Particulate matter mass measurements for low emitting diesel powered vehicles: What's next?

Progress in Energy and Combustion Science

Volumn 29, Issue 6, 2003, Pages 635-672

  Vouitsis, Elias ^a   Ntziachristos, Leonidas ^a   Samaras, Zissis ^a  

^a ARISTOTLE UNIVERSITY OF THESSALONIKI   (Greece)

Author keywords

Emission certification; Emissions; Particle; Particulate; Real time measurements; Sampling; Type approval

Indexed keywords

INTERNAL COMBUSTION ENGINES; PARTICULATE EMISSIONS; REAL TIME SYSTEMS; STANDARDIZATION;

DIESEL PARTICULATE MATTER (DPM);

DIESEL LOCOMOTIVES;

EID: 0242301074     PISSN: 03601285     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.pecs.2003.08.002     Document Type: Review

References (130)

1. Walsh M.P. Global trends in diesel emissions control: a update.SAE technical paper series 1999-01-0107; 1999.
2. Faiz A., Weaver C.S., Walsh M.P. Air pollution from motor vehicles. Standards and technologies for controlling emissions. 1996;The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank, Washington, DC.
3. Motor vehicles facts and figures. 1996;American Automobile Manufacturers Association (AAMA), Detroit, MI.
4. Davis S.C. Transportation energy data book. 18th ed:1998;Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN.
5. Understanding the health effects of components of the PM mix: progress and next steps. 2002;HEI Perspectives, Boston, MA.
6. Lloyd A.C., Cackette T.A. Diesel engines: environmental impact and control. J Air Waste Mgmt Assoc. 51:2001;809-847.
7. Chow J.C. Diesel engines: environmental impact and control. J Air Waste Mgmt Assoc. 51:2001;1258-1270.
8. US Environmental Protection Agency. Health assessment document for diesel engine exhaust. Report No. EPA/600/8-90/057F, Washington, DC; May 2002.
9. Kittelson DB, Arnold M, Watts WF. Review of diesel PM sampling methods: final report. University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN; 1999. Internet reference at http://www.me.umn.edu/centers/cdr/reports/Proj_EPA.html .
10. Burtscher H. Literature study on tailpipe particulate emission measurement for diesel engines. Fachhochschule Aargau, Switzerland; March 2001. Internet reference at http://www.akpf.org/pub/burtscher_bericht.pdf .
11. Witze P.O. Diagnostics for the measurement of pariculate matter emissions from reciprocating engines. 2001;Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, CA. Internet reference at http://www.ca.sandia.gov/pmc/images/COMODIAReciprocatingPaper.pdf.
12. Vorstudie: Beurteilung von potentiellen Meßverfahren zur Messung wirkungsrelevanter Partikelparameter. 2002;FVV, Frankfurt.
13. MacDonald J.S., Barsic N.J., Gross G.P., Shaded S.P., Johnson J.H. Status of diesel particulate measurement methods. SAE technical paper series 840345. 1984.
14. ACEA programme on emissions of fine particles from passenger cars. Brussels, Belgium; December 1999.
15. Kittelson D.B. Engines and nanoparticles: a review. J Aerosol Sci. 29:1998;575-588.
16. Ntziachristos L., Giechaskiel B., Pistikopoulos P., Fysikas E., Samaras Z. Particle emissions characteristics of different on-road vehicles. SAE technical paper series 2003-01-1888. 2003.
17. Mohr M., Lehmann U., Margaria G. ACEA programme on the emissions of fine particulates from passenger cars (2). Part 1. Particle characterization of a wide range of engine technologies. SAE technical paper series 2003-01-1889. 2003.
18. Mohr M., Lehmann U., Margaria G. ACEA programme on the emissions of the fine particulates from passenger cars (2). Part 2. Effect of sampling conditions and fuel sulphur content on the particle emission. SAE technical paper series 2003-01-1890. 2003.
19. Coordinating Research Council. Diesel aerosol sampling methodology, CRC-E43. Final report. University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN; August 2002. Internet reference at http://www.crcao.com/reports/recentstudies00-02/UMN%20Final%20E-43%20Report.pdf .
