An analysis of the present system of scientific publishing: What's wrong and where to go from here

Interdisciplinary Science Reviews

Volumn 28, Issue 4, 2003, Pages 293-302

  Greenbaum, Dov ^a   Lim, Joanna ^b   Gerstein, Mark ^b  

^a YALE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^b YALE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

BIOINFORMATICS; SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH;

COPYRIGHTS; DATA STORAGE EQUIPMENT; DATABASE SYSTEMS; INTERNET; LAWS AND LEGISLATION; MOLECULAR BIOLOGY; PUBLISHING;

INFORMATION DISSEMINATION;

EID: 0347603434     PISSN: 03080188     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1179/030801803225005238     Document Type: Review

References (96)

1. J.-C. GUÉDON: In Oldenburg's Long Shadow: Librarians, Research Scientists, Publishers, and the Control of Scientific Publishing; 2001, Annapolis Junction, MD, Association of Research Libraries (www.arl.org/arl/proceedings/138/guedon.html).
2. E. R. WERTMAN: 'Electronic preprint distribution: a case study of physicists and chemists at the University of Maryland', MSc thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, VI, USA, 1999 (scholar.lib.vt.edu/theses/available/etd-042499-103003).
3. R. SPIER: 'The history of the peer-review process', Trends in Biotechnology, 2002, 20, 357-358.
4. C. TENOPIR and D. W. KING: 'Lessons for the future of journals', Nature, 2001, 413, 672-674.
5. A. M. ODLYZKO: in Access to Publicly Financed Research: The Global Research Village III, (ed. S. Wouters), 273-278; 2000, Amsterdam, NIWI.
6. A. DE KEMP: in The Impact of Electronic Publishing on the Academic Community, (ed. I. Butterworth), 4-9; 1998, London, Portland Press.
7. P. GINSPARG: 'Creating a global knowledge network', in Proc. Symp. on Electronic Scientific, Technical, and Medical Journal Publishing and its Implications, Washington, DC, 2003, National Academies Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public Policy.
8. V. BUSH: 'As we may think', Atlantic Monthly, 1945, 176, 101-108.
9. See 'Grey literature: an annotated bibliography', prepared by the US Association of College and Research Libraries' STS Subject & Bibliographic Access Committee and available online at personal.ecu.edu/cooninb/greyliterature.htm.
10. W. WARNICK: 'Tailoring access to the source: preprints, grey literature and journal articles', 3 May 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/warnick.html.
11. A. OKERSON: 'What price "free"?', 5 April 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/okerson.html
12. 'Great expectations', Nature Neuroscience, 2001, 4, 1151.
13. J. KIRCZ: 'New practices for electronic publishing: how to maintain quality and guarantee integrity', in Proc. Second Joint ICSU Press-UNESCO Expert Conf. on Electronic Publishing in Science, Paris, France, February 2001, ICSU/UNESCO International (users.ox.ac.uk/̃icsuinfo/kirczppr.htm).
14. For information on the various initiatives, see A. M. F. BUCK, R. C. COLES and B. COLES: 'Scholars' Forum: a new model for scholarly communication', library.caltech.edu/publications/ScholarsForum/default.htm; www.arl.org/spare; and S. K. BAKER et al.: 'Principles for emerging systems of scholarly publishing', May 2000, www.arl.org/scomm/tempe.html.
15. For information on the various initiatives, see A. M. F. BUCK, R. C. COLES and B. COLES: 'Scholars' Forum: a new model for scholarly communication', library.caltech.edu/publications/ScholarsForum/default.htm; www.arl.org/spare; and S. K. BAKER et al.: 'Principles for emerging systems of scholarly publishing', May 2000, www.arl.org/scomm/tempe.html.
16. See J. RUMBLE: 'Publication and use of large data sets', in Proc. Second Joint ICSU Press-UNESCO Expert Conf. on Electronic Publishing in Science, Paris, France, February 2001, ICSU/UNESCO International (users.ox.ac.uk/̃icsuinfo/rumbleppr.htm).
17. M. J. GERSTEIN and J. JUNKER: 'Blurring the boundaries between scientific "papers" and biological databases', 7 May 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/gernstein.html.
18. A. M. CORREIA and M. C. NETO: 'The role of eprint archives in the access to and dissemination of scientific gray literature: LIZA - a case study by National Library of Portugal', in Proc. Int. Workshop on Electronic Media in Mathematics, Coimbra, Portugal, September 2001, Departamento de Matemática da Universidade de Coimbra (www.isegi.unl.pt/ensino/docentes/acorreia/preprint/EMM.pdf).
19. N. M. LUSCOMBE, D. GREENBAUM and M. GERSTEIN: 'What is bioinformatics? A proposed definition and overview of the field', Methods of Information in Medicine, 2001, 40, 346-358; D. GREENBAUM, N. M. LUSCOMBE, R. JANSEN, J. QIAN and M. GERSTEIN: 'Interrelating different types of genomic data, from proteome to secretome: 'oming in on function', Genome Research, 2001, 11, 1463-1468.
20. N. M. LUSCOMBE, D. GREENBAUM and M. GERSTEIN: 'What is bioinformatics? A proposed definition and overview of the field', Methods of Information in Medicine, 2001, 40, 346-358; D. GREENBAUM, N. M. LUSCOMBE, R. JANSEN, J. QIAN and M. GERSTEIN: 'Interrelating different types of genomic data, from proteome to secretome: 'oming in on function', Genome Research, 2001, 11, 1463-1468.
21. D. ADAM and J. KNIGHT: 'Journals under pressure: publish, and be damned ...', Nature, 2002, 419, 772-776.
22. D. SHULENBURGER: 'Principles for a new system of publishing for science', in Proc. Second Joint ICSU Press-UNESCO Expert Conf. on Electronic Publishing in Science, Paris, France, February 2001, ICSU/UNESCO International (users.ox.ac.uk/̃icsuinfo/shulenbergerppr.htm); R. SMITH: 'Electronic publishing in science', British Medical Journal, 2001, 322, 627-629.
23. D. SHULENBURGER: 'Principles for a new system of publishing for science', in Proc. Second Joint ICSU Press-UNESCO Expert Conf. on Electronic Publishing in Science, Paris, France, February 2001, ICSU/UNESCO International (users.ox.ac.uk/̃icsuinfo/shulenbergerppr.htm); R. SMITH: 'Electronic publishing in science', British Medical Journal, 2001, 322, 627-629.
24. Proc. Symp. on Electronic Scientific, Technical, and Medical Journal Publishing and its Implications, Washington, DC, 2003, National Academies Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public Policy.
25. S. HARNAD: 'The self-archiving initiative', Nature, 2001, 410, 1024-1025.
26. A. M. GETTO: 'The contribution of electronic communication to science - has it lived up to its promise?', in Proc. Second Joint ICSU Press-UNESCO Expert Conf. on Electronic Publishing in Science, Paris, France, February 2001, ICSU/UNESCO International (users.ox.ac.uk/̃icsuinfo/cettoppr.htm).
27. 'Costs of publication', in Proc. Symp. on Electronic Scientific, Technical, and Medical Journal Publishing and its Implications, Washington, DC, 2003, National Academies Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public Policy.
28. P. GOODEN, M. OWEN, S. SIMON and L. SINGLEHURST: 'Scientific publishing: knowledge is power', Morgan Stanley, London, UK, 2002 (www.alpsp.org/morgstan300902.pdf).
29. B.-C. BJÖRK and Z. TURK: 'How scientists retrieve publications: an empirical study of how the internet is overtaking paper media', Journal of Electronic Publishing, 2000, 6, www.press.umich.edu/jep/06-02/bjork.html; B.-C. BJÖRK and Z. TURK: 'A survey on the impact of the internet on scientific publishing in construction IT and construction management', Electronic Journal of Information Technology in Construction, 2000, 5, 73-88, www.itcon.org/2000/5.
30. B.-C. BJÖRK and Z. TURK: 'How scientists retrieve publications: an empirical study of how the internet is overtaking paper media', Journal of Electronic Publishing, 2000, 6, www.press.umich.edu/jep/06-02/bjork.html; B.-C. BJÖRK and Z. TURK: 'A survey on the impact of the internet on scientific publishing in construction IT and construction management', Electronic Journal of Information Technology in Construction, 2000, 5, 73-88, www.itcon.org/2000/5.
31. See the 26 June 1997 press release, 'Free MEDLINE', available online at www.nlm.nih.gov/news/press_releases/free_medline.html.
32. See www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov; R. J. ROBERTS: 'PubMed Central: the GenBank of the published literature', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2001, 98, 381-382; www.bioone.org; www.publiclibraryofscience.org; and J. E. TILL: 'Success factors for open access publishing', Journal of Medical Internet Research, 2003, 5, el, www.jmir.org/2003/1/e1/index.htm.
