Phase mixing modeling in multiphase reactors containing gas bubble: A review

International Journal of Chemical Reactor Engineering

Volumn 2, Issue , 2004, Pages

  Lefebvre, Sylvain ^a   Chaouki, Jamal ^a   Guy, Christophe ^a  

^a ÉCOLE POLYTECHNIQUE DE MONTRÉAL   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

BUBBLES (IN FLUIDS); HYDRODYNAMICS; MASS TRANSFER; MATHEMATICAL MODELS; MULTIPHASE FLOW; PETROCHEMICALS;

AXIAL DISPERSION MODEL (ADM); GAS BUBBLES; MULTIPHASE REACTORS; PHASE MIXING;

CHEMICAL REACTORS;

EID: 18444389981     PISSN: 15426580     EISSN: 15426580     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2202/1542-6580.1106     Document Type: Review

References (132)

1. Aufderheide, E. and E. Vogelpohl, "Convective model to interpret dispersed-phase residence time measurements in pulsed liquid/liquid extractors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 41, 1747-1757 (1986).
2. Becker, S., A. Sokolichin and G. Eigenberger, "Gas-liquid flow in bubble columns and loop reactors: part II. Comparison of detailed experiments and flow simulations.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 49, 5747-5762 (1994).
3. Bhaga, D. and M. Weber, "Bubbles in viscous liquids: shapes, wakes and velocities.", Journal of Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 105, 61-85 (1981).
4. Bhaga, D. and M. E. Weber, "In-line interaction of pair of bubbles in a viscous liquid.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 35, 2467-2474 (1980).
5. Bhatia, V. K. and N. Epstein (1974). Three-phase fluidization: a generalized wake model. Fluidization and its application. H. Angélino, Couderc, J.P., Gilbert, H. Laguérie, C. Toulouse, France, Cépaduès-Editions: 380-392.
6. Briens, C. L., A. Margaritis and G. Wild, "A new stochastic model and measurement errors in residence time distributions of multiphase reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 50, 279-287 (1995).
7. Cassanello, M., F. Larachi, C. Guy and J. Chaouki, "Solids mixing in gas-liquid-solid fluidized beds: experiments and modelling.", Chemical engineering Science, Vol. 51, 2011-2020 (1996).
8. Cassanello, M., F. Larachi, A. Kemoun, M. H. Al-Dahhan and M. P. Dudukovic, "Inferring liquid chaotic dynamics in bubble columns using CARPT.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 56, 6125-6134 (2001).
9. Cassanello, M., F. Larachi, M.-N. Marie, C. Guy and J. Chaouki, "Experimental characterization of the solid phase chaotic dynamics in three-phase fluidization.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, Vol. 34, 2971-2980 (1995).
10. Chen, R. C., J. Reese and L. S. Fan, "Flow structure in a three-dimensional bubble column and three-phase fluidized bed.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 40, 1093-1104 (1994).
11. Cockx, A., Z. Do-Quang, A. Line and M. Roustan, "Use of computational fluid dynamics for simulating hydrodynamics and mass transfer in industrial ozonation tower.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 5085-5090 (1999).
12. Colella, D., D. Vinci, R. Bagatin, M. Masi and A. B. E. Bakr, "A study on coalescence and breakage mechanisms in three different bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 4767-4777 (1999).
13. Dayan, A. and S. Zalmanovich, "Axial dispersion and entrainment of particles in wakes of bubbles.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 37, 1253-1257 (1982).
14. Deckwer, W.-D. and A. Schumpe, "Bubble columns - the state of the art and current trends.", International Chemical Engineering, Vol. 27, 405-422 (1987).
15. Deckwer, W.-D. and A. Schumpe, "Improved tools for bubble column reactor design and scale-up.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 48, 889-911 (1993).
16. Degaleesan, S., "Fluid dynamic measurements and modelling of liquid mixing in bubble columns", Department of chemical engineering, Saint-Louis, Washington university (1997)
17. Degaleesan, S., M. P. Dudukovic, B. A. Toseland and B. L. Bhatt, "A two-compartment convective-diffusion model for slurry bubble column reactors.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, Vol. 36, 4670-4680 (1997).
