Shifting frames for local people and forests in a global heritage: The Thung Yai Naresuan Wildlife Sanctuary in the context of Thailand's globalization and modernization

Geoforum

Volumn 34, Issue 3, 2003, Pages 375-393

  Buergin, Reiner ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF FREIBURG   (Germany)

Author keywords

Conservationism; Ethnicism; Forest policies; Globalization; Karen; Local resistance; Modernization; Protected areas; Thailand

Indexed keywords

ETHNIC MINORITY; FOREST MANAGEMENT; GLOBALIZATION; MODERNIZATION; NATURE CONSERVATION; PROTECTED AREA;

THAILAND; THUNG YAI NARESUAN WILDLIFE SANCTUARY;

EID: 0042303755     PISSN: 00167185     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0016-7185(02)00083-0     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Amara P. Forest policies and the convention on biological diversity in Thailand Glück P. Oesten G. Schanz H. Volz K.-R. Formulation and Implementation of National Forest Programmes vol. III 1999 European Forest Institute Joensuu, Finland
2. Ambrosino, M., 1993. Comparison of the vegetative and soil characteristics of primary forest, secondary forest and forest fallow in Karen shifting agriculture. Unpublished report, Wildlife Fund Thailand, Bangkok
3. Anan G. The politics of conservation and the complexity of local control of forests in the Northern Thai highlands Mountain Research and Development 18 1 1998 71-82
4. Bhadharajaya R. Thai Forestry in Perspective 1996 Royal Forest Department Bangkok
5. Braun B. Castree N. Remaking Reality. Nature at the Millennium 1998 Routledge London
6. Brenner, V., Buergin, R., Kessler, C., Pye, O., Schwarzmeier, R., Sprung, R.-D., 1999. Thailand's community forest bill: U- turn or roundabout in forest policy? SEFUT Working Paper 3, Graduate College Socio-Economics of Forest Use in the Tropics and Subtropics, Freiburg
7. Bryant R.L. Fighting over forests: political reform, peasant resistance and the transformation of forest management in late colonial Burma Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 32 2 1994 244-260
8. Bryant R.L. The Political Ecology of Forestry in Burma1824-1994 1997 Hurst London
9. Buergin, R., 2000. 'Hill tribes' and forests: minority policies and resource conflicts in Thailand. SEFUT Working Paper 7, Working Group Socio-Economics of Forest Use, Freiburg
10. Buergin, R., 2002a. Local change and cultural identity of Pwo Karen communities in Thung Yai Naresuan Wildlife Sanctuary, Western Thailand. SEFUT Working Paper 11, Working Group Socio-Economics of Forest Use, Freiburg
11. Buergin, R., 2002b. Lokaler Wandel und kulturelle Identität im Spannungsfeld nationaler Modernisierung und globaler Umweltdiskurse. Die Karen im Thung Yai Naresuan Wildlife Sanctuary, einem 'Weltnaturerbe' im Westen Thailands. Ph.D. Diss. forthcoming, Universität Freiburg, Institut für Ethnologie
12. Buergin, R., Kessler, C., 1999. Das Janusgesicht der Zivilgesellschaft: Demokratisierung und Widerstand im thailändischen Umweltdiskurs. SEFUT Working Paper 6, Working Group Socio-Economics of Forest Use, Freiburg
13. Buergin R. Kessler C. Intrusions and exclusions: democratization in Thailand in the context of environmental discourses and resource conflicts GeoJournal 52 1 2000 71-80
14. Carrere R. Lohmann L. Pulping the South. Industrial Tree Plantations and The World Paper Economy 1996 Zed Books London
15. Chan-ek T. Kulvadee B. Ambrosino M. The traditional farming system of the Karen of Sanehpong village, Thung-Yai Naresuan Wildlife Sanctuary, Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand Wood H. McDaniel M. Warner K. Community Development and Conservation of Forest Biodiversity Through Community Forestry 1995 RECOFTC Bangkok
