Infant sleeping position and the sudden infant death syndrome: Systematic review of observational studies and historical review of recommendations from 1940 to 2002

International Journal of Epidemiology

Volumn 34, Issue 4, 2005, Pages 874-887

  Gilbert, Ruth ^a   Salanti, Georgia ^b   Harden, Melissa ^a   See, Sarah ^a,c  

^a UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

^c PCT ^*  (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Meta analysis; Review; Sudden infant death

Indexed keywords

CAUSE OF DEATH; CHILD HEALTH; INFANT MORTALITY; META-ANALYSIS;

AUSTRALIA; CLINICAL OBSERVATION; CLINICAL TRIAL; CONFIDENCE INTERVAL; EUROPE; FAMILY STUDY; HEALTH PROMOTION; HISTORY; HUMAN; INFANT; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; META ANALYSIS; PATIENT POSITIONING; PREVALENCE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PUBLISHING; REVIEW; RISK ASSESSMENT; SAFETY; SLEEP; STATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE; SUDDEN INFANT DEATH SYNDROME; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; UNITED KINGDOM; UNITED STATES;

BAYES THEOREM; CAUSE OF DEATH; FEMALE; HUMANS; INFANT; INFANT, NEWBORN; MALE; MONTE CARLO METHOD; PRONE POSITION; RISK FACTORS; SLEEP; SUDDEN INFANT DEATH; SUPINE POSITION;

EID: 22244486380     PISSN: 03005771     EISSN: 14643685     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/ije/dyi088     Document Type: Review

References (111)