18. Degaleesan, S., S. Roy, B. Kumar and M. P. Dudukovic, "Liquid mixing based on convection and turbulent dispersion in bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 51, 1967-1976 (1996).
19. Delnoij, E., J. A. M. Kuipers and W. P. M. Van Swaaij, "Computional fluid dynamics applied to gas-liquid contactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 3623-3638 (1997).
20. Deshpande, N. S., M. Dinkar and J. B. Joshi, "Disengagement of the gas phase in bubble columns.", Int J. Multiphase Flow, Vol. 21, 1191-1201 (1995).
21. Devanathan, N., D. Moslemian and M. P. Dudukovic, "Flow mapping in bubble columns using CARPT.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 45, 2285-2291 (1990).
22. Dudukovic, M. P., F. Larachi and P. L. Mills, "Multiphase catalytic reactors: a perspective on current knowledge and future trends.", catalysis reviews, Vol. 44, 123-246 (2002).
23. El-Temtamy, S. A., Y. O. El-Sharnoubi and M. M. El-Halwagi, "Liquid dispersion in gas-liquid fluidized beds Part I: Axial dispersion. The axially dispersed plug-flow model.", The Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 18, 151-159 (1979a).
24. El-Temtamy, S. A. and N. Epstein, "Bubble wake solids content in three-phase fluidized beds.", Int J Multiphase Flow, Vol. 4, 19-31 (1978).
25. El-Temtamy, S. A. and N. Epstein, "Simultaneous solids entrainment and de-entrainment above a three-phase fluidized bed.", Fluidization, Vol., 519-528 (1980).
26. Epstein, N., "Three-phase fluidization: some knowledge gaps.", The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Vol. 59, 649-657 (1981).
27. Fan, L.-S., "Gas-liquid-solid fluidisation engineering", Butterworths, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, (1989).
28. Fan, L.-S. and K. Tsuchiya, "Bubble wake dynamics in liquid and liquid-solid suspensions", Butterworths, Massachusetts institute of technology, (1990).
29. Fan, L.-S. and G. Yang (2002). Gas-liquid-solid three-phase fluidization. Handbook of fluidization and fluid-particle systems. Y. a. D. Wen-Ching, M. Chapter 27.
30. Fan, L. T. and Y. Chang, "Mixing of large particles in two-dimesional gas fluidized beds.", The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Vol. 57, 88-97 (1979).
31. Field, R. W. and J. F. Davidson, "Axial dispersion in bubble columns.", Institution of Chemical Engineers, Vol. 58, 228-236 (1980).
32. Fischer, J., H. Kumazawa and E. Sada, "On the local gas holdup and flow pattern in standard-type bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering and Processing, Vol. 33, 7-21 (1994).
33. Franz, K., T. Börner, H. J. Kantorek and R. Buchholz, "Flow structures in bubble columns.", German Chemical Engineering, Vol. 7, 365-374 (1984).
34. Godbole, S. P., M. F. Honath and Y. T. Shah, "Holdup structure in highly viscous newtonian and non-newtonian liquids in bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Communications, Vol. 16, 119-134 (1982).
35. Godbole, S. P., S. Joseph and Y. T. Shah, "Hydrodynamics and mass transfer in a bubble column with an organic liquid.", The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Vol. 62, 440-445 (1984).
36. Grandjean, B. P. A. and J. Chaouki, "Application of a monte carlo method to solid flow pattern visualization in CFB.", Chemical Reactor Technology for Environmentally Safe Reactors and Products, Vol., 537-546 (1993).
37. Grandjean, B. P. A., C. Hyndman and C. Guy, "A monte-carlo simulation of gas phase hydrodynamics in bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Communications, Vol. 133, 93-105 (1995).
38. Groen, J. S., R. G. C. Oldeman, R. F. Mudde and H. E. A. Van den Akker, "Coherent structures and axial dispersion in bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 51, 2511-2520 (1996).
39. Grossman, S. and I. Procaccia, "Unified theory of relative turbulent diffusion.", Physical review, Vol. A29, 1358-1365 (1984).
40. Gunst, R. F. and R. L. Mason, "Regression analysis and its application", Dekker, (1980).
41. Hilborn, C., "Chaos and nonlinear dynamics", Oxford university press, (2000).
42. Hyndman, C. and C. Guy, "Gas phase flow in bubble columns: a convective phenomenon.", The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Vol. 73, 426-434 (1995a).