16. Chantaboon S. Highland agriculture: from better to worse McKinnon J. Vienne B. Hill Tribes Today 1989 107-142 Golden Lotus Bangkok
17. Chupinit K. Hill tribe relocation policy in Thailand Cultural Survival Quarterly 12 4 1988 2-6
18. Cronon W. Uncommon Ground. Rethinking the Human Place in Nature 1996 Norton - Company New York
19. De'Ath C. A history of timber exports from Thailand with emphasis on the 1870-1937 period Natural History Bulletin of the Siam Society 40 1992 49-66
20. Deuleu C. Naess M. Deuleu: a life history of an Akha woman McCaskill D. Kampe K. Development or Domestication? Indigenous Peoples of Southeast Asia 1997 183-204 Silkworm Books Chiang Mai
21. Enters T. The economics of land degradation and resource conservation in northern Thailand: challenging the assumptions Rigg J. Counting the Costs Economic Growth and Environmental Change in Thailand 1995 90-110 ISEAS Singapore
22. Eudey A.A. Hill tribe peoples and primate conservation in Thailand. A preliminary assessment of the problem of reconciling shifting cultivation with conservation objectives Else J.G. Lee P.C. Primate Ecology and Conservation 1986 237-248 University Press Cambridge
23. Eudey A.A. 14 April 1986: Eviction orders to the Hmong of Huai Yew Yee village, Huai Kha Khaeng Wildlife Sanctuary, Thailand McKinnon J. Vienne B. Hill Tribes Today 1989 249-259 Golden Lotus Bangkok
24. Ewers, K., 1994. Politics of biodiversity conservation in Thailand: global and local discourse. In: Proceedings of the IIAS and NIAS Workshop on 'Environmental Movement in Asia', Leiden, October 27-29, 1994
25. FAO Staff, 1957. Shifting cultivation: an appeal by FAO to governments, research centers, associations and private persons who are in a position to help. Unasylva 11 (1), 9-11
26. Feeny D. The Political Economy of Productivity. Thai Agricultural Development, 1880-1975 1982 University of British Columbia Press Vancouver
27. Feeny D. Agricultural expansion and forest depletion in Thailand 1900-1975 Richards J.F. Tucker R.P. World Deforestation in the Twentieth Century 1988 112-143 Duke University Press Durham
28. Forsyth T.J. Science, myth and knowledge: testing Himalayan environmental degradation in Thailand Geoforum 27 3 1996 375-392
29. Forsyth T.J. Questioning the impacts of shifting cultivation Watershed 5 1 1999 23-29
30. Goldman M. Privatizing Nature. Political Struggles for the Global Commons 1998 Pluto Press London
31. Hirsch P.H. Deforestation and development in Thailand Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 8 2 1987 129-138
32. Hirsch P.H. Dammed or damned? Hydropower versus people's power Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars 20 1 1988 2-10
33. Hirsch P.H. Forests, forest reserve, and forest land in Thailand The Geographical Journal 156 2 1990 166-174
34. Howitt R. Connell J. Hirsch P. Resources, Nations and Indigenous Peoples: Case Studies from Australasia, Melanesia and Southeast Asia 1996 Oxford University Press Melbourne
35. Jørgensen A.B. A natural view: Pwo Karen notions of plants, landscapes, people Folk 31 1989 21-51
36. Jørgensen, A.B., 1996. Elephants or people: the debate on the Huai Kha Khaeng and Thung Yai Naresuan World Heritage Site, Paper prepared for the 48th Annual Meeting of the Association for Asian Studies, Honolulu, Hawaii, April 11-14
37. Jørgensen, A.B., Ewers Andersen, K., 1982. Final report on Pwo Karen research in Changwat Uthai Thani, Amphur Ban Rai. National Research Council, Bangkok, January-February 1980
38. Kamon P. Thomas D.E. Evolving management systems in Thailand Poffenberger M. Keepers of the Forest 1990 167-186 Kumarian Press West Hartford, Connecticut
