The role of futility judgments in improperly limiting the scope of clinical research

Journal of Medical Ethics

Volumn 24, Issue 5, 1998, Pages 308-313

  Harper, William ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA   (United States)

Author keywords

Clinical research; Consumer; Futility; Medical ethics; Outcome measure

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CLINICAL RESEARCH; HUMAN; MEDICAL ETHICS; OUTCOMES RESEARCH; SURVIVAL;

EID: 0347573988     PISSN: 03066800     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1136/jme.24.5.308     Document Type: Article

References (53)

1. Lantos JD, Miles SH, Silverstein MD, Stocking CB. Survival after cardiopulmonary resuscitation in babies of very low birth-weight: is cpr futile therapy? The New England Journal of Medicine 1988; 318: 93.
2. See reference 1: 94.
3. See reference 1: 91.
4. Rubenfeld GD, Crawford SW. Withdrawing life support from mechanically ventilated recipients of bone marrow transplants: a case for evidence-based guidelines. Annals of Internal Medicine 1996; 125: 625-33.
5. See reference 4: 626.
6. See reference 4: 632.
7. See reference 4: 625.
8. See reference 4: 625 (emphasis added).
9. Covington DS, Wainwright DJ, Parks DH. Prognostic indicators in the elderly patient with burns. Journal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation 1996; 17: 222-30.
10. Hollmig KA, Soehngen D, Leschke M, Kobbe G, Schneider P, Klein RM et al. Long-term survival of recipients of allogeneic bone-marrow transplantation after mechanical ventilation. European Journal of Medical Research 1997; 2: 62-66.
11. Brown DL, Archer SB, Greenhalgh DG, Washam MA, James LE, Warden GD. Inhalation injury severity scoring system: a quantitative method. Journal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation 1996; 17: 552-7.
12. Caldwell Jr FT, Wallace BH, Cone JB. Sequential excision and grafting of the burn injuries of 1507 patients treated between 1967 and 1986: end results and the determinants of death. Journal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation 1996; 17: 137-46.
13. Frye KE, Izenberg SD, Williams MD, Luterman A. Simulated biologic intelligence used to predict length of stay and survival of burns. Journal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation 1996; 17: 540-6.
14. Grobmyer SR, Maniscalco SP, Purdue GF, Hunt JL. Alcohol, drug intoxication, or both at the time of burn injury as a predictor of complications and mortality in hospitalized patients with burns. Journal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation 1996; 17: 532-9.
15. Cummins RO, Chamberlain DA, Abramson NS, Allen M, Baskett PJ, Becker L et al. Recommended guidelines for uniform reporting of data from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: the Utstein style. A statement for health professionals from a task force of the American Heart Association, the European Resuscitation Council, the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada, and the Australian Resuscitation Council. Circulation 1991; 84: 970.
16. Jennett B, Bond M. Assessment of outcome after severe brain damage: a practical scale. Lancet 1975; 1: 480-4.
17. Brain Resuscitation Clinical Trial I Study Group. A randomized clinical study of cardiopulmonary-cerebral resuscitation: design, methods, and patient characteristics. American Journal of Emergency Medicine 1986; 4: 72-86.
18. See reference 15: 967.
19. Brody BA, Halevy A. Is futility a futile concept? The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1995; 20: 123-44.
20. Griener GG. The physician's authority to withhold futile treatment. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1995; 20: 207-24.
21. Harper W. Judging who should live: Schneiderman and Jecker on the duty not to treat. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy (forthcoming).
22. Kopelman LM. Conceptual and moral disputes about futile and useful treatments. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1995; 20: 109-21.
23. Lantos JD, Linger PA, Walker RM, Gramelspacher GP, Shapiro GR, Sanchez-Gonzales MA et al. The illusion of futility in clinical practice. The American Journal of Medicine 1989; 87: 81-4.
24. Teno JM, Nelson HL, Lynn J. Advance care planning: priorities for ethical and empirical research. Hastings Center Report 1994; 24: s32-s36.
25. Tong R. Towards a just, courageous, and honest resolution of the futility debate. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1995; 20: 165-89.
26. Truog RD, Brett AS, Frader J. The problem with futility. The New England Journal of Medicine 1992; 325: 1560-4.
27. Sawacki BE. The "futility debate" and the management of gordian knots. The Journal of Clinical Ethics 1995; 6: 112-27.
28. See reference 19: 137.