43. Hyndman, C. and C. Guy, "Gas-phase hydrodynamics in bubble columns.", Transactions of the Institute of Chemical Engineers, Vol. 73, 302-307 (1995b).
44. Hyndman, C., F. Larachi and C. Guy, "Understanding gas-phase hydrodynamics in bubble columns: a convective model based on kinetic theory.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 63-77 (1997).
45. Jean, R. H., W. T. Tang and L.-S. Fan, "The sedimentation-dispersion model for slurry bubble columns.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 35, 662-665 (1989).
46. Joseph, S. and Y. T. Shah, "Errors caused by tracer solubility in the measurement of gas phase axial dispersion.", The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Vol. 64, 380-386 (1986).
47. Joseph, S., Y. T. Shah and B. G. Kelkar, "Simple experimental technique to measure gas phase dispersion in bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Communications, Vol. 28, 223-230 (1984).
48. Joshi, J. B., "Computational flow modeling and design of bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 56, 5893-5933 (2001).
49. Joshi, J. B. and Y. T. Shah, "Hydrodynamic and mixing models for bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering Communications, Vol. à voir, 165-199 (1981).
50. Joshi, J. B. and M. M. Sharma, "A circulation cell model for bubble columns.", Transactions of the Institute of chemical Engineers, Vol. 57, 244-251 (1979).
51. Joshi, J. B., V. S. Vitankar, A. A. Kulkarni, M. T. Dhotre and K. Ekambara, "Coherent flow structures in bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 57, 3157-3183 (2002).
52. Kantak, M. V., R. P. Hesketh and B. G. Kelkar, "Effect of gas and liquid properties on gas phase dispersion in bubble columns.", The Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 59, 91-100 (1995).
53. Kara, S., B. Kelkar, Y. T. Shah and N. L. Carr, "Hydrodynamics and axial mixing in a three-phase bubble column.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry. Process Design and Development, Vol. 21, 584-594 (1982).
54. Kawagoe, M., T. Otake and C. W. Robinson, "Gas-phase mixing in bubble columns.", Journal of Chemical Engineering of Japan, Vol. 22, 136-142 (1989).
55. Kelkar, B. G., S. P. Godbole, M. F. Honath, Y. T. Shah, N. L. Carr and W.-D. Deckwer, " Effect of addition of alcohols on gas holdup and backmixing in bubble columns.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 29, 361-369 (1983).
56. Kennel, M. B. and S. Isabelle, "Method to distinguish possible chaos from noise and determine embeedding parameters.", Physical review A., Vol. 46, 3111-3118 (1992).
57. Kiared, K., F. Larachi, C. Guy and C. Chaouki, "Trajectory length and residence-time distributions of the solids in three-phase fluidized beds.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 3931-3939 (1997).
58. Kikuchi, R., A. Tsutsumi and K. Yoshida, "Fractal aspect of hydrodynamics in a three-phase fluidized bed.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 51, 2865-2870 (1996).
59. Kikuchi, R., T. Yano, A. Tsutsumi, K. Yoshida, M. Punchochar and J. Drahos, "Diagnosis of chaotic dynamics of bubble motion in a bubble column.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 3741-3745 (1997).
60. Kim, S. D. and Y. Kang, "Heat and mass transfer in three-phase fluidized-bed reactors-an overview.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 3639-3660 (1997).
61. Krishna, R., J. W. A. De Swart, D. E. Hennephof and J. Ellenberger, "Influence of increased gas density on hydrodynamics of bubble-column reactors.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 40, 112-119 (1994).
62. Lapin, A. and A. Lübbert, "Numerical simulation of the dynamics of two-phase gas-liquid flows in bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 49, 3661-3674 (1994).
63. Larachi, F., M. Cassanello, J. Chaouki and C. Guy, "Flow structure of the solids in a 3-D gas-liquid-solid fluidized bed.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 42, 2439-2452 (1996).
64. Larachi, F., M. Cassanello, M.-N. Marie, J. Chaouki and C. Guy, "Solids circulation pattern in three-phase fluidized beds containing binary mixtures of particles as inferred from RPT.", Transactions of the Institute of Chemical Engineers, Vol. 73, 263-268 (1995).