1. Westcott WW. Inebriety in women and the overlaying of infants. [i#The British Journal of Inebriety#1i] 1903;[b#4i#1b]:65-68.
2. Abramson H. Accidental mechanical suffocation in infants. [i#The Journal of Pediatrics#1i] 1944;[b#25#1b]:404-13.
3. Bowden KM. Sudden death or alleged accidental suffocation in babies. [i#The Medical Journal of Australia#1i] 1950;[b#1#1b]:65-72.
4. Davison H. Accidental infant suffocation. [i#BMJ#1i] 1945;[b#2#1b]:251-52.
5. New York State Department of Health. Merchanical suffocation: Leading cause of accidental death in early infancy. [i#Health News#1i] 1945;[b#22#1b] 33-34.
6. Woolley PV. Mechanical suffocation during infancy. A comment on its relation to the total problem of sudden death. [i#The Journal of Pediatrics#1i] 1945;[b#26#1b]:572-75.
7. Werne J, Garrow I. Sudden deaths of infants allegedly due to merchanical suffocation. [i#Am J Public Health#1i] 1947;[b#37#1b]:675-87.
8. Werne J, Garrow I. Sudden apparently unexplained death during infancy. I Pathologic findings in infants found dead. [i#Am J Pathol#1i] 1953;[b#29#1b] 633-53.
9. Polson CJ, Price DE. Suffocation by milk feeds. [i#Lancet#1i] 1948;[b#251#1b] 343.
10. Camps FE, Parish WE, Barrett AM, Coombs RRA, Gunther M. Hypersensitivity to milk and sudden death in infancy. [i#Lancet#1i] 1960;[b#276#1b]:1106-10.
11. Strimer R, Adelson L, Oseasohn R. Epidemiologic features of 1,134 sudden, unexpected infant deaths. A study in the Greater Cleveland Area from 1956 to 1965. [i#JAMA#1i] 1969;[b#209#1b]:1493-97.
12. Carpenter RG, Shaddick CW. Role of infection, suffocations and bottle-feeding in cot death: An analysis of some factors in the histories of 110 cases and their controls. [i#Br J Prev Soc Med#1i] 1965;[b#19#1b]:1-7.
13. Hiley CMH. [i#Back to Sleep: Cot death and Infant Care 1987-1994#1i]. Cambridge: University of Cambridge, 1995.
14. Greenland S, Rothman KJ. Measures of effect and measures of association. In: Rothman KJ, Greenland S (eds). [i#Modern Epidemiology#1i]. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven, 1998, pp. 47-64.
15. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. [i#BMJ#1i] 2003;[b#327#1b]:557-60.
16. Egger M, Davey SG, Schneider M, Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. [i#BMJ#1i] 1997;[b#315#1b]:629-34.
17. Begg CB, Mazumdar M. Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. [i#Biometrics#1i] 1994;[b#50#1b]:1088-101.
18. Lau J, Antman EM, Jimenez-Silva J, Kupelnick B, Mosteller F, Chalmers TC. Cumulative meta-analysis of therapeutic trials for myocardial infarction. [i#N Engl J Med#1i] 1992;[b#327#1b]:248-54.
19. Trikalinos TA, Churchill R, Ferri M [i#et al.#1i] Effect sizes in cumulative meta-analyses of mental health randomized trials evolved over time. [i#J Clin Epidemiol#1i] 2004;[b#57#1b]:1124-30.
20. Ioannidis JP, Contopoulos-Ioannidis DG, Lau J. Recursive cumulative meta-analysis: A diagnostic for the evolution of total randomized evidence from group and individual patient data. [i#J Clin Epidemiol#1i] 1999;[b#52#1b]:281-91.
21. Dwyer T, Couper D, Walter SD. Sources of heterogeneity in the meta-analysis of observational studies: The example of SIDS and sleeping position. [i#J Clin Epidemiol#1i] 2001;[b#54#1b]:440-47.
22. Sharp SJ, Thompson SG. Analysing the relationship between treatment effect and underlying risk in meta-analysis: Comparison and development of approaches. [i#Stat Med#1i] 2000;[b#19#1b]:3251-74.
23. Thompson SG, Smith TC, Sharp SJ. Investigating underlying risk as a source of heterogeneity in meta-analysis. [i#Stat Med#1i] 1997;[b#16#1b] 2741-58.
24. Spook B. [i#Baby and Child Care#1i]. London: The Bodley Head, 1958.
25. Illingworth RS. [i#The Normal Child#1i]. London: J & A Churchill Ltd, 1968.
26. Shepard KS. [i#Care of the Well Baby#1i]. Philadelphia: JP Lippincott Company, 1960.
