Threats of judicial counterreform in Putin's Russia

Demokratizatsiya

Volumn 13, Issue 3, 2005, Pages 325-345

  Solomon Jr , Peter H ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

Author keywords

Constitutional Court; Counterreform; Judicial Qualification Collegia

Indexed keywords

CONSTITUTIONAL REFORM; LEGAL SYSTEM; POLITICAL CONFLICT; REFORM PROCESS;

EURASIA; RUSSIAN FEDERATION;

EID: 28144458144     PISSN: 10746846     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3200/demo.13.3.325-346     Document Type: Article

References (78)

1. Alimov, Rashid, and Charles Digges. 2004. FSB "vents" its rage on Igor Sutyagin with a guilty verdict. Nuclear Russia on Bellona Web, April 6.
2. Babichenko, Denis. 2004. S 'delami' - na vyezd! Itogi.ru, February 17, http://www.itogi.ru/.
3. Barakhova, Alla. 2004. Suda na nikh net: Sovet Federatsii vstraivaet sudy v prezidentskuiu vertikal. Kommersant, September 30.
4. Baranova, Valentina. 2005. Sudia Olga Kudeshkina: Deviatnosto protsentov nashikh sudei prodazhny ili upravliaemy. Komsomolskaia pravda, February 7.
5. Burger, Ethan. 2004. Corruption in the Russian arbitrazh courts: Can we expect real progress in the near term? International Lawyer 38:1, 15-34.
6. Dadaeva, Diana. 2005. Dmitrii Kozak vzialsia za staroe (On khochet prodolzhit sudebnuiu reformu). Kommersant, January 28.
7. Diamond, Larry. 2002. Thinking about hybrid regimes. Journal of Democracy 13, no. 2 (April): 21-35.
8. Ekho Moskvy. 2003. Interviu s Grigorim Pasko, December 29.
9. Eniutina, Galina. 2001. Korruptsiia v sudebnykh organakh. St. Petersburg: Tsentr po problemam organizovannoi prestupnosti i korruptsii.
10. Ezhenedelnyi zhurnal. 2004. Prisiazhnye obviniteli: Sud prisiazhnykh v Rossii mozhet byt i mekhanizmom pravosudii i karatelnym orudiem v rukakh gosudarstva, April 12.
11. Filippov, Stepan. 2004. Vertikal Femidy: Vlast vinit pravosudie v svoikh sobstvennykh oshibakh. Politicheskii zhurnal 44, no. 47 (November 29).
12. Gelman, Vladimir. 2004. The unrule of law in the making: The politics of informal institutional building in Russia. Europe-Asia Studies 56, no. 7 (November): 1021-58.
13. Grigorev, Dmitry. 2003. Vidy na Femidy. Versti, October 14.
14. Guarnieri, Carlo, and Patrizia Pederzoli. 2002. The power of judges: A comparative study of courts and democracy. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
15. Ilichev, Georgy. 2004a. Zhdem vas, choby uznat vashe videnie. Izvestiya, October 10.
16. Ilichev, Georgy. 2004b. Valerii Zorkin: 'Mzdoimstvo v sudakh odnim iz samykh moshnykh korruptsionnykh rynkov. Izvestiya, October 25.
17. Ilichev, Georgy. 2004c. Sudi otvergaium obvineniia v korruptsii i otstaivaiut svoiu nezavisimost. Izvestiya, October 29.
18. Johnson, Karen, ed. 2000. Explaining the Nikitin acquittal. East European Constitutional Review 9, no. 4 (Fall): 91-108.
19. Katanian, Konstantin. 2004. S'ezd sudei pozadi, no voprosy ostaiutsia. Politicheskii zhurnal 46, no. 4 (December 14).
20. Kolesov, Yuri. 2004a. Medvezhia usluga Putinu. Vremia Novostei, October 6.
21. Kolesov, Yuri. 2004b. Ot sudi i slushy: kollegi prosiat Valeria Zorkina otvetit za svoi slova. Vremia novostei, October 28.
22. Kolesov, Yuri. 2005a. Za otkrovennost: Verkhovnyi sud otkazalsia vosstanavlivat na rabote sproptivogo sudiu. Vremia novostei, January 20.
23. Kolesov, Yuri. 2005b. Tolkovanie po Grefu. Vysshii arbitrazhnyi sud 'blokiruet' chinovnikov. Vremia novostei, March 30.
24. Kommersant. 2004. Sudei na mylo? September 30.
25. Kommersant. 2005. Federalov otpraviat v arkhiv. February 14.
26. Kornia, Anastasia. 2004a. Sudi zhdut prigovora. Nezavisimaia gazeta, November 29.
27. Kornia, Anastasia. 2004b. Led tronulsia, no kuda? Nezavisimaia gazeta, December 8.
