Conflicting notions of research ethics: The mutually challenging traditions of social scientists and medical researchers

Social Science and Medicine

Volumn 61, Issue 8, 2005, Pages 1741-1749

  Hoeyer, Klaus ^a   Dahlager, Lisa ^a   Lynöe, Niels ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF COPENHAGEN   (Denmark)

Author keywords

Anthropology; Clinical medicine; Informed consent; Politics of research; Research ethics

Indexed keywords

ETHICS;

ANTHROPOLOGY; CONFLICT; HUMAN; INFORMED CONSENT; MEDICAL ETHICS; MEDICAL RESEARCH; MEDICAL STAFF; MEDICINE; POLITICS; PROTECTION; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; REVIEW;

EID: 22144498034     PISSN: 02779536     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2005.03.026     Document Type: Article

References (47)

1. V. Amit The University as Panopticon. Moral claims and attacks on academic freedom M. Strathern Audit cultures. Anthropological studies in accountability, ethics and the academy 2000 Routledge London 215 235
2. R. Arnst Participation approaches to the research process J. Servaes T. Jacobsen S. White Participatory communication for social change 1996 Sage Publications London 109 126
3. T. Ashburn, S. Wilson, and B. Eisenstein Human tissue in the genomic era of medicine Archives of International Medicine 160 2000 3377 3384
4. L.M. Beskow, W. Burke, J.F. Merz, P.A. Barr, S. Terry, V.B. Penchazadeh, L.O. Gostin, M. Gwinn, and M. Khoury Informed consent for population-based research involving genetics Journal of the American Medical Association 286 18 2001 2315 2321
5. C. Bosk All god's mistakes. Genetic counseling in a pediatric hospital 1992 University of Chicago Press London
6. C. Bosk Irony, ethnography, and informed consent B. Hoffmaster Bioethics in social context 2001 Temple University Press Philadelphia 199 220
7. B. Brody A historical introduction to the requirement of obtaining informed consent from research participants L. Doyal J. Tobias Informed consent in medical research 2001 BMJ Books London 7 14
8. M. Bulmer Ethical problems in social research: The case of Covert participant observation M. Bulmer Social research ethics. An examination of the merits of covert participant observation 1982 Macmillan Press London 3 12
9. L. Butt The suffering stranger: Medical anthropology and internationel morality Medical Anthropology 21 1 2002 1 32
10. P. Caplan Introduction: Anthropology and ethics P. Caplan The ethics of anthropology: Debates and dilemmas 2003 Routledge London 1 33
11. J. Cassell, and A. Young Why we should not seek individual informed consent for participation in health services research Journal of Medical Ethics 28 2002 313 317
12. S. Cavan Investigative social research: Individual and team field resarch. A review The American Journal of Sociology 83 3 1977 809 811
13. R. D'Andrade Objectivity and militancy 1: A debate. Moral models in anthropology Current Anthropology 36 3 1995
14. E. Durkheim Professional ethics E. Durkheim Professional ethics and civic morals 1957 Routledge London
15. R. Eliasson, and P. Nygren Psykiatrisk Verksamhet. Samhälle, Människosyn och Modern Själavård 1981 Prisma Stockholm
16. R. Eliasson, and P. Nygren Närstudier i Psykoterapi. Psykiatrisk Verksamhet II 1983 Prisma Stockholm
17. C. Fluehr- Lobban Informed consent in anthropological research: We are not exempt Human Organization 53 1 1994 1 10
18. J. Gabe, M. Calnan, and M. Bury Introduction J. Gabe M. Calnan M. Bury The sociology of the health service 1991 Routledge London 1 10
19. C. Geertz Available light. Anthropological reflections on philosophical topics 2000 Princeton University Press Princeton
