Colonic stent vs. emergency surgery for management of acute left-sided malignant colonic obstruction: A decision analysis

Gastrointestinal Endoscopy

Volumn 60, Issue 6, 2004, Pages 865-874

  Targownik, Laura E ^a   Spiegel, Brennan M ^a   Sack, Jonathan ^a   Hines, Oscar J ^a   Dulai, Gareth S ^a   Gralnek, Ian M ^a   Farrell, James J ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MANITOBA   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

AGED; ARTICLE; CANCER SURGERY; COLON CANCER; COLON OBSTRUCTION; COLONIC STENT; CONTROLLED STUDY; CORRELATION ANALYSIS; COST EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS; DECISION MAKING; DEVICE; DISEASE COURSE; EMERGENCY SURGERY; HUMAN; MAJOR CLINICAL STUDY; MALE; MATHEMATICAL COMPUTING; MORTALITY; OUTCOMES RESEARCH; PRIORITY JOURNAL; STENT; STOMA; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE;

ACUTE DISEASE; AGED; COLECTOMY; COLONIC DISEASES; COLONIC NEOPLASMS; COLOSTOMY; COMBINED MODALITY THERAPY; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; DECISION SUPPORT TECHNIQUES; EMERGENCIES; HUMANS; INTESTINAL OBSTRUCTION; MALE; MATHEMATICAL COMPUTING; REOPERATION; SOFTWARE; STENTS; SURGICAL PROCEDURES, ELECTIVE; SURVIVAL RATE;

EID: 10644273542     PISSN: 00165107     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0016-5107(04)02225-4     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. P. Boyle Some recent developments in the epidemiology of colorectal cancer H.R.P. Bleiberg H.-J. Wilke Management of colorectal cancer 1998 Martin Dunitz London 19 34
2. U. Ohman Prognosis in patients with obstructing colorectal carcinoma Am J Surg 143 1982 742 747
3. G.T. Deans, Z.H. Krukowski, and S.T. Irwin Malignant obstruction of the left colon Br J Surg 81 1994 1270 1276
4. S. Riedl, H. Wiebelt, U. Bergmann, and P. Hermanek Jr. Postoperative complications and fatalities in surgical therapy of colon carcinoma. Results of the German multicenter study by the Colorectal Carcinoma Study Group [German] Chirurg 66 1995 597 606
5. N.M. Koruth, D.C. Hunter, Z.H. Krukowski, and N.A. Matheson Immediate resection in emergency large bowel surgery: a 7 year audit Br J Surg 72 1985 703 707
6. E. Mitry, F. Barthod, C. Penna, and B. Nordlinger Surgery for colon and rectal cancer Best Pract Res Clin Gastroenterol 16 2002 253 265
7. N.W. Pearce, S.D. Scott, and S.J. Karran Timing and method of reversal of Hartmann's procedure Br J Surg 79 1992 839 841
8. R.W. Wong, W.D. Rappaport, D.B. Witzke, C.W. Putnam, and G.C. Hunter Factors influencing the safety of colostomy closure in the elderly J Surg Res 57 1994 289 292
9. K.P. Nugent, P. Daniels, B. Stewart, R. Patankar, and C.D. Johnson Quality of life in stoma patients Dis Colon Rectum 42 1999 1569 1574
10. M.A. Sprangers, B.G. Taal, N.K. Aaronson, and A. te Velde Quality of life in colorectal cancer. Stoma vs. nonstoma patients Dis Colon Rectum 38 1995 361 369
11. E.E. Londono-Schimmer, A.P. Leong, and R.K. Phillips Life table analysis of stomal complications following colostomy Dis Colon Rectum 37 1994 916 920
12. J.J. Park, A. Del Pino, C.P. Orsay, R.L. Nelson, R.K. Pearl, and J.R. Cintron Stoma complications: the Cook County Hospital experience Dis Colon Rectum 42 1999 1575 1580
13. H.A. Dudley, A.G. Racliffe, and D. McGeehan Intraoperative irrigation of the colon to permit primary anastomosis Br J Surg 67 1980 80 81