33. See www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov; R. J. ROBERTS: 'PubMed Central: the GenBank of the published literature', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2001, 98, 381-382; www.bioone.org; www.publiclibraryofscience.org; and J. E. TILL: 'Success factors for open access publishing', Journal of Medical Internet Research, 2003, 5, el, www.jmir.org/2003/1/e1/index.htm.
34. A. M. ODLYZKO: 'Tragic loss or good riddance? The impending demise of traditional scholarly journals', International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 1995, 42, 71-122.
35. S. HARNAD: 'The self-archiving initiative' (see Note 22).
36. C. TENOPIR and D. W. KING: 'Designing electronic journals with 30 years of lessons from print', Journal of Electronic Publishing, 1998, 4, www.press.umich.edu/jep/04-02/king.html.
37. H. E. ROOSENDAAL, P. A. T. M. GEURTS and P. VENDER VET: 'Higher education needs may determine the future of scientific e-publishing', 18 September 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/roosendaal.html.
38. H. YU, V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, C. FRIEDMAN, A. RZHETSKY and W. J. WILBUR: 'Automatic extraction of gene and protein synonyms from MEDLINE and journal articles', in Proc. AMIA 2002 Symp., San Antonio, TX, USA, November 2002, 919-923; M. KRAUTHAMMER, P. KRA, I. IOSSIFOV, S. M. GOMEZ, G. HRIPCSAK, V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, C. FRIEDMAN and A. RZHETSKY: 'Of truth and pathways: chasing bits of information through myriads of articles', Bioinformatics, 2002, 18, S249-S257; V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, P. A. DUBOUE and A. RZHETSKY: 'Disambiguating proteins, genes, and RNA in text: a machine learning approach', Bioinformatics, 2001, 17, S97-S106.
39. H. YU, V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, C. FRIEDMAN, A. RZHETSKY and W. J. WILBUR: 'Automatic extraction of gene and protein synonyms from MEDLINE and journal articles', in Proc. AMIA 2002 Symp., San Antonio, TX, USA, November 2002, 919-923; M. KRAUTHAMMER, P. KRA, I. IOSSIFOV, S. M. GOMEZ, G. HRIPCSAK, V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, C. FRIEDMAN and A. RZHETSKY: 'Of truth and pathways: chasing bits of information through myriads of articles', Bioinformatics, 2002, 18, S249-S257; V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, P. A. DUBOUE and A. RZHETSKY: 'Disambiguating proteins, genes, and RNA in text: a machine learning approach', Bioinformatics, 2001, 17, S97-S106.
40. H. YU, V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, C. FRIEDMAN, A. RZHETSKY and W. J. WILBUR: 'Automatic extraction of gene and protein synonyms from MEDLINE and journal articles', in Proc. AMIA 2002 Symp., San Antonio, TX, USA, November 2002, 919-923; M. KRAUTHAMMER, P. KRA, I. IOSSIFOV, S. M. GOMEZ, G. HRIPCSAK, V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, C. FRIEDMAN and A. RZHETSKY: 'Of truth and pathways: chasing bits of information through myriads of articles', Bioinformatics, 2002, 18, S249-S257; V. HATZIVASSILOGLOU, P. A. DUBOUE and A. RZHETSKY: 'Disambiguating proteins, genes, and RNA in text: a machine learning approach', Bioinformatics, 2001, 17, S97-S106.
41. M. FRANKEL, R. ELLIOTT, M. BLUME, J.-M. BOURGOIS, B. HUGENHOLTZ, M. G. LINDQUIST, S. MORRIS and E. SANDEWALL: 'Defining and certifying electronic publication in science: a proposal to the international association of STM publishers', July 2000, www.aaas.org/spp/sfrl/projects/epub/define.shtml.
42. R. K. JOHNSON: 'Whither competition?', 15 June 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/johnson.html.
43. P. BROWN: 'What must scientists do to exploit the new environment', in Proc. Symp. on Electronic Scientific, Technical, and Medical Journal Publishing and its Implications, Washington, DC, 2003, National Academies Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public Policy.