27. Bax M, Bernal J. [i#Your Child's First Five Years#1i]. London: Heinemann Health Books, 1974.
28. Nelson WE. [i#Mitchell-Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics#1i]. London: WB Saunders, 1945.
29. Nelson WE. [i#Mitchell-Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics#1i]. London: WB Saunders Company, 1950.
30. Nelson WE. [i#Mitchell-Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics#1i]. London: WB Saunders Company, 1959.
31. Zabriskie L. [i#Mother and Baby in Pictures#1i]. London: JB Lippincott Company, 1953.
32. Gordon M, Gordon R. [i#A Baby in the House. A Guide to Practical Parenthood#1i]. London: Heinemann, 1966.
33. Nicholl JP, O'Cathain A, McGlashan ND. Sleeping positions and SIDS. [i#Lancet#1i] 1988;[b#3322#1b]:106.
34. Fleming PJ, Gilbert R, Azaz Y [i#et al.#1i] Interaction between bedding and sleeping position in the sudden infant death syndrome: A population based case-control study. [i#BMJ#1i] 1990;[b#301#1b]:85-89.
35. Ponsonby AL, Dwyer T, Gibbons LE, Cochrane JA, Wang YG. Factors potentiating the risk of sudden infant death syndrome associated with the prone position. [i#N Engl J Med#1i] 1993;[b#329#1b]:377-82.
36. Markestad T, Skadberg B, Hordvik E, Morild I, Irgens LM. Sleeping position and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS): Effect of an intervention programme to avoid prone sleeping. [i#Acta Paediatr#1i] 1995;[b#84#1b]:375-78.
37. Klonoff-Cohen HS, Edelstein SL. A case-control study of routine and death scene sleep position and sudden infant death syndrome in Southern California. [i#JAMA#1i] 1995;[b#273#1b]:790-94.
38. Taylor JA, Krieger JW, Reay DT, Davis RL, Harruff R, Cheney LK. Prone sleep position and the sudden infant death syndrome in King County, Washington: A case-control study. [i#J Pediatr#1i] 1996;[b#128#1b]:626-30.
39. Fleming PJ, Blair PS, Bacon C [i#et al.#1i] Environment of infants during sleep and risk of the sudden infant death syndrome: Results of 1993-5 case-control study for confidential inquiry into stillbirths and deaths in infancy. Confidential Enquiry into Stillbirths and Deaths Regional Coordinators and Researchers. [i#BMJ#1i] 1996;[b#313#1b]:191-95.
40. Hauck FR, Moore CM, Herman SM [i#et al.#1i] The contribution of prone sleeping position to the racial disparity in sudden infant death syndrome: The Chicago Infant Mortality Study. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 2002; [b#110#1b]:772-80.
41. Carpenter RG, Irgens LM, Blair PS [i#et al.#1i] Sudden unexplained infant death in 20 regions in Europe: Case control-study. [i#Lancet#1i] 2004; [b#363#1b]:185-91.
42. Brooke H, Gibson A, Tappin D, Brown H. Case-control study of sudden infant death syndrome in Scotland, 1992-5. [i#BMJ#1i] 1997;[b#314#1b] 1516-20.
43. McGarvey C, McDonnell M, Chong A, O'Regan M, Matthews T. Factors relating to the infant's last sleep environment in sudden infant death syndrome in the Republic of Ireland. [i#Arch Dis Child#1i] 2003;[b#88#1b] 1058-64.
44. Oyen N, Markestad T, Skaerven R [i#et al.#1i] Combined effects of sleeping position and prenatal risk factors in sudden infant death syndrome: The Nordic Epidemiological SIDS Study. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 1997;[b#100#1b]:613-21.
45. Dwyer T, Ponsonby AL, Newman NM, Gibbons LE. Prospective cohort study of prone sleeping position and sudden infant death syndrome. [i#Lancet#1i] 1991;[b#337#1b]:1244-47.
46. Dwyer T, Ponsonby AL, Couper D, Cochrane J. Short-term morbidity and infant mortality among infants who slept supine at 1 month of age - a follow-up report. [i#Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol#1i] 1999;[b#13#1b]:302-15.
47. Anon. Prone or supine? [i#BMJ#1i] 1961;[b#6#1b]:1304.
48. Brackbill Y, Douthitt TC, West H. Psychophysiologic effects in the neonate of prone versus supine placement. [i#J Pediatr#1i] 1973;[b#82#1b] 82-84.
