Methodology of studies evaluating death certificate accuracy were flawed

Journal of Clinical Epidemiology

Volumn 59, Issue 2, 2006, Pages 125-131

  Johansson, Lars Age ^a   Westerling, Ragnar ^b   Rosenberg, Harry M ^c  

^a CENTRE FOR EPIDEMIOLOGY   (Sweden)

^b UPPSALA UNIVERSITY   (Sweden)

^c CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION   (United States)

Author keywords

Cause of death; Death certificates; Medical records; Mortality statistics; Quality control; Reproducibility

Indexed keywords

ACCURACY; CAUSE OF DEATH; DEATH CERTIFICATE; HUMAN; METHODOLOGY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REPRODUCIBILITY; REVIEW; STATISTICAL ANALYSIS; WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION;

CAUSE OF DEATH; DEATH CERTIFICATES; EPIDEMIOLOGIC STUDIES; HUMANS; MEDICAL RECORDS; QUALITY CONTROL;

EID: 30944456308     PISSN: 08954356     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2005.05.006     Document Type: Review

References (59)

1. World Health Organization International statistical classification of diseases and related health problems. 10th Rev., Vol. 2 1993 WHO Geneva
2. G. Maudsley, and E.M.I. Williams "Inaccuracy" in death certification - where are we now? J Public Health Med 18 1996 59 66
3. I.M. Moriyama Problems in measurement of accuracy of cause-of-death statistics Am J Public Health 79 1989 1349 1350
4. R. Saracci Problems with the use of autopsy results as a yardstick in medical audit and epidemiology Qual Assur Health Care 5 1993 339 344
5. M.C. Kelson, and M. Farebrother The effect of inaccuracies in death certification and coding practices in the European Economic Community (EEC) on international cancer mortality statistics Int J Epidemiol 16 1987 411 414
6. L.A. Johansson, H. Bille, and H. Ahonen Cause-of-death statistics. In Health statistics in the Nordic countries 1997 Nordisk Med Komité 56 1999 175 208
7. E. Jougla, L. Papoz, B. Balkau Eurodiab Subarea C Study Group Death certificate coding practices related to diabetes in European countries - the "EURODIAB Subarea C" Study Int J Epidemiol 21 1992 343 351
8. B. Jansson, L.A. Johansson, and M. Rosen National adaptations of the ICD rules for classification - a problem in the evaluation of cause-of-death trends J Clin Epidemiol 50 1997 367 375
9. I. Muhlhauser, P.T. Sawicki, M. Blank, H. Overmann, B. Richter, and M. Berger Reliability of causes of death in persons with Type I diabetes Diabetologia 45 11 2002 1490 1497
10. L. Nyström, L.G. Larsson, and L.E. Rutqvist Determination of cause of death among breast cancer cases in the Swedish randomized mammography screening trials. A comparison between official statistics and validation by an endpoint committee Acta Oncol 34 2 1995 145 152
11. K.E. Sidenius, E.P. Munch, F.F. Madsen, P. Lange, K. Viskum, and U. Soes-Petersen Reliability of recorded deaths from asthma in Denmark during a 1-year period 1994-1995 (in Danish) Ugeskr Laeger 163 2001 6131 6133
12. K.E. Sidenius, E.P. Munch, F. Madsen, P. Lange, K. Viskum, and U. Soes-Petersen Accuracy of recorded asthma deaths in Denmark in a 12-month period in 1994/95 Respir Med 94 2000 373 377
13. I.M. Jorgensen, S. Bulow, V.B. Jensen, T.L. Dahm, P. Prahl, and K. Juel Asthma mortality in Danish children and young adults, 1973-1994: epidemiology and validity of death certificates Eur Respir J 15 2000 844 848
14. K.L. May Death certificates in asthma and COPD patients (survey of statistical data in Warsaw) Monaldi Arch Chest Dis 57 2002 253 257
15. H. Ebeling, A. Vuokko, and I. Moilanen Traumatic injuries of children and adolescents - are they associated with psychiatric contacts? Nord J Psychiatry 57 2003 345 350
16. F. Ederer, M.S. Geisser, S.J. Mongin, T.R. Church, and J.S. Mandel Colorectal cancer deaths as determined by expert committee and from death certificate: a comparison. The Minnesota Study J Clin Epidemiol 52 1999 447 452
17. J.D. Sington, and B.J. Cottrell Analysis of the sensitivity of death certificates in 440 hospital deaths: a comparison with necropsy findings J Clin Pathol 55 2002 499 502
18. K.F. Kock, V. Vestergaard, M. Hardt-Madsen, and E. Garne Declining autopsy rates in stillbirths and infant deaths: results from Funen County, Denmark, 1986-96 J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med 13 2003 403 407
