Recent developments in controller performance monitoring and assessment techniques

AIChE Symposium Series

Volumn 98, Issue 326, 2002, Pages 208-222

  Harris, Thomas J ^a   Seppala, Christopher T ^b  

^a QUEEN S UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b SHELL GLOBAL SOLUTIONS INTERNATIONAL B V   (United States)

Author keywords

Controller performance; Minimum variance control; Multivariable systems; Subspace methods; Vector autoregressions

Indexed keywords

EID: 0141836624     PISSN: 00658812     EISSN: None     Source Type: Conference Proceeding    
DOI: None     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (68)

1. Åström, K. J., "Computer Control of a Paper Machine - An Application of Linear Stochastic Control Theory," IBM Journal, July 1967, pages 389-404 (1967).
2. Åström, K. J., Introduction to Stochastic Control Theory. Academic Press, London (1970).
3. Basseville, M., "On-Board Component Fault Detection and Isolation Using the Statistical Local Approach," Automatica, 34, 1391-1415 (1998).
4. Bergh, D. and J. F. MacGregor, "Constrained Minimum Variance Controllers: Internal Model Structure and Robustness Properties," Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 26, 1558-1564 (1987).
5. Bittanti, S., P. Colaneri, and M. F. Mongiovi, The Spectral Interactor Matrix for the Singular Riccatti Equation, In Proc. 33rd CDC, pages 2165-2169 (1994).
6. Bittanti, S., M. Campi, and S. M. Savaresi, "Unbiased Estimation of a Sinusoid in Colored Noise via Adapted Notch Filters," Automatica, 33(2), 209-215 (1997).
7. Box, G. E. P. and G. M. Jenkins, Time Series Analysis: Forecasting and Control. Holden Day, San Francisco (1976).
8. De Vries, W. R. and M. Wu, "Evaluation of Process Control Effectiveness and Diagnosis of Variation in Paper Basis Weight via Multivariate Time-Series Analysis," IEEE Trans. Auto. Cont., 23, 702-708 (1978).
9. Desborough, L. D. and T. J. Harris, "Performance Assessment Measures for Univariate Feedback Control," Can. J. Chem. Eng., 70, 1186-1197 (1992).
10. Desborough, L. D. and T. J. Harris, "Performance Assessment Measures for Univariate Feedforward/Feedback Control," Can. J. Chem. Eng., 71, 605-616 (1993).
11. Dugard, L., G. C. Goodwin, and X. Xianya, "The Role of the Interactor Matrix in Multivariable Stochastic Adaptive Control," Automatica, 20, 701-709 (1984).
12. Foley, M. and T. J. Harris, "Performance and Structure of H∞ Controllers," J. Optim. Cont. Appl. Meth., 13, 1-28 (1992).
13. Forsman, K., On Detection and Classification of Valve Stiction, In TAPPI Conf. on Process Control, Williamsburg, VA (2000).
14. Furuta, K. and M. Wongsaisuwan, "Closed-Form Solutions to Discrete-Time LQ Optimal Control and Disturbance Attenuation," Sys. Cont. Let., 20, 427-437 (1993).
15. Furuta, K. and M. Wongsaisuwan, "Discrete-Time LQG Dynamic Controller Design Using Plant Markov Parameters," Automatica, 31, 1317-1324 (1995).
16. Goodwin, G. C. and K. S. Sin, Adaptive Filtering Prediction and Control. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N. J. (1984).
17. Gustafsson, F. and S. F. Graebe, "Closed-Loop Performance Monitoring in the Presence of System Changes and Disturbances," Automatica, 34, 1311-1326 (1998).
18. Hãgglund, T., "A Control-Loop Performance Monitor," Control Eng. Practice, 5(11), 1543-1551 (1995).
19. Haarsma, G. and M. Nikolaou, Multivariate Controller Performance Monitoring: Lessons from an Application to a Snack Food Process (2000). Submitted to Journal of Process Control.
20. Hamilton, J. D., Time Series Analysis. Princeton University Press, Princeton (1994).
21. Harris, T. J. and J. H. Davis, "An Iterative Method for Matrix Spectral Factorization," SIAM J. Sci. Statist. Comput., 13, 531-540 (1992).
