Electricity reform at a crossroads: Problems in South Korea's power liberalization strategy

Pacific Affairs

Volumn 77, Issue 3, 2004, Pages 493-516

  Byrne, John ^a,b   Glover, Leigh ^a,b   Lee, Hoesung ^a,b   Wang, Young Doo ^a,b   Yu, Jung Min ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF DELAWARE   (United States)

^b Council on Energy and Environment ^*  (South Korea)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ELECTRICITY GENERATION; ENERGY POLICY; LIBERALIZATION; REFORM PROCESS;

ASIA; EASTERN HEMISPHERE; EURASIA; FAR EAST; KOREA; SOUTH KOREA; WORLD;

EID: 14344255189     PISSN: 0030851X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (95)

1. Sung-Bong Cho and Jin-Woo Kim, Jeolyuk Gujo Gaepyun Banghyang-gwa Juyo Jungchaek Gwajae [The Direction of Electricity Industry Reform and Principal Policy Tasks], research report (Euiwang, Republic of Korea: Korea Energy Economics Institute, 2000).
2. Center for Energy and Environmental Policy (CEEP), A Review of US Restructuring Experience and Its Lessons for Korea's Electricity Industry, research report (University of Delaware, Newark, DE: CEEP, 2003).Three authors of this article (Bryne, Wang and Yu) participated in the preparation of the 2003 report and one individual (Bryne) provided public comments before rendering its recommendations to the president of South Korea regarding electricity liberalization (see section 5 below).
3. Rhan Kim, "Power Supply Privatization Plan Scrapped," The Korea Times, 17 June 2004.
4. Chaebols are companies that were originally family owned and that, with government support, evolved into large corporate conglomerates. The GNP shares of the top four chaebols (Hyundai, Samsung, Daewoo and LG) and the top 30 chaebols were 9.2 percent, respectively, in 1993.
5. See Kenneth L. Judd and Young-Ki Lee, eds., An Agenda for Economic Reform in Korea: International Perspectives (Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press and Seoul: Korea Development Institute, 2000).
6. See CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience, and table 3 below.
7. Letter of Intent of the Government of the Republic Korea (1999), and Memorandum of Economic Policies (1998), signed by Chol-Hwan Chon (Bank of Korea) and Kyu-Sung Lee (Minister of Finance and Economy, Republic of Korea) available from the IMF Web site , last accessed 18 October, 2004.
8. Yoon Ja Kim, "Hankuk Jeolyuk Minyounghwa Nonie Daehan Bipanjuk Gumto" [A Critical Analysis of the Privatization of KEPCO], paper presented to the symposium hosted by the Korean Federation of Environmental Movements and the Environmental Forum of the Korean National Assembly, Seoul, 12 November 1999.
9. "Hanjun Minyounghwa Bangan Jaengjumun?" [What are the Issues Regarding Privatization of KEPCO?], Hankyoreh, 23 November 2000.
10. Cho and Kim, "The Direction of Electricity Industry Reform"
11. Chang Hyun Cho, "Jeolyuk Sanup Gujo Gaepyungwa Minyounghwa: Jaehgjum Bunsukgwa Sarye Yungu" [Electricity Industry Restructuring and Privatization: Analysis of Issues and Case Study], report, Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade (assisted by staff of the Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy), 2002.
12. South Korea has modest reserves of medium-quality anthracite coal (82 million tons as of 1998). Due to the high cost of production, 384 mines were closed between 1989 and 1995. Coal needs for electricity generation are met through imports, principally from China and Australia.
13. See International Energy Agency, Energy Policies of IEA Countries: The Republic of Korea 2002 Review (Paris: IEA, 2002).
14. (Terry Ursacki and Ilan Vertinsky, "Long-Term Changes in Korea's International Trade and Investment," Pacific Affairs, vol. 67, no. 3 (1994), pp. 385-409).
