Wrong disc space level surgery: Medicolegal implications

Surgical Neurology

Volumn 61, Issue 4, 2004, Pages 323-341

  Goodkin, Robert ^a   Laska, Lewis L ^b   Fager, Charles A ^c   Pawl, Ron ^c   Matz, Marshall I ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^b TENNESSEE STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c NONE

Author keywords

Congenital variants; Informed consent; Obesity; Pre or intraoperative imaging studies; Short neck; Wrong level disc surgery

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CERVICAL SPINE; HUMAN; INTERVERTEBRAL DISK; INTERVERTEBRAL DISK HERNIA; LAW SUIT; LUMBAR SPINE; MALPRACTICE; MEDICOLEGAL ASPECT; PUBLICATION; RADIOGRAPHY; THORACIC SPINE;

EID: 1642313677     PISSN: 00903019     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.surneu.2003.08.022     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Abramovitz J.N., Neff S.R. Lumbar disc surgery results of the prospective lumbar discectomy study of the Joint Section on disorders of the Spine and Peripheral Nerves of the American Association of Neurlogical Surgeons and the Congress of Neurological Surgeons. Neurosurgery. 29:1991;301-308.
2. Adkins v. Minella. In: Ohio App; 1992:1992 WL 324329
3. Annotation, Modern status of views as to general measure of physicians' duty to inform patient of risks of purposed treatment. 88 American Law Reports, 3d 1008
4. Annotation, Necessity of expert evidence to support an action for malpractice against a physician or surgeon. 82 American Law Reports 2d:597.
5. Annotation, Physicians and surgeons: res ipsa loquitur, or presumption or inference of negligence in malpractice cases. 82 American Law Reports 2d:1262
6. Barrios C., Ahmed M., Arrótegui J., Björnsson A., Gillström P. Microsurgery versus standard removal of the herniated lumbar disc. A 3-year comparison in 150 cases. Acta Orthop Scand. 61:1990;399-403.
7. Bolger C., Wigfield C. Image-guided surgery applications to the cervical and thoracic spine and a review of the first 120 procedures. J Neurosurg (Spine 2). 92:2000;175-180.
8. Bush K., Cowan N., Katz D.E., Gishen P. The natural history of sciatica associated disc pathology a prospective study with clinical and independent radiologic follow-up. Spine. 17:1992;1205-1212.
9. Casper W., Campbell B., Barbier D.D., Kretschmmer R., Gotfried Y. The Caspar microsurgical discectomy and comparison with a conventional standard lumbar disc procedure. Neurosurgery. 28:1991;78-87.
10. Davis R.A. A long-term outcome analysis of 984 surgically treated herniated lumbar discs. J Neurosurg. 80:1994;415-421.
11. Delauche-Cavallier M.-C., Budet C., Laredo J.-D., et al. Lumbar disc herniation. Computed tomography scan changes after conservative treatment of nerve root compression. Spine. 17:1992;927-933.
12. Dvorak J., Gauchat M.-H., Valach L. The outcome of surgery for lumbar disc herniation. 1. A 4-17 years follow-up with emphasis on somatic aspects. Spine. 13:1988;1418-1422.
13. Ebeling U., Reichenberg W., Reulen H.-J. Results of microsurgical lumbar discectomy. Review on 485 patients. Acta Neurochir. 81:1986;45-52.
14. Echols D.H., Rehfeldt F.C. Failure to disclose ruptured intervertebral disks in 32 operations for sciatica. J Neurosurg. 6:1949;376-382.
15. Eie N., Solgaard T., Kleppe H. The knee-elbow position in lumbar disc surgery a review of complications. Spine. 8:1983;897-900.
16. English P.T., Dougal C., Griffiths P.D., Gholkar A. Technical note a simple method for skin/lesion localization using magnetic resonance imaging. Br J Radiol. 67:1994;813-815.
17. Foley K.T., Smith M.M. Image-guided spine surgery. Neurosurg Clin N Am. 7:1996;171-186.
18. Goald H.J. Microlumbar discectomy follow-up of 477 patients. J Microsurg. 2:1980;95-100.
19. Goodkin R., Laska L.L. Medicolegal implications of complications of lumbar disc surgery. Hardy R.W. Jr. Lumbar Disc Surgery. 2nd ed:1993;331-349 Raven Press, Ltd, New York.
20. Guinto F.C. Jr, Hashim H., Stumer M. CT demonstration of disc regression after conservative therapy. AJNR. 5:1984;632-633.
21. Gurdjian E.S., Webster J.E., Ostrowski A., Hardy W.G., Lindner D.W., Thomas L.M. Herniated lumbar intervertebral discs - an analysis of 1176 operated cases. J Trauma. 1:1961;158-176.
