People with learning disabilities as witnesses in court: What questions should lawyers ask?

British Journal of Learning Disabilities

Volumn 29, Issue 3, 2001, Pages 98-102

  Kebbell, Mark R ^a   Hatton, Chris ^b   Johnson, Shane D ^a   O'Kelly, Caitriona M E ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM   (United Kingdom)

^b LANCASTER UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Court; Cross examination; Evidence; Learning disabilities; Victim; Witness

Indexed keywords

EID: 0141468473     PISSN: 13544187     EISSN: 14683156     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1046/j.1354-4187.2001.00138.x     Document Type: Article

References (41)

1. Brown C.L. & Geiselman R.E. (1990) Eyewitness testimony of mentally retarded: effect of the cognitive interview. J Police Criminal Psychol, 6: 14-21.
2. Brown H., Stein J. & Turk V. (1995) The sexual abuse of adults with learning disabilities. Mental Handicap Res, 8: 3-24.
3. Bull R. (1995) Interviewing witnesses with communicative disability. In: Bull R., Carson D., editors. Handbook of psychology in legal contexts. Chichester, Wiley.
4. Bull R. & Cullen C. (1992) Witnesses who have mental handicaps. Edinburgh, Crown Office.
5. Carson D. (1995) Regulating the examination of children. Expert Evidence, 4: 2-9.
6. Clare I.C.H. & Gudjonsson G.H. (1993) Interrogative suggestibility, confabulation, and acquiescence in people with mild learning disabilities (mental handicap): implications for reliability during police interrogations. Br J Clin Psychol, 32: 295-301.
7. Clifford B.R. & George R. (1996) A field evaluation of training in three methods of witness/victim investigative interviewing. Psychology, Crime Law, 2: 231-48.
8. Davies G. & Noon E. (1991) An evaluation of the live-link for child witnesses. London, Home Office.
9. Dent H. (1986) An experimental study of the effectiveness of different techniques of interviewing mentally handicapped child witnesses. Br J Clin Psychol, 25: 13-7.
10. Detterman D.K. (1979) Memory in the mentally retarded. In: Ellis N.R., editor. Handbook of mental deficiency: psychological theory and research. Hillsdale, NJ, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: 727-60.
11. Fisher R.P., Geiselman R.E. & Raymond D.S. (1987) Critical analysis of police interviewing techniques. J Police Sci Administration, 15: 177-85.
12. Flin R., Bull R., Boon J. & Knox A. (1993) Child witnesses in Scottish criminal trials. Int Rev Victimol, 2: 309-29.
13. Gorden B.N., Jens K.G., Hollings R. & Watson T.E. (1994) Remembering activities performed versus those imagined: implication for testimony of children with mental retardation. J Clin Child Psychol, 23: 239-48.
14. Gudjonsson G.H. (1992) The psychology of interrogations, confessions and testimony. Chichester, Wiley.
15. Gudjonsson G.H. & Clark N.K. (1986) Suggestibility in police interrogation: a social-psychological model. Social Behav, 1: 83-104.
16. Gudjonsson G.H. & Gunn J. (1982) The competence and reliability of a witness in a criminal court. Br J Psychiatry, 141: 624-7.
17. Gudjonsson G.H., Murphy G.H. & Clare I.C.H. (2000) Assessing the capacity of people with intellectual disabilities to be witnesses in court. Psychol Med, 30 (307): 314.
18. Home Office (1999) Youth justice and criminal evidence act. London, HMSO.
19. Kebbell M.R. & Giles D.C. (2000) Some experimental influences of lawyers' complicated questions on eyewitness confidence and accuracy. J Psychol, 134: 129-39.
20. Kebbell M.R. & Hatton C. (1999) People with mental retardation as witnesses in court. Mental Retardation, 3: 179-87.
21. Kebbell M.R., Hatton C. & Johnson S.D. (2000) Witnesses with learning disabilities in court: full report of research activities and results. End of Grant Report to the Economic and Social Research Council. Unpublished manuscript, University of Birmingham, Birmingham.
22. Kebbell M.R. & Johnson S.D. (2000) The influence of lawyers' questions on witness confidence and accuracy. Law Human Behav, 24: 629-41.
23. Kebbell M.R. & Wagstaff G.F. (1999) Face value? Factors that influence eyewitness accuracy. London, Police Research Group, Home Office.
24. Matikka L.M. & Vesala H.T. (1997) Acquiescence in quality-of-life interviews with adults who have mental retardation. Mental Retardation, 35: 75-82.
25. Memon A. & Vartoukian R. (1996) The effects of repeated questioning on young children's eyewitness testimony. Br J Psychol, 87: 403-15.
26. Mencap (2001) Bullying - Living in Fear. Campaign report. London, Mencap.
27. Milne R. & Bull R. (1999) Investigative interviewing: psychology and practice. Chicester, Wiley.
28. Milne R., Clare I.C.H. & Bull R. (1999) Interviewing adults with learning disability with the cognitive interview. Psychology, Crime Law, 5: 81-100.
29. Murphy P., editor (1997) Blackstone's criminal practice, 7th edn. London, Blackstone.
30. Perlman N.B., Ericson K.I., Esses V.M. & Isaacs B.J. (1994) The developmentally handicapped witness: competency as a function of question format. Law Human Behav, 18: 171-87.
31. Regina v. Brown (1998) Criminal appeal reports, 2: 364.
32. Sanders A., Creaton J., Bird S. & Weber L. (1997) Victims with learning disabilities: negotiating the criminal justice system. Oxford, Centre for Criminological Research, University of Oxford.
33. Schooler J.W. & Loftus E.F. (1986) Individual differences and experimentation: complementary approaches to interrogative suggestibility. Social Behav, 1: 105-12.
34. Senn C. (1988) Vulnerable: sexual abuse and people with an intellectual handicap. Toronto, The G. Allan Roeher Institute.
35. Sigelman C., Budd E.C., Spaniel C. & Schoenrock C. (1981) When in doubt say yes: acquiescence in interviews with mentally retarded persons. Mental Retardation, 19: 53-8.
36. Sigelman C., Budd E.C., Winer J., Schoenrock C. & Martin P. (1982) Evaluating alternative techniques of questioning mentally retarded persons. Am J Mental Deficiency, 86: 511-8.
37. Sobsey D. & Varnhagen C. (1991) Sexual abuse, assault and exploitation of Canadians with disabilities. In: Bagley C., Thomlinson R.J., editors. Child sexual abuse: critical perspectives on prevention, intervention and treatment. Toronto, Wall & Emerson: 203-16
38. Valenti-Hein D.C. & Schwarz M.A. (1993) Witness competency in people with mental retardation: implications for prosecution of sexual abuse. Sexuality Disability, 11: 287-94.
39. Westcott H.L. (1995) Children's experiences of being examined and cross-examined: The opportunity to be heard? Expert Evidence, 4: 13-9.
40. Williams C. (1995) Invisible victims: crime and abuse against people with learning difficulties. London, Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
41. Wilson C. & Brewer N. (1992) The incidence of criminal victimisation of individuals with an intellectual disability. Aust Psychologist, 27: 114-7.