39. Krisadawan, H., 1999. Competing discourses on hill tribes: media representation of ethnic minorities in Thailand. Paper prepared for the 7th International Conference on Thai Studies, Amsterdam, 4-8 July 1999. IIAS; University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam
40. Kulvadee, B., 1997. Institutional arrangements in communal resource mangement: a case study of a Karen village in a protected area. MA thesis, Mahidol University, Faculty of Graduate Studies, Bangkok
41. Kunstadter P. Kunstadter S.L. Population movements and environmental changes in the hills of northern Thailand Wijeyewardene G. Chapman E.C. Patterns and Illusions: Thai History and Thought 1992 17-56 Australian National University Canberra
42. Kunstadter P. Chapman E.C. Sanga S. Farmers in the Forest. Economic Development and Marginal Agriculture in Northern Thailand 1978 University Press of Hawaii Honolulu
43. Lang C. Pye O. Blinded by science: the invention of scientific forestry and its influence in the Mekong Region Watershed 6 2 2001 25-34
44. Lipschutz R.D. Conca K. The State and Social Power in Global Environmental Politics 1993 Columbia University Press New York
45. Lohmann L. Land, power and forest colonization in Thailand Global Ecology and Biogeography Letters 3 4-6 1993 180-191
46. Lohmann L. Against the myths Colchester M. Lohmann L. The Struggle for Land and the Fate of the Forests 1995 16-34 Zed Books London
47. Malee T. World Bank repeating the same mistakes in GEF? Thai Development Newsletter 24 1994 15-17
48. Maxwell J.F. Vegetation and vascular flora of the Ban Saneh Pawng area, Lai Wo Subdistrict, Sangklaburi District, Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand Natural History Bulletin of the Siam Society 43 1995 131-170
49. McCaskill D. Kampe K. Development of Domestication? Indigenous Peoples of Southeast Asia 1997 Silkworm Book Chiang Mai
50. McKinnon J.M. Structural assimilation and the consensus: clearing grounds on which to rearrange our thoughts McKinnon J. Vienne B. Hill Tribes Today 1989 303-359 Golden Lotus Bangkok
51. McKinnon J.M. The forests of Thailand: strike up the ban? McCaskill D. Kampe K. Development or Domestication? Indigenous Peoples of Southeast Asia 1997 117-131 Silkworm Books Chiang Mai
52. McKinnon J.M. Vienne B. Hill Tribes Today 1989 Golden Lotus Bangkok
53. McKinnon J.M. Wanat B. Highlanders of Thailand 1983 Oxford University Press Kuala Lumpur
54. McNeely J.A. Miller K.R. National Parks, Conservation, and Development: The Role of Protected Areas in Sustaining Society (Proceedings of the World Congress on National Parks, Bali, Indonesia, October 11-22, 1982) 1984 Smithsonian Institution Press Washington, DC
55. Merchant C. The Death of Nature: Women, Ecology and the Scientific Revolution 1983 Harper - Row San Francisco
56. MIDAS, 1993. Conservation forest area protection, management, and development project. Pre-investment study. Final report. Bangkok, October 1993
57. Nash R. Wilderness and the American Mind 1982 Yale University Press New Haven
58. Orawan K. Commercial reforestation policy PER The Future of People and Forests in Thailand after the Logging Ban 1992 56-78 Paap Pim Printing Bangkok
59. Pasuk P. Baker C. Thailand. Economy and Politics 1997 Oxford University Press Oxford
60. Pearmsak M. The evolution of the policy making process: will there ever be a community forestry bill? Asia-Pacific Community Forestry Newsletter 13 2 2000 58-62
61. Peluso N.L. Rich Forests, Poor People. Resource Control and Resistance in Java 1992 University of California Press Berkeley