49. Keitel HG, Cohn R, Harnish D. Diaper rash, self-inflicted excoriations, and crying in full-term newborn infants kept in the prone or supine position. [i#J Pediatr#1i] 1960;[b#57#1b]:884-86.
50. Hunt L, Fleming P, Golding J. Does the supine sleeping position have any adverse effects on the child? I. Health in the first six months. The ALSPAC Study Team. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 1997;[b#100#1b]:E11.
51. Byard RW, Beal SM. Gastric aspiration and sleeping position in infancy and early childhood. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 2000;[b#36#1b]:403-5.
52. Dewey C, Fleming P, Golding J. Does the supine sleeping position have any adverse effects on the child? II. Development in the first 18 months. ALSPAC Study Team. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 1998;[b#101#1b]:E5.
53. Davis BE, Moon RY, Sachs HC, Ottolini MC. Effects of sleep position on infant motor development. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 1998;[b#102#1b]:1135-40.
54. Persing J, James H, Swanson J, Kattwinkel J. Prevention and management of positional skull deformities in infants. American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Practice and Ambulatory Medicine, Section on Plastic Surgery and Section on Neurological Surgery. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 2003;[b#112#1b]:199-202.
55. Persson S, Ekbom A, Granath F, Nordenskjold A. Parallel incidences of sudden infant death syndrome and infantile hypertrophic pyloric stenosis: A common cause? [i#Pediatrics#1i] 2001;[b#108#1b]:E70.
56. Galland BC, Taylor BJ, Bolton DP. Prone versus supine sleep position: A review of the physiological studies in SIDS research. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 2002;[b#38#1b]:332-8.
57. Froggatt P. Epidemiological aspects of the Northern Ireland study. In: Bergman AB, Beckwith JB, Ray CG (eds). [i#Sudden Infant Death Syndrome. Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Causes of Sudden Death in Infants#1i]. Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1970, pp. 32-46.
58. McGlashan ND. Sudden infant deaths in Tasmania, 1980-1986: A seven year prospective study. [i#Soc Sci Med#1i] 1989;[b#29#1b]:1015-26.
59. Cameron MH, Williams AL. Development and testing of scoring systems for predicting infants with high-risk of sudden infant death syndrome in Melbourne. [i#Aust Paediatr J#1i] 1986;[b#22 (Suppl. 1)#1b]:37-45.
60. Beal S. Sleeping position and SIDS. [i#Lancet#1i] 1988;[b#2#1b]:512.
61. Tonkin SL. Epidemiology of cot deaths in Auckland. [i#NZ Med J#1i] 1986;[b#99#1b]:324-26.
62. Beal SM. Sudden infant death syndrome: Epidemiological comparisons between South Australia and communities with a different incidence. [i#Aust Paediatr J#1i] 1986;[b#22(Suppl. 1)#1b]:13-16.
63. de Jonge GA, Engelberts AC, Koomen-Liefting AJM, Kostense PJ. Cot death and prone sleeping position in The Netherlands. [i#BMJ#1i] 1989;[b#298#1b] 722.
64. Tonkin S,.Hassell I. Infant sleeping position and cot death. [i#Aust Paediatr J#1i] 1989;[b#25#1b]:376-77.
65. Hassall IB, VandenBerg M. Infant sleep position: A New Zealand survey. [i#NZ Med J#1i] 1985;[b#98#1b]:97-99.
66. Froggatt P, Lynas MA, MacKenzie G. Epidemiology of sudden unexpected death in infants ('cot death') in Northern Ireland. [i#Br J Prev Soc Med#1i] 1971;[b#25#1b]:119-34.
67. Bergman AB, Ray CG, Pomeroy MA, Wahl PW, Beckwith JB. Studies of the sudden infant death syndrome in King County, Washington. 3. Epidemiology. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 1972;[b#49#1b]:860-70.
68. Engelberts AC, de Jonge GA, Kostense PJ. An analysis of trends in the incidence of sudden infant death in The Netherlands 1969-89. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 1991;[b#27#1b]:329-33.
69. Irgens LM, Markestad T, Baste V, Schreuder P, Skjaerven R, Oyen N. Sleeping position and sudden infant death syndrome in Norway 1967-91. [i#Arch Dis Child#1i] 1995;[b#72#1b]:478-82.
