Diktat and dialogue in stalinist culture: Staging patriotic historical opera in Soviet Ukraine, 1936-1954

Slavic Review

Volumn 59, Issue 3, 2000, Pages 597-624

  Yekelchyk, Serhy ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 0345220149     PISSN: 00376779     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2307/2697347     Document Type: Review

References (128)

1. Iu. Elagin, Ukroshchenie iskusstv (New York, 1952).
2. See Vera S. Dunham, In Stalin's Time: Middleclass Values in Soviet Fiction, with an introduction by Jerry F. Hough (Cambridge, Eng., 1976);
3. Sheila Fitzpatrick, "Culture and Politics under Stalin: A Reappraisal," Slavic Review 35, no. 2 (June 1976): 211-31,
4. reprinted in substantially revised form as "Cultural Orthodoxies under Stalin" in her The Cultural Front: Power and Culture in Revolutionary Russia (Ithaca, 1992), 238-56.
5. See, for example, Katerina Clark, The Soviet Novel: History as Ritual (Chicago, 1981);
6. Boris Grays, The Total Art of Stalinism: Avant-garde, Aesthetic Dictatorship, and Beyond, trans. Charles Rougle (Princeton, 1992);
7. Peter Kenez, Cinema and Soviet Society, 1917-1953 (Cambridge, Eng., 1992);
8. Régine Robin, Socialist Realism: An Impossible Aesthetic, trans. Catherine Porter (Stanford, 1992);
9. Richard Stites, Russian Popular Culture: Entertainment and Society since 1900 (Cambridge, Eng., 1992);
10. and Jeffrey Brooks, Thank You, Comrade Stalin! Soviet Public Culture from the Revolution to Cold War (Princeton, 2000).
11. See, for example, Leonid Maksimenkov, Sumbur vmesto muzyki: Stalinskaia kul'turnaia revoliutsiia 1936-1938 (Moscow, 1997), where the valuable archival findings often contradict the author's traditionalist conclusions.
12. It is significant that Bakhtin developed the notion of dialogism in the Stalinist Soviet Union. Much of his work celebrated unofficial resistance to the authoritative discourses that attempt to limit the polysemous impulses of language. Since meanings cannot be fixed and made absolute, the hegemonic quest for order and stability is frustrated by the persistent residual otherness of subversion, irresolution, and ambiguity. See M. M. Bakhtin, The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays, trans. Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist, ed. Michael Holquist (Austin, 1981);
13. V. N. Voloshinov, Marxism and the Philosophy of Language, trans. Ladislav Matejka and I. R. Titunik (New York, 1973);
14. Michael Holquist, Dialogism: Bakhtin and His World (New York, 1990).
15. Fredric Jameson, The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act (Ithaca, 1981).
16. Significantly, the study of the social history of Stalinism is developing in the same conceptual direction. Stephen Kotkin has recently argued that workers came to share Stalinism as a "civilization" through "positive integration" into official society by learning to "speak Bolshevik" and entering a subtle, if unequal, negotiation with the system. See Stephen Kotkin, Magnetic Mountain: Stalinism as a Civilization (Berkeley, 1995).
17. Here I agree with Yuri Slezkine. See his provocative "The USSR as a Communal Apartment, or How a Socialist State Promoted Ethnic Particularism," Slavic Review 53, no. 2 (Summer 1994): 414-52, here 447.
18. Ronald Grigor Suny has examined the Soviet ideal of "healthy" ethnolinguistic nationhood in The Revenge of the Past: Nationalism, Revolution, and the Collapse of the Soviet Union (Stanford, 1993), 111-12.
