Principles and applications of control in quantum systems

International Journal of Robust and Nonlinear Control

Volumn 15, Issue 15, 2005, Pages 647-667

  Mabuchi, Hideo ^a   Khaneja, Navin ^b  

^a CALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

^b HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Nonlinear; Quantum; Stochastic

Indexed keywords

CONTROL THEORY; MATHEMATICAL MODELS; NANOTECHNOLOGY; QUANTUM THEORY; RANDOM PROCESSES;

NANOSCALE SYSTEMS; QUANTUM CONTROL SYSTEMS;

NONLINEAR CONTROL SYSTEMS;

EID: 27644523720     PISSN: 10498923     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/rnc.1016     Document Type: Article

References (140)

1. Belavkin VP. Theory of the control of observable quantum-systems. Automation and Remote Control 1983: 44:178; also available as quant-ph 0408003.
2. Peirce AP. Dahleh MA, Rabitz H. Optimal-control of quantum-mechanical systems-existence, numerical approximation, and applications. Physical Review A 1988: 37:4950-4964.
3. Huang GM. Tarn TJ. Clark JW. On the controllability of quantum-mechanical systems, Journal of Mathematical Physics 1983; 24:2608-2618.
4. Preskill J. Reliable quantum computers. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A 1998; 454:385-410.
5. Steane AM. Overhead and noise threshold of fault-tolerant quantum error correction. Physical Review A 2003; 68:042322.
6. Rahn B, Doherty AC, Mabuchi H. Exact performance of concatenated quantum codes. Physical Review A 2002: 66:032304.
7. Khodjasteh K, Lidar DA. Concatenated dynamical decoupling, quant-ph/0408128 (2004).
8. Fern J, Kempe J, Simic S, Sastry S. Fault-tolerant quantum computation - a dynamical systems approach, quant-ph/0409084 (2004).
9. Armen MA, Au J-K, Stockton JK, Doherty AC, Mabuchi H. Adaptive homodyne measurement of optical phase. Physical Review Letters 2002: 89:133602.
10. Stockton JK, Geremia JM. Doherty AC, Mabuchi H. Robust quantum parameter estimation: coherent magnetometry with feedback. Physical Review A 2004; 69:032109.
11. Gustavson TL, Landragin A, Kasevich MA. Rotation sensing with a dual atom-interferometer Sagnac gyroscope. Classical and Quantum Gravity 2000: 17:2385-2398.
12. McGuirk JM, Foster GT. Fixler JB. Snadden MJ, Kasevich MA. Sensitive absolute-gravity gradiometry using atom interferometry. Physical Review A 2002; 65:033608.
13. Buonanno A, Chen YB. Mavalvala N. Quantum noise in laser-interferometer gravitational-wave detectors with a heterodyne readout scheme. Physical Review D 2003; 67:122005.
14. Rabitz H. de Vivie-Riedle R. Motzkus M. Kompa K. Chemistry-whither the future of controlling quantum phenomena? Science 2000; 288:824-828.
15. Rabitz H. Tying the loop tighter around quantum systems. Journal of Modern Optics 2003; 50:2291-2303.
16. Levis RJ, Menkir GM. Rabitz H. Selective bond dissociation and rearrangement with optimally tailored, strong-field laser pulses. Science 2001; 292:709-713.
17. Herek JL. Wohleben W. Cogdell RJ, Zeidler D. Motzkus M. Quantum control of energy flow in light harvesting. Nature 2002; 417:533-535.
18. Christov IP, Bartels R. Kapteyn HC. Murnane MM. Attosccond time-scale intra-atomic phase matching of high harmonic generation. Physical Review Letters 2001; 86:5458-5461.
19. Geremia JM, Rabitz H. Optimal identification of Hamiltonian information by closed-loop laser control of quantum systems. Physical Review Letters 2002; 89:263902.
20. Li BQ, Turinici G, Ramakrishna V, Rabitz H. Optimal dynamic discrimination of similar molecules through quantum learning control. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2002; 106:8125-8131.