70. Hogberg U, Bergstrom E. Suffocated prone: The iatrogenic tragedy of SIDS. [i#Am J Public Health#1i] 2000;[b#90#1b]:527-31.
71. Mitchell EA, Ford RP, Taylor BJ [i#et al.#1i] Further evidence supporting a causal relationship between prone sleeping position and SIDS. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 1992;[b#28(Suppl. 1)#1b]:S9-S12.
72. Taylor BJ. A review of epidemiological studies of sudden infant death syndrome in southern New Zealand. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 1991; [b#27#1b]:344-48.
73. Beal SM. Sudden infant death syndrome in South Australia 1968-97. Part I: Changes over time. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 2000;[b#36#1b]:540-47.
74. Mitchell EA. International trends in postneonatal mortality. [i#Arch Dis Child#1i] 1990;[b#65#1b]:607-09.
75. Gilbert R. The changing epidemiology of SIDS. [i#Arch Dis Child#1i] 1994;[b#70#1b]:445-49.
76. Golding J, Limerick S, MacFarlane A. Variation of incidence with time, place, and age of infant. In: Golding J, Limerick S, MacFarlane A (eds). [i#Sudden Infant Death: Patterns, Puzzles, and Problems#1i]. Shepton Mallet, UK: Open Books Publishing Ltd, 1985, pp. 22-42.
77. Willinger M, Hoffman HJ, Hartford RB. Infant sleep position and risk for sudden infant death syndrome: Report of meeting held January 13 and 14, 1994, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 1994;[b#93#1b]:814-19.
78. McKee M, Fulop N, Bouvier P [i#et al.#1i] Preventing sudden infant deaths - the slow diffusion of an idea. [i#Health Policy#1i] 1996;[b#37#1b] 117-35.
79. Pollack HA, Frohna JG. Infant sleep placement after the back to sleep campaign. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 2002;[b#109#1b]:608-14.
80. Spencer N, Logan S. Sudden unexpected death in infancy and socioeconomic status: A systematic review. [i#J Epidemiol Community Health#1i] 2004; [b#58#1b]:366-73.
81. Ponsonby AL, Dwyer T, Kasl SV, Couper D, Cochrane JA. Correlates of prone infant sleeping position by period of birth. [i#Arch Dis Child#1i] 1995;[b#72#1b]:204-08.
82. Ebrahim S, Smith GD. Health promotion for coronary heart disease: Past, present and future. [i#Eur Heart J#1i] 1998;[b#19#1b]:1751-57.
83. Engelberts AC. [i#Cot Death in The Netherlands: An Epidemiological Study#1i] Amsterdam: VU University Press, 1991.
84. Hoffman HJ, Hillman LS. Epidemiology of the sudden infant death syndrome: Maternal, neonatal, and postneonatal risk factors. [i#Clin Perinatol.#1i] 1992;[b#19#1b]:717-37.
85. Crowley P. Antenatal corticosteroids - current thinking. [i#BJOG#1i] 2003;[b#110 (Suppl. 20)#1b]:77-78.
86. Antman EM, Lau J, Kupelnick B, Mosteller F, Chalmers TC. A comparison of results of meta-analyses of randomized control trials and recommendations of clinical experts. Treatments for myocardial infarction. [i#JAMA#1i] 1992;[b#268#1b]:240-48.
87. Egger M, Schneider M, Davey SG. Spurious precision? Meta-analysis of observational studies. [i#BMJ#1i] 1998;[b#316#1b]:140-44.
88. Ioannidis JP, Haidich AB, Pappa M [i#et al.#1i] Comparison of evidence of treatment effects in randomized and nonrandomized studies. [i#JAMA#1i] 2001;[b#286#1b]:821-30.
89. Carpenter RG. Sudden and unexpected deaths in infancy (cot death). In: Camps FE, Carpenter RG (eds). [i#Sudden and Unexpected Deaths in Infancy (Cot Death)#1i]. Bristol. John Wright, 1972, pp. 7-15.
90. Wigfield RE, Fleming PJ, Berry PJ, Rudd PT, Golding J. Can the fall in Avon's sudden infant death rate be explained by changes in sleeping position? [i#BMJ#1i] 1992;[b#304#1b]:282-83.
91. Hiley CM, Morley CJ. Risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome: further change in 1992-3. [i#BMJ#1i] 1996;[b#312#1b]:1397-98.