22. Harris, T. J. and J. F. MacGregor, "Design of Multivariable Linear-Quadratic Controllers Using Transfer Functions," AIChE J., 33, 1481-1495 (1987).
23. Harris, T. J., F. Boudreau, and J. F. MacGregor, "Performance Assessment of Multivariable Feedback Controllers," Automatica, 32, 1505-1518 (1996).
24. Harris, T. J., C. T. Seppala, and L. D. Desborough, "A Review of Performance Monitoring and Assessment Techniques for Univariate and Multivariate Control Systems," J. Proc. Cont., 9(1), 1-17 (1999).
25. Harris, T. J., "Assessment of Control Loop Performance," Can. J. Chem. Eng., 67, 856-861 (1989).
26. Harris, T. J., Confidence estimation for performance assessment measures (2001). In Preparation, Queen's University, Kingston.
27. Horch, A. and A. J. Isaksson, A method for detection of stiction in control valves, In IFAC Workshop on On-Line-Fault Detection and Supervision in the Chemical Process Industry, Lyon, France (1998).
28. Horch, A. and A. J. Isaksson, "A Modified Index for Control Performance Assessment," J. Proc. Cont., 9, 475-483 (1999).
29. Horch, A., Condition Monitoring of Control Loops, Ph.D. Thesis, Royal Institute of Technology (KTH), Stockholm, Sweden (2000).
30. Huang, B. and S. L. Shah, "Practical Issues in Multivariable Feedback Control Performance Assessment," J. Proc. Cont., 8, 421-430 (1998).
31. Huang, B. and S. L. Shah, Performance Assessment of Control Loops. Springer-Verlag, London (1999).
32. Huang, B., S. L. Shah, and K. E. Kwok, "Good, Bad or Optimal? Performance Assessment of Multivariable Processes," Automatica, 33(6), 1175-1183 (1997b).
33. Huang, B., S. L. Shah, K. E. Kwok, and J. Zurcher, "Performance Assessment of Multivariate Control Loops on a Paper-Machine Headbox," Can. J. Chem. Eng., 75, 134-142 (1997c).
34. Huang, B., S. L. Shah, and H. Fujii, "The Unitary Interactor Matrix and its Estimation Using Closed-Loop Data," J. Proc. Cont., 7(3), 195-207 (1997a).
35. Huang, B., S. L. Shah, and R. Miller, "Feedforward Plus Feedback Controller Performance Assessment of MIMO Systems," IEEE Trans. Cont. Sys. Tech., 3, 580-587 (2000).
36. Isaksson, A. J., A. Horch, and G. A. Dumont, Event-triggered deadtime estimation: A comparison of methods, In Proc. Control Systems 2000, pages 209-215, Victoria, BC (2000).
37. Isaksson, A. J., PID Controller Performance Assessment, In Proc. Control Systems '96, pages 187-194, Halifax, NS (1996).
38. Isermann, R. and P. Ballé, "Trends in the Application of Model-Based Fault Detection and Diagnosis of Technical Processes," Control Eng. Practice, 5(5), 709-719 (1997).
39. Jofriet, P. and B. Bialkowski, Process Knowledge: The Key to On-Line Monitoring of Process Variability and Control Loop Performance, In Proc. Control Systems 96, pages 163-169, Halifax, NS (1996).
40. Jofriet, P., C. Seppala, M. Harvey, B. Surgenor, and T. Harris, "An Expert System for Control Loop Performance," Pulp and Paper Canada, 6, 207-211 (1996).
41. Kendra, S. J. and A. Çinar, "Controller Performance Assessment by Frequency Domain Techniques," J. Proc. Cont., 7(3), 181-194 (1997).
42. Kesavan, P. and J. H. Lee, "Diagnostic Tools for Multivariable Model-Based Control Systems," Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 36, 2725-2738 (1997).
43. Ko, B. and T. F. Edgar, Assessment of Achievable PI Control Performance for Linear Processes with Deadtime, In Proc. American Control Conference, pages 1548-1552, Philadelphia, PA (1998).
44. Ko, B. and T. F. Edgar, "Performance Assessment of Cascade Loops," AIChE J., 46, 281-291 (2000a).
45. Ko, B. and T. F. Edgar, Performance Assessment of Constrained Model Predictive Control Systems (2000b). Submitted to AIChE Journal.