19. See L. A. Shevchenko, "Kul'turno-ideolohichni protsesy v Ukraini u 40-50-kh rr.," Ukrains'kyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 1992, no. 7/8:39-48;
20. Shevchenko, "Kul'tura Ukrainy v umovakh stalins'koho totalitaryzmu (druha polovyna 40-kh-pochatok 50-kh rokiv)," in V. M. Danylenko, ed., Ukraina XX st.: Kul'tura, ideolohiia, polityka (Kiev, 1993), 1:119-30;
21. V. I. Iurchuk, Kul'turne zhyttia v Ukraini u povoienni roky: Svitlo i tini (Kiev, 1995);
22. O. V. Zamlyns'ka, "Ideolohichni represii v haluzi hul'tury v Ukraini u 1948-1953 rr.," in V. M. Danylenko, ed., Ukraina XX st: Kul'tura, ideolohiia, polityka (Kiev, 1996), 2:144-56.
23. This paper uses the following abbreviations for the names of the Russian and Ukrainian archives: RTsKhIDNI (Rossiiskii tsentr khraneniia i izucheniia dokumentov noveishei istorii; renamed Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv sotsial'no-politicheskoi istorii in March 1999), TsKhSD (Tsentr khraneniia sovremennoi dokumentatsii), GARF (Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii), RGALI (Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv literatury i iskusstva), TsDAHO (Tsentral'nyi derzhavnyi arkhiv hromads'kykh ob''iednan' Ukrainy), TsDAVOV (Tsentral'nyi derzhavnyi arkhiv vyshchykh orhaniv vlady i derzhavnoho upravlinnia Ukrainy), and TsDAMLM (Tsentral'nyi derzhavnyi arkhiv-muzei literatury i mystetstva Ukrainy).
24. The rehabilitation of Russian patriotism and traditional cultural values in the mid-1930s is the subject of Nicholas S. Timasheff, The Great Retreat: The Growth and Decline of Communism in Russia (New York, 1946);
25. Dunham, In Stalin's Time;
26. Robert C. Tucker, Stalin in Power: The Revolution from Above, 1928-1941 (New York, 1990);
27. Fitzpatrick, The Cultural Front;
28. and D. L. Brandenberger and A. M. Dubrovsky, "The People Need a Tsar': The Emergence of National Bolshevism as Stalinist Ideology, 1931-1941," Europe-Asia Studies 50, no. 5 (July 1998): 873-92.
29. A. A. Gozenpud, Russkii savetskii opernyi teatr (1917-1941): Ocherk istorii (Leningrad, 1963), 212-19, 252-64;
30. Boris Schwarz, Music and Musical Life in Soviet Russia, 1917-1981, enl. ed. (Bloomington, 1983), 122;
31. Tucker, Stalin in Power, 554, 570-71.
32. On the rise of the "friendship of peoples" paradigm in Soviet history writing, see Lowell Tillett, The Great Friendship: Soviet Historians on the Non-Russian Nationalities (Chapel Hill, 1969).
33. See the extensive coverage of the dekada in Pravda, 11-25 March 1936.
34. After the 1936 dekada, some Leningrad artists reportedly complained that Ukrainians had received awards as part of a political campaign to exalt "ethnics" rather than because they merited them. See Sheila Fitzpatrick, Everyday Stalinism: Ordinary Life in Extraordinary Times: Soviet Russia in the 1930s (New York, 1999), 167-68. This would not explain, however, the simultaneous promotion of the Kiev Opera's leading conductor, Arii Pazovskii, first to the artistic directorship of the Kirov Opera in Leningrad and then to the analogous post at the Bolshoi.
35. Pravda, 13 March 1936, 4.
36. Pravda, 23 March 1936, 4 (Kievans preparing Tarai); RTsKhIDNI, f. 17 (TsK VKP[b]), op. 163, d. 1103, ll. 144-46 (Kerzhentsev).
37. Similar observations have been made about the 1939 production of Ivan Susanin at the Bolshoi. See Bojan Bujic, "Anti-Polish Propaganda and Russian Opera: The Revised Version of Glinka's Ivan Susanin," European History Quarterly 15, no. 2 (April 1985): 175-86. The Kharkiv opera company staged Taras in 1924 and the Kiev company in 1927 and 1928.