65. Lee, S. L. P. and H. I. de Lasa, "Phase holdups in three-phase fluidized beds.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 33, 1359-1370 (1987).
66. Lee, S. L. P., A. Soria and H. I. de Lasa, "Evolution of bubble length distributions in three-phase fluidized beds.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 36, 1763-1767 (1990).
67. Lefebvre, S. and C. Guy, "Characterization of bubble column hydrodynamics with local measurements.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 4895-4902 (1999).
68. Levenspiel, O., "Chemical reaction engineering", John Wiley & Sons, Oregon state university (1999).
69. Levenspiel, O. and T. L. Fitzgerald, "A warning on the misuse of the dispersion model.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 38, 491-493 (1983).
70. Li, Y., J. Zhang and L.-S. Fan, "Numerical simulation of gas-liquid-solid fluidization systems using a combined CFD-VOF-DPM method: bubble wake behavior.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 5101-5107 (1999).
71. Lindt, J. T., "On the periodic nature of the drag on a rising bubble.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 27, 1775-1781 (1972).
72. Lindt, J. T. and R. G. F. De Groot, "Drag on a single bubble accompanied by periodic wake.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 29, 957-962 (1974).
73. Linneweber, K. W. and E. Blass, "Measurement of local gas and solid hold-ups in three-phase bubble columns.", German Chemical Engineering, Vol. 6, 28-33 (1983).
74. Lubbert, A. and B. Larson, "A new method for measuring local velocities of the continous liquid phase in strongly aerated gas-liquid multiphase reactors.", Chemical Engineering and technologies, Vol. 10, 27-32 (1987).
75. Lübbert, A. and B. Larson, "Detailed investigations of the multiphase flow in airlift tower loop reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 45, 3047-3053 (1990).
76. Luewisutthichat, W., A. Tsutsumi and K. Yoshida, "Chaotic hydrodynamics of continuous single-bubble flow systems.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 3685-3691 (1997).
77. Matsuura, A. and L.-S. Fan, "Distribution of bubble properties in a gas-liquid-solid fluidized bed.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 30, 894-903 (1984).
78. Miyahara, T., M. Kurihara, M. Asoda and T. Takahashi, "Gas-liquid interfacial area and liquid-phase mass transfer coefficient in sieve plate columns without downcomer operating at high gas velocities.", Journal of Chemical Engineering of Japan, Vol. 23, 280-285 (1990).
79. Modak, S. Y., V. A. Juvekar and V. C. Rane, "Dynamics of the gas phase in bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering technologies, Vol. 16, 303-306 (1993).
80. Modak, S. Y., V. A. Juvekar and V. C. Rane, "Comparison of the single-bubble-class and modified two-bubble-class models of bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering and technologies, Vol. 17, 313-32 (1994).
81. Molerus, O. and M. Kurtin, "Modelling of residence time distributions of the gas phase in bubble columns in the liquid circulation regime.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 41, 2693-2698 (1986).
82. Mudde, R. F., J. S. Groen and H. E. A. van den Akker, "Liquid velocity field in a Bubble Columns: LDA experiments.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 4217-4224 (1997).
83. Mudde, R. F. and O. Simonin, "Two-and three-dimensional simulation of bubble plume using a two-fluid model.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 5061-5069 (1999).
84. Muroyama, K. and L.-S. Fan, "Fundamentals of gas-liquid-solid fluidization.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 31, 1-34 (1985).
85. Murray, P. and L.-S. Fan, "Axial solid distribution in slurry bubble column.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, Vol. 28, 1697-1703 (1989).
86. Myers, K., M. P. Dudukovic and P. A. Ramachandran, "Modelling churn-turbulent bubble columns - I. Liquid-phase mixing.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 42, 2301-2311 (1987).
87. Nacef, S., G. Wild, A. Laurant and S. D. Kim, "Scale effects in gas-liquid-solid fluidisation.", International Chemical Engineering, Vol. 32, 51-72 (1992).
88. Nassar, R., J. Schmidt and A. Lubbert, "A stochastic dispersion model in gas-liquid flow systems.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 47, 3657-3664 (1992).