15. Over 45 percent of South Korea households relied on agriculture and fisheries for their income in 1970, but the share had fallen to less than 10 percent by 2000 (Korea National Statistical Office, "Census Population," "Farmhouse and Population," and "Fisheries Households and Population," online databases maintained by the South Korean government, and available online from , last accessed 18 January 2004).
16. See Korea Electric Power Corporation, Statistics of Electric Power in Korea (Seoul: KEPCO, 2003).
17. John Byrne and Jong-Dall Kim, "Centralization, Technicization and Development on the Semi-Periphery: A Study of South Korea's Commitment to Nuclear Power," Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society, vol. 10, no. 4 (1990), pp. 212-222.
18. Byrne and Kim, "Centralization, Technicization and Development on the Semi-Periphery."
19. John Byrne and In-Whan Jung, "The Politics of Nuclear Development in South Korea," proceedings of the Seventh Annual Meeting of the National Association for Science, Technology and Society (Alexandria, VA: 1992), pp. 132-152.
20. KEPCO officials that we contacted confirmed that cost had been won 25-30/ kWh (US$0.03/ kWh) on average during this period.
21. Yoon Hyung Kim, Kirk R. Smith and Kennon Breazle, eds., Electricity in Economic Development: The Experience of Northeast Asia (New York: Greenwood Press, 1987), p. 7.
22. Do Wan Ku, Hankuk Hwankyung Undongui Sahweihak [A Sociology of the Environmental Movement in Korea: Toward a Just and Sustainable Society] (Seoul: Munhakgwa Jisungsa, 1996).
23. Cho and Kim, "The Direction of Electricity Industry Reform," p. 21.
24. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Regulatory Reform in Korea (Paris: OECD, 2000), p. 246.
25. Insook Han, "The Political Economy of Unsustainability: An Analysis of South Korea's Energy, Environmental, and Development Vulnerability," (doctoral thesis, Center for Energy and Environmental Policy, University of Delaware, 1993).
26. CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience.
27. Energy Information Administration, "South Korea: Environmental Issues," country analysis brief (US Department of Energy, April 2003), available online from , last accessed 18 October 2004.
28. Tae Yong Jung and Yang Hoon Sonn, "Factor Demand and Economies of Scale for the Electric Industry in Korea," paper presented at the 16th Annual Conference of the International Association for Energy Economics, Denpasar, Bali, Indonesia, 1993.
29. Tae Yong Jung and Yang Hoon Sonn, "Scale Economies in Electric Utilities," Journal of Korea Economics, vol. 42 (1993), pp. 29-47.
30. Cho and Kim, "The Direction of Electricity Industry Reform."
31. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), OECD Economic Surveys 2000-2001: Korea (Paris: OECD, 2001), p. 163.
32. OECD, OECD Economic Surveys 2000-2001: Korea, p. 175.
33. OECD, OECD Economic Surveys 2000-2001: Korea, p. 175.
34. Total foreign debt for all state-owned companies was not available for the period reported in table 3. A reasonable proxy for the impact of foreign debt owed by central and local governments. This is reported in table 3.
35. Liberalization of the power sector in developing countries has generally conformed with the broader re-orientaion of the national economy following an economic crisis. Sweeping changes to monetary policy. revised limits on foreign ownership, increased foreign access to capital markets, significantly changed trade, fiscal and labour policies and restructuring of national utilities (including electricity) often follow on economic emergency in order t obtain World Bank or IMF support.
36. See John Byrne and Yu-Mi Mun, "Rethinking Reform in the Electricity Sector: Power Liberalisation or Energy Transformation?" in Njeri Wamukonya, ed., Electricity Reform: Social and Environmental Challenges (Roskilde, Denmark: UNEP-Risoe Center, 2003).
