Making 'dirty' nations look clean? The nation state and the problem of selecting and weighting indices as tools for measuring progress towards sustainability

Geoforum

Volumn 36, Issue 5, 2005, Pages 625-640

  Morse, Stephen ^a   Fraser, Evan D G ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF READING   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Aggregation; Environmental Sustainability Index; Global leaders of tomorrow; Nation state; Scale; Sustainability indicators

Indexed keywords

AGGREGATION; ENVIRONMENTAL INDICATOR; INDEX METHOD; NATION STATE; SUSTAINABILITY;

EID: 24344451229     PISSN: 00167185     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.geoforum.2004.10.005     Document Type: Article

References (55)

1. S. Bell S. Morse Sustainability Indicators: Measuring the Immeasurable 1999 Earthscan London
2. S. Bell S. Morse Measuring Sustainability: Learning from Doing 2003 Earthscan London
3. S. Biggs G. Smith Beyond methodologies: Coalition-building for participatory technology development World Development 26 1998 239-248
4. P. Blaikie Development, post-, anti-, and populist: A critical review Environment and Planning A 32 2000 1033-1050
5. S. Boehmer-Christiansen The geo-politics of sustainable development: bureaucracies and politicians in search of the holy grail Geoforum 33 2002 351-365
6. R. Chambers The origins and practice of participatory rural appraisal World Development 22 1994 953-969
7. R. Chambers Participatory rural appraisal (PRA): Analysis of experience World Development 22 1994 1253-1268
8. P. Chasek Earth Negotiations: Analysing Thirty Years of Environmental Diplomacy 2001 United Nations University Press Tokyo
9. Coast Information Team, 2002. Coast Information Team. Government of British Columbia, Canada. Retrieved 5 November 2003. Available from:
10. A. Cornwall Whose voices? Whose choices? Reflections on gender and participatory development World Development 31 2003 1325-1342
11. P. Dauvergne Shadows in the Forest 1997 MIT Press Cambridge, MA
12. A. de Waal Famine Crimes 1997 African Rights and the International African Institute Bloomington
13. Environmental Sustainability Index, 2001. Data set used to create environmental sustainability index. World Leaders of Tomorrow, Yale University, Columbia University. Retrieved 24 February 2004. Available from:
14. Environmental Sustainability Index, 2002. Data set used to create environmental sustainability index. World Leaders of Tomorrow, Yale University, Columbia University. Retrieved 24 February 2004. Available from: .
15. A. Escobar Encountering Development: The Making and Unmaking of the Third World 1995 Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ
16. A. Escobar Constructing nature: Elements for a post-structural political ecology In: R. Peet M. Watts (Eds.) Liberation Ecologies: Environment, Development, Social Movements 1996 Routledge Montreal 46-68
17. Esty, D., Levy, M., 2000. Pilot environmental sustainability index [web page]. World Leaders of Tomorrow, Yale University and Columbia University. Retrieved 24 February 2003. Available from: .
18. R. Eversole Managing the pitfalls of participatory development: Some insight from Australia World Development 31 2003 781-795
19. E. Fraser W. Mabee Summit: Vague answers to well-known problems Nature 417 22 August 2002 2002 817
20. E. Fraser W. Mabee O. Slaymaker Mutual dependence, mutual vulnerability: the reflexive relation between society and the environment Global Environmental Change 13 2003 137-144
21. C.H. Gladwin J.S. Peterson A.C. Mwale The quality of science in participatory research: A case study from Eastern Zambia World Development 30 2002 523-543
22. Global Leaders of Tomorrow Environment Task Force, 2002. Environmental Sustainability Index. World Economic Forum; Yale Center for Environmental Law and Policy. Retrieved 29 May 2002. Available from: .
23. Global Leaders of Tomorrow Environment Task Force and the World Economic Forum, 2002. Pilot Environmental Performance Index. Global Leaders of Tomorrow Environment Task Force, The World Economic Forum, Columbia University and Yale University. Retrieved 24 February 2004. Available from: .
24. J. Graz How powerful are transnational elite clubs? The social myth of the World Economic Forum New Political Economy 8 2003 321-340