38. See Iu. O. Stanishevs'kyi, Ukrains'kyi radians'kyi muzychnyi teatr: Narysy istorii (1917-1967) (Kiev, 1970), 63-67.
39. See the collection of reviews and newspaper clippings in TsDAMLM, f. 71 (N. V. Smolich), op. 1, spr. 38, and M. Stefanovych, Kyivs'kyi derzhavnyi ordena Lenina akademichnyi teatr opery i baleta URSR im. T. H. Shevchenka: Istorychnyi narys (Kiev, 1968), 138-41.
40. Slezkine, "The USSR as a Communal Apartment," 446-47.
41. Pravda, 24 October 1937, 6.
42. TsDAMLM, f. 71, op. 1, spr. 20, ark. 206. Glavlit was the Soviet censorship office. In 1895, Nikolai Rimskii-Korsakov wrote about Taras as follows: "In Kiev I met with my former students Ryb and the composer Lysenko. At Lysenko's I ate dumplings and listened to excerpts from his Taras Bulba. Didn't like it - Taras Bulba, that is, not the dumplings." N. A. Rimskii-Korsakov, Letopis' moei muzykal'noi zhizni (Moscow, 1955), 197.
43. M. P. Pashchyn, "Nash tvorchyi raport," Festyval' opernoho i baletnoho mystetstva: 24 bereznia-7 kvitnia [1941] (Kiev, 1941), 9; TsDAMLM, f. 573 (Natsional'na opera Ukrainy), op. 1, spr. 171, ark. 2.
44. See Timasheff, The Great Retreat, 167-76;
45. Bernd Uhlenbruch, "The Annexation of History: Eisenstein and the Ivan Groznyi Cult of the 1940s," in Hans Gunther, ed., The Culture of the Stalin Period (New York, 1990), 266-87;
46. Maureen Perrie, "The Tsar, the Emperor, the Leader: Ivan the Terrible, Peter the Great and Anatolii Rybakov's Stalin," in Nick Lampert and Gábor T. Rittersporn, eds., Stalinism: Its Nature and Aftermath: Essays in Honor of Moshe Lewin (London, 1992), 77-100.
47. However outdated, the best survey of the changing Soviet views on Khmel'nyts'kyi remains John Basarab, Pereiaslav 1654: A Historiographical Study (Edmonton, 1982), 162-213.
48. See M. Mykhailov, Kostiantyn Fedorovych Dan'kevych: Narodnyi artyst SRSR (Kiev, 1964), 15, 75 (Dan'kevych);
49. Stanishevs'kyi, Ukrains'kyi radians'kyi muzychnyi teatr, 177 (Shostakovich).
50. TsDAHO, f. 1 (TsK KP[b]U), op. 23, spr. 441, ark. 5zv.
51. Emphasis added. The resolution was published in Literaturna hazeta, 12 October 1946, 2;
52. Radians'ke mystetstvo, 15 October 1946, 1;
53. Iu. Iu. Kondufor, ed., Kul'turne budivnytstvo v Ukrains'kii RSR: Cherven' 1941-1950: Zbirnyk dokumentiv i materialiv (Kiev, 1989), 271-76.
54. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 1, spr. 729, ark. 149 (Lytvyn); Radians'ke mystetstvo, 1 October 1946, 1, and 15 October 1946, 1 (Verykivs'kyi).
55. TsDAMLM, f. 146 (M. P. Stefanovych), op. 1, spr. 203, ark. 1-15 (typescripts of negative reviews); f. 573, op. 1, spr. 46 (contemporary critical discussion); TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 3653, ark. 165-70 (later comments containing valuable insights into the causes of the 1946 fiasco); Radians'ke mystetstvo, 4 December 1946, 3 (dismissive review).
56. TsDAMLM, f. 71, op. 1, spr. 20, ark. 270. As a professor at the Kiev Conservatory from 1913 to 1920, Glière taught both Revuts'kyi and Liatoshyns'kyi.