20. European Commission. Particulates: characterisation of exhaust particulate emissions from road vehicles. DG TREN Contract No. 2000-RD10.249. Internet reference at http://vergina.eng.auth.gr/mech/lat/particulates/
21. Particulates. OICA contribution to PMP (Particulate Measurement Programme). Internet reference at http://www.oica.net/htdocs/WWH/Particulates/Particulates.htm .
22. Andersson JD, Wedekind B. DETR/SMMT/CONCAWE Particulate Research Programme 1998-2001. Summary report. Ricardo DP01/0115; May 2001. Internet reference at http://www.ricardo.com/downloads/SummaryReport.pdf23
23. Ntziachristos L., Samaras Z. New directions: emerging demands for vehicle particle emission characterisation. Atmos Environ. 37:2003;441-442.
24. Bérubé K.A., Jones T.P., Williamson B.J., Winters C., Morgam A.J., Richards R.J. Physicochemical characterization of diesel exhaust particles: factors for assessing biological activity. Atmos Environ. 33:1999;1599-1614.
25. Weingartner E., Burtscher H., Baltensperger U. Hygroscopic properties of carbon and soot particles. J Aerosol Sci. 31:1997;2311-2327.
26. Khalek I.A., Kittelson D.B. Real time measurement of volatile and solid exhaust particles using a catalytic stripper. SAE technical paper series 950236. 1995.
27. Kerminen V.M., Mäkelä T.E., Ojanen C.H., Hillamo R.E., Vilhunen J.K., Rantanen L., Havers N., Von Bohlen A., Klockow D. Characterization of the particulate phase in the exhaust from a diesel car. Environ Sci Technol. 31:1997;1883-1889.
28. Schmidt-Ott A., Wüstenberg J. Equivalent diameters of non-spherical particles. J Aerosol Sci. 26:1995;S923-S924.
29. Skillas G., Künzel S., Burtscher H., Baltensperger U., Siegmann K. High fractal-like dimension of diesel soot agglomerates. J Aerosol Sci. 29:1998;411-419.
30. Park K., Cao F., Kittelson D.B., McMurry P.H. Relationship between particle mass and mobility for diesel exhaust particles. Environ Sci Technol. 37:2003;577-583.
31. Virtanen A., Ristimäki J., Vaaraslahti K., Keskinen J., Lappi M. Effective density of diesel exhaust particle as a function of size. SAE Technical paper series 2002-01-0056. 2002.
32. Klingen H.-J., Roth P. Size analysis and fractal dimension of diesel particles based on REM measurements with an automatic imaging system. J Aerosol Sci. 20:1989;861-864.
33. Lipkea W.H., Johnson J.H., Vuk C.T. The physical and chemical character of diesel particulate emissions-measurement techniques and fundamental considerations. Johnson J.H., Rosebrock T.L., Somers J.H. The measurement and control of diesel particulate emissions. 1979;1-57 Society of Automotive Engineers, Warendale, PA. PT-79/17.
34. SAE handbook, vol. 3. Engines, fuels, lubricants emissions, and noise; 1989.
35. Frisch L.E., Johnson J.H., Leddy D.G. Effect of fuels and dilution ratio on diesel particulate emissions. Johnson J.H., Rosebrock T.L., Somers J.H. The measurement and control of diesel particulate emissions. 1979;245-273 Society of Automotive Engineers. PT-79/17.
36. Brown JE. Heavy duty diesel fine particulate emissions: development and application of on-road measurement capabilities. EPA report 600/R-01-079; 2001.
37. Standard practice for conducting an interlaboratory study to determine the precision of a test method. 1999;ASTM, West Conshohocken, PA.
38. Traver M.L., Tennant C.J., McDaniel T.I., McConnel S.S. Interlaboratory cross-check of heavy-duty vehicle chassis dynamometers. SAE technical paper No. 2002-01-2879. 2002.
39. Stein H.J., Ekermo A.E., Treiber P.J.H. Emission correlation of heavy duty transient test facilities. SAE technical paper series 892492. 1989.
40. Kittelson D.B., Johnson J.H. Variability in particle emission measurements in the heavy duty transient test. SAE technical paper series 910738. 1991.