21. Khaneja N, Brockett RW, Glaser SJ. Time optimal control of spin systems. Physical Review A 2001; 63:032308.
22. Khaneja N. Glaser SJ. Brockett RW. Sub-Riemannian geometry and optimal control of three spin systems. Physical Review A 2002; 65:032301.
23. Khaneja N, Luy B, Glaser SJ. Boundary of quantum evolution under decoherence. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 2003: 100:13162-13166.
24. Khaneja N. Reiss T, Luy B, Glaser SJ. Optimal control of spin dynamics in the presence of relaxation. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 2003; 162:311 -319.
25. Khaneja Jr N, Li S. Kehlet C. Luy B, Glaser SJ. Broadband relaxation optimized polarization transfer in magnetic resonance. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 2004: 101:14742-14747.
26. van Handel R. Stockton JK, Mabuchi H. Feedback control of quantum state reduction, quant-ph/0402136 (2004).
27. Ernst RR, Bodenhausen G, Wokaun A. Principles of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in One and Two Dimensions. Clarendon Press: Oxford. 1987.
28. Slichter CP. Principles of Magnetic Resonance. Springer: Berlin. 1978.
29. Abragam A. The Principles of Nuclear Magnetism. Oxford University Press: Oxford. 1978.
30. Wüthrich K. NMR of Proteins and Nucleic Acids. Wiley: New York, 1986.
31. Cavanagh J, Fairbrother WJ, Palmer AG. Skelton NJ. Protein NMR Spectroscopy, Principles and Practice. Academic Press: New York, 1996.
32. Roos I, Mølmer K. Quantum computing with an inhomogeneously broadened ensemble of ions: supression of errors from detuning variations by specially adapted pulses and coherent population trapping. Physical Review A 2004; 69:022321.
33. Calarco T. Dorner U, Julienne PS, Williams CJ, Zoller P. Quantum computations with atoms in optical lattices: marker qubits and molecular interactions. Physical Review A 2004; 70:012306.
34. Morrow NV, Dutta SK. Raithel G. Feedback control of atomic motion in an optical lattice. Physical Review Letters 2002; 88:093003.
35. Vuletic V, Black AT, Thompson JK. External-feedback laser cooling of gases, quant-ph/0410168 (2004).
36. Tanaka U, Bergquist JC. Bize S, Diddams SA, Drullinger RE, Hollberg L, Itano WM, Tanner CE, Wineland DJ. Optical frequency standards based on the Hg-199(+) ion. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 2003; 52:245-249.
37. Wineland DJ, Barrett M, Britoon J, Chiaverini J, DeMarco B, Itano WM, Jelenkovic B, Langer C, Leibfried D, Meyer V, Rosenband T, Schatz T. Quantum information processing with trapped ions. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A 2003; 361:1349-1361.
38. Rangan C, Bloch AM. Monroe C, Bucksbaum PH. Control of trapped ion quantum states with optical pulses. Physical Review Letters 2004; 92:113004.
39. Brockett R, Rangan C, Bloch AM. Controllability of infinite dimensional quantum systems. Proceedings of Conference on Decision and Control. Hawaii, 2003.
40. Guthorhrlein GR, Keller M, Hayasaka K, Lange W, Walther H. A single ion as a nanoscopic probe of an optical field. Nature 2002: 414:49-51.
41. Mundt AB, Kreuter A, Becher C, Leibfried D, Eschner J, Schmidt-Kaler F, Blatt R. Coupling a single atomic quantum bit to a high finesse optical cavity. Physical Review Letters 2002; 89:103001.
42. Berman PR (ed.). Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics. Academic Press: San Diego, 1994.
43. Raimond J-M, Brune M, Haroche S. Colloquium: manipulating quantum entanglement with atoms and photons in a cavity. Reviews of Modern Physics 2001; 73:565-582.
44. Walther H. Quantum phenomena of single atoms. Advances in Chemical Physics 2002; 122:167-197.