28. Kornia, Anastasia, and Romanicheva. 2004. Sudi vozmushcheny initisiativoi Sovfeda: Proekt priamogo podchineniia prezidentu 'tretei vlasti' vstreil reshitelnoe soprotivlenie sluzhiteli Femidy. Nezavisimaia gazeta, October 1.
29. Korolkov, Igor. 2004. Za chto v Rossii srok daiut. Moskovskie novosti, December 12.
30. Kozlova, Natalia. 2005. Sporim na dengi pri sivdeteliakh: Presedatel Vysshego arbitrazhnogo suda Anton Ivanov predlagaet dlia profilaktiki korruptsii prevrati sud bolee otkrytuiu sistemu. Rossiiskaia gazeta, February 17.
31. Krasnov, Mikhail. 2004. The rule of law. In Between dictatorship and democracy: Russian post-communist political reform, ed. Michael McFaul et al. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
32. Kremlin. ru. 2004. Vstrecha s predsedateliami ... sudov, October 20, http://www.kremlin.ru/.
33. Kudeshkina, Olga. 2005. Est li v Rossii nezavisimyi sud? Informatsionno-analiticheskoe agentsvo MiK, http://www.iamik.ru/.
34. Levitsky, Steven, and Lucan Way. 2002. The rise of competitive authoritarianism. Journal of Democracy 131, no. 2 (April): 51-65.
35. Medvedeva, Aleksandra. 2005. Nikolai Kropachev: Iurist dolzhen umet otstaivat svoi prava. Fontanka.ru, February 25, http://www.fontanka.ru/.
36. Minklukha, Yuri. 2004. Ne chitai! Strana.ru, April 6, http:// www.strana.ru/.
37. Nemytina, M. V. 1999. Sud v Rossii vtoraia polovina XIX-nachalo XX vv. Saratov, Russia: Saratovskii iuridicheskii institut MVD Rossii.
38. Nikitinsky, Leonid. 2004. Femidu s zaviazannymi glazami ubezut v Piter? Russkii kurer, Februrary 2
39. Nikitinsky, Leonid. 2005. Pokushenie na prisiazkhnykh. Novaia gazeta, February 28.
40. Postanovlenie. 2004. O sostoianii pravosudiia v Rossiiskoi Federatsii i perspektivakh ego sovershenstvovaniia. Postanovlenie VI Vserossiiskogo s'zeda sudei. http://www.supcourt.ru/ojc/congress/VI/2004.
41. Prezident. 2004. Obrashcherie Prezideuta Rossii Vladimira. Putina, September 4, http://prezident.kremlin.ru/text/appears/2004/09/ 76320.shtml.
42. Proekt federalnyi zakon. 2004a. O vnesenii izmenenii v Federalnyi zakon 'Ob organakh sudeiskogo soobshchestva v Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Proekt N 93807-4, vnesen Sovetom Federatsii FS RF.
43. Proekt federalnyi zakon. 2004b. O vnesenii izmennii v statiu 11 Federalnogo zakona 'Ob organakh sudeiskogo soobshchestva v Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Proekt N 96856-4, vnesen Gosudarstvennoi Dumy V. V. Pokhmelkinym.
44. Regnum.ru. 2005. Resheniia sudov 4 federalnykh okrugov RF budut publikovat v seti internet, February 25, http://www.regnum.ru/.
45. Satarov, Georgy. 2003. Prorzhvevshee pravosudie. Otechestvennye zapiski 2 (11): 87-98. http://www.strana-oz.ru/.
46. Sharlet, Robert. 2003. Constitutional law and politics in Russia: Surviving the first decade. Democratizatsiya 11 no. 1 (Winter 2003): 122-28.
47. Shesterina, Elena. 2003. Pridetsia brat liudei iz glubinki. Izvestiia.ru, October 10.
48. Solomon, Peter H., Jr., 2002. Putin's judicial reform: Making judges accountable as well as independent. East European Constitutional Review 11, nos. 1-2 (Winter-Spring): 117-24.
49. Solomon, Peter H., Jr., 2003a. The new justices of the peace in the Russian Federation: A cornerstone of judicial reform. Demokratizatsiya 11 no. 3 (Summer 2003): 363-80.
50. Solomon, Peter H., Jr., 2003b. Prodvizhenie i obogashchenie sudebnoi reformy v Rossii: Vzgliad so storony. Rossiiskaia iustitsiia 6.
51. Solomon, Peter H., Jr., 2004a. Courts in Russia: Independence, power, and accountability. In Judicial Integrity, ed. Andras Sajo, 225-53. Leiden, Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff.
52. Solomon, Peter H., Jr., 2004b. The Sutyagin case doesn't indict all Russian justice. Globe and Mail, April 14.
53. Solomon, Peter H., Jr., 2005a. Vladimir Putin's quest for a strong state. Munk Centre Monitor 2.