37. Byrne and Mun, "Rethinking Reform in the Electricity Sector."
38. Byrne and Mun, "Rethinking Reform in the Electricity Sector," p. 52.
39. See Letter of Intent of the Government of the Republic of Korea (1999) and Memorandum of Economic Policies (1998), signed by Chol-Hwan Chon (Bank of Korea) and Kyu-Sung Lee (Minister of Finance and Economy, Republic of Korea); available from the IMF Web site at , site last accessed 18 October 2004.
40. CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience.
41. OECD, OECD Economic Surveys 2000-2001: Korea.
42. Korea Power Exchange (KPX), "The Korea Power Exchange and Electricity Market," report (Seoul: KPX, 2001).
43. CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience.
44. Korea Power Exchange (KPX), "The Korea Power Exchange and Electricity Market," report (Seoul: KPX, 2001).
45. CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience.
46. John Byrne and Steven M. Hoffman, eds., Governing the Atom: The Politics of Risk (New Brunswick, NJ and London, UK: Transaction, 1996).
47. Jong-Dall Kim and John Byrne, "The Asian Atom: Hard-Path Nuclearization in East Asia," in John Byrne and Steven M. Hoffman, eds., Governing the Atom: The Politics of Risk (New Brunswick, NJ and London. UK: Transaction, 1996).
48. Korean Federation of Environmental Movements, "Haek Baljungwa Haek Paegijangui Munjaejum, Hankukui Energy Jungchaekui Junwhan" [The Problems of Nuclear Power and Nuclear Waste Facilities and their implications for an Energy Transition in Korea], report (Seoul: KFEM, 2003).
49. Kim and Byrne, "The Asian Atom."
50. Joo Won Seo, "Hanjun-ui Jeolyuk Sanup Dogjum, Mueosi Munjaeinga?" [What Are the Problems of KEPCO Being an Electricity Industry Monopoly?], paper presented to the Seminar on Electricity Restructuring for Participation and Energy Autonomy, supported by the Korean Federation of Environmental Movements and Hankook IIbo, Seoul, 7 May 1998.
51. Kwang Hoon Seok, "Hankukui Jeolyuk Sanup Gujo Gaehyuk Banganurosoeui Minyounghwaui Wisanggwa Janggijuk Junmang" [The Status and Long-term Prospects of Privatization of South Korea's Electricity Sector as a Restructuring Option], paper presented to the Seminar on Environmentally-friendly Electricity Restructuring, supported by Korea NGO's Energy Network and the Korea Environmental Conference, Seoul, 25 April 2002.
52. Won Young Yanglee, "Jeolyuk Sanup Gujo Gaepyungwa Haek Baljunso, Ban Haek Undong" [Electricity Restructuring and Nuclear Power Plants, Anti-Nuclear Movements], paper presented to the Workshop on Environmentally-friendly Electricity Restructuring, sponsored by Korea NGO's Energy Network and Korea Environmental Conference, Seoul, 25 April 2002.
53. Sung-Jin Lim, "Jeolyuk Sanupui Gujo Gaepyun Banghyang" [The Direction of Electricity Restructuring] in Ways of Living Together, Korean Federation of Environmental Movements magazine (February 1999).
54. Kim and Byrne, "The Asian Atom"
55. Pil Ryul Lee, "Jungang Jipjungjuk Energy System ui Gisuljuk Sahweijuk Uihum" [Social and Technical Risks of a Centralized Energy System], Munwha Gwahak 35 (1 September 2003), pp. 167-183.
56. Kwang Hoon Seok, "Hansuwon-en Odo Hagoita" [KHNP is Deceiving the Public], Hankyoreh, 8 October 2003.
57. Myung Jae Song, "Buan-en Ohae Hagoita" [Buan is Misunderstood], Hankyoreh, 3 October 2003.
58. Su-Hoon Lee, "Transitional Politics of Korea, 1987-1992: Activation of Civil Society," Pacific Affairs, vol. 66, no. 3 (1993), pp. 351-367.