89. Nauman, E. B., " Residence time distribution in systems governed by the dispersion equation.", Chemical engineering Science, Vol. 36, 957-966 (1981).
90. Nauman, E. B. and B. A. Buffham, "Mixing in continuous flow systems", John Wiley & Sons, (1983).
91. Nguyen, k., C. S. Daw, P. Chakka, M. Cheng, D. D. Bruns, C. E. A. Finney and M. B. Kennel, "Spatiotemporal dynamics in a train of rising bubbles.", The Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 65, 191-197 (1996).
92. Ohki, Y. and H. Inoue, "Longitudinal mixing of the liquid phase in bubble coumns.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 25, 1-16 (1970).
93. Olmos, E., C. Centric, C. Vial, G. Wild and N. Midoux, "Numerical simulation of multiphase flow in bubble column reactors. Influence of bubble coalescence and break-up.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 56, 6359-6365 (2001).
94. Patel, S. A., J. G. Daly and D. B. Bukur, "Holdup and interfacial area measurements using dynamic gas disengagement.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 35, 931-942 (1989).
95. Pfleger, D., S. Gomes, N. Gilbert and H.-G. Wagner, "Hydrodynamics simulations of laboratory scale bubble columns fundamental studies of the eulerian-eulerian modelling approach.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 5091-5099 (1999).
96. Prichard, D. and J. Theiler, "Generating surrogate data for time series with several simultaneaously measured variables.", Physical review letters, Vol. 73, 951-954 (1994).
97. Richardson, J. F. and W. N. Zaki, "Sedimentation and fluidization-Part 1.", Transactions of the Institute of Chemical Engineers, Vol. 32, 35-53 (1954).
98. Rigby, G. R., G. P. van Blockland, P. E.H. and C. E. Capes, "Properties of bubbles in three phase fluidized beds as measured by an electroresistivity probe.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 25, 1729-1741 (1970).
99. Rogalewicz, V. and I. Fort, "Stochastic model of an agitated gas-liquid system.", Computers Chemical Engineering, Vol. 15, 437-444 (1991).
100. Rustemeyer, U., J. Pauli, T. Menzel, R. Buchholz and U. Onken, "Liquid-Phase Mixing Model for Hydrodynamics of Bubble Columns.", Chemical Engineering and Processing, Vol. 26, 165-172 (1989).
101. Sanyal, J., S. Vasquez, S. Roy and M. P. Dudukovic, "Numerical simulation of gas-liquid dynamics in cylindrical bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 5071-5083 (1999).
102. Schlüter, S., A. Steiff and P. M. Weinspach, "Modeling and simulation of bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering and Processing, Vol. 31, 97-117 (1992).
103. Schmidt, J., R. Nassar and A. Lubbert, "Influence of the wakes in bubble driven multiphase flow systems.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 47, 2295-2300 (1992a).
104. Schmidt, J., R. Nassar and A. Lübbert, "Local dispersion in the liquid phase of gas-liquid reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 47, 3363-3370 (1992b).
105. Schumpe, A. and W.-D. Deckwer, "Gas holdups, specific interfacial areas, and mass transfer coefficients of aerated carboxymethyl cellulose solutions in a bubble column.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry. Process Design and Development, Vol. 21, 706-711 (1982).
106. Schumpe, A. and G. Grund, "The gas disengagement technique for studying gas holdup structure in bubble columns.", The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Vol. 64, 891-896 (1986).
107. Shah, Y. T., S. Joseph, D. N. Smith and A. J. Ruether, "Two-bubble class model for churn-turbulent bubble-column reactors.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry. Process Design and Development, Vol. 24, 1096-1104 (1985a).
108. Shah, Y. T., S. Joseph, D. N. Smith and A. J. Ruether, "On the behavior of the gas phase in bubble column with ethanol-water mixtures.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry. Process Design and Development, Vol. 24, 1140-1148 (1985b).
109. Shah, Y. T., B. G. Kelkar, S. P. Godbole and W.-D. Deckwer, "Design parameters estimation for bubble column reactors.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 28, 353-379 (1982).
110. Shah, Y. T., G. J. Stiegel and M. M. Sharma, "Backmixing in gas-liquid reactors.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 24, 369-400 (1978).