22. Haberland N., Ebmeier K., Grunewald J.P., Hliscs R., Kalff R.L. Incorporation of intraopertive computerized tomography in a newly developed spinal navigation technique. Computerized Aided Surgery. 5:2000;18-27.
23. Haberland N., Ebmeier K., Hliscs R., et al. Neuronavigation in surgery of intracranial and spinal tumors. J Cancer Res Clin Oncol. 126:2000;529-541.
24. Harsha W.N. Medical Malpractice Handling Orthopedic Casesed. 1990;Shepard's, Colorado Springs.
25. Henegar M.M., Vollmer D.G., Silbergeld D.L. Intraoperative transligamentous ultrasound in the evaluation of thoracic intraspinal disease. Spine. 21:1996;124-127.
26. Hudgins W.R. Exposure of two interspaces for lumbar disc surgery. J Neurosurg. 42:1975;59-60.
27. Hudgins W.R. The role of microdiscectomy. Orthop Clin North Am. 14:1983;589-603.
28. Hum B., Feigenbaum F., Cleary K., Henderson C. Intraoperative computed tomography for complex craniocervical operations and spinal tumor resections. Neurosurgery. 47:2000;374-381.
29. Javedan S., Sonntag V.K.H. Lumbar disc herniation Microsurgical approach. Neurosurgery. 52:2003;160-164.
30. Kahanovitz N., Viola K., Muculloch J. Limited surgical discectomy and microdiscectomy. A clinical comparison. Spine. 14:1989;79-81.
31. Kalfas I.H. Image-guided spinal navigation. Clin Neurosurg. 46:2000;70-88.
32. Keskimäki I., Seitsalo S., Österman H., Rissanen P. Reoperations after lumbar disc surgery a population-based study of regional and interspecialty variations. Spine. 25:2000;1500-1508.
33. Komori H., Shinomiya K., Nakai O., Yamaura I., Takeda S., Furuya K. The natural history of herniated nucleus pulposus with radiculopathy. Spine. 21:1996;225-229.
34. Kotilainen E, Valtonen S, Carlson C-Å. Microsurgical treatment of lumbar disc herniation: follow-up of 237 patients. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 1993;120:143-9
35. Lewis P.J., Weir B.K.A., Broad R.W., Grace M.G. Long-term prospective study of lumbosacral discectomy. J Neurosurg. 67:1987;49-53.
36. Long v. Hacker. In: Neb. App, 1993:1993 WL 439952
37. Macnab I. Negative disc exploration. An analysis of the causes of nerve-root involvement in sixty-eight patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 53:(-A):1971;891-903.
38. Maigne J.-Y., Rime B., Deligne B. Computed tomographic follow-up study of forty-eight cases of nonoperatively treated lumbar intervertebral disc herniation. Spine. 17:1992;1071-1074.
39. Man awarded $3.3 million after wrong vertebra fused. The Seattle Times. Seattle, 2000:6
40. Marro v. Gopez. In: Del Super, 1994:1994 WL 45338
41. McCulloch, JA. Complications (Adverse effects). In: McCulloch JA. Principles of Microsurgery for Lumbar Disc Disease. New York: Raven Press, 1989:225-38
42. Merli G.A., Angiari P., Tonelli L. Three years experience with microsurgical technique in the treatment of protruded lumbar disc. J Neurosurg Sci. 28:1984;25-31.
43. Mullin W.J., Heithoff K.B., Gilbert T.J., Refrew D.L. Magnetic resonance evaluation of recurrent disc herniation. Is gadolinium necessary? Spine. 25:2000;1493-1499.
44. Murphy v. Rutkowski. In: Will County (IL); 2002;No. 95-10397
45. Nolte L.-P., Slomczykowski M.A., Berlemann U., et al. A new approach to computer-aided spine surgery fluoroscopy-based surgical navigation. Eur Spine J. 9:(suppl 1):2000;S78-88.
46. Oppel F., Schramm J., Schirmer M., Zeitner M. Results and complicated course after surgery for lumbar disc herniation. Wüllenweber R., Brock M., Hamer J., et al. Adv Neurosurg. 1977;36-51 Springer-Verlag, New York.
47. Pappas C.T.E., Harrington T., Sonntag V.K.H. Outcome analysis in 654 surgically treated lumbar disc herniations. Neurosurgery. 30:1992;862-866.
48. Pierot L., Boulin A. Percutaneous biopsy of the thoracic and lumbar spine transpedicular approach under fluoroscopic guidance. AJNR. 20:1999;23-25.
49. Promen v. Ward. In: Ohio App. 1990.:591 N. E. 2d 813
50. Raaf J. Some observations regarding 905 patients operated upon for protruded lumbar intervertebral disc. Am J Surg. 97:1959;388-399.