59. Do Wan Ku, "A Sociology of the Environmental Movement in Korea."
60. Pil Ryul Lee, "Saengtae Juiwa Jeolyuk Sanup Gujo" [Ecology and Electricity Restructuring], paper presented to the Seminar on Environmentally-friendly Electricity Restructuring, supported by Korea NGO's Energy Network and the Korea Environmental Conference, Seoul, 25 April 2002.
61. Pil Ryul Lee, "Hankuk Jeolyuk Gujo Gaepyun: Jaesaeng Ganung Energy-ae Gichohan Energy System Junwhanul Uihae" [Restructuring of KEPCO: Toward an Energy Transition Based on Renewable Energy], paper presented to the Seminar on "How to Restructure KEPCO," supported by the Environmental Forum of the National Assembly and Korean Federation of Environmental Movements Seoul, 12 November 1999.
62. Pil Ryul Lee, "Hanjunui Jeolyuk Dokjum Munjaewa Jeolyuk Sanup Jaepyunui Gibon Wonchik" [The Problem of KEPCO's Monopoly and Basic Principles for Electricity Restructuring], paper presented to the Seminar on "Electricity Restructuring for Participation and Energy Autonomy," supported by the Korean Federation of Environmental Movements and Hankook Ilbo, Seoul, 7 May 1998.
63. Korean Federation of Environmental Movement, Green Korea, Korea Women's Associations United, People's Solidarity for Participatory Democracy, Korea Confederation of Trade Unions, Union of Power Generation Industry, "Jeolyuk Sanup Minyounghwa Yubowa Chin Hwankyungjukin Jeolyuk Sanup Gujo Gaehyukul Chokguhanun Simin, Nodong Danchae Gongdong Sunun" [Joint Statement Supporting for Halt to Electricity Privatization and a Call for Environmentally-friendly Electricity Restructuring], 2002. The joint statement was released at a press conference on (27 March 2002). The full statement is available at the Korean Federation of Environmental Movements Web site, at ,site last accessed 28 October 2004. site last accessed 28 October 2004.
64. Interviews with NGO leaders and union representatives indicate that efforts to forge an alliance have stalled. Environmentalist' opposition to nuclear power and unions' support for it, disagreements regarding KEPCO's continuation as a national monopoly, and the lack of a prior track record of cooperation on policy issues are cited as important barriers to the formation of a red-green alliance at this time.
65. Sung-Jin Lim, "Jeolyuk Sanupui Gujo Gaepyun Banghyang" [The Direction of Electricity Restructuring], Ways of Living Together, Korean Federation of Environmental Movements magazine (February 1999).
66. Byong-Hun Ahn and Yong-Gun Kim, "Tradable Tagged Permit System for Global Pollution Control," Journal of Policy Modeling, vol. 23, issue 5 (2001), pp. 569-594.
67. Pil Ryul Lee, "Hankuk Jeolyuk Guio Gaepyun: Jaesaeng Ganung Energy-ae Gichohan Energy System Junwhanul Uihae" [Restructuring of KEPCO: Toward an Energy Transition Based on Renewable Energy], paper presented to the Seminar on "How to Restructure KEPCO," supported by the Environmental Forum of the National Assembly and Korean Federation of Environmental Movements, Seoul, 12 November 1999.
68. Pil Ryul Lee, "Energy System Junwhanul Uihan Jeolyuk Sanup Gujo Gaepyun" [Electricity Restructuring for Energy Transformation], Ways of Living Together, Korean Federation of Environmental Movements magazine (January 2000).
69. In-Young Lee, "Jung Janggi Shin Jaesaeng Energy Gibon Gaehwik (2003-2012)" [The Mid and Long-term Basic Plan for New and Renewable Energy (2003-2012)], paper presented to the Workshop on National Renewable Energy Strategies in Response to the WSSD, hosted by the Korea Energy Economics Institute and sponsored by the South Korea Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy, Seoul, 16 January 2004.