25. J. Jesinghaus The World Economic Forum's Environmental Sustainability Index: Strong and Weak Points 2000 European Commission Joint Research Centre Ispra, Italy
26. Joint Research Centre (JRC) of the European Commission and the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), 2003. Summary. First Workshop on Composite Indicators of Country Performance, Ispra, Italy, 12 May 2003.
27. M. Jones R. Jones Nation states, ideological power and globalisation: can geographers catch the boat? Geoforum 35 2004 409-424
28. I. Kapoor Towards participatory environmental management? Journal of Environmental Management 63 2001 269-279
29. V. Lenin Imperialism: The Highest State of Capitalism 1939 International Publishers New York
30. B. Lomborg The Sceptical Environmentalist. Measuring the Real State of the World 2001 Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
31. J. MacNeill P. Winsemius T. Yakushiji Beyond Interdependence: The Meeting of the World's Economy and the Earth's Ecology 1991 Oxford University Press New York
32. S. Matthews Power shift Foreign Affairs 76 1997 50-66
33. J. Meadowcroft Politics and scale: Some implications for environmental governance Landscape and Urban Planning 61 2002 169-179
34. D. Niemeijer Developing indicators for environmental policy: Data-driven and theory-driven approaches examined by example Environmental Science & Policy 5 2002 91-103
35. R. Nowak How the rich stole the rain New Scientist 174 2347 2002 4-6
36. O'Brien, K., 2000. S11's case gets put before World Economic Forum. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 24 February 2004. Available from: .
37. T. Parris R. Kates Characterizing and measuring sustainable development Annual Review of Environment and Resources 28 2003 13.11-31.28
38. K. Pezzoli Sustainable development: A transdisciplinary overview of the literature Journal of Environmental Planning and Management A 40 1997 549-574
39. R. Prescott-Allen The Wellbeing of Nations 2001 Island Press and the International Development Research Council Ottawa, Canada
40. J.N. Pretty Participatory learning for sustainable agriculture World Development 23 1995 1247-1263
41. M.S. Reed A.J. Dougill Participatory selection process for indicators of rangeland condition in the Kalahari The Geographical Journal 168 2002 224-234
42. W.E. Rees M. Wackernagel Our Ecological Footprint: Reducing Human Impact on the Earth 1995 New Society Pub. Gabriola Island
43. W. Rostow The Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto second ed. 1971 Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
44. G.R. Sands T.H. Podmore A generalized environmental sustainability index for agricultural systems Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 79 2000 29-41
45. T. Shannon An Introduction to the World System 1996 West View Press Boulder, Colorado
46. M. Smale M.R. Bellon J.A. Aguirre I. Manuel Rosas J. Mendoza A.M. Solano R. Martinez A. Ramirez J. Berthaud The economic costs and benefits of a participatory project to conserve maize landraces on farms in Oaxaca, Mexico Agricultural Economics 29 2003 265-275
47. K. Smith C.B. Barrett P.W. Box Participatory risk mapping for targeting research and assistance: With an example from East African pastoralists World Development 28 2000 1945-1959
48. P. Sutton An empirical environmental Sustainability Index derived solely from nighttime satellite imagery and ecosystem service valuation Population and Environment 24 2003 293-311
49. The Ecologist, 2001 Keeping score, April, 44-47, or for on line edition see
50. United Nations, 1992. Agenda 21. United Nations. Retrieved 10 July 2002. Available from: .
51. M. Wackernagel Ecological Footprint and Appropriated Carrying Capacity a Tool for Planning Toward Sustainability 1994 University of British Columbia Press Vancouver, British Columbia
52. M. Wackernagel W.E. Rees Our Ecological Footprint: Reducing Human Impact on the Earth 1996 New Society Publishers Gabriola Island, B.C
53. I. Wallerstein The Present State of the Debate on World Inequality In: I. Wallerstein (Eds.) World Inequality: Origins and Perspectives on the World System 1975 Black Rose Books Montrea
54. World Economic Forum, 2003-2004. Global Competitiveness Report. World Economic Forum and Euromoney Publications. Retrieved 24 February 2004. Available from:
55. World Economic Forum, 2004. Organization's home page. World Economic Forum. Retrieved 24 February 2004. Available from: