Horner versus Holdred: An Episode in the History of Root Computation

Historia Mathematica

Volumn 26, Issue 1, 1999, Pages 29-51

  Fuller, A Thomas ^a  

^a Hillcrest   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

De Morgan; Holdred; Horner; Root computation; Synthetic division

Indexed keywords

EID: 0348224204     PISSN: 03150860     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1006/hmat.1998.2214     Document Type: Article

References (86)

1. Anon., [Review of Horner's 1819 paper], The Monthly Review or Literary Journal 91 (1820), 373-376.
2. Anon., [Review of Nicholson's books], The Monthly Review or Literary Journal 93 (1820), 408-416.
3. W. A. J. Archbold, Horner, William George, in Dictionary of National Biography, ed. Sidney Lee, London: Smith, Elder, 1891, 27:372.
4. Henry Atkinson, A New Method of Extracting the Roots of Equations, Newcastle: privately printed, 1831.
5. Peter Barlow, New Mathematical Tables, Containing the Factors, Squares, Cubes, Square Roots, Cube Roots, Reciprocals, and Hyperbolic Logarithms, of all Numbers from 1 to 10000; an Extensive Table of Formulae, or General Synopsis of the Most Important Particulars Relating to the Doctrines of Equations, Series, Fluxions, Fluents, &c. &c. &c., London: Robinson, 1814.
6. Peter Barlow, Barlow's Tables of Squares, Cubes, Square Roots, Cube Roots and Reciprocals of All Integers up to 12,500, ed. L. J. Comrie, London: Spon, 1971.
7. J. Lennart Berggren, Episodes in the Mathematics of Medieval Islam, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1986.
8. G. C. Boase, Davies, Thomas Stephens, in Dictionary of National Biography, ed. Leslie Stephen, London: Smith, Elder, 1888, 14:159-160.
9. Jacques Borowczyk, Sur la vie et l'oeuvre de François Budan (1761-1840), Historia Mathematica 18 (1991), 129-157.
10. Carl Benjamin Boyer, A History of Mathematics, New York: Wiley, 1968.
11. François-Désiré Budan, Nouvelle méthode pour la résolution des équations numériques d'un degré quelconque d'après laquelle tout le calcul exigé pour cette résolution se réduit à l'emploi des deux premières règles de l'arithmétique, Paris: Courcier, 1807.
12. François-Désiré Budan, Nouvelle méthode pour la résolution des équations numériques d'un degré quelconque d'après laquelle tout le calcul exigé pour cette résolution se réduit à l'emploi des deux premières règles de l'arithmétique, revue, augmentée d'un appendice à la nouvelle méthode et suivie d'un apperçu [sic] concernant les suites syntagmatiques, Paris: Dondey-Dupré, 1822.
13. William Snow Burnside and Arthur William Panton, The Theory of Equations: With an Introduction to the Theory of Binary Algebraic Forms, 5th ed., 2 vols., Dublin: Hodges, Figgis, 1904.
14. Florian Cajori, A History of the Arithmetical Methods of Approximation to the Roots of Numerical Equations of One Unknown Quantity, Colorado College Publication, Science Series 12 (1910), 171-287.
15. Florian Cajori, Horner's Method of Approximation Anticipated by Ruffini, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society 17 (1911), 409-414.
16. E. Irving Carlyle, Young, John Radford, in Dictionary of National Biography, ed. Sidney Lee, London: Smith, Elder, 1900, 63:383-384.
17. Jean-Luc Chabert, Évelyne Barbin, Michel Guillemot, Anne Michel-Pajus, Jacques Borowcyzyk, Ahmed Djebbar, and Jean-Claude Martzloff, Histoire d'algorithmes: Du caillou à la puce, Paris: Belin, 1994.
18. A. M. Clerke, Barlow, Peter, in Dictionary of National Biography, ed. Leslie Stephen, London: Smith, Elder, 1885, 3:222-224.
19. Julian Lowell Coolidge, The Mathematics of Great Amateurs, Oxford: Clarendon, 1949.
20. Thomas Stephens Davies, [Introduction to Horner's paper, "On Algebraic Transformation," The Mathematician 1 (1845), 108.