14. A.G. Radcliffe, and H.A. Dudley Intraoperative antegrade irrigation of the large intestine Surg Gynecol Obstet 156 1983 721 723
15. N.M. Koruth, Z.H. Krukowski, G.G. Youngson, W.S. Hendry, J.R. Logie, and P.F. Jones Intra-operative colonic irrigation in the management of left-sided large bowel emergencies Br J Surg 72 1985 708 711
16. S.G. Tan, R. Nambiar, A. Rauff, S.S. Ngoi, and H.S. Goh Primary resection and anastomosis in obstructed descending colon due to cancer Arch Surg 126 1991 748 751
17. M. Dohmoto New method: endoscopic implantation of rectal stent in palliative treatment of malignant stenosis Endoscopia Digestiva 3 1991 1507 1512
18. A. Mainar, E. Tejero, M. Maynar, H. Ferral, and W. Castaneda-Zuniga Colorectal obstruction: treatment with metallic stents Radiology 198 1996 761 764
19. J.J. Farrell, and D.C. Carr-Locke Metal enteral stents: an endoscopist's perspective Seminars in Interventional Radiology 18 2001 327 337
20. T.H. Baron, P.A. Dean, M.R. Yates 3rd, C. Canon, and R.E. Koehler Expandable metal stents for the treatment of colonic obstruction: techniques and outcomes Gastrointest Endosc 47 1998 277 286
21. A. Mainar, M.A. De Gregorio Ariza, E. Tejero, R. Tobio, E. Alfonso, and I. Pinto Acute colorectal obstruction: treatment with self-expandable metallic stents before scheduled surgery - results of a multicenter study Radiology 210 1999 65 69
22. M. Keymling Colorectal stenting Endoscopy 35 2003 234 238
23. C.A. Binkert, H. Ledermann, R. Jost, P. Saurenmann, M. Decurtins, and C.L. Zollikofer Acute colonic obstruction: clinical aspects and cost-effectiveness of preoperative and palliative treatment with self-expanding metallic stents - a preliminary report Radiology 206 1998 199 204
24. M.F. Drummond, W.S. Richardson, B.J. O'Brien, M. Levine, and D. Heyland Users' guides to the medical literature. XIII. How to use an article on economic analysis of clinical practice. A. Are the results of the study valid? Evidence-Based Medicine Working Group JAMA 277 1997 1552 1557
25. Stamatakis JT, M Chave, H. National audit of bowel obstruction due to colorectal cancer, April 1998-March 1999. London: Association of Coloproctology of Great Britain and Ireland; 2000.
26. L. Smothers, L. Hynan, J. Fleming, R. Turnage, C. Simmang, and T. Anthony Emergency surgery for colon carcinoma Dis Colon Rectum 46 2003 24 30
27. S. Repse, M. Calic, B. Zakelj, Z. Stor, R. Juvan, and F. Jelenc Emergency colorectal surgery: our results and complications Ann Ital Chir 67 1996 205 209
28. K.R. Anderson, P.T. Fadden, K. Kerbl, E.M. McDougall, and R.V. Clayman Laparoscopic assisted continent urinary diversion in the pig J Urol 154 1995 1934 1938
29. H.S. Chen, and S.M. Sheen-Chen Obstruction and perforation in colorectal adenocarcinoma: an analysis of prognosis and current trends Surgery 127 2000 370 376
30. R.K. Phillips, R. Hittinger, J.S. Fry, and L.P. Fielding Malignant large bowel obstruction Br J Surg 72 1985 296 302
31. C.A. Sommeling, and L. Haeck Caecostomy in the management of acute left colonic obstruction Acta Chir Belg 97 1997 217 219
32. J.W. Serpell, F.T. McDermott, H. Katrivessis, and E.S. Hughes Obstructing carcinomas of the colon Br J Surg 76 1989 965 969
33. J.C. Garcia-Valdecasas, J.M. Llovera, A.M. deLacy, J.C. Reverter, L. Grande, and J. Fuster Obstructing colorectal carcinomas. Prospective study Dis Colon Rectum 34 1991 759 762