41. ACEA. Problems associated with the measurement of low particulate levels. ACEA report 99000524.
42. Adapted from data of Ricardo Consulting Engineers. Personal Communication with John Andersson.
43. Berger C., Horvath H., Schindler W. The deposition of soot particles from hot gas streams through pipes. J Aerosol Sci. 26:1995;211-217.
44. Thimsen D.P., Baumgard K.J., Kotz T.J., Kittelson D.B. The performance of an electrostatic agglomerator as a diesel soot emission device. SAE technical paper series 900330. 1990.
45. Kittelson D.B., Reinertsen J., Michalski J. Further studies of electrostatic collection and agglomeration of diesel particles. SAE technical paper series 910329. 1991.
46. Ziskind G., Fichman M., Gutfinger C. Resuspension of particulates from surfaces to turbulent flows: review and analysis. J Aerosol Sci. 26:1995;613-644.
47. Matsusaka S., Masuda H. Particle reentrainment from a fine powder layer in a turbulent air flow. Aerosol Sci Technol. 24:1996;69-84.
48. Silvis W.M., Marek G., Kreft N., Schindler W. Diesel particulate measurement with partial flow sampling systems: a new probe and tunnel design that correlates with full flow tunnels. SAE technical paper series 2002-01-0054. 2002.
49. MacDonald J.S., Plee S.L., D'Arcy J.B., Schreck R.M. Experimental measurements of the independent effect of dilution ratio and filter temperature on diesel particulate matter. SAE technical paper series 800185. 1980.
50. Reichel S., Pishinger F.F., Lepperhoff G. Influence on particles in diluted diesel engine exhaust gas. SAE technical paper series 831333. 1983.
51. Plee S.L., MacDonald J.S. Some mechanism affecting the mass of diesel exhaust particulate collected following a dilution process. SAE technical paper series 800186. 1980.
52. Clerc J.C., Johnson J.H. A computer heat transfer and hydrocarbon adsorption model for predicting diesel particulate emissions in dilution tunnels. SAE technical paper series 821218. 1982.
53. Engeljehringer K., Schindler W. Experiences with a mini-dilution system for engine homologation and development. SAE technical paper series 942418. 1994.
54. Directive 1999/96/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council. Official J 1999;L044:0001-155.
55. Control of emissions from new and in-use highway vehicles. Rules Regul. 66:(12):2001.
56. ISO/TC 22/SC 5/WG 2 N 195E. ISO/FDIS 16183: heavy-duty engines - measurement of gaseous emissions from raw exhaust gas and of particulate emissions using partial flow dilution systems under transient test conditions; 2002-02-07.
57. Personal communication with Mr Jürgen Stein, Daimler Chrysler.
58. Stein HJ. Worldwide harmonized heavy duty emissions certification procedure. Exhaust emission measurement ISO second Interim report; 2001, http://www.unece.org/trans/doc/2001/wp29grpe/TRANS-WP29-GRPE-41-inf03.pdf .
59. Stein HJ. Potential of gravimetric PM measurement method. Presentation to the Worldwide Hewavy Duty Certification Group, 43rd GRPE session; January 2002.
60. Schweizer, T., Havenith, C., Stein, H.J., Worldwide Harmonized Heavy Duty Emissions Certification Procedure. Validation Results, 2002, http://www.unece.org/trans/doc/2002/wp29grpe/TRANS-WP29-GRPE-43-inf12.pdf .
61. Schweizer T., Stein H.J. New approach to particulate measurement on transient test cycles: partial flow dilution as alternative to CVS full flow systems. SAE technical paper series 2000-01-1134. 2000.
62. Duran A., De Lucas A., Carmona M., Ramos M.J., Armas O. Accuracy of the European standard method to measure the amount of DPM emitted to the atmosphere. Fuel. 81:2002;2053-2060.
63. Personal communication with Mr Miro Janda, Horiba Europe GmbH.
64. Personal communication with Mr Thomas Schweizer, EMPA.
65. Allen R., Box M., Liu L.-J.S., Larson T.V. A cost-effective weighing chamber for particulates matter filters. J Air Waste Mgmt Assoc. 51:2001;1650-1653.