21. Augustus De Morgan, Arithmetic and Algebra, Library of Useful Knowledge, Mathematics I, London: Baldwin & Cradock, 1836.
22. Augustus De Morgan, Notices of the Progress of the Problem of Evolution, in Companion to the British Almanac [of the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge], 1839, 34-52.
23. Augustus De Morgan, Involution and Evolution, in The Penny Cyclopaedia of the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge, London: Knight, 1839, 13:7-11.
24. Augustus De Morgan, Involution and Evolution, in Supplement to the Penny Cyclopaedia of the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge, London: Knight, 1846, 2:101-106.
25. Augustus De Morgan, Arithmetical Books from the Invention of Printing to the Present Time Being Brief Notices of a Large Number of Works Drawn Up from Actual Inspection, London: Taylor & Walton, 1847; reprint ed., London: Elliott, 1967.
26. Augustus De Morgan, Remark on Horner's Method of Solving Equations, The Mathematician 3 (1850), 289-291.
27. Augustus De Morgan, Involution and Evolution, in The English Cyclopaedia: Arts and Sciences, London: Bradbury & Evans, 1860, 4:951-967.
28. Augustus De Morgan, A Budget of Paradoxes, London: Longmans, Green, 1872; reprint edited by D. E. Smith, 2 vols., Chicago: Open Court, 1915.
29. Sophia Elizabeth De Morgan, Memoir of Augustus De Morgan, London: Longmans, Green, 1882.
30. John M. Dubbey, De Morgan, Augustus, in Dictionary of Scientific Biography, ed. Charles C. Gillispie, New York: Scribner, 1971, 4:35-37.
31. Anthony William Fairbank Edwards, Pascal's Arithmetical Triangle, London: Griffin, 1987.
32. Ivor Grattan-Guinness, Convolutions in French Mathematics, 1800-1840, 3 vols., Basel: Birkhäuser, 1990.
33. Niccolò Guicciardini, The Development of the Newtonian Calculus in Britain 1700-1800, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1989.
34. A. Rupert Hall, [Introduction to the reprint of De Morgan's Arithmetical Books . . .], London: Elliott, 1967.
35. Thomas Harriot, Artis analyticae praxis, London: Barker, 1631; trans. Muriel Seltman in A Commentary on the Artis Analyticae Praxis of Thomas Harriot, M.Sc. dissertation, University of London, 1972, 138-203.
36. Thomas Harriot, Artis analyticae praxis, London: Barker, 1631; trans. Muriel Seltman in A Commentary on the Artis Analyticae Praxis of Thomas Harriot, M.Sc. dissertation, University of London, 1972, 138-203.
37. Theophilus Holdred, A New Method of Solving Equations with Ease and Expedition; by which the True Value of the Unknown Quantity is Found without Previous Reduction. With a Supplement, Containing Two Other Methods of Solving Equations, Derived from the Same Principle, London: Davis & Dickson, 1820. (Copies are in the libraries of London University and the Royal Society of London.)
38. Theophilus Holdred, On Mr. Holdred's Tract Entitled "A New Method of Solving Equations," &c. and Mr. Nicholson's "Essay on Involution and Evolution," Philosophical Magazine 56 (1820), 374-379.
39. Theophilus Holdred, On Mr. Holdred's Tract Entitled "A New Method of Solving Equations," &c. and Mr. Nicholson's "Essay on Involution and Evolution," Philosophical Magazine 56 (1820), 374-379.
40. William Horner, On the Popular Methods of Approximation, Mathematical Repository 4 (1819), 131-136.
41. William Horner, A New Method of Solving Numerical Equations of All Orders, by Continuous Approximation, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Part II (1819), 308-335.
42. William Horner, Letter from Mr. W. G. Horner, Mathematical Repository 5 (1830), 37-40.
43. William Horner, Horae arithmeticae, Mathematical Repository 5 (1830), 21-37, 41-75.
44. William Horner, [Reprint of [39], with additions], The Ladies' Diary (1838), 49-72.