45. Mabuchi H, Doherty AC. Cavity quantum electrodynamics: coherence in context. Science 2002; 298:1372-1377.
46. McKeever J, Boca A. Boozer AD, Miller R, Buck JR, Kuzmich A, Kimble HJ. Deterministic generation of single photons from one atom trapped in a cavity. Science 2004; 303:1992-1994.
47. Steck DA, Jacobs K, Mabuchi H, Bhattacharya T, Habib S. Quantum feedback control of atomic motion in an optical cavity. Physical Review Letters 2004: 92:223004.
48. Reiner JE, Wiseman HM, Mabuchi H. Quantum jumps between dressed states: a proposed cavity-QED test using feedback. Physical Review A 2003; 67:042106.
49. Mabuchi H. Quantum feedback and the quantum-classical transition. In Science and Ultimate Reality: Quantum Theory, Cosmology and Complexity. Barrow JD. Davies PCW, Harper Jr CL (eds). Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 2004.
50. Bajcsy M, Zibrov AS, Lukin MD. Stationary pulses of light in an atomic medium. Nature 2003; 426:638-641.
51. Julsgaard B, Sherson J, Cirac J-I, Fiurasek J. Polzik ES. Experimental demonstration of a quantum memory for light. Nature 2004: 432:482-486.
52. Chou C-W, Polyakov SV, Kuzmich A. Kimble HJ. Single-photon generation from stored excitation in an atomic ensemble. Physical Review Letters 2004; 92:213601.
53. Felinto D. Acioli LH, Vianna SS. Temporal coherent control of a sequential transition in rubidium atoms. Optics Letters 2000; 25:917-919.
54. Geremia JM, Stockton JK, Mabuchi H. Real-time quantum feedback control of atomic spin-squeezing. Science 2004; 304:270.
55. Georgiades NP, Polzik ES, Kimble HJ. Frequency metrology by use of quantum interference. Optics Letters 1996; 21:1688-1690.
56. Chuang IL, Gershenfeld N. Kubinec MG, Leung DW. Bulk quantum computation with nuclear magnetic resonance: theory and experiment. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A 1998; 454:447-467.
57. Boutis GS, Greenbaum D, Cho H, Cory DG, Ramanathan C. Spin diffusion of correlated two-spin states in a dielectric crystal. Physical Review Letters 2004; 92:137201.
58. Sih V, Lau WH, Myers RC. Gossard AC. Flatte ME, Awschalom DD. Control of electron-spin coherence using Landau level quantization in a two-dimensional electron gas. Physical Review B 2004; 70:161313.
59. Deutsch IH, Jessen PS. Quantum-state control in optical lattices. Physical Review A 1998; 98:1972-1986.
60. Ghose S, Alsing PM, Deutsch IH. Atomic motion in magneto-optical double-well potentials: a testing ground for quantum chaos. Physical Review E 2001; 64:056119.
61. Brennen GK. Caves CM, Jessen PS, Deutsch IH. Quantum logic gates in optical lattices. Physical Review Letters 1999; 82:1060-1063.
62. Calarco T. Hinds EA, Jaksch D, Schmiedmayer J, Cirac J-I, Zoller P. Quantum gates with neutral atoms: controlling collisional interactions in time-dependent traps. Physical Review A 2000; 61:022304.
63. Rom T, Best T, Mandel O, Widera A. Greiner M, Mansch TW. Bloch I. State selective production of molecules in optical lattices. Physical Review Letters 2004; 93:073002.
64. Paredes B, Widera A, Murg V, Mandel O, Foiling S, Cirac J-I, Shlyapnikov GV, Hansch TW. Bloch I. Tonks-Girardeau gas of ultracold atoms in an optical lattice. Nature 2004; 429:277-281.
65. Jaksch D, Bruder C, Cirac J-I, Gardiner CW. Zoller P. Cold bosonic atoms in optical lattices. Physical Review Letters 1998; 81:3108.
66. Cirac J-I, Lewenstein M, Mølmer K. Zoller P. Quantum superposition states of Bose-Einstein condensates. Physical Review A 1998: 57:1208-1218.