57. L. Arkhimovych, Shliakhy rozvytku ukrains'koi radians'koi opery (Kiev, 1970), 290;
58. M. Mykhailov, M. A. Skorul's'kyi: Narys pro zhyttia i tvorchist' (Kiev, 1960), 71.
59. Radians'ke mystetstvo, 18 February 1948, 2;
60. Literaturna hazeta, 4 April 1948, 2, and 27 May 1948, 1.
61. See TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 1, spr. 144, ark. 15 (1947), and spr. 93, ark. 52-53 (1949).
62. TsDAMLM, f. 71, op. 1, spr. 20, ark. 237, 241.
63. Ibid., ark. 270zv-271.
64. See George O. Liber, Soviet Nationality Policy, Urban Growth, and Identity Change in the Ukrainian SSR, 1923-1934 (Cambridge, Eng., 1992), 112, 176;
65. Myroslav Shkandrij, Modernists, Marxists and the Nation: The Ukrainian Literary Discussion of the 1920s (Edmonton, 1992), 92.
66. TsDAMLM, f. 71, op. 1, spr. 20, ark. 216, 272.
67. Ibid., ark. 272zv. Today, to be sure, Russian classical operas are customarily performed in Russian in both France and Spain. It should be remembered, however, that staging operas in the language of the original is a relatively recent innovation in the west.
68. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2051, ark. 176-77 (audit); RGALI, f. 962 (Vsesoiuznyi komitet po delam iskusstv pri Sovete Ministrov SSSR), op. 11, d. 560, ll. 51-53 (Susanin in L'viv). The ostensible aim of the 1950 audit was to ensure that Ukrainian opera companies were complying with the rule on performing Russian operas in Ukrainian translation. Nevertheless, the republican officials did not seem overly concerned about poor compliance on the part of opera companies outside Kiev.
69. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2015, ark. 185.
70. RGALI, f. 962, op. 11, d. 558, l. 82. Of course, "Pushkin's text" did not refer to Ivan Susanin.
71. RGALI, f. 962, op. 11, d. 558, ll. 21, 48, 17. At the time, Kompaniiets' served as head of the Administration of Theaters at the Ukrainian Committee for the Arts. The first draft of the libretto can be found in TsDAMLM, f. 435 (O. Ie. Korniichuk), op. 1, d. 297. On Dan'kevych, see Radians'ke mystetstvo, 28 July 1948, 3.
72. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2041, ark. 1 (telegram to Nazarenko), and spr. 2051, ark. 1 (telegram to Kyrychenko); Radians'ke mystetstvo, 15 February 1950, 3 (first audition), and 23 August 1950, 3 (score ready).
73. Radians'ke mystetstvo, 31 January 1951, 1;
74. Literaturna hazeta, 8 February 1951, 3 (the quotation is from the second article);
75. RGALI, f. 962, op. 2, d. 2336, l. 13, and op. 3, d. 2306, l. 6. Even such a discriminating and cultured singer as Borys Hmyria genuinely liked the role of Colonel Kryvonis. After reading the score in October 1950, he immediately wrote to a friend: "A good role - both for singing and acting." In February 1951, he again characterized this role as "significant both musically and artistically." See TsDAMLM, f. 443 (B. R. Hmyria), op. 1, spr. 58, ark. 105, 108.
76. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2050, ark. 3.
77. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2050; RGALI, f. 962, op. 3, dd. 2306, 2336.
78. TsDAVOV, f. 4763 (Komitet u spravakh mystetstv URSR), op. 1, spr. 360, ark. 25; TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 1, spr. 171, ark. 25.
79. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 1875, ark. 47-94, esp. ark. 73 (Hrechukha), 88 (Dan'kevych), and 75 (Nazarenko).
80. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2428, ark. 3-85. Compare the official chronicle of the decade in Pravda, 16-28 June 1951, and in Dekada ukrains'koho mystetstva u Moskvi 15-24 chervnia 1951 r.: Zbirka materialiv (Kiev, 1953).