45. William Horner, On Algebraic Transformation; as Deducible from First Principles; and Connected with Continuous Approximation and the Theory of Finite and Infinitesimal Differences: including some New Modes of Numerical Solution, The Mathematician 1 (1845), 108-112, 136-142, 311-316.
46. Harold Jeffreys and Bertha Swirles Jeffreys, Methods of Mathematical Physics, 3rd ed., Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1962.
47. Adolf P. Juschkewitsch, Geschichte der Mathematik im Mittelalter, Leipzig: Teubner, 1964. (See also [81].)
48. Ulrich Libbrecht, Chinese Mathematics in the Thirteenth Century: The Shu-shu Chiu-chang of Ch 'in Chiu-shao, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1973.
49. E. Keith Lloyd, Mr Peter Nicholson, the Practical Builder and Mathematician, The Mathematical Gazette 66 (1982), 203-307.
50. Paul Luckey, Die Ausziehung der n-ten Wurzel und der binomische Lehrsatz in der islamischen Mathematik, Mathematische Annalen 120 (1947-1949), 217-274.
51. e ūd al-Kāšī mit Rückblicken auf die ältere Geschichte des Rechnens, Abhandlungen für die Kunde des Morgenlandes 31 (1951), i-x, 1-143.
52. 3 + pxx + qx + r = 0, Waste Book (manuscript), c. 1665.
53. Peter Nicholson, Essays on the Combinatorial Analysis, Shewing its Application to Some of the Most Useful and Interesting Problems of Algebra, such as the Expansion of a Multinomial, according to any Given Exponent, the Reversion and Conversion of Series, the Theory of Indeterminate Equations, &c., and Clearly Indicating the Law of Expansion, London: Longman, 1818.
54. Peter Nicholson, Account of Certain Improvements in Involution and Evolution, Philosophical Magazine 52 (1818), 341-348.
55. Peter Nicholson, The Rudiments of Algebra: in which the Subject is Explicitly Treated in a New Manner, the Theory Rendered Clear, and the Practice More Expeditious then Hitherto. For the Use of Schools, and for the Assistance of Those Who Have Not the Advantage of a Master; as also to Prepare the Student to Read the More Intricate Branches of the Mathematics with Less Difficulty, London: Barfield, 1819.
56. Peter Nicholson, Essay on Involution and Evolution; Containing a New, Accurate, and General Method of Ascertaining the Numerical Value of any Function of an Unknown Quantity; Particularly Applied to the Operation of Extracting the Roots of Equations, Pure or Adfected, . . . . Together with an Appendix, Shewing the Use of Figurate Numbers and Arithmetical Equivalents in the Extraction of Roots: the Whole Adapted Equally to the Skilful Analyst and the Expert Arithmetician, London: Davis & Dickson, 1820.
57. Peter Nicholson, Essay on Involution & Evolution; Particularly Applied to the Operation of Extracting the Roots of Equations and Numbers, According to a Process Entirely Arithmetical; Superseding, by its Greater Simplicity, Swiftness, and Regularity, Every Other Method That Has Yet Been Attempted. A New Edition; with a Postscript, Vindicating the Claims of the Author . . . , London: Davis & Dickson, 1820.
58. Peter Nicholson, Answer of Mr. P. Nicholson to Mr. Holdred on Mr. N.'s Work on Involution and Evolution, Philosophical Magazine 57 (1821), 33-40.
59. Peter Nicholson, New Demonstrations of the Method Invented by Budan, and Improved by Others, of Extracting the Roots of Equations, Philosophical Magazine 60 (1822), 173-178.
60. Peter Nicholson, On the Transformation of Functions, Philosophical Magazine 62 (1823), 168-175.
61. Peter Nicholson, Derivative Analysis; Being a New and More Comprehensive Method of Transformation of Functions Than Any Hitherto Discovered: Extending Not Only to the Extraction of Roots of Equations, but Also to the Reduction of Quantities from the Multiples of Powers or Products to Other Equivalent Expressions, by Which the Summation of Any Rational Series May Be Readily Effected, Philosophical Magazine 62 (1823), 244-252, 348-355, 433-439.