67. Duan L-M, Demler E, Lukin MD. Controlling spin exchange interactions of ultracold atoms in optical lattices. Physical Review Letters 2003; 91:090402.
68. Berggren KK. Quantum computing with superconductors. Proceedings of the IEEE 2004: 92:1630-1638.
69. Siddiqi I, Vijay R. Pierre F. Wilson CM, Metcalfe M. Rigetti C. Frunzio L, Devoret MH. RF-driven Josephson bifurcation amplifier for quantum measurement. Physical Review Letters 2004: 93:207002.
70. Wallraff A, Schuster DI. Blais A, Frunzio L. Huang RS. Mayer J, Kumar S. Girvin SM, Schoelkopf RJ. Strong coupling of a single photon to a superconducting qubit using circuit quantum electrodynamics. Nature 2004: 431:162-167.
71. Kato Y. Myers RC, Gossard AC. Awschalom DD. Coherent spin manipulation without magnetic fields in strained semiconductors. Nature 2004; 427:50-53.
72. Huang XMH, Zorman CA. Mehregany M. Roukes ML. Nanoelectromechanical systems: nanodevice motion at microwave frequencies. Nature 2003; 421:496.
73. LaHaye MD, Buu O, Camarota B, Schwab KC. Approaching the quantum limit of a nanomechanical resonator. Science 2004: 304:74-77.
74. Hopkins A, Jacobs K. Habib S, Schwab K. Feedback cooling of a nanomechanical resonator. Physical Review B 2003; 68:235328.
75. Armour AD, Blencowe MP. Schwab KC. Entanglement and decoherence of a micromechanical resonator via coupling to a Cooper-pair box. Physical Review Letters 2002: 88:148301.
76. Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Cartan decomposition of SU(2n) and control of spin systems. Chemical Physics 2001: 267:11-23.
77. D'Alessandro D. Small time controllability of systems on compact Lie groups and spin angular momentum, Journal of Mathematical Physics 2001; 42:4488-4496.
78. D'Alessandro D. Bilinear and geometric control based on Lie algebras. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 2002: 47(1):87-92.
79. Albertini F, D'Alessandro D. Notions of controllability for multilevel bilinear quantum mechanical systems. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 2003; 48(8): 1399-1403.
80. Dahleh M, Pierce A, Rabitz H, Ramakrishna V. Control of molecular motion. Proceedings of the IEEE 1996; 84:7.
81. Ramakrishna V, Rabitz H, Salapaka MV. Dahleh M. Peirce A. Controllability of the molecular systems. Physical Review A 1995; 51:960-966.
82. Ober RJ. Ramakrishna V, Ward S. Attainability in NMR. Journal of Mathematical Chemistry 1999: 26:15-26.
83. Schirmer SG. Fu H. Solomon AI. Complete controllability of quantum systems. Physical Review A 2001: 63:063410.
84. Schirmer SG. Lehay JV, Solomon AI. Criteria for reachability of states for quantum systems. Journal of Physics A 2002:35:8551-8562.
85. Turnici G, Rabitz H. Quantum wave function controllability. Chemical Physics 2001; 267:1-9.
86. Altafini C. Controllability of quantum mechanical systems by root space decomposition of su(N). Journal of Mathematical Physics 2002; 43(5):2051-2062.
87. Brockett RW. System theory on group manifolds and coset spaces. SIAM Journal of Control 1972: 10:265-284.
88. Jurdjevic V, Sussmann H. Control systems on Lie groups. Journal of Differential Equations 1972: 12: 313-329.
89. Brockett RW. Nonlinear control theory and differential geometry. Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians. Warsaw. 1984: 1357-1367.
90. Law CK, Eberly JH. Arbitrary control of a quantum electromagnetic field. Physical Review Letters 1996; 76:1055.
91. Kneer B, Law CK. Preparation of arbitrary entangled quantum states of a trapped ion. Physical Review A 1998; 57:2096.
92. Skinner TE, Reiss T, Luy B, Khaneja N. Glaser SJ. Application of optimal control theory to the design of broadband excitation pulses for high resolution NMR. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 2003; 163:8-15.