81. Pravda, 16 June 1951, 1.
82. As both the printed program of the concert of 24 June 1951 and the transcript of the television coverage attest, no arias from Bohdan were performed that evening. The archival materials do not reveal who overruled Nazarenko on this matter or when the decision occurred. See TsDAMLM, f. 146, op. 1, spr. 215, ark. 1-3zv (program); GARF, f. 6903 (Komitet po radioveshchaniiu i televideniiu pri Sovete Ministrov SSSR), op. 26, d. 21, program listing for 26 June (this folder has no continuous pagination).
83. GARF, f. 6903, op. 26, d. 21, programs for 15 and 16 June. Interestingly, the record shows that Bohdan was supposed to end by 11:30 P.M. on 15 June but continued until midnight.
84. On 30 June, Orders of Lenin were conferred on Mykhailo Hryshko (Bohdan) and Mykhailo Romens'kyi, who sang the role of the Muscovite ambassador in Bohdan. Dan'kevych received the Order of the Red Banner for Labor, while Honored Artist of Ukraine Borys Hmyria (Colonel Kryvonis in the opera) skipped a step in the hierarchy of Soviet actors to attain the highest rank of People's Artist of the Soviet Union. See Pravda, 1 July 1951, 1-2.
85. TsDAMLM, f. 661 (Spilka radians'kykh kompozytoriv Ukrainy), op. 1, spr. 130. To be sure, Boris had some ensembles, but apparently not enough for the 1950s notion of a classical opera.
86. Pravda, 2 July 1951, 2.
87. See Yaroslav Bilinsky, The Second Soviet Republic: The Ukraine after World War II (New Brunswick, 1964), 15-17;
88. Volodymyr Baran, Ukraina 1950-1960-kh rr.:Evoliutsiia totalitarnoi systemy (L'viv, 1996), 60-65.
89. Pravda, 20 July 1951, 3-4.
90. Which is not to say that the games themselves were ideologically coherent. See an excellent recent study: Alexei Kojevnikov, "Rituals of Stalinist Culture at Work: Science and the Games of Intraparty Democracy circa 1948," Russian Review 57, no. 1 (January 1998): 25-52.
91. Pravda, 24 July 1951,
92. and Literaturna hazeta, 26 July 1951, 4; TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2424, ark. 5-76 (Korniichuk, esp. ark. 13-14, on his own mistakes).
93. RTsKhIDNI, f. 17, op. 133, d. 311, ll. 34-39 (26 July 1951); TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 24, spr. 785, ark. 61-67 (14 August 1951).
94. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 1, spr. 976, ark. 12, 18-20 (Mel'nikov), 227-29 (Korniichuk).
95. Ibid., ark. 208: "Tse ukhyliannia vid suchasnykh tem i koposhinnia v tsykh istoriiakh drevnosti - tse tezh slid rozhlaiadaty iak svoieridnyi proiav natsionalizmu."
96. Ibid., ark. 77-82.
97. RTsKhIDNI, f. 17, op. 132, d. 419, ll. 219-21.
98. Radians'ke mystetstvo, 24 October 1951, 4. The party's Central Committee requested a copy of the libretto for review and approved it. See RTsKhIDNI, f. 17, op. 132, d. 419, ll. 222-52.
99. RGALI, f. 962, op. 11, d. 613, ll. 1-47. The censorship permit stamp no. Sh-00125, dated 30 January 1952, is on 1. 1.
100. TsKhSD, f. 5 (TsK KPSS), op. 17, d. 445, ll. 35-38. As an example of the "Ukrainian reading" of The Zaporozhian Cossack, Ryl's'kyi wrote in 1949 about the "lofty patriotism that permeates this opera from first note to last." See TsDAMLM, f. 146, op. 1, spr. 192, ark. 2.
101. TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 1, spr. 216, ark. 5.
102. S. Hulak-Artemovs'kyi, Zaporozhets' za Dunaiem, Kharkivs'kyi akademichnyi teatr opery ta baletu: Sezon 1935-36 r. (n.p., n.d.), 10; Zaporozhets' za Dunaiem: Postava Derchavnoho akademichnoho teatru opery ta baleta URSR, Kyiv, Hastrol' u Moskvi 11-21 bereznia 1936 roku (n.p., 1936), 52. The copy of the original libretto from the 1860s can be found in TsDAMLM, f. 1106 (I. S. Patorzhyns'kyi), op. 1, spr. 22, ark. 166-94, here 172.
103. TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 4, spr. 17, ark. 17 and 25. Compare the 1949 libretto in TsDAMLM, f. 146, op. 1, spr. 192, ark. 5-39. Interestingly, after Ukrainian independence, the Kiev Opera restored some elements of The Zaporozhian Cossack's original score, including the references to God - but not the Arnauts. The 1951 prohibition of Moscow ideologues was still in force as late as May 1999.
104. TsDAMLM, f. 1106, op. 1, spr. 22, ark. 1-166, here 1a, 9-10, 21.
105. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 3268, ark. 29 (released in July 1953).
106. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 3266, ark. 117, 120-27 (Askol'd's Tomb), 119 (The Siege of Dubno), and spr. 3265, ark. 96-138 (Aleksandrov's libretto; Nazarenko's quoted notes are on ark. 133 and 136).
107. Radians'ke mystetstvo, 11 August 1954, 1 ("intolerable situation"), 2 ("forgotten treasures"); TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 24, spr. 3528, ark. 21-22 (Khrushchev at the opera).
108. TsDAVOV, f. 4763, op. 1, spr. 360, ark. 1-55 (Ryl's'kyi on ark. 50); TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 1, spr. 171, ark. 2-56.
109. TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 1, spr. 171, ark. 23, 47.
110. TsDAMLM, f. 443, op. 1, spr. 58, ark. 115-16. Previously, the Ukrainian Committee for the Arts had wanted the Kiev Opera to renew Taras for the 1951 dekada in Moscow. The management avoided the issue, arguing that only Patorzhyns'kyi could sing Taras and that he was too busy with other roles. See TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 1, spr. 141, ark. 5. In fact, the republican artistic elite was simply reluctant to become involved with the much-criticized work. The prominent theater artist OIeksandr Khvostenko-Khvostov openly told the company's director that "he would not like to be held responsible for this spectacle." See TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 1, spr. 171, ark. 4. After three more years of heavy editing, the Kiev Opera finally produced a successful Taras Bul'ba in 1955. See TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 3653, ark. 165-70; TsDAMLM, f. 573, op. 4, spr. 26; op. 1, spr. 241, ark. 10-22; spr. 250, ark. 3-4zv; E. N. Iavors'kyi, "Taras Bul'ba": Opera M. Lysenka (Kiev, 1964).
111. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2773, ark. 97-98.
112. TsDAMLM, f. 435, op. 1, spr. 305 (manuscript changes to the libretto); TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2747 (printed copy from the archive of the Central Committee, dated January 1952); TsDAVOV, f. 4763, op. 1, spr. 357, ark. 2-5, 44; TsDAMLM, f. 435, op. 1, spr. 304, ark. 1-8 (outline of changes); N. Pirogova, Opera "Bogdan Klimel'nilskii" K. Dankevicha: Poiasnenie (Moscow, 1959), 8-9.
113. TsDAMLM, f. 435, op. 1, spr. 2012, ark. 5-6, 8.
114. See TsDAMLM, f. 673, op. 4 (10), spr. 16, ark. 19 (old text); TsDAMLM, f. 146, op. 1, spr. 194, ark. 22, and TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2851, ark. 23 (new text).
115. TsDAMLM, f. 435, op. 1, spr. 1959, ark. 25 (Levada), 31 (Kozyts'kyi), 57 (Dol'd-Mykhailyk), 15 (Composers' Union); TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2851, ark. 23 (second draft of the aria submitted to the Ukrainian Central Committee); TsDAVOV, f. 4763, op. 1, spr. 357, ark. 95 (concluding words).
