Should governmental water responsibilities flow downwards?

Journal of Water Law

Volumn 16, Issue 2, 2005, Pages 49-57

  Porter, Keith S ^a  

^a New York Resources Institute ^*  (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

GOVERNANCE APPROACH; LEGISLATION; WATER MANAGEMENT;

EID: 22344432321     PISSN: 14785277     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (110)

1. Crossroads Ventures LLC.
2. 'Protection for a City's Water' New York Times editorial 17 February 2004.
3. K S Porter 'Protecting a 'necessity of life': water supplies protected at their watershed source' WL 14 [2003] 2 61.
4. USCA § 1412 (b)(7)(i).
5. CFR § 141.71 (b)(2).
6. E Goldstein and R Marx 'A New York Watershed protection Program for the 21st Century' Environmental Law in New York 14 [2003] 1 5.
7. ECL article 8.
8. NYCRR Parts 617, 621 and 624.
9. Pursuant to NYCRR 62.4 and 624.5.
10. Letter from W Mugden, Division of Environmental Planning, USEPA Region II to Alexander Ciasluk (DEC).
11. Comments of the New York City Watershed Inspector General on the draft Environmental Impact Statement and associated environmental permits with respect to the proposed Belleayre Resort at Catskill Park, New York State DEC Application No 3-9903-00059/00001 23 April 2004.
12. 'Catskill proposals stir debate: hotel development plan pits environment vs economy' Ithaca Journal 7/5/2003.
13. 'Water, land on the line' Albany Times Union 20 June 2004.
14. A V Dicey Lectures on the Relation between Law & Public Opinion in England (Macmillan and Co 1926) 259.
15. For example R E Meiners & A P Morris (eds) The Common Law and the Environment; Rethinking the Statutory Basis for Modern Environmental Law (Rowman & Littlefield 2000).
16. West's Encyclopedia of American Law (West Group 1998) 4 265.
17. W H Rodgers Jr Environmental Law Vol 1 (West Publishing 1986) 1.
18. A P Morris and R E Meiners 'Reclaiming the Common Law's Role in Environmental Law' in The Common Law and the Environment (n 15) xiii.
19. W Howarth and D McGillivray Water Pollution and Water Quality Law (Shaw & Sons 2001) 66.
20. 12 Ric 2 c 13 (1388) cited in Water Pollution 66 (n 19).
21. Sir William Holdsworth A History of English Law (Methuen & Co 1981) 10 199.
22. ibid 202.
23. W J Broderip The Readings of the famous and learned Robert Callis Esq upon the Statute of Sewers (Butterworth and Son 1824) vii.
24. Holdsworth (n 21) 202.
25. ibid 205.
26. 10 & 11 Vict c 15 & c17.
27. 11 &12 Vict c 63.
28. T Smith The Parish (H Sweet 1857) 401.
29. Economist 13 May 1848, cited by J H Clapham An Economic History of Modern Britain: The Early Railway Age (Cambridge 1939) 545.
30. J C Eastman A Fistful of Denial: The Supreme Court takes a Pass on Commerce Clause Challenges to Environmental Laws in CATO Supreme Court Review 2003-2004 (CATO Institute 2004) 470.
31. G M Binnie Early Victorian Water Engineers (Thomas Telford Limited 1981) 1.
32. Mrs Gaskell Life of Charlotte Bronte vii Life and Works of Charlotte Bronte and her Sisters (Smith Elder & Co 1914) 356.
33. E Jenkins 'The Legal Aspects of Sanitary Reform' in A P Stewart and E Jenkins The Medical and Legal Aspects of Sanitary Reform (Humanities Press 1969 reprint of the 1867 2nd edn) 93.
34. R A Lewis Edwin Chadwick and the Public Health Movement 1832-1854 (Longmans Green 1952).
35. J A Tobey Public Health Law 2nd edn (The Commonwealth Fund 1939) 13.
36. Gibbons v Ogden 9 Wheat 1 (1824). This case affirmed the supremacy of federal powers under the commerce clause of the constitution. This clause is the bedrock of federal environmental law.
37. C A Beard American Government and Politics (Macmillan Company 1914) 654.
38. H Finer Theory and Practice of Local Government (Methuen 1965) 757.
39. R J Lazarus The Making of Environmental Law (University of Chicago Press 2004) 49.
40. E F Murphy Water Purity: A Study in Legal Control of Natural Resources (University of Wisconsin Press 1961) 20.
41. 33 USCA § 1251.
42. R E Beck (ed) Waters and Water Rights (Lexis Law Publishing 1998) 5 236.
43. Senator Cooper A Legislative History of the Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972 (US Government Printing Office 1973) 2 1304.
44. 33 USCA § 1311(a) [FWPCA § 301].
45. 33 USCA § 1342 [FWPCA § 402].
46. O A Houck The Clean Water Act TMDL Program: Law, Policy, and Implementation (Environmental Law Institute 1992) 2nd edn 3.