54. Solomon, Peter H., Jr., 2005b. The criminal procedure code of 2001: Will it make Russian justice more fair? In Ruling Russia: Crime, law and justice in a changing society, ed. William Pridemore. London: Roman and Littlefield.
55. Solomon, Peter H., Jr. and Todd S. Foglesong. 2000a. Courts and transition in Russia. Boulder, CO: Westview.
56. Solomon, Peter H., Jr. 2000b. The procuracy and the courts. East European Constitutional Review 9, no. 4 (Fall 2000): 105-8.
57. Soviet Sudei. 2005. O merakh po realizatsii Kontseptsii informatsionnoi politiki sudebnoi sistemy. Postanovlenie Sovet Sudei Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 29 aprelia 2005 g., no.140. http://www.supcourt.ru/ print_page.php?id=2566/.
58. Stanovaia, Tatiana. 2005. Rossiiskaia sudebnaia sistema: Tretia vetv kremlevskoi vertikali. Politkom.ru, January 6, http://www.politkom.ru/.
59. Sterkin, Filipp. 2004. Prezident RF: Tam, gde vershitsia pravosudie, narusheniia prosto nedopustimy. Strana.ru, November 30, http:// www.strana.ru/.
60. Strana.ru. 2004. Putin provel vstrechyu s predsedateliami sudov. November 29, http://www.strana.ru/.
61. Strana.ru. 2005. Anton Ivanov poobeshchal povysit doverie obshchesstva k sudebnoi sisteme, January 26, http://www.strana.ru/.
62. Tarnovski, Theodore. 1981. The aborted counter-reform: Muraviev commission and the judicial statues of 1864. Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas, no. 29:161-84.
63. Tkachuk, Sergei. 2004. Viktor Pokhmelkin. Novye izvestiya, October 12.
64. Torocheshnikova, Marina. 2003. Peredacha. Perevod vysshikh sudebnykh organov iz Moskvy v Peterburg. Sudebnaia reforma v Rossii provalilas? Radio Svoboda, November 3.
65. Trochev, Alexei. 2002. Implementing Russian constitutional court decisions. East European Constitutional Review 11, nos. 1-2 (Winter-Spring): 95-103.
66. Trochev, Alexei, 2005a. Judicial selection in Russia: Towards accountability and centraliztion. In Appointing judges in an age of judicial power: Critical perspectives from around the world, ed. Peter H. Russsell and Kate Malleson. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press.
67. Trochev, Alexei, 2005b. "The zigzags of judicial power: The constitutional court in Russian politics, 1990-2003" (PhD diss., University of Toronto).
68. Vasileva, Vera. 2004. Sud 'skoryi, prozrachnyi, transparantnyi. Novosti iugry, December 11.
69. Verkhovnyi Sud. 2004. Polozhenie po sozdaniiu i soprovozhdeniiu ofitsialnykh Internetsaitov sudov obshchei iurisdiktsii Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Utverzhdeno Postanovleniem Verkhovnogo Suda RF ot 24 noiabria 2004. http://www.supcourt.ru/new_detale.php?id=2597/.
70. Vilensky, B. V. 1969. Sudebnaia reforma i kontrreforma v Rossii. Saratov, Russia: Privolzhnoe knizhnoe izdalelstvo.
71. Wagner, William G. 1976. Tsarist legal policies at the end of the nineteenth century: A study in inconsistencies. Slavonic and East European Review 54 (3): 371-94.
72. Wortman, Richard. 1976. The development of a Russian legal consciousness. Chicago: Chicago Univ. Press.
73. Wortman, Richard. 2005. Russian monarchy and the rule of law: New considerations of the court reform of 1864. Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History 6, no. 1 (Winter): 145-70.
74. Zakatnova, Anna. 2003. Sudebnyi protsess prervetsia na polgoda. Rossiiskaia gazeta, October 21.
75. Zakatnova, Anna. 2004a. Spokoino, grazhdanie sudi! Vladimir Putin uteshil tretiu vlast. Rossiiskaia gazeta, October 21.
76. Zakatnova, Anna. 2004b. Kurs dlia tretei vlast. Sudi budut chistymi gosudarstvennikami. Rossiiskaia gazeta, Februrary 12.
77. Zharkov, Dmitry, and Nikolai Gulko. 2004. Sud udaliaetsia na zaveshchanie. Kommersantvlast, October 11.
78. Zorkin, Valery. 2004. Otstaivat avtoritet sudebnoi vlasti mozhno, tolko priznav pravdu. Izvestiya, October 29.