66. Nakajima M., Ichikawa J., Suzuki T. Development of a measuring method for particulate emission using a mini tunnel-ISATA paper No. 90090. 1990.
67. Hirakouchi N., Fukano I., Shoji T. Measurement of diesel exhaust emissions with mini-dilution tunnel. SAE technical paper series 890181. 1989.
68. Yamagishi Y. The MDLT-1302T partial-flow dilution tunnel for transient test cycle PM sampling. Horiba technical reports; 1999, http://global.horiba.com/engine_e/engmeas/techpapers/index.htm .
69. Engeljehringer K., Schindler W., Sultzer R. Meeting ISO 8178 requirements for the measurement of diesel particulates with partial flow dilution systems. SAE technical paper series 932466. 1993.
70. Mollenhauer K, Israël GW, Gnuschke H, Mooser D, Bollmann-Weiss R, Beckmann C. Entwicklung eines Verfahrens zur Messung der Partikelemission NFZ- Motoren im Rahmen der ECER49. Forschungsberichte Verbrennungskraft (FVV), Heft 466; 141S; 1990.
71. Moose D, Bollman-Weiss R, Carli S. Entwicklung einer vereifachten Meßtechnick zur Bestimmung der Partikelemission Stationärer Diesel- und Gasmotoren. FVV Fortschrittsberichte Heft R471. Abschlußbericht uber das Vorhaben Nr. 477; 1993. Quoted by Engeljehringer and Schindler, Ref. [8].
72. Starr M.E. Transient and steady-state emissions testing of ten nonroad diesel engines each using two fuels. EPA draft final report. SwRI project 0803316. 2001.
73. Khalek I.A., Ulmann T.L., Shimpi S.A., Jackson C.C., Dharmawardhana B., Silvis W.M., Kreft N., Harvey R.N., Munday D., Yamagishi Y., Graze R., Smitherman J., Adkins J. Performance of partial flow sampling systems relative to flow CVS for determination of particulate emissions under steady-state and transient diesel engine operation. SAE technical paper series 2002-01-1718. 2002.
74. Okrent D.A. Description of an on-line method for measuring the ratio of soot to organics in diesel exhaust particulates. SAE technical paper series 960252. 1996.
75. Fukushima H., Uchicara H., Asano L., Adachi M., Nakamura S., Ikeda M., Ishidsa K. An alternative technique for low particulate measurement. SAE technical paper series 2001-01-0218. 2001.
76. Israel GW, Mollenhauer K, Ulrich E. Entwicklung eines Thermographischen Meßverfahrens als Alternative zur Gravimetrie bei der Ermittlung von Dieselpartikel-Emissionen. FVV Fortschrittsberichte Heft 540. Abschlußbericht über das Vorhaben Nr. 548; 1994.
77. Friedlander S.K. Smoke, dust, and haze. Fundamentals of aerosol dynamics. 2000;Oxford University Press, New York.
78. Willeke K., Baron P.A. Aerosol measurements: principles techniques and applications. 2001;Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.
79. Hinds W.C. Aerosol technology. properties, behaviour, and measurement of airborne particles. 1999;Wiley, New York.
80. Zhao H., Ladommatos N. Optical diagnostics for soot and temperature measurement in diesel engines. Prog Energy Combust Sci. 24:1998;221-255.
81. Bockhorn H., Geitlinger H., Jungfleisch B., Lehre T., Schön A., Streibel T., Suntz R. Progress in characterization of soot formation by optical methods. Phys Chem Chem Phys. 4:2002;3780-3793.
82. Lehre T., Bockhorn H., Jungfleisch B., Suntz R. Development of a measuring technique for simultaneous in situ detection of nanoscaled particle size distributions and gas temperatures. Chemosphere. 51:2003;1055-1061.
83. Zahoransky R.A., Kuhnt W., Laile E. In-line particle measurements of the undiluted exhaust of the combustion engines by multi-wavelength extinction technique. J Aerosol Sci. 28:1997;S49-S50.
84. Carey A.W. Steady-state correlation of diesel smoke meters: an SAE task force report. SAE technical paper series 690492. 1969.
85. Hills F.J., Wagner T.O., Lawrence D.K. CRC correlation of diesel smokemeter measurements. SAE technical paper series 690493. 1969.
86. Vuk C.T., Jones M.A., Johnson J.H. The measurement and analysis of the physical characteristics of diesel particulate emissions. SAE technical paper series 760131. 1976.
