Does the right hemisphere take over after damage to Broca's area? The Barlow case of 1877 and its history

Brain and Language

Volumn 85, Issue 3, 2003, Pages 385-395

  Finger, Stanley ^a   Buckner, Randy L ^a,b   Buckingham, Hugh ^c  

^a WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^c LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Aphasia; Barlow; Broca; Broca's area; Plasticity; Recovery of function; Speech; Vicariation

Indexed keywords

ANAMNESIS; ARTICLE; BRAIN DISEASE; BRAIN INJURY; BRAIN REGION; BRAIN SCINTISCANNING; CASE REPORT; CHILD; CONVALESCENCE; DIAGONAL BAND OF BROCA; EMBOLISM; EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE; HEART; HUMAN; MALE; MEDICAL RESEARCH; MOTOR DYSFUNCTION; PHYSICIAN; POSITRON EMISSION TOMOGRAPHY; PREMOTOR CORTEX; RIGHT HEMISPHERE; SPEECH DEVELOPMENT; SPEECH DISORDER; SPEECH REHABILITATION; SUPPORT GROUP; THEORY; UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 0037690818     PISSN: 0093934X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0093-934X(03)00060-9     Document Type: Article

References (61)

1. Almli C.R., Finger S. Toward a definition of recovery of function. Finger S., LeVere T.E., Almli C.R., Stein D.G. Brain injury and recovery: Theoretical and controversial issues. 1988;1-14 Plenum Press, New York.
2. Aspin R.K. The papers of Sir Thomas Barlow, BT, KCVO, FRS, PRCP (1845-1945). Medical History. 37:1993;140-333.
3. Barkow H.C.L. Bemerkungen zur Pathologischen Osteologie. 1964;Ferdinand Hirt's Königliche Universitäts-Buchhandlung, Breslau.
4. Barlow A. Sir Thomas Barlow, 1845-1945. Great Ormond Street Hospital Journal. 10:1955-1956;59-65.
5. Barlow H., Barlow A. Sir Thomas Barlow, Bt.: Three selected lectures and a biographical sketch. 1965;Dawsons of Pall Mall, London.
6. Barlow T. On a case of double cerebral hemiplegia, with cerebral symmetrical lesions. British Medical Journal. 2:1877;103-104.
7. Barlow T. On cases described as acute rickets which are probably a combination of scurvy and rickets, the scurvy being an essential and the rickets a variable element. Medico-Chirurgical Transactions. 66:1883;159-220.
8. Barlow T. Harvey, the man and the physician. British Medical Journal. 2:1916;739-746.
9. Basso A., Gardelli M., Grassi M.P., Mariotti M. The role of the right hemisphere in recovery from aphasia: Two case studies. Cortex. 25:1989;555-566.
10. Bastian H.C. On the various forms of loss of speech in cerebral disease. British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review. 43:1869;209-236.
11. Bastian H.C. A treatise on aphasia and other speech defects. 1898;Lewis, London.
12. Bell C. Idea of a new anatomy of the brain. 1811;Strahan and Preston, London. (Reprinted in Medical Classics, 1, 105-120 (1936)).
13. Bichat X. Recherches physiologiques sue la vie et la mort. 3rd ed. 1805;Brosson/Gabon, Paris.
14. Boyd R. Tables of the weights of the human body and internal organs in the same and insane of both sexes and of various ages, arranged from 2614 post-mortem examinations. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. 151:1861;241-262.
15. Broca, P. (1865). Sur le siège de la faculté du langage articulé. Bulletin de la Société d'Anthropologie, 6, 337-393. (Trans. by E.A. Berker, A.H. Berker, & A. Smith (1986) as Localization of speech in the third left frontal convolution. Archives of Neurology, 43, 1065-1072).
16. Broca P. Sur les poids relatifs des deux hémisphères cérébraux et de leurs lobes frontaux. Bulletin de la Société d'Anthropologie. 10:1875;534.
17. Buckner R.L., Corbetta M., Schatz J., Raichle M.E., Petersen S.E. Preserved speech abilities and compensation following prefrontal damage. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 93:1996;1249-1253.
18. Buckner R.L., Petersen S.E. Neuroimaging of functional recovery. Levin H.S., Graffman J. Cerebral reorganization of function after brain damage. 2000;318-330 Oxford University Press, New York.
19. Czopf J. Ueber die Rolle der nicht dominantent Hemisphäre in der Restitution der Sprache der Aphasischen. Archiv für Psychiatrie und Nervenkrankheiten. 216:1972;162-171.
20. Daniels S.K. Swallowing apraxia: A disorder of the praxis system? Dysphagia. 15:2000;159-166.
21. Dax G. Sur le même sujet. Gazette Hebdomidaire de Médecine et de Chirurgerie. 2(2nd ser.):1865;260-262.
22. Dax, M. (1865). Lésions de la moitié gauche de l'encéphale coïncidant avec l'oubli des signes de la pensée (lu au Congrés Méridional tenu à Montpellier en 1836. Gazette Hebdomidaire de Médecine et de Chirurgerie, 2 (2nd ser.), 259-260.
23. Ecker A. Zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Furchen und Windungen des Grosshirn-Hemisphären im Foetus des Menschen. Archiv für Anthropologie. 3:1868;203-223.
24. Elliott T.R. Thomas Barlow, 1845-1945. Obituaries of Fellows of the Royal Society. 5:1945;159-167.
25. Evans P.R. Infantile scurvy: The centenary of Barlow's disease. British Medical Journal. 2(287):1983;1862-1863.
26. Ferrier D. The localization of cerebral disease. 1879;GP Putnam's Sons, New York.
27. Finger S. Origins of Neuroscience. 1994;Oxford University Press, New York.
