Flixborough: The explosion and its aftermath

Process Safety and Environmental Protection

Volumn 82, Issue 2 B, 2004, Pages 105-127

  Venart, J E S ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NEW BRUNSWICK   (Canada)

Author keywords

Cyclohexane; Disaster; Flixborough; Loss prevention; Risk assessment; Vapour cloud explosion

Indexed keywords

CHEMICAL PLANTS; DETONATION; FIRES; PIPE; RISK ASSESSMENT; WELDING; WIND EFFECTS;

CYCLOHEXANE; VAPOR CLOUD EXPLOSION;

EXPLOSIONS;

EID: 1942445117     PISSN: 09575820     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1205/095758204322972753     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. Ale, B.J.M. and Bruning, F., 1980a, Unconfined vapour cloud explosions, Letter, Chem Eng, 352: 47-49.
2. Ale, B.J.M. and Bruning, F., 1980b, Unconfined vapour cloud explosions, Letter of reply, Chem Eng, 358: 494.
3. Amtec Engineering Inc., 1996, Tecplot User's Manual, version 7 (Bellevue, WA).
4. Artingstall, G., 1974, Appraisal of the damage in the reactor vessels in Section 25 A, Report no. 4, Part I, Safety in Mines Research Establishment (SMRE), September 11.
5. Au-Yang, M.K., 1999, Common mistakes and misconceptions in flow-induced vibration and coupled fluid-structural dynamics analysis, ASME PVPD, 29: 6.1-6.17.
6. Ayre, E., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Thirty-fourth Day, November 15.
7. Ball, J.G., 1975, After the Flixborough Report: do we know the real truth?, Proc Eng, 56(12): 39-46.
8. Ball, J.G., 1976, Was this what caused the Flixborough explosion?, Proc Eng, 57(1): 53-60.
9. Batstone, R.J., 1975, Description and results of bellows test program and 20 dog leg pipe tests, Cremer and Warner Report no. 7, January 7.
10. Bjerketvedt, D., Bakke, J.R. and van Wingerden, K., 1997, Gas explosion handbook, J Hazard Mater, 52: 1-150.
11. Butler, P., 1975, The lessons to be learned from the Flixborough inquiry, Engineer (GB), 241(6247): 20-24.
12. Carter, B., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Fourth Day, September 12.
13. Center for Chemical Process Safety (CPPS), 1994a, Guidelines for evaluating the characteristics of vapor-cloud explosions, flash fires, and BLEVEs (American Institute of Chemical Engineers, New York, USA), Section 2.4, Fig. 2.4, p 12.
14. Center for Chemical Process Safety (CPPS), 1994b, Guidelines for evaluating the characteristics of vapor-cloud explosions, flash fires, and BLEVEs (American Institute of Chemical Engineers, New York), Appendix F, pp 363-382.
15. Colquhoun, D.C., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Third Day, September 11.
16. Cottrell, A.H. and Swan, P.R., 1976, A metallurgical examination of the eight-inch line, Chem Eng, April: 266-274.
17. Cox, J.I., 1976, Flixborough-some additional lessons, Chem Eng, May: 353-358, 387.
18. Dickinson, J., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Second Day, September 10.
19. EJMA, 1993, Standards for the Expansion Joint Manufacturers Association, Inc., 6th edition (Tarrytown, NY, USA).
20. Fishburn, B., Slagg, N. and Lu, P., 1981, Blast effect from a pancake shaped fuel-drop-air cloud detonation (theory and experiment), J Hazard Mater, 5: 65-75.
21. Flomerics, 1994, FloVent Reference Manual, Document no. FloVent/RM/0994/1/0 (Flomerics Ltd, Surrey).
22. Foley, J.H., 1974a, Metallurgical examination of the damaged pipes from section 25A, Report no. 1, Part I, Safety in Mines Research Establishment (SMRE), September 10.
23. Foley, J.H., 1974b, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Thirty-third Day, November 14, pp 34-35.
24. Foley, J.H., 1974c, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Thirty-fourth Day, November 15.
25. Foley, J.H., 1974d, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Thirty-seventh Day, p 26-27.