62. PER (Project for Ecological Recovery) The Future of People and Forests in Thailand after the Logging Ban 1992 Paap Pim Printing Bangkok
63. PER (Project for Ecological Recovery), 1995. Protecting Thailand's biological diversity. A discussion paper on Thailand's Conservation Area Protection, Management, and Development Project. PER, Bangkok
64. Perapong, M., 1992. The changing role of the Thai military from orthodox function to national development. Ph.D. Dissertation, Fakultät für Soziologie, Bielefeld
65. Phairot, S., 1996. Past-present-future of Thai forestry. (unpubl. ms.) Bangkok
66. Pinkaew, L., 1992. Ecological knowledge of an agricultural community in the forest: a case study of Karen in Thung Yai Naresuan Wildlife Sanctuary. MA thesis in Thai, Thammasat University, Bangkok
67. Pinkaew L. Rai, rai lu'an loy, rai mun wian and the politics of 'shifting cultivation' Watershed 5 1 1999 39-46
68. Pinkaew L. The ambiguity of 'watershed': the politics of people and conservation in northern Thailand Sojourn 15 1 2000 52-75
69. RECOFTC, 2002. RECOFTC E-letter 2002.6 (March 15, 2002). Regional Community Forestry Training Center for Asia and the Pacific (RECOFTC), Bangkok
70. Renard R.D. The role of the Karens in Thai society during the Early Bangkok Period, 1782-1873 Contributions to Asian Studies 15 1980 16-28
71. Renard R.D. The delineation of the Kayah states frontiers with Thailand: 1809-1894 Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 18 1 1987 81-92
72. Renard R.D. The differential integration of hill people into the Thai state Turton A. Civility and Savagery 2000 63-83 Curzon Press Richmond
73. RFD (Royal Forest Department) Forestry Statistics of Thailand for 1984 1985 RFD Bangkok
74. RFD (Royal Forest Department) Thai Forestry Sector Master Plan Subsectoral Plan for People and Forest Environment vol. 5 1993 RFD Bangkok
75. RFD (Royal Forest Department) Forestry Statistics of Thailand 1995 1995 RFD Bangkok
76. RFD (Royal Forest Department) Forestry Statistics of Thailand 1999 1999 RFD Bangkok (Internet)
77. RFD (Royal Forest Department) Thailand National Forestry Policy 2001 RFD Bangkok http://www.forest.go.th/rfd/policy/policy_e.thm
78. Rigg J. Thailand's Nam Choan Dam project: a case study of the 'greening' of South-East Asia Global Ecology and Biogeography Letters 1 1 1991 42-54
79. Sathi C. Thailand Forestry Policies of Selected Countries in Asia and the Pacific FAO FAO Forestry Paper vol. 115 1993 151-161 FAO Rome
80. Sayamol K. Brodt S. Networks--giving the people a voice in forest conservation planning Forests, Trees and People Newsletter 42 2000 69-75
81. Schmidt-Vogt D. Swidden farming and fallow vegetation in Northern Thailand 1997 Franz Steiner Verlag Stuttgart
82. Schmidt-Vogt D. Indigenous knowledge and the use of fallow forests in Northern Thailand Lawrence A. Forestry, Forest Users and Research: New Ways of Learning 2000 167-176 ETFRN Wageningen
83. Seub N. Stewart-Cox B. Nomination of the Thung Yai-Huai Kha Khaeng Wildlife Sanctuary to be a UNESCO World Heritage Site 1990 Royal Forest Department Bangkok
84. Sompop M. Economic Development of Thailand 1850-1950. Response to the Challenge of the World Economy 1989 Institute of Asian Studies, Chulalongkorn University Bangkok
85. Steinlin, H., Pretzsch, J., 1984. Der tropische Feuchtwald in der internationalen Forstpolitik. Holz-Zentralblatt 138
86. Steinmetz R. Landscape Ecology and Wildlife Habitats: An Indigenous Karen Perspective in Thung Yai Wildlife Sanctuary of Western Thailand 1996 Wildlife Fund Thailand Bangkok
87. Steinmetz R. Mather R. Impact of Karen villages on the fauna of Thung Yai Naresuan Wildlife Sanctuary. A participatory research project Natural History Bulletin of the Siam Society 44 1996 23-40