20. H. Greely Informed consent and other ethical issues in human population genetics Annual Review of Genetics 35 2001 785 800
21. E.H. Hansen Censorship or bias: The conditions for critical medical sociology Social Science and Medicine 33 6 2003 743 744
22. F.V. Harrison Decolonizing anthropology. Moving toward and anthropology for liberation 1991 Association of Black Anthropologists American Anthropological Association Arlington, Virginia 1 13
23. K. Hastrup A passage to anthropology. Between experience and theory 1995 Routledge London
24. L. Humphreys Tearoom trade, impersonal sex in public places 1975 Aldine Chicago
25. I. Hydle Snedvriden Debatt om Forskningsetik [Twisted debate about research ethics] Läkartidningen 96 48 1999 5338 5339
26. I. Hydle Reflexion Över Vad Medicinsk Kunskap Gör Med Människor Läkartidningen 97 4 2000 351
27. S. Joffe, F. Cook, P. Cleary, J. Clark, and J. Weeks Quality of informed consent in cancer clinical trials: A cross-sectional survey The Lancet 358 2001 1772 1777
28. A. Kuper Anthropology and anthropologists. The Modern British School 3rd ed. 1999 Routledge London
29. R.E. Lappalainen Står Yrkesetikerna över vanlig moral. En Fallbeskrivning VEST 9 4 1996 57 65
30. A. Lindblom Jag Bör Ha Sama Rätt som Alla Försö kspersoner [I should have the same rights as every research participant] Läkartidningen 96 48 1999 5339
31. N. Lynöe Mellan Cowboyetik och Scoutmoral. Medicinsk Forskningsetik i Pratiken [Between cowboy ethics and scout morality. Medical research ethics in practice] 1999 Liber Stockholm
32. J. Marks "We're going to tell these people who they really are": Science and relatedness S. Franklin S. McKinnon Relative values. Reconfiguring Kinship studies 2001 Duke University Press Durham and London 355 383
33. P. Marshall Human subjects protections, institutional review boards, and cultural anthropological research Anthropological Quarterly 76 2 2003 269 286
34. D. Mills 'Like a Horse in Blinkers'. A Political History of Anthropology's Research Ethics P. Caplan The Ethics of Anthropology: Debates and Dilemmas 2003 Routledge London 37 54
35. L. Nader Up the anthropologist - perspectives gained from studying up D. Hymes Reinventing anthropology 1972 Pantheon Books New York 284 311
36. L. Nader The life of the law. Anthropological projects 2002 University of California Press Berkeley
37. P. Örn Skilda Synsätt på Forskningsetik Upphov till Långdragen Konflikt [Conflicting views on research ethics reason for protracted conflict] Läkartidningen 96 42 1999 4503 4505
38. P. Pels Professions of duplexity. A prehistory of ethical codes in anthropology Current Anthropology 40 2 1999 101 114
39. D.J. Rothman Strangers at the bedside. A history of how law and bioethics transformed medical decision making 1991 BasicBooks New York
40. L. Sachs Att Leva med Risk. Fem Kvinnor, Gentester och Kunskapens Frukter [Living with risk. Five women, genetic tests and the fruits of knowledge] 1998 Gedins Smedjebacken, Sweden
41. N. Scheper-Hughes Ire in Ireland Ethnography 1 2000 118 140
42. L. Scocozza Forkning for Livet. De Medicinske Forskningsetiks Forudsætninger og Praktikker - En Sociologisk Analyse [Research for life. The preconditions and practices of medical research ethics - a sociological analysis] 1994 Akademick Forlag Copenhagen
43. M. Tattersall Examining informed consent to cancer clinical trials The Lancet 358 2001 1742 1743
44. L. Terenius Citaten Borda ha Kontrollerats [The quotes should have been verified] Läkartidningen 96 48 1999 5340
45. S. Van der Geest Censorship and medical sociology in the Netherlands Social Science and Medicine 28 12 1989 1339 1341
46. M. Wax Commentary Human Organization 54 3 1995 330 331
47. World Medical Association. (2002). Declaration of Helsinki.