44. M. A. KELLER: 'The changing role and form of scientific journals', Proc. Second Joint ICSU Press-UNESCO Expert Conf. on Electronic Publishing in Science, Paris, France, February 2001, ICSU/UNESCO International (users.ox.ac.uk/̃icsuinfo/kellerppr.htm).
45. 'Is a government archive the best answer?', Science, 2001, 291, 2318-2319.
46. I. MELLMAN: 'Setting logical priorities', 5 April 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/mellman.html.
47. P. BOLMAN: 'The effects of open access on commercial publishers', in Proc. Symp. on Electronic Scientific, Technical, and Medical Journal Publishing and its Implications, Washington, DC, 2003, National Academies Committee on Scientific Engineering and Public Policy.
48. F. GODLEE: 'Making reviewers visible', Journal of the American Medical Association, 2002, 287, 2762-2765.
49. F. J. GODLEE and T. JEFFERSON (ed.): Peer Review in Health Sciences; 1999, London, BMJ Publishing.
50. E. J. LERNER: 'Fraud shows peer review flaws', Industrial Physicist, 2002, 8, (6), 12-17.
51. 'Bad peer reviewers', Nature, 2001, 413, 93.
52. T. GURA: 'Scientific publishing: peer review, unmasked', Nature, 2002, 416, 258-260.
53. R. DALTON: 'Peers under pressure', Nature, 2001, 413, 102-104.
54. F. GODLEE: 'Making reviewers visible' (see Note 41).
55. S. HARNAD: Science, 1980, 208, 974, 976.
56. W. Y. ARMS: 'Quality control in scholarly publishing on the web', Journal of Electronic Publishing, 2001, 8, www.press.umich.edu/jep/08-01/arms.html.
57. P. GINSPARG: 'Can peer review be better focused?', March 2003, arxiv.org/blurb/pg02pr.html.
58. 'Is a government archive the best answer?' (see Note 38).
59. See 'Task Group on Access to Biological Collection Data (ABCD)', www.bgbm.org/TDWG/CODATA/default.htm and M. J. GERSTEIN and J. JUNKER: 'Blurring the boundaries' (Note 16).
60. See 'Task Group on Access to Biological Collection Data (ABCD)', www.bgbm.org/TDWG/CODATA/default.htm and M. J. GERSTEIN and J. JUNKER: 'Blurring the boundaries' (Note 16).
61. J. MCENTYRE and D. J. LIPMAN: 'GenBank - a model community resource?', 5 April 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/lipman.html.
62. P. GINSPARG: 'Creating a global knowledge network' (see Note 7).
63. S. HITCHCOCK, L. CARR, W. HALL, W. HARRIS, S. PROBETS, D. EVANS and D. BRAILSFORD: 'Linking electronic journals: lessons from the Open Journal project', D-Lib Magazine, 1998, 4, (12), www.dlib.org/dlib/december98/12hitchcock.html.
64. D. M. EAGLEMAN and A. O. HOLCOMBE: 'Improving science through online commentary', Nature, 2003, 423, 15.
65. M. S. FRANKEL: 'Seizing the moment: scientists' authorship rights in the digital age', American Association for the Advancement of Science, New York, NY, USA, 2002, www.aaas.org/spp/sfrl/projects/epub/finalreport.pdf.
66. T. BERNERS-LEE and J. HENDLER: 'Scientific publishing on the "semantic web"', 12 April 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/bernerslee.htm.
67. See http://140.234.1.105 (BioMed Archives Consortium), muse.jhu.edu (Project Muse), highwire.stanford.edu (also M. A. KELLER: 'The changing role and form of scientific journals' (Note 37)), and (on CrossRef) E. PENTZ: 'Evolution and revolution: pragmatism versus dogmatism', 28 August 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/pentz.html.
68. See http://140.234.1.105 (BioMed Archives Consortium), muse.jhu.edu (Project Muse), highwire.stanford.edu (also M. A. KELLER: 'The changing role and form of scientific journals' (Note 37)), and (on CrossRef) E. PENTZ: 'Evolution and revolution: pragmatism versus dogmatism', 28 August 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/pentz.html.
69. M. SINCELL: 'A man and his archive seek greener pastures', Science, 2001, 293, 419-421.
70. R. LUCE: 'Evolution and scientific literature: towards a decentralized adaptive web', 10 May 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/luce.html.
71. M. COCKERILL: 'Distributed and centralized technologies: complementary tools to build a permanent digital archive', 28 August 2001, www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/articles/cockerill.html.
72. See E. PENTZ: 'Evolution and revolution' (Note 59).
