The preservationist paradox: Modernism, environmentalism and the politics of spatial division

Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers

Volumn 28, Issue 3, 2003, Pages 318-332

  Murdoch, Jonathan ^a   Lowe, Philip ^b  

^a CARDIFF UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Classification; CPRE; Environmentalism; Sustainability; Urban rural divisions

Indexed keywords

ENVIRONMENTALISM; MODERNITY; POLITICAL PROCESS; RURAL POLITICS; RURAL-URBAN COMPARISON; SUSTAINABILITY;

UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 0141749325     PISSN: 00202754     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1475-5661.00095     Document Type: Article

References (85)

1. Abercrombie P 1933 Town and country planning Allen and Unwin, London
2. Allison L 1975 Environmental planning Allen and Unwin, London
3. Allmendinger P and Tewdwr-Jones M 2000 New Labour new planning? The trajectory of planning in Blair's Britain Urban Studies 37 1379-402
4. Barlow J and Savage M 1986 Conflict and cleavage in a Tory heartland Capital and Class 31 32-56
5. Beck U 1992 Risk society Sage, London
6. Bell M M 1994 Childerley University of Chicago Press, London
7. Botkin D 1990 Discordant harmonies: a new ecology for the twenty-first century Oxford University Press, Oxford
8. Bowker G and Star S L 2000 Sorting things out: classification and practice MIT Press, Cambridge MA
9. Boyle P and Halfacree K eds 1998 Migration into rural areas Wiley, London
10. Bramley G 1998 Memorandum in House of Commons Select Committee on Environment, Transport and the Regions: Tenth Report: housing Stationary Office, London
11. Bramley G and Watkins C 1996 Circular projections CPRE, London
12. Breheny M ed 1996 The people; where will they go? Town and Country Planning Association, London
13. Breheny M 1999 People households and houses: the basis of the 'great housing debate' in England Town Planning Review 70 275-93
14. Buller H and Lowe P 1982 Politics and class in rural preservation: a study of the Suffolk Preservation Society in Mosely M ed Power, planning and people in East Anglia Centre for East Anglian Studies, Norwich
15. Champion T 1994 Population change and migration in Britain since 1981; evidence for continuing deconcentration Environment and Planning A 26 1501-20
16. Champion T 1997 The facts about the urban exodus Town and Country Planning March 77-9
17. Cherry G E 1974 The evolution of British town planning Leonard Hill, Leighton Buzzard
18. Cherry G E and Rogers A 1996 Rural change and planning Spon, London
19. Council for the Protection of Rural England 1994a Housing: a paper for the Policy Committee CPRE, London
20. Council for the Protection of Rural England 1994b Urban footprints CPRE, London
21. Council for the Protection of Rural England 1996 Housing development and the countryside: a paper for the Policy Committee CPRE, London
22. Council for the Protection of Rural England 1997a Making sense of environmental capacity CPRE, London
23. Council for the Protection of Rural England 1997b Housing and urban campaigns: a paper for the Policy Committee CPRE, London
24. Council for the Protection of Rural England 1998 Policy Committee Report l6th July CPRE, London
25. Council for the Protection of Rural England 1999 Renaissance pays CPRE, London
26. Council for the Protection of Rural England 2000 Memorandom in House of Commons Select Committee on Environment, Transport and the Regions Report: Urban White Paper HMSO, London
27. Council for the Protection of Rural England 2001a Planning the way forward 2001-2005 - A strategic review CPRE, London
28. Council for the Protection of Rural England 2001B Sprawl patrol - first year report CPRE, London
29. Countryside Agency 2000 The state of the countryside Countryside Agency, Cheltenham
30. Crandell G 1993 Nature pictorialised: 'the view' in landscape history John Hopkins Press, Baltimore
31. Cronon W 1995 Introduction: in search of nature in Cronon W ed Uncommon ground: toward reinventing nature Norton, New York
32. Davoudi S and Stead D 2002 Urban-rural relationships: an introduction and brief history Built Environment 28 269-77
33. Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions 1998 Planning for the communities of the future DETR, London
34. Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions 2000a Planning policy guidance rate 11: regional planning DETR, London
35. Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions 2000b Planning policy guidance 3: housing DETR, London
36. Dudley G and Richardson J 2000 Why does policy change? Lessons from British transport policy 1945-99 Routledge, London
37. Eder K 1996 The social construction of nature Sage, London
38. Fielding A 1990 Counterurbanisation: threat or blessing? in Pinder D ed Western Europe: challenge and change Belhaven, London
39. Hacking I 1999 The social construction of what? Harvard University Press, London