28. Finger S., LeVere T.E., Almli C.R., Stein D.G. Recovery of function: Sources of controversy. Finger S., LeVere T.E., Almli C.R., Stein D.G. Brain injury and recovery: Theoretical and controversial issues. 1988;351-362 Plenum Press, New York.
29. Finger S., Roe D.L. Gustave Dax and the early history of cerebral dominance. Archives of Neurology. 53:1996;806-813.
30. Finger S., Stein D.G. Vicariation theory and radical reorganization of function. Brain damage and recovery: Research and clinical perspectives. 1982;287-302 Academic Press, New York.
31. Gainotti G. The riddle of the right hemisphere's contribution to the recovery of language. European Journal of Disorders of Communication. 28:1993;227-246.
32. Godlee R.J. Sir Thomas Barlow, Bart., F.R.S. University College Hospital Magazine. 1:1910;4.
33. Gold B.T., Kertesz A. Right hemisphere semantic processing of visual words in an aphasic patient: An fMRI study. Brain and Language. 73:2000;456-465.
34. Gowers W.R. 2nd ed. A manual of diseases of the nervous system. vol. 2:1893;110-125 P. Blakiston, Philadelphia.
35. Gratiolet, P., & Leuret, F. (1839-1857). Anatomie Comparée du Système Nerveux, Considerée dans ses Rapports avec l'Intelligence. (2 vols., vol. 2 by Gratiolet alone). Paris: J.B. Ballière.
36. Harrington A. Medicine, mind and the double brain: A study in nineteenth-century thought. 1987;Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
37. Henschen S.E. Klinische und pathologische Beiträge zur Pathologie des Gehirns. Über motorische Aphasie und Agraphie. vol. VII:1922;Nordiske Bokhandeln, Stockholm.
38. Henschen S.E. On the function of the right hemisphere of the brain in relation to the left in speech, music and calculation. Brain. 49:1926;110-123.
39. Horder L. Sir Thomas Barlow, Bart.: On the occasion of his 90th birthday. 1935;British Medical Association, London.
40. Jackson J.H. Hemispheral coordination. Medical Times and Gazette. 2:1868;208-209.
41. Jackson J.H. Case of disease of the brain - left hemiplegia - mental affection. Medical Times and Gazette. 1:1872;513-514.
42. Jackson J.H. On convulsive seizures (Lumleian Lecture). British Medical Journal. 1:1890;821-827.
43. Joynt R.J., Benton A.L. The memoir of Marc Dax on aphasia. Neurology. 14:1964;851-854.
44. Kertesz A. Recovery and treatment. Heilman K., Valenstein E. Clinical neuropsychology. 1979;503-534 Oxford University Press, New York.
45. Kinsbourne M. The minor hemisphere as the source of aphasic speech. Archives of Neurology. 25:1971;306-3012.
46. Levine D.N., Mohr J.P. Language after bilateral cerebral infarctions: Role of the minor hemisphere in speech. Neurology. 29:1979;927-938.
47. Mempel E., Srebrzynska J., Subczynska J., Zarski S. Compensation of speech disorders by the non-dominant cerebral hemisphere in adults. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry. 26:1963;96.
48. Moxon W. On the connexion between loss of speech and paralysis of the right side. British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review. 37:1866;481-489.
49. Nielsen J.M. Agnosia, apraxia, aphasia: Their value in cerebral localization. 1946;Paul B. Hoeber, New York.
50. Ohyama M., Senda M., Kitamura S., Ishii K., Mishina M., Terashi A. Role of the nondominant hemisphere and undamaged are during word repetition in poststroke aphasics. Stroke. 27:1996;897-903.
51. Roe D.L., Finger S. Gustave Dax and his fight for recognition: An overlooked chapter in the early history of cerebral dominance. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences. 5:1996;228-240.
52. Rosen H.J., Petersen S.E., Linenweber M.R., Snyder A.Z., White D.A., Chapman L.et al. Neural correlates of recovery from aphasia after damage to left inferior frontal cortex. Neurology. 26:2000;1883-1894.
53. Ryalls J., Lecours A.R. Broca's first two cases: From bumps on the head to cortical convolutions. Code C., Wallesch C.-W., Yoanette J., Lecours A.R. Classic cases in neuropsychology. 1996;235-242 Psychology Press, East Sussex, UK.
54. Slavin M.D., Laurence S., Stein D.G. Another look at vicariation. Finger S., LeVere T.E., Almli C.R., Stein D.G. Brain injury and recovery: Theoretical and controversial issues. 1988;165-178 Plenum Press, New York.
55. Taylor J. Paralysis and other diseases of the nervous system in childhood and early life. 1905;JA Churchill, London.
56. Thurman J. On the weight of the brain, and on the circumstances affecting it. Journal of Mental Science. 12:1866;1-43.
57. Vallar G. Hemispheric control of articulatory speech output in aphasia. Hammond G.R. Cerebral control of speech. 1990;387-416 North-Holland, Amsterdam.
58. Vicq d'Azyr F. Moreau J.L. Oeuvres de Vicq d'Azyr. 1805;L. Duprat-Duverger, Paris.
59. Warburton E., Price C.J., Swinburn K., Wise R.J. Mechanisms of recovery from aphasia: evidence from positron emission tomography studies. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry. 66:1999;155-161.
60. Weiller C., Isensee C., Rijntjes M., Huber W., Muller S., Bier D.et al. Recovery from Wernicke's aphasia: A positron emission tomographic study. Annals of Neurology. 37:1995;723-732.
61. Wernicke C. Der aphasische Symptomenkomplex: eine psychologische Studie auf anatomischer Basis. 1874;Cohn and Weigert, Breslau.