93. Kobzar K, Skinner TE. Khaneja N, Glaser SJ, Luy B. Exploring the limits of broadband excitation and inversion pulses. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 2004: 170:236-243.
94. Kehlet CT. Sivertsen AC. Bjerring M. Reiss TO, Khaneja N. Glaser SJ. Nielsen NC. Improving solid-state NMR dipolar recoupling by optimal control. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2004: 126:10202-10203.
95. Skinner TE, Reiss TO, Luy B, Khaneja N. Glaser SJ. Reducing the duration of broadband excitation pulses using optimal control with limited RF amplitude. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 2004; 167:68-74.
96. D'Alessandro D. Constructive controllability of one and two spin 1/2 particles. Proceedings 2001 American Control Conference, Arlington, VA, June 2001.
97. Kraus B, Cirac JI. Optimal creation of entanglement using a two qubits gate. Physical Review A 2001; 63:062309.
98. Vidai G, Hammerer K, Cirac JI. Interaction cost of nonlocal gates. Physical Review Letters 2002; 88:237902.
99. Zhang J, Vala J, Sastry S, Whaley KB. Minimum construction of two-qubit quantum operations. Physical Review Letters 2004; 93:020502.
100. Zhang J, Vala J, Sastry S. Whaley KB. Exact two-qubit universal quantum circuit. Physical Review Letters 2003; 91:027903.
101. Zhang J, Vala J, Sastry S, Whaley KB. Geometric theory of nonlocal two-qubit operations. Physical Review A 2003:67:042313.
102. Reiss T, Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Time-optimal coherence-order-selective transfer of in-phase coherence in heteronuclear IS spin systems. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 2002; 154:192-195.
103. Khaneja N, Kramer F, Glaser SJ. Optimal experiments for maximizing coherence transfer between coupled spins. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 2005; 173:116-124.
104. Brockett RW. Control theory and singular Riemannian geometry. In New Directions in Applied Mathematics. Hilton P, Young G (eds). Springer: New York, 1981; 76-79.
105. Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Efficient transfer of coherence through Ising Spin chains. Physical Review A 2002; 66:060301(R).
106. Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Optimal control of coupled spins in presence of cross-correlated relaxation. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Decision and Control. Maui, 2003.
107. Dionisis S, Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Optimal control of coupled spins in the presence of longitudinal and transverse relaxation. IEEE Conference on Physics and Control, St. Petersburg, Russia, 2003.
108. Redfield AG. The theory of relaxation processes. Advances in Magnetic Resonance 1965; 1:1-32.
109. Lindblad G. On the generators of quantum dynamical semigroups. Communications in Mathematical Physics 1976; 48:199.
110. Altafini C. Controllability properties of finite dimensional quantum Markovian master equation. Journal of Mathematical Physics 2003; 44(6):2357-2372.
111. Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Constrained bilinear systems. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Las Vegas, 2002.
112. Tannor DJ, Bartana A. On the interplay of control fields and spontaneous emission in laser cooling. Journal of Physical Chemistry A 1999; 103:10359.
113. Sklarz SE, Tannor DJ, Khaneja N. Optimal control of quantum dissipative dynamics: analytic solution for cooling the three level Lambda system. Physical Review A 2004; 69:053408.