26. Foley, J.H., 1974e, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Thirty-seventh Day, p 21, para 5.
27. Foley, J.H. and Nicholson, C.E., 1974, Metallurgical examination of the damaged pipes from Section 25A, Report no. 1, Part III, Safety in Mines Research Establishment (SMRE), November 8.
28. Fu, W.B. and Eyre, J.A., 1974, Unconfined vapour cloud explosions, Letter, Chem Eng, 359/360: 368.
29. Games, G.A.C. and Waterhouse, D., 1974, Construction of and tests on a reconstructed bridging pipe assembly, Report no. 2, Part II, Safety in Mines Research Establishment (SMRE), November 10.
30. Gill, S.S., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Thirty seventh Day, pp 51-52.
31. Goodchild, M.B., 1975, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Fifty-fourth Day, January 24, pp 24-26.
32. Gromles, M.A., 1984, A simple approach to transient two-phase level swell, Multi-phase Flow and Heat Transfer III, Vol 1 (Miami Beach, FL, USA), pp 527-538.
33. Grover, F.H., 1974, Infrasonic and seismic wave records from the Flixborough and St Bridget explosions, AWRE Report no 046/74, p. 27.
34. Gugan, K., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Thirty-ninth Day, p. 17, November 22.
35. Gugan, K., 1976, Flixborough-A combustion specialists view, Chem Eng, 341-352, 387.
36. Gugan, K., 1979, Unconfined Vapour Cloud Explosions (IChemE, Rugby, UK).
37. Gugan, K., 1980a, Unconfined vapour cloud explosions, Letter of reply, Chem Eng, 358: 491-493.
38. Gugan, K., 1980b, Unconfined vapour cloud explosions, Letter of reply, Chem Eng, 359/360: 567.
39. Gugan, K., 2000, Flixborough kicking, Letter, Chem Eng, 25: 30.
40. Harris, R.J., 1983, The Investigation and Control of Gas Explosions in Buildings and Heating Plant (E&FN Spon, London, in association with British Gas, UK).
41. Harris, R.J. and Wickens, M.J., 1989, Understanding vapour cloud explosions-an experimental study, 55th Autumn Meeting of the Institute of Gas Engineers, Kensington, London, UK.
42. Harry, L., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Third Day, September 11.
43. Høiset, S., Hjertager, B.H., Solberg, T. and Malo, K.A., 2000, Flixborough revisited-an explosion simulation approach, J Hazard Mater, 77(1-3): 1-9.
44. Humberside Police, 1974, Major Incident files, Explosion, Nypro (UK) Ltd, June 1, 1974. Books 1-4 plus photograph albums 1-6.
45. Jakubauskas, V.F. and Weaver, D.S., 1998a, Transverse vibrations of bellows expansion joints. Part I: fluid added mass, J Fluids Struct, 12: 445-456.
46. Jakubauskas, V.F. and Weaver, D.S., 1998b, Transverse vibrations of bellows expansion joints. Part II: beam model development and experimental verification, J Fluids Struct, 12: 457-473.
47. Jones, T.B. and Spracklen, C.T., 1974, Ionospheric effects of the Flixborough explosion, Nature, 250: 719-721.
48. Kataoka, I. and Ishii, M., 1987, Drift flux model for large diameter pipe and new correlations for pool void fraction, Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 30(9): 1927-1939.
49. King, E., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Second Day, September 10.
50. King, R., 1975, Flixborough-role of water re-examined, Proc Eng, September, 69-72.
51. King, R., 1977, Latent superheat-a hazard of two-phase liquid systems, Chem Proc Haz IChemE Symp Ser, 49: 139-145.
52. King, R., 1999, Flixborough, 25 years on, Process Eng, June: 27-28.
53. King, R., 2000, Flixborough: re-open public inquiry, Letter, Chem Eng, May 25: 30.
54. Kitching, R., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Thirty seventh Day, 51-52.
55. Kletz, T., 2000, Flixborough, no whitewash, Letter, Chem Eng, April 20:18.
56. Krasnov, V.M., Drobzheva, Ya.V., Venart, J.E.S. and Lastovicka, J., 2003, A re-analysis of the atmospheric and ionospheric effects of the Flixborough explosion, J Atmos Solar-Terrest Phys, 65: 1205-1212.
