The oil drop experiment: A rational reconstruction of the Millikan-Ehrenhaft controversy and its implications for chemistry textbooks

Journal of Research in Science Teaching

Volumn 37, Issue 5, 2000, Pages 480-508

  Niaz, Mansoor ^a  

^a UNIVERSIDAD DE ORIENTE   (Venezuela)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 0040884819     PISSN: 00224308     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(200005)37:5<480::AID-TEA6>3.0.CO;2-X     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Achinstein, P. (1991). Particles and waves: Historical essays in the philosophy of science. New York: Oxford University Press.
2. Ander, P., & Sonnessa, A.J. (1968). Principles of chemistry. New York: Macmillan.
3. Anderson, C.B., Ford, P.C., & Kennedy, J.H. (1973). Chemistry: Principles and applications. Lexington, MA: Heath.
4. Anderson, D.L. (1966). Resource letter ECAN-1 on the electronic charge and Avogadro's number. American Journal of Physics, 34, 2-8.
5. Arons, A.B. (1990). A guide to introductory physics teaching. New York: Wiley.
6. Bär, R. (1922). Naturwissenschaften, 10, 344-345.
7. Barrow, G. (1974). General chemistry (Spanish ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
8. Becker, R.S., & Wentworth, W.E. (1977). General chemistry (Spanish ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
9. Blanco, R., & Niaz, M. (1997). Epistemological beliefs of students and teachers about the nature of science: From "Baconian inductive ascent" to the "irrelevance" of scientific laws. Instructional Science, 25, 203-231.
10. Blanco, R., & Niaz, M. (1998). Baroque tower on a gothic base: A Lakatosian reconstruction of students' and teachers' understanding of structure of the atom. Science and Education, 7, 327-360.
11. Bodner, G.M., & Pardue, H.L. (1989). Chemistry: An experimental science. New York: Wiley.
12. Brady, J.E., & Humiston, G.E. (1996). General chemistry: Principles and structure (Spanish ed). New York: Wiley.
13. Brescia, F., Arents, J., Meislich, H., & Turk, A. (1975). Fundamentals of chemistry: A modern introduction (2nd ed., Spanish). New York: Academic Press.
14. Brown, T.L., LeMay, H.E., & Bursten, B.E. (1997). Chemistry: The central science (7th ed). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
15. Burbules, N., & Linn, M.C. (1991). Science education and philosophy of science: Congruence or contradiction? International Journal of Science Education, 13, 227-241.
16. Burns, R.A. (1996). Fundamentals of chemistry (2nd ed., Spanish). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
17. Chang, R. (1999). Chemistry (6th ed., Spanish). New York: McGraw-Hill.
18. Daub, G.W., & Seese, W.S. (1996). Basic chemistry (7th ed., Spanish). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
19. Dickerson, R.E., Gray, H.B., Darensbourg, M.Y., & Darensbourg. D.J. (1984). Chemical principles (4th ed.). Menlo Park, CA: Benjamin/Cummings.
20. Dirac, P.A.M. (1977). Ehrenhaft, the subelectron and the quark. In C. Weiner (Ed.), History of Twentieth Century physics (pp. 290-293). New York: Academic Press.
21. Ebbing, D.D. (1997). General chemistry (5th ed., Spanish). New York: McGraw-Hill.
22. Ehrenhaft, F. (1902). Kolloidale metalle. Anzeiger Akad. Wiss. (Vienna), 18, 241-243.
23. Ehrenhaft, F. (1909a). Eine methode zur messung der elektrischen ladung kleiner teilchen zur bestimmung des elektrischen elementarquantums. Anzeiger Akad. Wiss. (Vienna), 27, 72.
24. Ehrenhaft, F. (1909b). Eine methode zur bestimmung des elektrischen elementarquantums. I. Physikalische Zeitschrift, 10, 308-310.
25. Ehrenhaft, F. (1910a). Uber die kleinsten messbaren elektrizitätsmengen. Zweite vorläufige mitteilung der methode zur bestimmung des elektrischen elementarquantums. Anzeiger Akad. Wiss. (Vienna), 10, 118-119.
26. Ehrenhaft, F. (1910b). Uber die messung von elektrizitätsmengen, die ladung des einwertigen wasserstoffions oder elektrons zu unterschreiten scheinen. Zweite vorläufige mitteilung seiner methode zur bestimmung des elektrischen elementarquantums. Anzeiger Akad. Wiss. (Vienna), 13, 215.
