press.
82. P.C.P.O.S. (Pontificio Consiglio della Pastorale per gli Operatori Sanitari). 1995. Carta degli operatori sanitari. (Charter of health professionals) Città del Vaticano: Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
83. Pascal, B. 1941. Pensèes: Provincial letter 9. (English trans. W. F. Trotter). In Provincial letters. New York: Modern Library.
84. Pegoraro, R. 1991. Comunicazione della verità al paziente. Riflessioni etico-teologiche: I. (Telling the patient the truth: Ethical and theological thoughts) Medicina e Morale 6: 959-986.
85. Pegoraro, R. 1992. Comunicazione della verità al paziente. Riflessioni etico-teologiche II. (Telling the patient the truth: Ethical and theological thoughts) Medicina e Morale 3: 425-446.
86. Pius XII. 1945. Allocuzione all'Unione Italiana Medico-biologica "San Luca," (Allocution to the Italian Medical and Biological Society "St. Luke") 12 Nov. 1944. In Atti e discorsi di S.S. Pio XII, Vol 6. Gennaio-dicembre: 151-152. Torino: Pia Società San Paolo.
87. Plass, E. M. (ed.) 1959. What Luther says: An anthology. St. Louis, MO: Concordia Press.
88. Pronzato, P., G. Bertelli, P. Losardo, and M. Landucci. 1994. What do advanced cancer patients know of their disease? A report from Italy. Supportive Care in Cancer 2: 242-244.
89. Pufendorf, S. 1934. De jure naturae et gentium libri octo. 1, IV. Oxford, UK: The Clarendom Press and London: H. Milford.
90. Rodrigue-Marin, J., S. Lòpez-Roig, and M. A. Pastor, 1996. Doctors' decision-making on giving information to cancer patients. Psychological Heath 11: 839-844.
91. Seale, C. F. 1991. Communication and awareness about death: A study of a random sample of dying people. Social Science & Medicine 32: 943-942.
92. Seale, C. F., J. M. Addington-Hall, and M. McCarthy, 1997. Awareness of dying: Prevalence, cause and consequences. Social Science & Medicine 45: 477-484.
93. Sidgwick, H. 1907. Methods of ethics, 7th rev. ed. London, UK: MacMillan.
94. Speck, P. 1998. Spiritual issues in palliative care. In Oxford textbook of palliative medicine (2nd edn.) ed. D. Doyle, G. W. C. Hanks, and N. McDonald, 805-814. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
95. Stiefel, F., and H. J. Senn. 1992. Cancer diagnosis disclosure in a Spanish hospital: How do they discuss treatment options? Annals of Oncology 2(3): 422.
96. Surbone, A. 1992. Letter from Italy. Journal of the American Medical Association 268: 1661-1662.
97. Surbone, A. 1993. The information to the cancer patient: Psychosocial and spiritual implications. Supportive Care in Cancer 1: 89-91.
98. Surbone, A., and M. Zwitter, 1997. Learning from the world. The editors' perspective. Annals of New York Academy of Science 809: 1-6.
99. Thomas Aquinas (St.). 1948. Summa theologiae (English trans. The Fathers of the English Dominican province). New York: Benzinger Brothers Inc.
100. Toscani, F., L. Cantoni, G. Di Mola, et al. 1991. Death and dying: Perceptions and attitudes in Italy. Palliative Medicine 5: 334-343.
101. Twycross, R., and I., Litcher, 1998. The terminal phase. In Oxford texbook of palliative medicine (2nd edn.) ed. D. Doyle, G. W. C. Hanks, and N. McDonald, 805-814. Oxford, UK, New York, and Tokyo: Oxford University Press.
102. Veatch, R. M. 1978. Truth-telling: attitudes. In Encyclopedia of bioethics, ed. W. T. Reich, 1677-1682. New York: The Free Press.
103. Vermeersch, A. 1920. De mendacio. (On lying) Gregorianum 1: 11-40, 427-474.
104. Vidal, M. 1991. Moral de la persona y bioetica teologica. (Person's ethics and theological bioethics) Madrid: Editorial PS.
105. Wesley, J. n.d. Sermons on several occasions. Sermon 90: Behold an Israelite indeed, in whom is no guile (available at the Christian Classics Ethereal Library at Calvin College: http://www.ccel.org/ccel/wesley/sermons.vi. xxxvii.html#vi.xxxvii-p0.2)