46. Ko, B. and T. F. Edgar, Performance Assessment of Multivariable Feedback Control Systems (2000c). Submitted to Automatica.
47. Kozub, D. J. and C. E. Garcia, Monitoring and Diagnosis of Automated Controllers in the Chemical Process Industries, In AIChE Proceedings, St. Louis, MO (1993).
48. Kozub, D. J., Monitoring and Diagnosis of Chemical Processes with Automated Process Control, In CPC V Proceedings, Lake Tahoe (1996).
49. Kucera, V., Discrete Linear Control: The Polynomial Equation Approach. John Wiley & Sons, New York (1979).
50. Lütkepohl, H., Introduction to Multiple Time Series Analysis. Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1991).
51. Miller, R. M. and L. D. Desborough, "Web-enabled control loop assessment," Chemical Engineering (2000).
52. Miller, R. M. and B. Huang, Perspectives on Multivariate Feedforward/Feedback Controller Performance Measures for Process Diagnosis, In Proc. IFAC Adchem 97, pages 435-440, Banff, AB (1997).
53. Mutho, Y. and R. Ortega, "Interactor Structure Estimation for Adaptive Control of Discrete-Time Multivariable Nondecouplable Systems," Automatica, 29, 635-647 (1993).
54. Mutho, Y., "A note on the invariant properties of ineractors," Int. J. Control, 62, 1247-1252 (1995).
55. Owen, J. G., D. Read, H. Blekkenhorst, and A. A. Roche, A Mill Prototype for Automatic Monitoring of Control Loop Performance, In Proc. Control Systems 96, pages 171-178, Halifax, NS (1996).
56. Owen, J. G., Automatic control loop monitoring and diagnostics (1997). Patent Application. Int. Publ No WO 97/41494, Int. Appl. No PCT/CA97/00266.
57. Peng, Y. and M. Kinnaert, "Explicit Solution to the Singular LQ Regulation Problem," IEEE Trans. Auto. Cont., 37, 633-636 (1992).
58. Qin, S. J., "Control Performance Monitoring - A Review and Assessment," Comput. Chem. Eng., 23, 173-186 (1998).
59. Rogozinski, M. W., A. P. Paplinski, and M. J. Gibbard, "An Algorithm for Calculation of a Nilpotent Interactor Matrix for Linear Multivariable Systems," IEEE Trans. Auto. Cont., 32, 2234-2237 (1987).
60. Seborg, D. and T. Miao, Automatic detection of excessively oscillatory feedback control loops, In IEEE Int. Conf. on Control Applications, pages 359-364, Hawaii, USA (1999).
61. Seppala, C. T., T. J. Harris, and D. W. Bacon, Time Series Methods for Dynamic Analysis of Multiple Controlled Variables (2001). Submitted to Journal of Process Control.
62. Seppala, C. T., Dynamic Analysis of Variance Methods for Monitoring Control System Performance, Ph.D. Thesis, Queen's University, Canada (1999).
63. Stanfelj, N., T. E. Marlin, and J. F. MacGregor, "Monitoring and Diagnosing Process Control Performance: The Single-Loop Case," Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 32, 301-314 (1993).
64. Thornhill, N. F., M. Oettinger, and P. Fedenczuk, "Refinery-wide control loop performance assessment," J. Proc. Cont., 9, 109-124 (1999).
65. Tsiligiannis, C. A. and S. A. Svoronos, "Dynamic Interactors in Multivariable Process Control - I: The General Time Delay Case," Chem. Eng. Sci., 43, 339-347 (1988).
66. Tyler, M. L. and M. Morari, Performance assessment for unstable and nonminimum-phased systems, In Proc. IFAC Workshop on On-Line Fault Detection and Supervision in the Chemical Process Industries, pages 200-205, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK (1995).
67. Tyler, M. L. and M. Morari, "Performance Monitoring of Control Systems Using Likelihood Methods," Automatica, 32, 1145-1162 (1996).
68. Vishnubhotla, A., S. L. Shah, and B. Huang, Feedback and Feedforward Performance Analysis of the Shell Industrial Closed Loop Data Set, In Proc. IFAC Adchem 97, pages 295-300, Banff, AB (1997).