40. Hall P, Thomas R, Gracey H and Drewett R 1973 The containment of urban England Allen and Unwin, London
41. House of Commons 1995 Select Committee on the Environment Second Report: housing need Stationary Office, London
42. House of Commons 1998 Select Committee on Environment, Transport and the Regions Tenth Report; housing Stationary Office, London
43. King D 2000 Projected household numbers for rural districts of England Countryside Agency, Chelmsford
44. Latour B 1993 We have never been modern Harvester Wheatsheaf, London
45. Latour B 1998 Politiques de la nature: comment faire entrer les sciences en democratie La Decouverte, Paris
46. Latour B 1999 Pandora's hope Harvard University Press, London
47. Lee N and Stenner P 1999 Who pays? Can we pay them back? in Hassard J and Law J eds Actor-network and after Routledge, London
48. Lowe P 1977 Amenity and equity: a review of local environmental pressure groups in Britain Environment and Planning A 9 35-58
49. Lowe P and Goyder J 1983 Environmental groups in politics Allen and Unwin, London
50. Lowe P and Murdoch J 2003 Mediating the 'national' and the 'local' in the environmental policy process: a case study of the CPRE Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy forthcoming
51. Lowe P and Pye-Smith C 1980 No nukes in Ambridge: an interview with Chris Hall Ecos 1 8-9
52. Lowe P, Cox G, O'Riordan T, MacEwan M and Winter M 1986 Countryside conflicts: the politics of farming forestry and conservation Gower, Aldershot
53. Lowe P, Murdoch J and Cox G 1995 A civilised retreat? Anti-urbanism rurality and the making of an Anglo-centric culture in Healey P, Davoudi S, Huth A and Madami-Pour A eds Managing cities: the new urban context Wiley, Chichester
54. Lowe P, Murdoch J and Norton A 2001 Professionals and volunteers in the environmental process Centre for Rural Economy, University of Newcastle
55. Macnaghten P and Urry J 1998 Contested natures Sage, London
56. Matless D 1998 Landscape and Englishness Reaktion, London
57. Michael M 2000 Reconnecting culture technology and nature: from society to heterogeneity Routledge, London
58. Murdoch J 2000 Space against time: competing rationalities in planning for housing Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 25 503-19
59. Murdoch J 2001 Ecologising sociology: actor-network theory co-construction and the problem of human exemptionalism Sociology 35 111-33
60. Murdoch J and Abram S 2002 Rationalities of planning: development versus environment in planning for housing Ashgate, Aldershot
61. Murdoch J and Marsden T 1994 Reconstituting rurality: class community and power in the development process UCL Press, London
62. Murdoch J and Marsden T 1995 The spatialisation of politics: local and national actor-spaces in environmental conflict Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 20 368-80
63. Neumann R 1998 Imposing wilderness: struggles over livelihood and nature preservation in Africa University of California Press, Berkley
64. Oerlemans O 2002 Romanticism and the materiality of nature University of Toronto Press, Toronto
65. Owens S and Cowell R 2001 Land and limits: interpreting sustainability in the planning process Routledge, London
66. Pahl R 1966 Urbs in rure LSE, London
67. Rawcliffe P 1998 Environmental pressure groups in transition Manchester University Press, Manchester
68. Raynsford N 2000 PPG 3 - making it work Town and Country Planning September 262-3
69. Robbins P 2001 Tracking invasive land covers in India or why our landscapes have never been modern Annals of the Association of American Geographers 91 637-59
70. Scott J 1994 CPRE Marketing Initiatives Project: interim summary and research prospectus CPRE, London
71. Sharp T 1932 Town and countryside Allen and Unwin, London
72. Sheail J 1976 Nature in trust Blackie, London
73. Sheail J 1997 Scott revisited: post-war agriculture planning and the British countryside Journal of Rural Studies 13 387-98
74. Sheail J 2002 An environmental history of the twentieth century Palgrave, London
75. Short J R, Fleming S and Witt S 1986 House building, planning and community action Routledge and Kegan Paul, London
76. Sutton P 2000 Explaining environmentalism: in search of a new social movement Ashgate, Aldershot
77. Thomas K 1984 Man and the natural world Penguin, London
78. Urban Task Force 1999 Towards urban renaissance DETR, London
79. Vigar G, Healey P, Hull A and Davoudi S 2000 Planning governance and spatial strategy in Britain: an institutionalist approach Macmillan, London
80. Ward S 1994 Planning and urban change PCP, London
81. Whatmore S 2002 Hybrid geographies Sage, London
82. Williams-Ellis C 1928 England and the octopus Bles, London
83. Williams R 1973 The country and the city Chatto and Windus, London
84. Wilson E 1998 Consilience Knopf, New York
85. Zimmerer K 2000 The reworking of conservation geographies: nonequilibrium landscapes and nature-society hybrids Annals of the Association of American Geographers 90 356-69