73. Information Today, 1999, 16, 32; S. C. MICHALAK: 'The evolution of SPARC', Serials Review, 2000, 26, (1), 10-21.
74. Information Today, 1999, 16, 32; S. C. MICHALAK: 'The evolution of SPARC', Serials Review, 2000, 26, (1), 10-21.
75. A. KLUGKIST: 'The changing role of the librarian - a virtual library and a real archive?', Proc. Second Joint ICSU Press-UNESCO Expert Conf. on Electronic Publishing in Science, Paris, France, February 2001, ICSU/UNESCO International (users.ox.ac.uk/̃icsuinfo/klugkistppr.htm).
76. J. ROTHENBERG: 'Ensuring the longevity of digital documents', Scientific American, 1995, 272, 42-47.
77. J. ROTHENBERG: Avoiding Technological Quicksand: Finding a Viable Technical Foundation for Digital Preservation; 1999, Washington, DC, Council on Library and Information Resources (www.clir.org/pubs/reports/rothenberg/contents.html).
78. M. A. E. DEMENTI: 'Access and archiving as a new paradigm', Journal of Electronic Publishing, 1998, 3, www.press.umich.edu/jep/03-03/dementi.html; K. GUTHRIE: 'Archiving in the digital age: there's a will, but is there a way?', Educause Review, 2001, 36, (6), 56-65 (www.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/erm0164.pdf).
79. M. A. E. DEMENTI: 'Access and archiving as a new paradigm', Journal of Electronic Publishing, 1998, 3, www.press.umich.edu/jep/03-03/dementi.html; K. GUTHRIE: 'Archiving in the digital age: there's a will, but is there a way?', Educause Review, 2001, 36, (6), 56-65 (www.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/erm0164.pdf).
80. See J. ROTHENBERG: Avoiding Technological Quicksand (Note 67).
81. R. MOORE, C. BARU, A. RAJASEKAR, B. LUDASCHER, R. MARCIANO, M. WAN, W. SCHROEDER and A. GUPTA: 'Collection-based persistent digital archives', D-Lib Magazine, 2000, 6, (3), www.dlib.org/dlib/march00/moore/03moore-pt1.html.
82. B. RAGON: 'Castles made of sand: building sustainable digitized collections using XMU', Computers in Libraries, 2003, 23, 10-14.
83. F. ACHARD, G. VAYSSEIX and E. BARILLOT: 'XML, bioinformatics and data integration', Bioinformatics, 2001, 17, 115-125.
84. See J. ROTHENBERG: Avoiding Technological Quicksand (Note 67).
85. R. LORIE: 'A project on preservation of digital data', RLG DigiNews, 2001, 5, (3), www.rlg.org/preserv/diginews/diginews5-3.html#feature2.
86. PL 96-517; Bayh-Dole Act, 35 USC 200-212, 1980.
87. D. GREENBAUM: 'The database debate: in support of an inequitable solution', Albany Law Journal of Science & Technology, 2003, 13, 431-515.
88. D. KREEGER: Law and Contemporary Problems, 1947, 12, 7414-7445.
89. S. HARNAD and M. HEMUS: 'All or none: no stable hybrid or half-way solutions for launching the learned periodical literature into the post-Gutenberg galaxy', in The Impact of Electronic Publishing on the Academic Community, (ed. I. Butterworth), 18-27; 1998, London, Portland Press.
90. S. I. COLBERT and O. R. GRIFFIN: 'The impact of "fair use" in the higher education community: a necessary exception?', Albany Law Review, 1998, 62, 437-465.
91. S. BACHRACH, R. S. BERRY, M. BLUME, T. VON FOERSTER, A. FOWLER, P. GINSPARG, S. HELLER, N. KESTNER, A. ODLYZKO, A. OKERSON, R. WIGINGTON and A. MOFFAT: 'Who should own scientific papers?', Science, 1998, 281, 1459-1460; C. MCSHERRY: Who Owns Academic Work? Battling for Control of Intellectual Property; 2001, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press.
92. S. BACHRACH, R. S. BERRY, M. BLUME, T. VON FOERSTER, A. FOWLER, P. GINSPARG, S. HELLER, N. KESTNER, A. ODLYZKO, A. OKERSON, R. WIGINGTON and A. MOFFAT: 'Who should own scientific papers?', Science, 1998, 281, 1459-1460; C. MCSHERRY: Who Owns Academic Work? Battling for Control of Intellectual Property; 2001, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press.
93. L. GUERNSEY: 'Research libraries' newsletter examines profits of journal publishers', Chronicle of Higher Education, 1998, 30 October, A29.
94. M. WADMAN: 'Publishers challenged over access to papers', Nature, 2001, 410, 502.
95. See D. SHULENBURGER: 'Principles for a new system' (Note 20).
96. R. DREYFUSS: 'Collaborative research: conflicts on authorship, ownership, and accountability', Vanderbilt Law Review, 2000, 53, 1162-1232.