70. In-Young Lee, Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy, Jae E-cha Shin, Jaesaeng Energy Gisul Mit Eyong, Bogeup Gaehwik (2003-2012) [The 2nd Basic Plan for Development, Use and Dissemination of New and Renewable Energy (2003-2012)] (Seoul: Government of South Korea, 2003).
71. John Byrne,Young-Doo Wang,Jong-Dall Kim, Hoesung Lee and Jung-Wk Kim, Energy Revolution: 21st Century Energy and Environmental Strategy (Seoul: Maeil Kyungjae, 2004).
72. Soon-Bin Park, "Hanjun Bunhal, Minyounghwa Baramjik Anhae" [Unbundling and Privatization of KEPCO is not Supported], Hankyoreh, 21 April 2003.
73. The Korea Tripartite Commission was established in 1998 as a consultative body to South Korea's president. It includes representatives of government, business and labour, who meet to discuss comprehensive labour policy, including employment security, conditions of workers and public sector restructuring.
74. This research team consist of eight members:one labour union representative, one business representative, two experts recommended by the union and business sectors, and two neutral researchers recommended by the chair of the Special Committee.
75. Korea Tripartite Commission, Minutes of the 60th Meeting of the Special Committee on Restructuring of Public Sector, August 2003, available online from , last accessed 28 January 2004.
76. Interviews with staff of the Korea Tripartite Commision and KEPCO indicate that the commision is responsible for a comprehensive investigation of the country's electricity restructuring policy.
77. Korea Tripartite Commission, "Summary of the Joint Research Team's Final Report on Reform of the Electricity Industry," 2004.
78. CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience.
79. Yoon Ja Kim, "A Critical Analysis of the Privatization of KEPCO.'
80. Bang Lim Kim, "Jeolyuk Sanup Gujo Gaepyun: Munjaejumgwa Gaesun Banghyang" [Electricity Industry Restructuring: Problems and Plans for Improvement], paper presented at hearings in the Korean National Assembly on MOCIE's Electricity Restructuring Plan, Seoul, 2001.
81. Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights, HOAX: How Deregulation Let the Power Industry Steal $71 Billion from California (Santa Monica, CA: FTCR, 2002)
82. Harvey Wasserman, "Power Struggle: California's Engineered Energy Crisis and the Potential of Public Power," Multinational Monitor (June 2001), pp. 9-20.
83. CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience.
84. Amory B. Lovins and L. Hunter Lovins, Brittle Power: Energy Strategy and National Security (Andover, MA: Brick House Publishing, 1982)
85. John Byrne and Steven M. Hoffman, "The Ideology of Progress and the Globalization of Nuclear Power," in John Byrne and Steven M. Hoffman, eds., Governing the Atom: The Politics of Risk (New Brunswick, NJ and London, UK: Transaction, 1996)
86. Howard Geller, Energy Revolution: Policies for a Sustainable Future (Washington, DC: Island Press, 2003).
87. Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy, The First Basic Plan for Power Supply: 2002-2015 (Seoul: MOCIE, 2002)
88. International Energy Agency, Nuclear Power in the OECD (Paris: IEA, 2001), pp. 130-131.
89. CEEP, A Review of US Restructuring Experience, Korea Power Exchange (KPX),"The Korea Power Exchange and Electricity Market," report (Seoul: KPX, 2001).
90. See Korea Tripartite Commission, "Summary of the Joint Research Team's Final Report on Reform of the Electricity Industry," (Seoul: KEPCO, 2004).
91. Byrne and Mun, "Rethinking Reform in the Electricity Sector."
92. See Kenneth Rose, "The State of Retail Electricity Markets in the US," The Electricity Journal, vol. 17, issue 1 (2004), pp. 26-36.
93. Byrne and Mun, "Rethinking Reform in the Electricity Sector."
94. Byrne and Mun, "Rethinking Reform in the Electricity Sector."
95. Korea Power Exchange (KPX), "The Korea Power Exchange (KPX) and Electricity Market," report (Seoul: KPX, 2001).