29. Eisenberg MS, Cummins RO, Damon S, Larsen MP, Hearne TR. Survival rates from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: recommendations for uniform definitions and data to report. Annals of Emergency Medicine 1990; 19: 1250.
30. Brigham PA, McLoughlin E. Burn incidence and medical care use in the United States: estimates, trends, and data sources. Journal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation 1996; 17: 95-107.
31. Chan DKL, Ho LY, Joseph VT. Mortality among infants with high-risk congenital diaphragmatic hernia in Singapore. Journal of Pediatric Surgery 1997; 32: 95-8.
32. Herlitz J, Ekström L, Wennerblom B, Axelsson Å, Bång A, Lindkvist J et al. Lidocaine in out-of-hospital ventricular fibrillation. Does it improve survival? Resuscitation 1997; 33: 199-205.
33. Murphy DJ, Hope PL, Johnson A. Neonatal risk factors for cerebral palsy in very preterm babies: case-control study. British Medical Journal 1997; 314: 404-8.
34. Pranikoff T, Hirschl RB, Steimle CN, Anderson III HL, Bartlett RH. Mortality is directly related to the duration of mechanical ventilation before the initiation of extracorporeal life support for severe respiratory failure. Critical Care Medicine 1997; 25: 28-32.
35. Suominen P, Korpela R, Kuisma M, Silfvast T, Olkkola KT. Paediatric cardiac arrest and resuscitation provided by physician-staffed emergency care units. Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica 1997; 41: 260-5.
36. Varon J, Fromm Jr RE. In-hospital resuscitation among the elderly: substantial survival to hospital discharge. American Journal of Emergency Medicine 1996; 14: 130-2.
37. Callaham M, Madsen CD. Relationship of timeliness of paramedic advanced life support interventions to outcome in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest treated by first responders with defibrillators. Annals of Emergency Medicine 1996; 27: 638-48.
38. Fischer M, Fischer NJ, Schüttler J. One-year survival after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in Bonn city: outcome report according to the "Utstein style". Resuscitation 1997; 33: 233-43.
39. Herlitz J, Bang A, Holmberg M, Axelsson A, Lindkvist J, Holmberg S. Rhythm changes during resuscitation from ventricular fibrillation in relation to delay until defibrillation, number of shocks delivered and survival. Resuscitation 1997; 34: 17-22.
40. Lee KH, Angus DC, Abramson NS. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation: what cost to cheat death? Critical Care Medicine 1996; 24: 2046-52.
41. Weston CFM, Wilson RJ, Jones SD. Predicting survival from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a multivariate analysis. Resuscitation 1997; 34: 27-34.
42. Arensman RM, Statter MB, Bastawrous AL, Madonna MB. Modern treatment modalities for neonatal and pediatric respiratory failure. The American Journal of Surgery 1996; 172: 41-7.
43. Dunagan DP, Baker AM, Hurd DD, Haponik EF. Bronchoscopic evaluation of pulmonary infiltrates following bone marrow transplantation. Chest 1997; 111: 135-41.
44. Nuñez-Gutiérrez H, Castro-Muñozledo F, Kuri-Harcuch W. Combined use of allograft and autograft epidermal cultures in therapy of burns. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 1996; 98: 929-39.
45. Bavaria JE, Kotloff R, Palevsky H, Rosengard B, Robects JR, Wahl PM et al. Bilateral versus single lung transplantation for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery 1997; 113: 520-8.
46. Headley AS, Tolley E, Meduri GU. Infections and the inflammatory response in acute respiratory distress syndrome. Chest 1997; 111: 1306-21.
47. Herlitz J, Ekstrom L, Axelsson A, Bang A, Wennerblom B, Waagstein L et al. Continuation of CPR on admission to emergency department after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Occurrence, characteristics and outcome. Resuscitation 1997; 33: 223-31.
48. Plaisance P, Adnet F, Vicaut E, Hennequin B, Magne P, Prudhomme C et al. Benefit of active compression-decompression cardiopulmonary resuscitation as a prehospital advanced cardiac life support: a randomized multicenter study. Circulation 1997; 95: 955-61.
49. Sarnaik AP, Meert KL, Pappas MD, Simpson PM, Lieh-Lai MW, Heidemann SM. Predicting outcome in children with severe acute respiratory failure treated with high-frequency ventilation. Critical Care Medicine 1996; 24: 1396-1402.
50. Schiller WR, Bay RC, Garren RL, Parker I, Sagraves SG. Hyperdynamic resuscitation improves survival in patients with life-threatening burns. Journal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation 1997; 18: 10-16.
51. Steiner T, Mendoza G, De Georgia M, Schellinger P, Holle R, Hacke W. Prognosis of stroke patients requiring mechanical ventilation in a neurological critical care unit. Stroke 1997; 28: 711-715.
52. See reference 51: 713.
53. See reference 47: 231.