62. Martin Andrew Nordgaard, A Historical Survey of Algebraic Methods of Approximating the Roots of Numerical Higher Equations up to the Year 1819, New York: Columbia University, 1922.
63. William Oughtred, The Key of the Mathematicks, London: Whitaker, 1647.
64. George Peacock, Report on Recent Progress and Present State of Certain Branches of Analysis, in Reports of the British Association for the Advancement of Science (1833), 185-352.
65. Charles Platts, Leybourn, Thomas, in Dictionary of National Biography, ed. Sidney Lee, London: Smith, Elder, 1893, 33:208.
66. B. Porter, Nicholson, Peter, in Dictionary of National Biography, ed. Sidney Lee, London: Smith, Elder, 1895, 41:23-25.
67. Roshdi Rashed, Résolution des équations numériques et algèbre: Šaraf-al-Dīn al-Tüsi, Viète, Archive for History of Exact Sciences 12 (1974), 244-290.
68. Adrian Rice, Augustus De Morgan: Historian of Science, History of Science 34 (1996), 201-240.
69. Adrian Rice, Mathematics in the Metropolis: A Survey of Victorian London, Historia Mathematica 23 (1996), 376-417.
70. Paolo Ruffini, Sopra la determinazione delle radici neue equazioni numeriche di qualunque grado, Modena: Societa' Italiana delle Scienze, 1804.
71. Paolo Ruffini, Di un nuovo metodo generale di estrarre le radici numeriche, Memorie di matematica e di fisica della Societa' italiana delle scienze Part 116 (1813), 373-429, 17 (1816), 1-15, 462.
72. Paolo Ruffini, Di un nuovo metodo generale di estrarre le radici numeriche, Memorie di matematica e di fisica della Societa' italiana delle scienze Part 116 (1813), 373-429, 17 (1816), 1-15, 462.
73. D. V. S., On Horner's Synthetic Division, The Mathematician 1 (1845), 74-76.
74. David Eugene Smith, A Source Book in Mathematics, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1929; reprint ed., 2 vols., New York: Dover, 1959.
75. Isaac Todhunter, An Elementary Treatise on the Theory of Equations, with a Collection of Examples, 2nd ed., Cambridge, UK: Macmillan, 1867.
76. Herbert Western Turnbull, Theory of Equations, 2nd ed., Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd, 1944.
77. James Victor Uspensky, Theory of Equations, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1948.
78. François Viète, De numerosa potestatum ad exegesim resolutione, Paris: Le Clerc, 1600; abridged trans. by T. R. Witmer in The Analytic Art by François Viète, Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 1983, 311-370.
79. François Viète, De numerosa potestatum ad exegesim resolutione, Paris: Le Clerc, 1600; abridged trans. by T. R. Witmer in The Analytic Art by François Viète, Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 1983, 311-370.
80. François Viète, Francisci Vietae opera mathematica, ed. F. Schooten, Leiden: Elzevir, 1646.
81. Derek Thomas Whiteside, ed., The Mathematical Papers of Isaac Newton, 8 vols., Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1967-1981.
82. Edmund Taylor Whittaker and George Robinson, The Calculus of Observations, 4th ed., Glasgow: Blackie, 1944.
83. John Radford Young, An Elementary Treatise on Algebra, Theoretical and Practical; with Attempts to Simplify Some of the More Difficult Parts of the Science, Particularly the Demonstration of the Binomial Theorem in Its Most General Form; the Solution of Equations of the Higher Orders; the Summation of Infinite Series, &c. Intended for the Use of Students, London: Whittaker, 1823.
84. John Radford Young, On the Theory and Solution of Algebraical Equations, with the Recent Researches of Budan, Fourier, and Sturm, on the Separation of the Real and Imaginary Roots of Equations, London: Souter, 1835.
85. e siècles), Paris: Vrin, 1976. (Translation of a chapter of [45].)
86. e ūd, in Dictionary of Scientific Biography, ed. Charles C. Gillispie, New York: Scribner, 1973, 7:255-262.