Towards a philosophy of approximations in the 'exact' sciences

Hyle

Volumn 11, Issue 2, 2005, Pages 101-126

  Ostrovsky, Valentin N ^a  

^a ST PETERSBURG STATE UNIVERSITY   (Russian Federation)

Author keywords

Approximations in quantum chemistry; Born Oppenheimer approximation; Complementarity; Orbitals; Periodic Table; Shape of molecules

Indexed keywords

EID: 29244482583     PISSN: 14335158     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (39)

1. Belyaev, V.B.; Motovilov, A.K.; Miller, M.B.; Sermyagin, A.V.; Kuznetzov, I.V.; Sobolev, Yu.G.; Smolnikov, A.A.; Klimenko, A.A.; Osetrov, S.B. & Vasiliev, S. L.: 2001, 'Search for Nuclear Reactions in Water Molecules', Physics Letters B, 522, 222-6.
2. Bohr, N.: 1999, Collected Works, Vol. 10 (Complementarity beyond Physics), ed. D. Favrholdt, Elsevier, Amsterdam.
3. Brion, C.E.; Cooper, G.; Zheng, Y.; Litvinyuk, L.V. & McCarthy, I.E.: 2001, 'Imaging of Orbital Electron Densities by Electron Momentum Spectrsocopy - a Chemical Interpretation of the Binary (e, 2e) Reaction', Chemical Physics, 70, 13-30.
4. Chung, K.T.: 2004, 'Resonances in Atomic Photoionization', Radiation Physics and Chemistry 70, 83-94.
5. Del Re, G.: 2000, 'Models and Analogies in Science', Hyle - International Journal for Philosophy of Chemistry, 6, 5-15.
6. Del Re, G.: 2003, 'Reaction Mechanisms and Chemical Explanation', Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 988, 133-140.
7. Feng, R.; Sakai, Y.; Zheng, Y.; Cooper, G. & Brion, C.E.: 2000, Orbital Imaging for the Valence Shell of Sulphur Dioxide: Comparison of EMS Measurements with Near Hartree-Fock Limit and Density Functional Theory', Chemical Physics, 260, 29-43.
8. Feynman, R.P. & Leighton R.B.: 1964, Feynman Lectures on Physics. Electromagnetism and Matter, Addison-Wesley, London.
9. Feynman R.P.: 1992, The Character of Physical Laws, Penguin, New York.
10. Fock, V.: 1936, 'Printzipial'noe Znachenie Priblizhennykh Metodov v Teoreticheskoi Fizike [Principle Significance of Approximate Methods in Theoretical Physics]', Uspekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk, 16, 1070-83.
11. Fock, V.: 1974, 'Printzipial'naya Rol' Priblizhennykh Metodov v Fizike' [Principle Role of Approximate Methods in Physics], in: Filosofskie voprosy fiziki [Philosophical problems in physics], Leningrad State University Publishing House, Leningrad, pp. 3-7.
12. Friedrich, B.: 2004, 'Hasn't it? A Commentary on Eric Scerri's paper "Has Quantum Mechanics Explained the Periodic Table?", now Published under the Title "Just How Ab Initio is Ab Initio Quantum Chemistry', Foundations of Chemistry, 6, 117-132.
13. Garcia-Ripoll, JJ. & Perez-Garcia, V.M.: 2001, 'Vortex Bending and Tightly Packed Vortex Lattices in Bose-Einstein Condensates', Physical Review A, 64, 053611(1-7).
14. Garcia-Sucre, M. & Bunge, M.: 1981, 'Geometry of a Quantum System', International journal of Quantum Chemistry, 19, 83-93.
15. Hatani, J.; Levesque, J.L.; Zeidler, D.; Niikura, H.; Pepin, H.; Kieffer, J.C.; Corkum, P.B. & Villeneuve, D.M.: 2004, 'Tomographic Imaging of Molecular Orbitals, Nature, 432, 867-71.
16. Hecht, E.: 2002, Optics, Addison-Wesley, London.
17. Jasper, A.W.; Kendrick, B.K.; Mead, C.A. & Truhlar, D.G.: 2004, 'Non-Born-Oppenheimer Chemistry: Potential Surfaces, Couplings, and Dynamics', in: Modern Trends in Chemical Reaction Dynamics: Experiment and Theory, Part I, World Scientific, Singapore, pp. 329-391.
18. Litvinyuk, I.V.; Zheng, Y. & Brion, C.E.: 2000, 'Valence Shell Orbital Imaging in Adamantane by Electron Momentum Spectroscopy and Quantum Chemical Calculations', Chemical Physics, 253, 41-50.