34. T.T. Irvin, and M.G. Greaney The treatment of colonic cancer presenting with intestinal obstruction Br J Surg 64 1977 741 744
35. W.H. Isbister, and J. Prasad The management of left-sided large bowel obstruction: an audit Aust N Z J Surg 66 1996 602 604
36. O. Kronborg Acute obstruction from tumour in the left colon without spread. A randomized trial of emergency colostomy versus resection Int J Colorectal Dis 10 1995 1 5
37. S.P. Huddy, A.J. Shorthouse, and C.G. Marks The surgical treatment of intestinal obstruction due to left sided carcinoma of the colon Ann R Coll Surg Engl 70 1988 40 43
38. J.P. Welch, and G.A. Donaldson Management of severe obstruction of the large bowel due to malignant disease Am J Surg 127 1974 492 499
39. H.C. Umpleby, and R.C. Williamson Survival in acute obstructing colorectal carcinoma Dis Colon Rectum 27 1984 299 304
40. J.P. Arnaud, and R. Bergamaschi Emergency subtotal/total colectomy with anastomosis for acutely obstructed carcinoma of the left colon Dis Colon Rectum 37 1994 685 688
41. D. DeFriend, and J. Hill A review of emergency colonic surgery Br J Hosp Med 56 1996 326 329
42. A.R. Dixon, and J.T. Holmes Hartmann's procedure for carcinoma of rectum and distal sigmoid colon: 5-year audit J R Coll Surg Edinb 35 1990 166 168
43. Y.S. Feng, H. Hsu, and S.S. Chen One-stage operation for obstructing carcinomas of the left colon and rectum Dis Colon Rectum 30 1987 29 32
44. L. Vigder, N. Tzur, M. Huber, M. Mahagna, and I. Amir Management of obstructive carcinoma of the left colon. Comparative study of staged and primary resection Arch Surg 120 1985 825 828
45. D. van Geldere, P. Fa-Si-Oen, L.A. Noach, P.J. Rietra, J.L. Peterse, and R.P. Boom Complications after colorectal surgery without mechanical bowel preparation J Am Coll Surg 194 2002 40 47
46. J. Whittle, E.P. Steinberg, G.F. Anderson, and R. Herbert Results of colectomy in elderly patients with colon cancer, based on Medicare claims data Am J Surg 163 1992 572 576
47. M. Massa, G. Corradini, R. Bucchianeri, F. Xiume, and R. Scibe Emergency surgical treatment in cancer of the colon Ann Ital Chir 66 1995 467 471
48. J. Mella, A. Biffin, A.G. Radcliffe, J.D. Stamatakis, and R.J. Steele Population-based audit of colorectal cancer management in two UK health regions. Colorectal Cancer Working Group, Royal College of Surgeons of England Clinical Epidemiology and Audit Unit Br J Surg 84 1997 1731 1736
49. W.J. Mileski, R.V. Rege, R.J. Joehl, and D.L. Nahrwold Rates of morbidity and mortality after closure of loop and end colostomy Surg Gynecol Obstet 171 1990 17 21
50. H. Mochizuki, E. Nakamura, K. Hase, and S. Tamakuma The advantage of primary resection and anastomosis with intraoperative bowel irrigation for obstructing left-sided colorectal carcinoma Surg Today 23 1993 771 776
51. A.G. Greenburg, R.P. Saik, and D. Pridham Influence of age on mortality of colon surgery Am J Surg 150 1985 65 70
52. D.C. Nyam, F. Seow-Choen, A.F. Leong, and Y.H. Ho Colonic decompression without on-table irrigation for obstructing left-sided colorectal tumours Br J Surg 83 1996 786 787
53. I.M. Leitman, J.D. Sullivan, D. Brams, and J.J. DeCosse Multivariate analysis of morbidity and mortality from the initial surgical management of obstructing carcinoma of the colon Surg Gynecol Obstet 174 1992 513 518
54. F. Camunez, A. Echenagusia, G. Simo, F. Turegano, J. Vazquez, and I. Barreiro-Meiro Malignant colorectal obstruction treated by means of self-expanding metallic stents: effectiveness before surgery and in palliation Radiology 216 2000 492 497