87. Greeves G., Wang C.H.T. Origins of diesel particulate mass emissions. SAE technical paper series 810260. 1981.
88. Japar S., Szkarlat A. Real-time measurements of diesel vehicle exhaust particulate using photoacoustic spectroscopy and total light extinction. SAE technical paper series 811184. 1981.
89. Gerke D.H. Real-time measurement of diesel particulate emissions with a light extinction opacity meter. SAE technical paper series 830183. 1983.
90. Homan H.S. Conversion factors among smoke measurements. SAE technical paper series 850267. 1985.
91. Krempl P., Schindler W., Schiefer E. Dynamic measurements of particulate mass emission on light-duty diesel engines under steady-state and transient conditions. SAE technical paper series 850269. 1985.
92. Zahoransky R.A., Laile E., Terwey B., Konstandopoulos A. Mayer A. On line/in line measurements of particle emissions of diesel engines by optical multi-wavelength technique. Proceedings of the ETH Conference on Nanoparticle Measurement, paper 26. 2000.
93. Hansen A.D.A., Rosen H., Novakov T. The aethalometer: an instrument for the real-time measurement of optical absorption by aerosol particles. Sci Total Environ. 36:1984;191-196.
94. Alkidas J.S. Relationships between smoke measurements and particulate measurements. SAE technical paper series 840412. 1984.
95. Moosmüller H., Arnott W.P., Rogers C.F., Bowen J.I., Gillies J.A., Pierson W.R., Collins J.F., Durbin T.D., Norbeck J.M. Time resolved of diesel particulate emissions. 1. Instruments for particle mass measurements. Environ Sci Technol. 35:2001;781-787.
96. Hansen ADA. The aethalometer. Magee Scientific Company. www.mageesci.com .
97. Cheung S.K., Elder S.T., Raine R.R. Diesel particulate measurements with a light scattering photometer. SAE technical paper series 2000-01-1136. 2000.
98. Eckbreth A.C. Effects of laser-modulated particulate incandescence on Raman scattering diagnostics. J Appl Phys. 48:1977;4473-4479.
99. Hofeldt D.L. Real-time soot concentration measurement technique for engine exhaust streams. SAE technical paper series 930079. 1993.
100. Case M.E., Hofeldt D.L. Soot mass concentration in diesel engine exhaust using laser-induced incandescence. Aerosol Sci Techol. 25:1996;46-60.
101. Snelling D.R., Smallwood G.J., Sawchuk R.A., Neil W.S., Gareau D., Chippior W.L., Liu F., Gülder Ö.L., Bachalo W.D. Particulate matter measurements in a diesel engine exhaust by laser-induced incandescence and the standard gravimetric procedure. SAE technical paper series 1999-01-3663. 1999.
102. Schraml S., Will S., Leipertz A. Simultaneous measurement of soot mass concentration and primary particle size in the exhaust of a DI diesel engine by time-resolved laser-induced incandescence (TIRE-LII). SAE technical paper series 1999-01-0146. 1999.
103. Schraml S., Heimgärtner C., Will S., Leipertz A. Application of a new soot sensor for exhaust emission control based on time resolved laser induced incandescence (TIRE-LII). SAE technical paper series 2000-01-2864. 2000.
104. Snelling D.R., Smallwood G.J., Sawchuk R.A., Neil W.S., Gareau D., Clavel D.J., Chippior W.L., Liu F., Gülder Ö.L. In situ real time characterization of particulate emissions from a diesel engine exhaust by laser-induced incandescence. SAE technical paper series 2000-01-1994. 2000.
105. Bachalo W.D., Sankar S.V., Smallwood G.J., Snelling D.R. Development of the laser-induced incandescence method for the reliable characterization of particulate emissions. 11th International Symposium on Applications of Laser Techniques to Fluid Mechanics, Lisbon, Portugal, July 8-111. 2002.
106. Roessler D.M. Photoacoustic insights on diesel exhaust particle. Appl Opt. 23:1984;1148-1155.
107. Abe T., Sato T., Hayashida M.M. Particulate matter emission characteristics under transient pattern drivings. SAE technical paper series 890468. 1989.