114. Rohr K, Speiss M. Multidimensional Solid State NMR of Polymers. Academic Press: New York, 1994.
115. Lloyd S. Coherent quantum feedback. Physical Review A 2000; 62:022108.
116. Silberfarb A. Jessen PS. Deutsch IH. Quantum state reconstruction via continuous measurement, quant-ph/0412032 (2004).
117. Beuten L, Guta M, Maassen H. Stochastic Schröodinger equations. Journal of Physics A 2004; 37:3189-3209.
118. Wiseman HM, Milburn GJ. Quantum-theory of field-quadrature measurements. Physical Review A 1993: 47: 642-662.
119. Gardiner CW, Zoller P. Quantum Noise. Springer: Berlin, 2004.
120. James MR. Risk-sensitive optimal control of quantum systems. Physical Review A 2004; 69:032108.
121. Wiseman HM. In-loop squeezing is like real squeezing to an in-loop atom. Physical Review Letters 1998; 81: 3840-3843.
122. Bouten L. Filtering and control in quantum optics, quant-ph/0410080 (2004).
123. Carmichael HJ. An Open Systems Approach to Quantum Optics. Springer: Berlin, 1993.
124. Thomsen LK, Mancini S, Wiseman HM. Continuous quantum nondemolition feedback and unconditional atomic spin squeezing. Journal of Physics B 2002; 35:4937-4952.
125. Stockton JK, van Handel R, Mabuchi H. Deterministic Dicke-state preparation with continuous measurement and control. Physical Review A 2004; 70:022106.
126. Belavkin VP. Optimal measurement and control in quantum dynamical systems. Preprint Instytut Fizyki 1979: 411:3-38; also available at http://www.maths.nott.ac.uk/personal/vpb.
127. Wiseman HM, Doherty AC. Optimal unravellings for feedback control in linear quantum systems, quant-ph/0408099 (2004).
128. Geremia JM, Stockton JK, Doherty AC, Mabuchi H. Quantum Kalman filtering and the Heisenberg limit in atomic magnetometry. Physical Review Letters 2003; 91:250801.
129. van Handel R. Almost global stochastic stability. math.PR/0411311 (2004).
130. Mabuchi H. Dynamical identification of open quantum systems. Quantum Semiclassical Optics 1996; 8:1103.
131. Verstraete F. Doherty AC. Mabuchi H. Sensitivity optimization in quantum parameter estimation. Physical Review A 2001; 64:032111.
132. Warszawski P. Gambetta J, Wiseman HM. Dynamical parameter estimation using realistic photodetection. Physical Review A 2004; 69:042104.
133. Brockett RW, Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Optimal input design for NMR identification problem. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Orlando, 2001.
134. Judson RS, Rabitz H. Teaching lasers to control molecules. Physical Review Letters 1992; 68:1500-1503.
135. Assion A, Baumert T, Bergt M, Brixner T, Kiefer B, Seyfried V, Strehle M. Gerber G. Control of chemical reactions by feedback-optimized phase-shaped femtosecond laser pulses. Science 1998; 282:919-922.
136. Levis RJ, Menkir GM, Rabitz H. Selective bond dissociation and rearrangement with optimally tailored, strong-field laser pulses. Science 2001; 292:709-713.
137. Kosut RL, Walmsley I, Eldar Y. Rabitz H. Quantum state detector design: optimal worst-case a posteriori performance, quant-ph/0403150 (2004).
138. Cirac J-I, Ekert AK, Huelga SF. Macchiavello C. Distributed quantum computation over noisy channels. Physical Review A 1999; 59:4249-4254.
139. Dionisis S. Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Optimal control of spin dynamics in the presence of longitudinal and transverse relaxation. Physical Review A 2004; 69:022319.
140. Kobzar K, Luy B, Khaneja N, Glaser SJ. Pattern pulses: design of arbitrary excitation profiles as a function of pulse amplitude and offset. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 2005; 173:229-235.