55. E. Tejero, R. Fernandez-Lobato, A. Mainar, C. Montes, I. Pinto, and L. Fernandez Initial results of a new procedure for treatment of malignant obstruction of the left colon Dis Colon Rectum 40 1997 432 436
56. M.A. de Gregorio, A. Mainar, E. Tejero, R. Tobio, E. Alfonso, and I. Pinto Acute colorectal obstruction: stent placement for palliative treatment - results of a multicenter study Radiology 209 1998 117 120
57. W.L. Law, K.W. Chu, J.W. Ho, H.M. Tung, S.Y. Law, and K.M. Chu Self-expanding metallic stent in the treatment of colonic obstruction caused by advanced malignancies Dis Colon Rectum 43 2000 1522 1527
58. I.W. Choo, Y.S. Do, S.W. Suh, H.K. Chun, S.W. Choo, and H.S. Park Malignant colorectal obstruction: treatment with a flexible covered stent Radiology 206 1998 415 421
59. Y. Saida, Y. Sumiyama, J. Nagao, and M. Takase Stent endoprosthesis for obstructing colorectal cancers Dis Colon Rectum 39 1996 552 555
60. C.L. Canon, T.H. Baron, D.E. Morgan, P.A. Dean, and R.E. Koehler Treatment of colonic obstruction with expandable metal stents: radiologic features AJR Am J Roentgenol 168 1997 199 205
61. H. Liberman, D.R. Adams, G.J. Blatchford, C.A. Ternent, M.A. Christensen, and A.G. Thorson Clinical use of the self-expanding metallic stent in the management of colorectal cancer Am J Surg 180 2000 407 411 discussion 412
62. E. Desroches, J.L. Faucheron, C. Sengel, F. Lachachi, O. Risse, and P. Delannoy Self-expandable metal stent in the treatment of obstructive cancer of the left colon. Preliminary results and review of the literature Ann Chir 53 1999 1029 1032
63. S. Miyayama, O. Matsui, K. Kifune, M. Yamashiro, T. Yamamoto, and K. Kitagawa Malignant colonic obstruction due to extrinsic tumor: palliative treatment with a self-expanding nitinol stent AJR Am J Roentgenol 175 2000 1631 1637
64. F. Wallis, K.L. Campbell, O. Eremin, and J.K. Hussey Self-expanding metal stents in the management of colorectal carcinoma: a preliminary report Clin Radiol 53 1998 251 254
65. T. Arnell, M.J. Stamos, P. Takahashi, S. Ojha, G. Sze, and V. Eysselein Colonic stents in colorectal obstruction Am Surg 64 1998 986 988
66. R.I. Aviv, G. Shyamalan, A. Watkinson, J. Tibballs, and G. Ogunbaye Radiological palliation of malignant colonic obstruction Clin Radiol 57 2002 347 351
67. E. Ben Soussan, G. Savoye, P. Hochain, M. Antonietti, S. Herve, and F. Forestier Expandable metal stents in palliative treatment of malignant colorectal stricture. A report of 17 consecutive patients Gastroenterol Clin Biol 25 2001 463 467
68. S.J. Cole, P. Boorman, H. Osman, M. Sathananthan, and M.C. Parker Endoluminal stenting for relief of colonic obstruction is safe and effective Colorectal Dis 2 2000 282 287
69. L. Paul Diaz, I. Pinto Pabon, R. Fernandez Lobato, and C. Montes Lopez Palliative treatment of malignany colorectal strictures with metallic stents Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol 22 1999 29 36
70. C.E. Dauphine, P. Tan, R.W. Beart Jr., P. Vukasin, H. Cohen, and M.L. Corman Placement of self-expanding metal stents for acute malignant large-bowel obstruction: a collective review Ann Surg Oncol 9 2002 574 579
71. R. Fernandez Lobato, I. Pinto, L. Paul, E. Tejero, C. Montes, and L. Fernandez Self-expanding prostheses as a palliative method in treating advanced colorectal cancer Int Surg 84 1999 159 162