88. Stevens S. Conservation through Cultural Survival. Indigenous Peoples and Protected Areas 1997 Island Press Washington, DC
89. Stewart-Cox, B., 1998. Forests too precious for Seub legacy to be lost. Nation, September 28
90. Stott P.A. Mu'ang and Pa: Elite views of nature in a changing Thailand Chitakasem M. Turton A. Thai Construction of Knowledge 1991 142-154 School of Oriental and African Studies London
91. TDN (Thai Development Newsletter), 1994. The coexistence of people and their forests. Thai Development Newsletter, 26
92. Thailand National Assembly Constitution of the Kingdom of Thailand 1997 Government of Thailand Bangkok
93. Thongchai W. Siam mapped. A history of the geo-body of a nation 1994 University of Hawaii Press Honolulu
94. Thongchai W. The others within: travel and ethno-spatial differenentiation of Siamese subjects 1885-1910 Turton A. Civility and Savagery 2000 38-62 Curzon Press Richmond
95. Thongchai W. The quest for 'Siwilai': a geographical discourse of civilizational thinking in the late nineteenth and early twentieth-century Siam Journal of Asian Studies 59 3 2000 528-549
96. Turton A. Civility and Savagery. Social Identity in Tai States 2000 Curzon Press Richmond
97. Uhlig H. Problems of land use and recent settlement in Thailand's highland-lowland transition zone Ives J.D. Sabhasri S. Voraurai P. Conservation and Development in Northern Thailand 1980 33-42 The United Nations University Tokyo
98. Vandergeest P. Mapping nature: territorialization of forest rights in Thailand Society and Natural Resources 9 2 1996 159-175
99. Vandergeest P. Property rights in protected areas: obstacles to community involvement as a solution in Thailand Environmental Conservation 23 3 1996 259-268
100. Waranoot T. Highland-lowland conflict over natural resources: a case of Mae Soi, Chiang Mai, Thailand Society and Natural Resources 8 1995 279-288
101. Warren D.M. Slikkerveer L.J. Brokensha D. The Cultural Dimension of Development. Indigenous Knowledge Systems 1995 Intermediate Technology Publications London
102. Watershed Ethnicity and resources Watershed 3 1 1997
103. Watershed Conflict or resolution? People and forests in northern Thailand Watershed 4 1 1998 10-28
104. Watershed Army troops demolish Karen homes in Thung Yai forest Watershed 5 1 1999 6
105. Watershed This is like dying while still alive Watershed 6 2 2001 43-47
106. Wells M. Brandon K. People and Parks: Linking Protected Area Management with Local Communities 1992 The World Bank Washington, DC
107. Western D. Pearl M.C. Conservation for the Twenty-First Century 1989 Oxford University Press New York
108. Western D. Wright R.M. Natural Connections: Perspectives in Community-Based Conservation 1994 Island Press Washington, DC
109. WFT (Wildlife Fund Thailand), 1993. Population Statistics for Laiwo Sub-district, Sangklabury District, Kanjanaburi Province, Thailand (as of April 1993). WFT, Bangkok
110. WFT (Wildlife Fund Thailand), 1996. The study of natural resource use of Karen in Thungyai Naresuan Wildlife Sanctuary (Draft). WFT, Bangkok
111. Williams N.M. Baines G. Traditional Ecological Knowledge. Wisdom for Sustainable Development 1993 Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies Canberra
112. World Bank Thailand. Assessment of Buffer Community Development and Protection of Conservation Forests Huay Kha Khaeng and Thung Yai Naresuan WS 1995 RAMBOLL Copenhagen
113. World Bank Revised Workplan. Bank Forest Sector Strategy and Policy Review 1998 The World Bank Washington
114. Yos S. Community-based natural resource management in Thailand Asian Review 6 1992 78-124