51. Ramirez L.F., Thisted R. Complications and demographic characteristics of patients undergoing lumbar discectomy in community hospitals. Neurosurgery. 25:1989;226-231.
52. Roberts M.P. Complications of lumbar disc surgery. Hardy R.W. Jr. Lumbar Disc Disease. 1993;161-170 Raven Press, Ltd, New York.
53. Roberts M.P. Complications of lumbar disc surgery. Spinal Surg. 2:1988;13-19.
54. Rosahl S.K., Gharabaghi A., Liebig T., Feste C.D., Tatagiba M., Samii M. Skin markers for surgical planning for intradural lesions of the thoracic spine. Technical note. Surg Neurol. 58:2002;346-348.
55. Ruggieri F., Specchia L., Sabalat S., Galli G., Ruggieri P., Arlecchini S. Lumbar disc herniation diagnosis, surgical treatment, recurrence. A review of 872 operated cases. Ital J Orthop Traumatol. 14:1988;15-22.
56. Saal J.A. Natural history and nonoperative treatment of lumbar disc herniation. Spine. 21:1996;2S-9S.
57. Saal J.A., Saal J.S. Nonoperative treatment of herniated lumbar intervertebral disc with radiculopathy. An outcome study. Spine. 14:1989;431-437.
58. Saal J.A., Saal J.S., Herzog R.J. The natural history of lumbar intervertebal disc extrusions treated nonoperatively. Spine. 15:1990;683-686.
59. Sachdev V.P. Microsurgical lumbar discectomy a personal series of 300 patients with at least 1 year follow-up. Microsurgery. 7:1986;55-62.
60. Salenius P., Laurent L.E. Results of operative treatment of lumbar disc herniation. Acta Orthop Scand. 48:1977;630-634.
61. Schlenzka D., Laine T., Lund T. Computer-assisted spine surgery. Eur Spine J. 9:(suppl 1):2000;S57-S64.
62. Schramm J., Oppel F. Negative exploration for lumbar disc prolapse findings and possible causes. Acta Neurochir. 46:1979;267-280.
63. Scoville W.B., Corkill G. Lumbar disc surgery technique of radical removal and early mobilization. J Neurosurg. 39:1973;265-269.
64. Silvers H.R. Microsurgical versus standard lumbar discectomy. Neurosurgery. 22:1988;837-841.
65. nd Cir; 1987:811 F. 2d 738
66. Spangfort E.V. The lumbar disc herniation a computer-aided analysis of 2504 operations. Acta Ortho Scand Suppl. 142:1972;1-95.
67. Spurling R.G., Grantham E.G. The end-results of surgery for ruptured lumbar intervertebral discs. A follow-up study of 327 cases. J Neurosurg. 6:1949;57-64.
68. Stolke D., Sollmann W.-P., Seifert V. Intra- and postoperative complications in lumbar disc surgery. Spine. 14:1989;56-59.
69. Teplich J.G., Haskin M.E. Computer tomography of the postoperative lumbar spine. AJR. 141:1983;865-884.
70. Teplich J.G., Haskin M.E. Spontaneous regression of herniated nucleus pulposus. AJR. 145:1985;371-375.
71. Thomson J.L. A simple skin marker for magnetic resonance imaging. Br J Radiol. 61:1988;638-639.
72. Törmä T. Post-operative recurrence of lumbar disc herniation. Acta Chir Scand. 103:1952;213-221.
73. Vollrath, M. Surgical errors-The "wrong side" of surgery: update! A Periodic Report from the Washington State Medical Quality Assurance Commission, 2000
74. Weber H. Lumbar disc herniation a controlled, prospective study with ten years of observation. Spine. 8:1983;131-140.
75. Weber H. The natural history of disc herniations and the influence of intervention. Spine. 19:1994;2234-2238.
76. Weir B.K.A. Prospective study of 100 lumosacral discectomy. J Neurosurg. 50:1979;283-289.
77. Weir B.K.A., Jacobs G.A. Reoperation rate following lumbar discectomy. An Analysis of 662 lumbar discectomies. Spine. 5:1980;366-370.
78. Wildförster U. Intraoperative komplikationen während lumbaler bandscheibenoperationen. Neurochirurgia. 34:1991;53-56.
79. Williams R.W. Microdiskectomy - myth, mania, or milestone? An 18-year surgical adventure. Mt Sinai J Med. 58:1991;139-145.
80. Williams R.W. Microlumbar discectomy a conservative surgical approach to the virgin herniated lumbar disc. Spine. 3:1978;175-182.
81. Wilson D.H., Harbaugh R. Microsurgical and standard removal of the protruded lumbar disc a comparative study. Neurosurgery. 8:1981;422-427.
82. Yasargil M.G. Microsurgical operation of the herniated lumbar disc. Adv Neurosurg. 4:1977;81-82.
83. Zeiger H.E. Jr. Comparison of chemonucleolysis and microsurgical discectomy for the treatment of herniated lumbar disc. Spine. 12:1987;796-799.