72. C.L. Zollikofer, R. Jost, E. Schoch, and M. Decurtins Gastrointestinal stenting Eur Radiol 10 2000 329 341
73. R. Rocca, C. De Angelis, F. Coppola, C. Barletti, A. Pera, and M. Rizzetto Enteral wallstent for the emergency treatment of acute colonic obstruction due to malignant strictures [abstract] Gastrointest Endosc 51 2000 AB105
74. A. Repici, D. Reggio, C. De Angelis, C. Barletti, P. Marchesa, and A. Musso Covered metal stents for management of inoperable malignant colorectal strictures Gastrointest Endosc 52 2000 735 740
75. J.F. Rey, T. Romanczyk, and M. Greff Metal stents for palliation of rectal carcinoma: a preliminary report on 12 patients Endoscopy 27 1995 501 504
76. P. Spinelli, M. Dal Fante, and A. Mancini Rectal metal stents for palliation of colorectal malignant stenosis Bildgebung 60 Suppl 1 1993 48 50
77. S. Adamsen, J. Holm, S. Meisner, P. Moller, L.P. Naver, and F. West Endoscopic placement of self-expanding metal stents for treatment of colorectal obstruction with long-term follow-up Dan Med Bull 47 2000 225 227
78. G.N. Buchanan, A.R. Khawaja, E.I. Okojie, P.H. Rowe, M.P. Saunders, and B.J. Stoodley A retrospective analysis of palliative colonic stent placement in an elderly population Colorectal Dis 2 2000 277 281
79. E. Knopfle, G. Wamser, H. Mayer, N. Zugel, and K. Bohndorf Emergency decompression of a mechanical colonic ileus before elective surgery: first clinical results of fluoroscopic stent placement [German] Rofo Fortschr Geb Rontgenstr Neuen Bildgeb Verfahr 168 1998 380 384
80. W.Z. Tamim, A. Ghellai, T.C. Counihan, R.S. Swanson, J.M. Colby, and W.B. Sweeney Experience with endoluminal colonic wall stents for the management of large bowel obstruction for benign and malignant disease Arch Surg 135 2000 434 438
81. J. Tack, A.M. Gevers, and P. Rutgeerts Self-expandable metallic stents in the palliation of rectosigmoidal carcinoma: a follow-up study Gastrointest Endosc 48 1998 267 271
82. M.H. Wholey, E.A. Levine, H. Ferral, and W. Castaneda-Zuniga Initial clinical experience with colonic stent placement Am J Surg 175 1998 194 197
83. M. Fava, O. Contreras, S. Loyola, and F. Lopez Colorectal neoplasms. Treatment of obstruction with autoexpanding metal stents [Spanish] Rev Med Chil 127 1999 1207 1212
84. I. Raijman, M. Siemens, and N. Marcon Use of an expandable Ultraflex stent in the treatment of malignant rectal stricture Endoscopy 27 1995 273 276
85. K.L. Campbell, J.K. Hussey, and O. Eremin Expandable metal stent application in obstructing carcinoma of the proximal colon: report of a case Dis Colon Rectum 40 1997 1391 1393
86. M. Dohmoto, M. Hunerbein, and P.M. Schlag Application of rectal stents for palliation of obstructing rectosigmoid cancer Surg Endosc 11 1997 758 761
87. R. Davidson, and W.B. Sweeney Endoluminal stenting for benign colonic obstruction Surg Endosc 12 1998 353 354
88. P. Boorman, Z. Soonawalla, N. Sathananthan, P. Macfarlane, and M.C. Parker Endoluminal stenting of obstructed colorectal tumours Ann R Coll Surg Engl 81 1999 251 254
89. M. Lamah, P. Mathur, B. McKeown, H. Blake, and R.I. Swift The use of rectosigmoid stents in the management of acute large bowel obstruction J R Coll Surg Edinb 43 1998 318 321
90. Z. Soonawalla, K. Thakur, P. Boorman, P. Macfarlane, N. Sathananthan, and M. Parker Use of self-expanding metallic stents in the management of obstruction of the sigmoid colon AJR Am J Roentgenol 171 1998 633 636