19. Migdal, A.B.: 1989, Qualitative Methods in Quantum Theory, Addison-Wesley, New York (1st edition, 1977).
20. Ogilvie, J.F.: 1990, 'The Origin of Chemical Bonds - There are no Such Things as Orbitals', Journal of Chemical Education, 67, 280-289.
21. Ostrovsky, V.N.: 2001, 'What and how Physics Contributes to Understanding the Periodic Law?', Foundations of Chemistry, 3, 145-182.
22. Ostrovsky, V.N.: 2003a, 'Physical Explanation of the Periodic Table', Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 988, 182-192.
23. Ostrovsky, V.N.: 2003b, 'Modern Quantum Look at the Periodic Table of Elements', in: E.J. Brändas & E.S. Kryachko (eds.), Fundamental World of Quantum Chemistry. A Tribute to the Memory of Per-Olov Löwdin, Vol. 2, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 631-74.
24. Ostrovsky, V.N.: 2004, 'The Periodic Table and Quantum Physics', in: D.H. Rouvray & R.B. King (eds.), The Periodic Table: Into the 21st Century, Research Studies Press, Baldock, UK, pp. 331-70.
25. Pechenkin, A.A.: 1980, 'Priblizhennye Metody v Teorii Fizicheskogo Znaniya (Metodologicheskie Problemy)' [Approximate Methods in the Theory of Physical Knowledge (Methodological Problems)], in: Fizicheskaya teoriya [Physical Theory], ed. Nauka, Moscow, pp. 136-153.
26. Prudov, N.V. & Ostrovsky, V.N.: 1998, 'Vibrorotational Structure in Asymmetric Doubly-Excited States', Physical Review Letters, 81, 285-8.
27. Pyykko, P.: 1988, 'Relativistic Effects in Structural Chemistry', Chemical Reviews, 88, 563-94.
28. Ramsey, J.L.: 1997, 'Molecular Shape, Reduction, Explanation and Approximate Concepts', Synthese, 111, 233-51.
29. Scerri, E.R.: 2000, 'Have Orbitals Really been Observed?', Journal of Chemical Education, 77, 1492-1494 &
30. Scerri, E.R.: Journal of Chemical Education, 79, 310.
31. Scerri, E.R.: 2001, 'The Recently Claimed Observation of Atomic Orbitals and Some Related Philosophical Issues', Philosophy of Sciences, 68, (Proceedings), S76-88.
32. Scerri, E.R.: 2003, 'Löwdin's Remarks on the Aufbau Principle and a Philosopher's View of Ab Initio Quantum Chemistry', in: E.J. Brändas & E.S. Kryachko (eds.), Fundamental World of Quantum Chemistry. A Tribute to the Memory of Per-Olov Löwdin, Vol. 2, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 675-94.
33. Wang, S.G. & Schwarz, W.H.E.: 2000a, 'On Closed Shell Interactions, Polar Covalence, d Shell Holes and Direct Images of Orbitals: the Case of Cuprite', Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 39, 1757-61.
34. Wang, S.G. & Schwarz, W.H.E.: 2000b, 'Final comments on the discussions of "the case of cuprite"', Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 39, 3794-6.
35. Wigner, E.P.: 1995, 'The unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in natural sciences', in: E.P. Wigner, Philosophical Reflections and Syntheses, Springer, Berlin.
36. Zakhar'ev, B.N., 1996, Uroki Kvantovoi Intuitzii [Lessons of Quantum Intuition], Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna.
37. Zheng, Y.; Rolke, J.; Cooper, G. & Brion C.E.: 2002, 'Valence Orbital Momentum Distributions for Dimethyl Sulfide: EMS Measurements and Comparison with Near-Hartree-Fock Limit and Density Functional Theory Calculations', Journal of Electron Spectroscopy, 123, 377-88.
38. 2O', Nature, 401, 49-52.
39. Zuo, J.M.; O'Keeffe, M.; Kim, M. & Spence, J.C.H.: 2000, 'On Closed Shell Interactions, Polar Covalence, d Shell Holes and Direct Images of Orbitals: the Case of Cuprite. Response to the Essay by S.G. Wang and W.H.E. Schwarz', Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 39, 3791-4.