19. The falling mortality from coronary heart disease: a clinicopathological perspective. The United Kingdom Heart Attack Study (UKHAS) Collaborative Group Heart 80 1998 121 126
20. R.A. Lahti, and A. Penttila The validity of death certificates: routine validation of death certification and its effects on mortality statistics Forensic Sci Int 115 2001 15 32
21. D.W. Reid, V.J. Hendrick, T.C. Aitken, W.T. Berrill, S.C. Stenton, and D.J. Hendrick Age-dependent inaccuracy of asthma death certification in Northern England, 1991-1992 Eur Respir J 12 1998 1079 1083
22. S.A. Coady, P.D. Sorlie, L.S. Cooper, A.R. Folsom, W.D. Rosamond, and D.E. Conwill Validation of death certificate diagnosis for coronary heart disease: the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) Study J Clin Epidemiol 54 2001 40 50
23. R.M. Hoffman, S.N. Stone, W.C. Hunt, C.R. Key, and F.D. Gilliland Effects of misattribution in assigning cause of death on prostate cancer mortality rates Ann Epidemiol 13 2003 450 454
24. P.C. Albertsen, S. Walters, and J.A. Hanley A comparison of cause of death determination in men previously diagnosed with prostate cancer who died in 1985 or 1995 J Urol 163 2000 519 523
25. H. Englert, J. Small-McMahon, K. Davis, H. O'Connor, P. Chambers, and P. Brooks Systemic sclerosis prevalence and mortality in Sydney 1974-88 Aust N Z J Med 29 1999 42 50
26. N.S. Crowcroft, N. Andrews, C. Rooney, M. Brisson, and E. Miller Deaths from pertussis are underestimated in England Arch Dis Child 86 2002 336 338
27. B.I. Lindahl Selection of the principal cause of death. Studies on the basis of mortality statistics for rheumatoid arthritis. Thesis 1985 Department of Social Medicine, Karolinska Institute, Huddinge University Hospital Huddinge, Sweden
28. World Health Organization Manual of the international statistical classification of diseases, injuries, and causes of death. Sixth revision of the international lists of diseases and causes of death 1948 World Health Organization Geneva
29. N.F. Hodgson, T.C. Stewart, and M.J. Girotti Autopsies and death certification in deaths due to blunt trauma: what are we missing? Can J Surg 43 2000 130 136
30. D.R. Murdoch, M.P. Love, S.D. Robb, T.A. McDonagh, A.P. Davie, I. Ford, S. Capewell, C.E. Morrison, and J.J. McMurray Importance of heart failure as a cause of death. Changing contribution to overall mortality and coronary heart disease mortality in Scotland 1979-1992 Eur Heart J 19 1998 1829 1835
31. M.E. Rimsza, R.A. Schackner, K.A. Bowen, and W. Marshall Can child deaths be prevented? The Arizona Child Fatality Review Program experience Pediatrics 110 2002 e11
32. H. Tunstall-Pedoe Perspectives on trends in mortality and case fatality from coronary heart attacks: the need for a better definition of acute myocardial infarction Heart 80 1998 112 113
33. A. Donabedian Advantages and limitations of explicit criteria for assessing the quality of health care Milbank Mem Fund Q Health Soc 59 1981 99 106
34. L. Wibell, L. Nystrom, J. Ostman, H. Arnqvist, G. Blohme, F. Lithner, B. Littorin, and G. Sundkvist Increased mortality in diabetes during the first 10 years of the disease. A population-based study (DISS) in Swedish adults 15-34 years old at diagnosis J Intern Med 249 2001 263 270
35. K. Jones, W.T. Berrill, C.L. Bromly, and D.J. Hendrick A confidential enquiry into certified asthma deaths in the North of England, 1994-96: influence of co-morbidity and diagnostic inaccuracy Respir Med 93 12 1999 923 927
36. J. Moorman, and M.E. Edginton Cause of death of patients on treatment for tuberculosis: a study in a rural South African hospital Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 3 9 1999 786 790
37. R.M. Ladeira, and M.D. Guimaraes Analysis of agreement between coding of underlying cause of death by traffic accidents (in Portuguese) Rev Saude Publica 32 1998 133 137
38. J. Arudo, J.E. Gimnig, F.O. ter Kuile, S.P. Kachur, L. Slutsker, M.S. Kolczak, W.A. Hawley, A.S. Orago, B.L. Nahlen, and P.A. Phillips-Howard Comparison of government statistics and demographic surveillance to monitor mortality in children less than five years old in rural western Kenya Am J Trop Med Hyg 68 Suppl 4 2003 30 37