108. Arnott W.P., Moosmüller H.C., Fred Rogers C.F., Jin T., Bruch R. Photoacoustic spectrometer for measuring light absorption by aerosol: instrument sescription. Atmos Environ. 33:1999;2845-2852.
109. Arcoumanis C., Megaritis A. Real-time measurement of particulate emissions in a turbocharged DI diesel engine. SAE technical paper series 922390. 1992.
110. Sun J.H., Chan S.H. A time-resolved measurement technique for particulate number density in diesel exhaust using a fast-response flame ionization detector. Meas Sci Technol. 8:1997;279-286.
111. Kawai T., Iuchi Y., Nakamura S., Ishida K. Real-time analysis of particulate matter by flame ionization detection. SAE technical paper series 980048. 1998.
112. Cheng W.K., Summers T., Collings N. The fast-response flame ionization detector. Prog Energy Combust Sci. 24:1998;89-124.
113. Abbass M.K., Andrews G.E., Williams P.T., Bartle K.D. Diesel particulate composition changes along an air cooled exhaust pipe and dilution tunnel. SAE technical paper series 890789. 1989.
114. Fukushima H., Asano L., Nakamura S., Ishida K., Gregory D. Signal processing and practical performance of a real-time PM analyzer using fast FIDs. SAE technical paper series 2000-01-1135. 2000.
115. Whitby R., Gibbs R., Johnson R., Hill B., Shimpi S., Jorgenson R. Real-time diesel particulate measurement using a tapered element oscillating microbalance. SAE technical paper series 820463. 1982.
116. ® and conventional filtration techniques. SAE technical paper series 850403, Detroit. 1985.
117. Shore R.P., Cutbertson R.D. Application of a tapered element oscillating microbalance to continuous diesel particulate measurements. SAE technical paper series 850405. 1985.
118. Saito K., Shinozaki O. The measurement of diesel particulate emissions with a tapered element oscillating microbalance and an opacimeter. SAE technical paper series 900644. 1990.
119. Burtscher H., Kunzel S., Huglin C. Characterization of particles in combustion engine exhaust. J Aerosol Sci. 29:1998;389-396.
120. Chan S.H., He Y.S. Measurements of particulate mass concentration using a tapered-element oscillating microbalance and a flame ionization detector. Meas Sci Technol. 10:1999;323-332.
121. Jarrett R.P., Clark N.N., Gilbert M., Ramamurthy R. Evaluation and correction of moisture adsorption and desorption from a tapered element oscillating microbalance. Powder Technol. 119:2001;215-228.
122. Kelly N.A., Morgan C. An evaluation of the tapered element oscillating microbalance method for measuring diesel particulate emissions. J Air Waste Mgmt Assoc. 52:2002;1362-1377.
123. ® monitor for measuring diesel particulate in real-time. SAE technical paper series 980409. 1998.
124. Rickeard D.J., Bateman J.R., Kwon Y.K., McAughey J.J., Dickens C.J. Exhaust particulate size distribution: vehicle and fuel influences in light duty vehicles. SAE technical paper series 1996. 1980.
125. Ricardo Consulting Engineers Ltd. UK particle measurement programme: heavy duty methodology. Final report, W. Sussex; July 2002. Internet reference at http://www.ricardo.com/downloads/SummaryReport.pdf .
126. Moisio M., Niemelä V. Device for continuous measurement of density and mass concentration of vehicle exhaust aerosol. Sixth International Aerosol Conference, September 8-11. 2002;. Taipei, Taiwan.
127. Keskinen J., Pietarinen K., Lehtimäki M. Electrical low pressure impactor. J Aerosol Sci. 23:1992;353-360.
128. Ristimäki J., Virtanen A., Marjamäki M., Rostedt A., Keskinen J. On-line measurement of size distribution and effective density of submicron aerosol particles. J Aerosol Sci. 33:2002;1541-1557.
129. Harris S.J., Maricq M.M. Signature size distributions for diesel and gasoline engine exhaust particulate matter. J Aerosol Sci. 32:2001;749-764.
130. Official J. L107:2001;10-23.