116. RTsKhIDNI, f. 17, op. 33, d. 369, ll. 14-24. Molotov's note is on l. 20, the decision on ll. 22-24. By 1952, the ailing Stalin had fully entrusted Malenkov with running everyday party business. As the party archives reveal, Malenkov normally circulated documents among the other secretaries of the Central Committee (Stalin was not included, although he was probably consulted verbally on major questions); decisions were reached by consensus.
117. TsDAVOV, f. 4763, op. 1, spr. 357, ark. 44.
118. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2775; TsDAVOV, f. 4763, op. 1. spr. 356 (discussion on 4 November); TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 2773, ark. 165, 167 (the logistics of two closed performances), 165-66 (summary of opinions).
119. Radians'ke mystetstvo, 24 June 1953, 1;
120. Literaturna hazeta, 25 June 1953, 3 (premiere).
121. Radians'ke mystetstvo, 30 September 1953, 3 (Bohdan as season opener); 14 October 1953, 3; and Literaturna hazeta, 1 October 1953, 3, and 29 October 1953, 2 (reviews). Apparently, Khrushchev did not attend a performance of Bohdan during his visit to Kiev in October 1953. As noted earlier, he definitely went to see The Zaporozhian Cossack and possibly indicated his general approval of the theater's work.
122. TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 3632, ark. 20-22; TsDAVOV, f. 5116 (Ministerstvo kul'tury URSR), op. 4, spr. 19, ark. 1-2 (Bohdan produced in Ukrainian theaters); TsKhSD, f. 5, op. 17, d. 402, l. 71; TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 24, spr. 3504, ark. 24; TsDAVOV, f. 5116, op. 4, spr. 15, ark. 44, and spr. 20, ark. 1-7, 25.
123. GARF, f. 6903, op. 26, d. 39 (television program and transcripts for 10 May - no pagination); TsKhSD, f. 5, op. 17, d. 402, ll. 76-77 (all-union radio); TsDAHO, f. 1, op. 30, spr. 3631, ark. 25 (republican radio); spr. 3633, ark. 47-54 (gramophone disks); spr. 3632, ark. 180-86 (major concert in Kiev to celebrate the anniversary); Radians'ke mystetstvo, 17 November 1954, 1 (Dan'kevych's accolade).
124. Novyi shliakh, 15 January 1954, 4. The reference to Bohdan's "boring" aria on the need for reunification seems to add some credibility to the story. Indeed, two of the hetman's arias were devoted to this subject.
125. GARF, f. 6646 (Slavianskii komitet SSSR), op. 1, d. 356, ll. 14-18.
126. RGALI, f. 2329 (Ministerstvo kul'tury SSSR), op. 3, d. 168, l. 35ob. Only a rarity, Puccini's Tosca, surpassed the record average attendance: 2,959 people showed up at a mere two performances of this opera in Kiev. A general statistical survey of all Soviet opera companies in 1954 revealed that seven theaters - Kiev and six other smaller oblast houses, all of them in Ukraine - staged 129 performances of Bohdan for a total of 136,123 spectators, an average of 1,055. No Russian classical opera enjoyed such an average attendance unionwide that year. Ivan Susanin, staged by all the largest theaters, came close, with 15 theaters, 126 performances, and 128,276 patrons (1,018). Eugene Onegin, The Queen of Spades, and other classics lagged far behind. The most frequently performed opera on a Soviet subject, Iulii Meitus's The Young Guard, incidentally also a work by a Ukrainian composer, scored 9 - 87 - 49,980 (574). See RGALI, f. 2329, op. 3, d. 111, ll. 1-3.
127. TsKhSD, f. 5, op. 17, d. 445, ll. 85-86. Amusingly, there is every likelihood that Hryshko met Borys Hmyria (Colonel Kryvonis) regularly on Pasazh Street, where both men lived.
128. TsDAMLM, f. 435, op. 1, spr. 1302, ark. 1-2.