57. Leclude, J. and Venart, J.E.S., 1996, Single and two-phase discharge from a pressurized vessel, Rev Gen Therm, 35: 503-516.
58. Leclude, J. and Venart, J.E.S., 1997, Determination of the amounts discharged in the Flixborough disaster, unpublished work, University of New Brunswick, Canada.
59. Marshall, H., 1974, Official Statement to Humberside Police, H Div., Scunthorpe, June 9, 1974, Humberside Police Book 1, pp 167-169.
60. Meyer, R., 1987, Explosives, 3rd edition (revised) (VCH, New York, USA) pp 239 and 367.
61. Miller, K.J., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd, Flixborough, Fifty-first Day and Fifty-second Day, pp 16 and 27.
62. Newland, D.E., 1964, Buckling of double bellows expansion joints under internal pressure, J Mech Eng Sci, 6: 270-277.
63. Newland, D.E., 1976, Buckling and rupture of the double bellows expansion joint assembly at Flixborough, Proc R Soc Lond, A351: 525-549.
64. NIST, 1999, Standard Reference Database 4; Thermophysical Properties of Hydrocarbon Mixtures, Supertrapp, Version 3.00 (National Institute Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, USA).
65. Phillips, H., 1981, Unconfined vapour cloud explosions: a new look at Gugan's book, Chem Eng, 369: 286-287.
66. Rajaratnam, N. and Chamani, M.R., 1995, Energy loss at drops, J Hydraul Res, 33: 373-384.
67. Ramier, S. and Venart, J.E.S., 2000, Boiling liquid expanding vapour explosions: dynamic re-pressurization and two-phase discharge, Hazards XV, IChemE Symp Ser 147: 527-537.
68. Roberts, A.F. and Pritchard, D K., 1982, Blast effect from unconfined vapour cloud explosions, J. Occup Accidents, 3: 231-247.
69. Ryder, D.A., 1974, Minutes of Proceedings at the Court of Inquiry; into the disaster which occurred at Nypro (UK) Ltd., Flixborough, Thirty seventh Day, pp 57-58.
70. Sadee, C., Samuels, D.E. and O'Brien, T.P., 1976/1977, The characteristics of the explosion at the Nypro (UK) Flixborough Plant on 1st June 1974, J Occup Accidents, 1: 203-235.
71. Secretary of State for Employment, 1975, The Flixborough Disaster (HMSO, London).
72. Snedden, N.W., 1981, The strength and stability of corrugated bellows expansion joints, PhD Thesis, Churchill College, Cambridge, UK.
73. Snedden, N.W., 1985, Analysis and design guidance for the lateral stiffness of bellows expansion joints, Thin-Walled Structures, 3: 145-162.
74. Snee, T., 2004, Flixborough: water hypothesis laid to rest?, TCE, February, pp 28-29.
75. Swan, R., 2000, This is beginning to look like a cover-up, Editorial, Chem Eng, April 6:2.
76. Teng-yang, R., Sollows, K.F. and Venart, J.E.S., 2000, Froude modeling of the Flixborough 'By-pass' pipe, Hazards XV, IChemE Symp Ser, 147: 139-154.
77. Usher, A., 1979, The Flixborough disaster, Med Leg J, 43(3): 84-102.
78. Venart, J.E.S., 1999, Flixborough; a final resolution?, INTERFLAM'99, Vol 1, Grayson, S. (ed.), pp 257-272.
79. Venart, J.E.S. and Tan, D.M., 2000, Flixborough; twenty-five years after, the final resolution?, Proceedings of ICPVT-9, Sydney, April 9-14, Vol 2, pp 525-539.
80. Warner, F., 1975, The Flixborough, Chem Eng Prog, 71(9): 77-84.
81. Warner, F. and Newland, D.E., 1975, Flixborough Explosion-Mechanical engineering provides the key, Chart. Mech. Eng. (GB), June: 76-81.
82. Weaver, D.S. and Ainsworth, P., 1989, Flow induced vibration in bellows, ASME J Press Vessel Technol, 111: 402-406.
83. Wehmeier, G., Westphal, F. and Friedel, L., 1994, Pressure relief system design for vapour or two-phase flow?, Trans IChemE, Part B, Proc Safe Env Prot, 72: 142-148.
84. Westgate, K., 1976, Flixborough-the human response, University of Bradford, Disaster Research Unit, Occasional Paper no. 7, January 1975 (reprinted September 1976).