27. Ehrenhaft, F. (1914). Annalen der Physik, 44, 657.
28. Ehrenhaft, F. (1941). The microcoulomb experiment. Philosophy of Science, 8, 403-457.
29. Giere, R.N. (1988). Explaining science: A cognitive approach. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
30. Gillespie, R.J. (1997). Reforming the general chemistry textbook. Journal of Chemical Education, 74, 484.
31. Gullstrand, A. (1965). Nobel prize presentation speech. Nobel lectures: Physics. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
32. Heald, M.A. (1974). Millikan oil-drop experiment in the introductory laboratory. American Journal of Physics, 42, 244-246.
33. Hein, M., & Arena, S. (1997). Foundations of college chemistry (Spanish ed). Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.
34. Holton, G. (1978). Subelectrons, presuppositions, and the Millikan-Ehrenhaft dispute. Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences, 9, 161-224.
35. Holton, G. (1986). The advancement of science and its burdens. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
36. Holton, G. (1995). Einstein, history and other passions. Woodbury, NY: American Institute of Physics.
37. Holton, G. (1999). Personal communication, April 29, 1999.
38. Holtzclaw, H.F., &Robinson, W.R. (1988). General chemistry (8th ed.). Lexington, MA: Heath.
39. Joesten, M.D., Johnston, D.O., Netterville, J.T., & Wood, J.L. (1991). World of chemistry. Philadelphia: Saunders.
40. Kapusta, J.I. (1975). Best measuring time for a Millikan oil drop experiment. American Journal of Physics, 43, 799-800.
41. Kruglak, H. (1972). Another look at the Pasco-Millikan oil-drop apparatus. American Journal of Physics, 40, 768-769.
42. Kühn, T.S. (1970). The structure of scientific revolutions (2nd ed). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
43. Lakatos, I. (1970). Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. In I. Lakatos & A. Musgrave (Eds.), Criticism and the growth of knowledge (pp. 91-195). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
44. Laudan, L. (1996). Beyond positivism and relativism. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
45. Laudan, R., Laudan, L., & Donovan, A. (1988). Testing theories of scientific change. In A. Donovan, L. Laudan, & R. Laudan (Eds.), Scrutinizing science: Empirical studies of scientific change (pp. 3-44). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer.
46. Lippincott, W.T., Garrett, A.B., & Verhoek, F.H. (1977). Chemistry: A study of matter (3rd ed.). New York: Wiley.
47. Lorentz, H.A. (1952). The theory of electrons. New York: Dover. (Original work published 1909)
48. Mahan, B.M., & Myers, R.J. (1990). University chemistry (4th ed., Spanish). Wilmington, DE: Addison-Wesley.
49. Masterton, W.L., Slowinski, E.J., & Stanitski, C.L. (1985). Chemical principles (5th ed., Spanish). Philadelphia: Saunders.
50. Matthews, M.R. (1994). Science teaching: The role of history and philosophy of science. New York: Routledge.
51. McComas, W.F., Almazroa, H., & Clough, M.P. (1998). The nature of science in science education: An introduction. Science and Education, 7, 511-532.
52. McMullin, E. (1995). Underdetermination. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 20, 233-252.
53. Mendenhall, C.E. (1929). Book review. Physical Review, 33, 106.
54. Millikan, R.A. (1910). A new modification of the cloud method of determining the elementary electrical charge and the most probable value of that charge. Philosophical Magazine, 19, 209-228.
55. Millikan, R.A. (1911). Physical Review, 32, 349.
56. Millikan, R.A. (1913). On the elementary electrical charge and the Avogadro constant. Physical Review, 2, 109-143.
57. Millikan, R.A. (1916). The existence of a subelectron? Physical Review, 8, 595-625.
58. Millikan, R.A. (1917). The electron: Its isolation and measurement and the determination of some of its properties. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
59. Millikan, R.A. (1947). Electrons (+ and -), protons, photons, neutrons, mesotrons, and cosmic rays (2nd ed.). Chicago: University of Chicago Press. (Original work published 1935)
60. Millikan, R.A. (1950). The autobiography of Robert A. Millikan. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
61. Millikan, R.A. (1965). The electron and the light-quant from the experimental point of view (Nobel prize acceptance speech, 1923). Nobel lectures: Physics. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
62. Millikan, R. A., & Begeman, L. (1908). On the charge carried by the negative ion of an ionized gas. Physical Review, 26, 197-198.