111. Shetty, S. A., M. V. Kantak and B. G. Kelkar, "Gas-phase backmixing in bubble-columns reactors.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 38, 1013-1026 (1992).
112. Siram, K. and R. Mann, "Dynamic gas disengagement: a new technique for assessing the bahaviour of bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 32, 571-580 (1977).
113. Sokolichin, A. and G. Eigenberger, "Gas-liquid flow in bubble columns and loop reactors: part I. Detailed modelling and numerical simulation.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 49, 5735-5746 (1994).
114. Sokolichin, A., G. Eigenberger, A. Lapin and A. Lubbert, "Dynamics numerical simulation of gas-liquid two-phase flows.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 52, 611-626 (1997).
115. Stewart, C. W., "Bubble interaction in low-v iscosity liquids.", International Journal of Multiphase Flow, Vol. 21, 1037-1046 (1995).
116. Tang, W. T. and L.-S. Fan, "Hydrodynamics of a three-phase fluidized bed containing low-density particles.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 35, 355-364 (1989).
117. TARMY, B. L. and C. A. COULALOGLOU, "Alpha-omega and beyond industrial view of gas/liquid/solid reactor development.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 47, 3231-3246 (1992).
118. Theiler, J., S. Eubank, A. Longtin, B. Galdrikian and J. Doyne F., "Testing for nonlinearity in time series: the method of surrogate data.", Physica D, Vol. 58, 77-94 (1992).
119. Towell, G. D. and G. H. Ackerman, "Axial mixing of liquid and gas in large bubble reactors.", Proceeding of the symposium on chemical reaction engineering, Vol., Amsterdam, Holland, B3-1-B3-13. (1972).
120. Tsutsumi, A., T. Charinpanitkul and K. Yoshida, "Prediction of solid concentration profiles in three-phase reactors by a wake shedding model.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 47, 3411-3418 (1992).
121. Turi, E. and K. M. Ng, "Axial distribution of soid particles in bubble column slurry reactors in the bubble flow regime.", Chemical Engineering Communications, Vol. 46, 323-345 (1986).
122. Ueyama, K. and T. Miyauchi, "Properties of recirculating turbulent two phase flow in gas bubble columns.", American Institute of Chemical Engineering Journal, Vol. 25, 258-266 (1979).
123. Van Der Laan, G. P., A. A. C. M. Beenackers and R. Krishna, "Multicomponent reaction engineering model for Fe-catalyzed Fischer-Tropsch synthesis in comercial scale slurry bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 54, 5013-5019 (1999).
124. Vermeer, D. J. and R. Krishna, " Hydrodynamics and mass transfer in bubble columns operating in the churn-turbulent regime.", Industrial and Engineering Chemistry. Process Design and Development, Vol. 20, 475-482 (1981).
125. Villermaux, J., "Génie de la réaction chimique: conception et fonctionnement des réacteurs", Paris: Tec & Doc Lavoisier, (1993).
126. Villermaux, J., "Trajectory length distribution (TLD), a novel concept to characterize mixing in flow systems.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 51, 1939-1946 (1996).
127. Wachi, S. and Y. Nojima, "Gas-phase dispersion in bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 45, 901-905 (1990).
128. Weber, M. E. and D. Bhaga, "Fluid drift caused by a rising bubble.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 37, 113-116 (1982).
129. Wild, G., M. Saberian, J.-L. Schwartz and J.-C. Charpentier, "Gas-liquid-solid fluidized-bed reactors. State of the art and industrial possibilities.", International Chemical Engineering, Vol. 24, 639-678 (1984).
130. Yang, Y. B., M. P. Dudukovic and M. P. Dudukovic, "Liquid backmixing in bubble column via computer-automated radioactive particle tracking (CARPT).", Experiments in fluids, Vol. 16, 1-9 (1993).
131. Yao, B. P., C. Zheng, H. E. Gasche and H. Hofmann, "Bubble behaviour and flow structure of bubble columns.", Chemical Engineering and Processing, Vol. 29, 65-75 (1991).
132. Zahradnik, J. and M. Fialova, "Effect of bubbling regime on gas and liquid phase mixing in bubble column reactors.", Chemical Engineering Science, Vol. 51, 2491-2500 (1996).