47. G T Mehan III and R H Savage 'Congress Should Consider Modest Proposals to Revive Environmental Federalism' Environment Reporter 36 no 15 784.
48. 33 USCA § 1329.
49. D Zaring 'Best Practices as Regulatory Regime: The Case of Agricultural Nonpoint Source Pollution' 34 ELR 11025.
50. Houck (n 46) 101s.
51. United States Environmental Protection Agency National Coastal Condition Report II (EPA-620/R-03/002 December 2004) http://www.epa. gov/owow/oceans/nccr2/.
52. 42 USCA § 300G-1 (b)(7)(C)(i).
53. 42 USCA § 4321-4370f.
54. W H Rodgers Environmental Law (West Publishing 1994) 2nd edn 801.
55. J R Nolon Well Grounded: Using Local Land Use Authority to Achieve Smart Growth (Environmental Law Institute 2001) 183.
56. ECL article 8.
57. Nolon (n 55) 183.
58. Rodgers (n 17).
59. A D Tarlock 'The Potential Role of Local Governments in Watershed Management' in J R Nolon (ed) New Ground: The Advent of Local Environmental Law (Environmental Law Institute 2003).
60. W H Rodgers Jr Environmental Law: Air and Water (West Publishing 1986) 1 16.
61. J R Nolon 'National Land Use Planning: Revisiting Senator Jackson's 1970 Policy Act' Land Use Law and Zoning Digest May 1996 5.
62. I b i d.
63. I b i d.
64. D T Kendall Redefining Federalism: Listening to the States in Shaping 'Our Federalism' (Environmental Law Institute 2004) 11.
65. I b i d.
66. I b i d.
67. Mehan (n 47) 784.
68. Tarlock in New Ground (n 59) 215.
69. Beard (n 37) 654.
70. ibid 655.
71. M S Greve Real Federalism: What It Is, Why It Matters (American Enterprise Institute For Public Policy Research 1999).
72. D Schoenbrod 'Protecting the Environment in the Spirit of the Common Law' in The Common Law and the Environment (n 15) 5.
73. A P Morris 'Lessons for Environmental Law from the American Codification Debate' in The Common Law and the Environment (n 15) 130.
74. Laws of Maryland 1808 ch 79.
75. J Duffy The Sanitarians (University of Illinois Press 1990).
76. W P Prentice Police Powers Arising Under the Law of Overruling Necessity (Banks & Brothers 1894) 136.
77. Powell vs Penna 127 US 678 cited in W R Bierly Police Power (Rees Welsh & Co 1907) 71.
78. J R Nolon 'In Praise of Parochialism: The Advent of Local Environmental Law' in New Ground (n 59) 3.
79. K S Porter 'Protecting a "Necessity of Life": Water Supplies Protected at their Watershed Source' Water Law [2003] 14 2 61.
80. Delaware County Board of Supervisors Resolution no 229: pursuant to the authority granted by Section 204 of the County Law.
81. W Stasiuk, Deputy Commissioner of the New York City Department of Environmental Protection. Comment during meeting of the New York City Watershed federal and state Partners to review DCAP 2 November 1999.
82. ECL article 8.
83. Public Health Law §§ 201[1][1] 1100: arts 2, 11.
84. 40 CFR § 141.71 (b)(2).
85. 42 USCA § 1412 (b)(7)(C)(i).
86. Nolon (n 78) 38.
87. Finer (n 38) 945
88. Sir William Wade and C Forsyth Administrative Law (Oxford, 2004) 83
89. J Redlich Local Government in England (Macmillan & Co 1903) 1 10.
90. D Krane and others Home Rule in America: A Fifty-State Handbook (CQ Press 2001) 1.
91. D Tarlock 'The Potential Role of Local Governments in Watershed Management' in Nolon (n 78) 213.
92. Beard (n 37) 655.
93. R S Lorch State and Local Politics (Prentice Hall 2001) 6th edn 270.
94. D Krane (n 90) 19.
95. P S Nivola and J A Shields Managing Green Mandates: Local Rigors of US Environmental Regulation (AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies 2001) 27.
96. I b i d.
97. D Krane (n 90) 5.
98. J DeWitt Civic Environmentalism: Alternatives to Regulation in States and Communities (CC Press 1994) 7.
99. Kendall (n 64) 1.
100. Younger v Harris 401 US 37, 91 S Ct 746, 27 L Ed 2d 669 [1971].
101. W Howarth and D McGillivray Water Pollution and Water Quality Law (Shaw & Sons) 811.
102. Porter (n 3).
103. N Burnett Behind the Scenes: The Inside Story of the Watershed Agreement nburnettυsa.net 2002.
104. K S Porter 'Does the Cap Fit? Rectifying Eutrophication in the Chesapeake Bay' Water Law 15 [2004] 5 188.
105. Mrs Gaskell (n 32).
106. W Shakespeare Anthony and Cleopatra 2.1 5.
107. G Orsen 'Fall from Grace: The Public's Loss of Faith in Government' in J S Nye Sr and others Why People Don't Trust Government (Harvard University Press 1997) 83.
108. Lazarus (n 39) 232.
109. Krane (n 90) 3.
110. National Water Commission Water Policies for the Future: Final Report to the President and to the Congress of the United States (Washington DC June 1973) 83.