63. Millikan, R.A., & Fletcher, H. (1911). Ursachen der scheinbaren unstimmigkeiten zwischen neueren arbeiten über e. Physikalische Zeitschrift, 12, 161-163.
64. Millikan, R.A., Gale, H.G., & Edwards, C.W. (1928). A first course in physics for colleges. Boston: Ginn. (Original work published 1906)
65. Monk, M., & Osborne, J. (1997). Placing the history and philosophy of science on the curriculum: A model for the development of pedagogy. Science Education, 81, 405-424.
66. Mortimer, C.E. (1983). Chemistry (5th ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
67. Nagel, E. (1961). The structure of science. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
68. Newell, S.B. (1977). Chemistry: An introduction. Boston: Little, Brown.
69. Niaz, M. (1994). Enhancing thinking skills: Domain specific/domain general strategies - a dilemma for science education. Instructional Science, 22, 413-422.
70. Niaz, M. (1998). From cathode rays to alpha particles to quantum of action: A rational reconstruction of structure of the atom and its implications for chemistry textbooks. Science Education, 82, 527-552.
71. Niaz, M. (1999). Should we put observations first? Journal of Chemical Education, 76, 734.
72. Niaz, M. (2000). A rational reconstruction of the kinetic molecular theory of gases based on history and philosophy of science and its implications for chemistry textbooks. Instructional Science, 28, 23-50.
73. Olson, D.E. (1965). Apparatus review: A new Millikan oil-drop apparatus. American Journal of Physics, 33, 858-859.
74. Oxtoby, D.W., Nachtrieb, N.H., & Freeman, W.A. (1994). Chemistry: Science of change. Philadelphia: Saunders.
75. Pauling, L. (1977). General chemistry (10 ed., Spanish). San Francisco: Freeman. (Original work published 1947)
76. Popper, K.R. (1962). Conjectures and refutations: The growth of scientific knowledge. New York: Basic Books.
77. Quagliano, J.V., & Vallarino, L.M. (1969). Chemistry (3rd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
78. Rutherford, E., & Geiger, H. (1908). The charge and the nature of the alpha particle. Proceedings of the Royal Society (London), 81, 168-171.
79. Schwab, J.J. (1962). The teaching of science as enquiry. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
80. Schwab, J.J. (1974). The concept of the structure of a discipline. In E.W. Eisner & E. Vallance (Eds.), Conflicting conceptions of curriculum. Berkeley, CA: McCutchan. (Original work published 1962)
81. Segal, B.C. (1989). Chemistry: Experiment and theory (2nd ed.). New York: Wiley.
82. Sienko, M.J., & Plane. R.A. (1971). Chemistry (4th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
83. Silverman, M.P. (1992). Raising questions: Philosophical significance of controversy in science. Science and Education, 1, 163-179.
84. Sisler, H.H., Dresdner, R.D., &Mooney, W.T. (1980). Chemistry: A systematic approach. New York: Oxford University Press.
85. Stoker, H.S. (1990). Introduction to chemical principles (3rd ed.). New York: Macmillan.
86. Thomson, J.J. (1897). Cathode rays. Philosophical Magazine, 44, 293-316.
87. Thomson, J.J. (1898). Philosophical Magazine, 46, 528.
88. Townsend, J.S. (1897). Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society. 9, 244.
89. Van Frassen, B.C. (1980). The scientific image. Oxford: Clarendon.
90. Weiss, I.R. (1993). Science teachers rely on the textbook. In R.E. Yager (Ed.), What research says to the science teacher. Vol. 7: The science, technology, society movement. Washington, DC: National Science Teachers Association.
91. Whitten, K.W., Davis, R.E., & Peck, M.L. (1998). General chemistry (3rd ed., Spanish). New York: McGraw-Hill.
92. Wilson, H.A. (1903). Philosophical Magazine, 5, 429.
93. Wolfe, D.H. (1988). Introduction to college chemistry. New York: McGraw-Hill.
94. Zumdahl, S.S. (1990). Introductory chemistry. Lexington, MA: Heath.