The critical review process according to ISO 14040-43: An analysis of the standards and experiences gained in their application

International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment

Volumn 10, Issue 2, 2005, Pages 98-102

  Klöpffer, Walter ^a  

^a LCA Consult and Review   (Germany)

Author keywords

Comparative assertions; Critical review; ISO 14040; SETAC code of practice

Indexed keywords

LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT; PEER REVIEW; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE;

EID: 14644394341     PISSN: 09483349     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1065/lca2004.12.190     Document Type: Review

References (24)

1. Klöpffer W, Heinrich A (1999): Peer Reviewing in a New Journal: Experiences from the First Three Years. Editorial in Int J LCA 4 (2) 61
2. Klöpffer W (1997): Peer (Expert) Review According to SETAC and ISO 1440. Theory and Practice. Editorial in Int J LCA 2 (4) 183-184
3. International Standard (ISO); Norme Européenne (CEN) (1997): Environmental management - Life cycle assessment: Principles and framework. ISO EN 14040
4. Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) (1993): Guidelines for Life-Cycle Assessment: A 'Code of Practice'. From the SETAC Workshop held at Sesimbra, Portugal, 31 March - 3 April 1993. Edition 1, Brussels and Pensacola (Florida)
5. Marsmann M (2000): The ISO 14040 Family. Int J LCA 5, 317-318
6. International Standard (ISO); Norme Européenne (CEN) (1998): Environmental management - Life cycle assessment: Goal and scope definition and inventory analysis. ISO EN 14041
7. De Groot-van Dam A (chair), Gensch C-O; Klöpffer W, Klüppel H-J (2000): Abschließender Prüfbericht vom 25.7.2000, S 1-17. In: Flinke E, Schonen M, Meckel H, Detzel A, Giegrich J, Fehrenbach H, Ostermayer A, Schorb A, Heinisch J, Luxenhofer K, Schmitz S: Ökobilanz für Getränkeverpackungen II, Zwischenbericht (Phase 1) zum Forschungsvorhaben FKZ 296 92 504 des Umweltbundesamtes Berlin - Hauptteil (ISSN 0722-186X): UBA Texte 37/00, Berlin
8. Klöpffer W, Grahl B, Gensch C-O (2002): Abschlussbericht zum Critical Review nach ISO 14040, Juli 2002, S 1-15. Anhang 1 in: Schonert M, Metz G, Detzel A, Giegrich J, Ostermayer A, Schorb A, Schmitz S: Ökobilanz für Getränkeverpackungen II, Phase 2. Forschungsbericht 103 50 504 UBA-FB 000363 des Umweltbundesamtes Berlin (ISSN 0722-186X): UBA Texte 51/02, Berlin
9. Klöpffer W (1997): Critical Review Report on Life Cycle Inventories for the Production of Sodium Silicates. In: Fawer M, EMPA Bericht Nr. 241, St. Gallen 43-47
10. International Standard (ISO); Norme Européenne (CEN) (2000): Environmental management - Life cycle assessment: Life cycle impact assessment. ISO EN 14042
11. International Standard (ISO); Norme Européenne (CEN) (2000): Environmental management - Life cycle assessment: Interpretation. ISO EN 14043
12. Giacomucci A, Baldo GL (1999): LCA Certification According to ISO 14040: First Experience. Int J LCA 4, 165-166
13. Frischknecht R (2004): Transparency in LCA - a heretical request? Editorial in Int J LCA 9 (4) 211-213
14. Klöpffer W, Grießhammer R, Sundström G (1995): Overview of the Scientific Peer Review of the European Life Cycle Inventory for Surfactant Production. Tenside Surf Det 32, 378-383
15. Klöpffer W, Sundström G, Grießhammer R (1996): The Peer Reviewing Process - A Case Study: European Life Cycle Inventory for Surfactant Production. Int J LCA 1, 113-115
16. Günther A, Langowski H-C (1997): Life Cycle Assessment Study on Resilient Floor Coverings. Int J LCA 2, 78-80
17. Klöpffer W, Tukker A, Richter K (1998): Life Cycle Inventory with Impact Assessment. Expert Review, Final Report August 1997, 11 pp. In: Langowski H-C (ed), Life Cycle Assessment Study on Resilient Floorcoverings. For ERFMI (European Resilient Flooring Manufacturers' Institute). Fraunhofer IRB Verlag, ISBN 3-8167-5210-1, Stuttgart
18. Kremer M, Goldhan G, Heyde M (1998): Waste Treatment in Product Specific Life Cycle Inventories. An Approach of Material-Related Modelling. Part I: Incineration. Int J LCA 3, 47-55
19. Bez J, Heyde M, Goldhan G (1998): Waste Treatment in Product Specific Life Cycle Inventories. An Approach of Material-Related Modelling. Part II: Sanitary Landfill. Int J LCA 3, 100-105
20. Fava J, Pomper S (1997): Life-Cycle Critical Review! Does it Work? Implementing a Critical Review Process as a Key Element of the Aluminium Beverage Container LCA. Int J LCA 2, 144-153
21. Bontoux L, Papameletiou D (eds) (1999): Critical Review of the Study 'Recycling and Recovery of Plastics from Packaging in Domestic Waste - LCA-type analysis of different strategies'. In: Heyde M, Kremer M: LCA Documents Vol. 5, 183-194
22. Stiftung Arbeit und Umwelt (ed.) (2000): Ökobilanzen & Produktverantwortung. Dokumentation. ISBN 3-89384-041-9. Hannover
23. Committee Draft ISO TC 207/SC 5/WG6: ISO/CD 14040.2, 2004-09-30
24. Committee Draft ISO TC 207/SC 5/WG6: ISO/CD 14044.2, 2004-09-30