92. Willinger M, Hoffman HJ, Wu KT [i#et al.#1i] Factors associated with the transition to nonprone sleep positions of infants in the United States: the National Infant Sleep Position Study. [i#JAMA#1i] 1998;[b#280#1b] 329-35.
93. Senecal J, Roussey M, Defawe G, Delahaye M, Piquemal B. Procubitus et mort subite inattendue du nourrison. [i#Arch Fr Pediatr#1i] 1987;[b#44#1b] 131-36
94. Beal SM, Finch CF. An overview of retrospective case-control studies investigating the relationship between prone sleeping position and SIDS. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 1991;[b#27#1b]:334-39.
95. Lee M, Davies DP, Chan YF. Prone or supine for preterm babies? [i#Lancet#1i] 1988;[b#1#1b]:1332.
96. Bouvier-Colle MH, Varnoux V, Hausherr E. Revue bibliographique des etudes sur la mort subite en relation avec la position de sommeil chez le nourrisson. Proceedings of Reunion du Groupe d'Etudes de Langue Francaise sur la mort subite du nourrisson. Nice. France. 1990.
97. Mitchell EA, Scragg R, Stewart AW [i#et al.#1i] Results from the first year of the New Zealand cot death study. [i#NZ Med J#1i] 1991;[b#104#1b] 71-76.
98. Jorch G, Schmidt TS, Bajanowski T [i#et al.#1i] Risk factors for sudden infant death (SID): Epidemiologic study of two German districts 1990-1992 epidemiologische risikofaktoren des plotzlichen kindstods. Ergebnisse der westfalischen kindstodstudie 1990-1992. [i#Monatsschr Kinderheilkd#1i] 1994;[b#142#1b]:45-51.
99. Gormally S, Matthews TG. Sleep position and SIDS in Irish infants. [i#Ir Med J#1i] 1994;[b#87#1b]:58.
100. Andersen M, Arnestad M, Rognum TO, Vege A. Krybbedod i ostlandsregionen 1984-92. En kartlegging av risikofaktorer. [Crib death in the eastern regions of Norway 1984-1992. A survey of risk factors]. [i#Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen#1i] 1995;[b#115#1b]:34-37.
101. Mitchell EA, Tuohy PG, Brunt JM [i#et al.#1i] Risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome following the prevention campaign in New Zealand: a prospective study. [i#Pediatrics#1i] 1997;[b#100#1b]:835-40.
102. Schellscheidt J, Ott A, Jorch G. Epidemiological features of sudden infant death after a German intervention campaign in 1992. [i#Eur J Pediatr#1i] 1997;[b#156#1b]:655-60.
103. Kleemann WJ, Schlaud M, Fieguth A, Hiller AS, Rothamel T, Troger HD. Body and head position, covering of the head by bedding and risk of sudden infant death (SID). [i#Int J Legal Med#1i] 1999;[b#112#1b]:22-26.
104. Skadberg BT, Morild I, Markestad T. Abandoning prone sleeping: Effect on the risk of sudden infant death syndrome. [i#J Pediatr#1i] 1998;[b#132#1b] 340-43.
105. L'Hoir MP, Engelberts AC, van Well GT [i#et al.#1i] Case-control study of current validity of previously described risk factors for SIDS in The Netherlands. [i#Arch Dis Child#1i] 1998;[b#79#1b]:386-93.
106. Mitchell EA, Thach BT, Thompson JM, Williams S. Changing infants' sleep position increases risk of sudden infant death syndrome. New Zealand Cot Death Study. [i#Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med#1i] 1999;[b#153#1b]:1136-41.
107. Dwyer T, Ponsonby AL, Gibbons LE, Newman NM. Prone sleeping position and SIDS: Evidence from recent case-control and cohort studies in Tasmania. [i#J Paediatr Child Health#1i] 1991;[b#27#1b]:340-43.
108. Toro K, Sotonyi P. Distribution of prenatal and postnatal risk factors for sudden infant death in Budapest. [i#Scand J Prim Health Care#1i] 2001;[b#19#1b]:178-80.
109. Saternus KS. Plötzlicher Kindstod-eine Folge der Bauchlage? [i#Festschrift Professor Leithoff#1i]. Heidelberg: Kriminalistik Verlag, 1985, pp. 67-81.
110. Kahn A, Blum D, Hennart P [i#et al.#1i] A critical comparison of the history of sudden-death infants and infants hospitalised for near-miss for SIDS. [i#Eur J Pediatr#1i] 1984;[b#143#1b]:103-07.
111. Nelson EA, Taylor BJ, Mackay SC. Child care practices and the sudden infant death syndrome. [i#Aust Paediatr J#1i] 1989;[b#25#1b]:202-04.