91. F. Turegano-Fuentes, A. Echenagusia-Belda, G. Simo-Muerza, F. Camunez, F. Munoz-Jimenez, and E. Del Valle Hernandez Transanal self-expanding metal stents as an alternative to palliative colostomy in selected patients with malignant obstruction of the left colon Br J Surg 85 1998 232 235
92. K. Tominaga, M. Yoshida, I. Maetani, and Y. Sakai Expandable metal stent placement in the treatment of a malignant anastomotic stricture of the transverse colon Gastrointest Endosc 53 2001 524 527
93. A.J. Pikarsky, J.E. Efron, E.G. Weiss, P. Eisenberg, J.J. Nogueras, and S.D. Wexner Overcoming Wallstent malposition in the treatment of rectosigmoid obstruction Surg Endosc 14 2000 372 374
94. E. Knopfle, H. Mayer, G. Wamser, K. Bohndorf, and J. Witte Ileus in colorectal carcinoma. Preoperative implantation of self-expanding metal stents and early elective surgery as an alternative to emergency surgery [German] Chirurg 72 2001 1137 1143
95. K.D. Rupp, M. Dohmoto, R. Meffert, A. Holzgreve, and G. Hohlbach Cancer of the rectum: palliative endoscopic treatment Eur J Surg Oncol 21 1995 644 647
96. D. Xinopoulos, D. Dimitroulopoulos, K. Tsamakidis, N. Apostolikas, and E. Paraskevas Treatment of malignant colonic obstructions with metal stents and laser Hepatogastroenterology 49 2002 359 362
97. H. Osaka, K. Maeda, Y. Nishiguchi, M. Yashiro, M. Swai, and Y. Yamashita Expandable metallic stent for the treatment of left-sided colonic obstruction with malignant disease [Japanese] Gan To Kagaku Ryoho 27 2000 1970 1972
98. M.A. Mauro, R.E. Koehler, and T.H. Baron Advances in gastrointestinal intervention: the treatment of gastroduodenal and colorectal obstructions with metallic stents Radiology 215 2000 659 669
99. C. Martinez-Santos, R.F. Lobato, J.M. Fradejas, I. Pinto, P. Ortega-Deballon, and M. Moreno-Azcoita Self-expandable stent before elective surgery vs. emergency surgery for the treatment of malignant colorectal obstructions: comparison of primary anastomosis and morbidity rates Dis Colon Rectum 45 2002 401 406
100. J.I. Vrazas, S. Ferris, S. Bau, and I. Faragher Stenting for obstructing colorectal malignancy: an interim or definitive procedure ANZ J Surg 72 2002 392 396
101. G.J. Harris, A.J. Senagore, I.C. Lavery, and V.W. Fazio The management of neoplastic colorectal obstruction with colonic endolumenal stenting devices Am J Surg 181 2001 499 506
102. M. Itabashi, K. Hamano, S. Kameoka, and K. Asahina Self-expanding stainless steel stent application in rectosigmoid stricture Dis Colon Rectum 36 1993 508 511
103. U.P. Khot, A.W. Lang, K. Murali, and M.C. Parker Systematic review of the efficacy and safety of colorectal stents Br J Surg 89 2002 1096 1102
104. P. Gandrup, L. Lund, and I. Balslev Surgical treatment of acute malignant large bowel obstruction Eur J Surg 158 1992 427 430
105. H.S. Osman, H.I. Rashid, N. Sathananthan, and M.C. Parker The cost effectiveness of self-expanding metal stents in the management of malignant left sided large bowel obstruction Colorectal Dis 2 2000 233 237
106. J.A. Dominitz, and D. Provenzale Patient preferences and quality of life associated with colorectal cancer screening Am J Gastroenterol 92 1997 2171 2178
107. N.F. Boyd, H.J. Sutherland, K.Z. Heasman, D.L. Tritchler, and B.J. Cummings Whose utilities for decision analysis? Med Decis Making 10 1990 58 67