39. C.S. Moy, D.M. Albert, M. Diener-West, L.D. McCaffrey, R.E. Scully, and J.K. Willson Cause-specific mortality coding. Methods in the collaborative ocular melanoma study. COMS report no. 14 Control Clin Trials 22 2001 248 262
40. T.H. Lu, H.Y. Chang, C.M. Hwu, H.C. Chiu, W.H. Yin, and W.H. Pan Comparison of official coders versus physician panel in assignment of underlying cause of death J Formos Med Assoc 100 2001 365 369
41. A.E. Smith Sehdev, and G.M. Hutchins Problems with proper completion and accuracy of the cause-of-death statement Arch Intern Med 161 2001 277 284
42. R. al-Mahroos Validity of death certificates for coding coronary heart disease as the cause of death in Bahrain East Mediterr Health J 6 2000 661 669
43. T.Y. Goraya, S.J. Jacobsen, P.G. Belau, S.A. Weston, T.E. Kottke, and V.L. Roger Validation of death certificate diagnosis of out-of-hospital coronary heart disease deaths in Olmsted County, Minnesota Mayo Clin Proc 75 2000 681 687
44. B. Ermenc Discrepancies between clinical and post-mortem diagnoses of causes of death Med Sci Law 39 1999 287 292
45. M. D'Amico, E. Agozzino, A. Biagino, A. Simonetti, and P. Marinelli Ill-defined and multiple causes on death certificates - a study of misclassification in mortality statistics Eur J Epidemiol 15 1999 141 148
46. D.M. Lloyd-Jones, D.O. Martin, M.G. Larson, and D. Levy Accuracy of death certificates for coding coronary heart disease as the cause of death Ann Intern Med 129 1998 1020 1026
47. H.G. Peach, and D.J. Brumley Death certification by doctors in non-metropolitan Victoria Aust Fam Physician 27 1998 178 182
48. J.M. Leppala, J. Virtamo, and O.P. Heinonen Validation of stroke diagnosis in the National Hospital Discharge Register and the Register of Causes of Death in Finland Eur J Epidemiol 15 1999 155 160
49. M.L. Browne, E.L. Lewis-Michl, and A.D. Stark Investigation and reporting practices for drownings: implications for injury prevention research in New York state Am J Forensic Med Pathol 23 2002 398 401
50. I. Saito, H. Ozawa, H. Aono, T. Ikebe, T. Yamashita, and Y. Makino Trends in fatal coronary heart disease among people aged 25-74 years in Oita City, Japan, from 1987-1998 J Clin Epidemiol 55 2002 469 476
51. G.B. Sharp, J.B. Cologne, T. Fukuhara, H. Itakura, M. Yamamoto, and S. Tokuoka Temporal changes in liver cancer incidence rates in Japan: accounting for death certificate inaccuracies and improving diagnostic techniques Int J Cancer 93 2001 751 758
52. A. Majeed, P. Lehmann, L. Kirby, R. Knight, and M. Coleman Extent of misclassification of death from Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in England 1979-96: retrospective examination of clinical records BMJ 320 2000 145 147
53. N. Sarraf-Zadegan, M. Boshtam, H. Malekafzali, N. Bashardoost, F.A. Sayed-Tabatabaei, M. Rafiei, A. Khalili, S. Mostafavi, M. Khami, and R. Hassanvand Secular trends in cardiovascular mortality in Iran, with special reference to Isfahan Acta Cardiol 54 1999 327 333
54. N. Behrendt, S. Heegaard, and G.G. Fornitz The hospital autopsy. An important factor in hospital quality assurance (in Danish) Ugeskr Laeger 161 1999 5543 5547
55. R. Cordeiro, E.R. Penaloza, C.F. Cardoso, D.B. Cortez, E. Kakinami, J.J. Souza, M.T. Souza, R.A. Fernandes, R.F. Guercia, and T. Adoni Validity of information on occupation and principal cause on death certificates in Botucatu, Sao Paulo (in Portuguese) Cad Saude Publica 15 1999 719 728
56. A.A. Siqueira, E.M. Rio, A.C. Tanaka, N. Schor, A.T. Alvarenga, and L.C. Almeida Female mortality in the Municipality of Sao Paulo: quality of medical death certificates (in Portuguese) Rev Saude Publica 33 1999 499 504
57. A. Laplanche Quality of death certificates in cases of cancer death in France (in French) Bull Cancer 85 1998 967 969
58. C. Iribarren, R.S. Crow, P.J. Hannan, D.R. Jacobs Jr., and R.V. Luepker Validation of death certificate diagnosis of out-of-hospital sudden cardiac death Am J Cardiol 82 1998 50 53
59. D.K. Pandey, D.R. Labarthe, D.C. Goff, W. Chan, and M.Z. Nichaman Community-wide coronary heart disease mortality in Mexican Americans equals or exceeds that in non-Hispanic whites: the Corpus Christi Heart Project Am J Med 110 2001 81 87