The sun protection factor (SPF) inadequately defines broad spectrum photoprotection: Demonstration using skin reconstructed in vitro exposed to UVA, UVB or UV-solar simulated radiation

European Journal of Dermatology

Volumn 13, Issue 3, 2003, Pages 242-249

  Bernerd, Françoise ^a   Vioux, Corinne ^a   Lejeune, François ^a   Asselineau, Daniel ^a  

^a L ORÉAL RECHERCHE   (France)

Author keywords

Dermal damages; Skin equivalent; Sunscreens; UV radiation

Indexed keywords

4 METHOXYCINNAMIC ACID 2 ETHYLHEXYL ESTER; CINNAMIC ACID DERIVATIVE; DIBENZOYLMETHANE DERIVATIVE; OCTYLMETHOXYCINNAMATE; PARSOL 1989; SULISOBENZONE; SUNSCREEN; UNCLASSIFIED DRUG; UVINUL N539; WATER OIL CREAM; Z COTE; ZINC OXIDE;

ADULT; ARTICLE; CONTROLLED STUDY; DRUG EFFECT; DRUG FORMULATION; HUMAN; HUMAN CELL; HUMAN TISSUE; IN VITRO STUDY; NORMAL HUMAN; RADIATION DOSE; RADIATION INJURY; SIMULATION; SKIN INJURY; SKIN PIGMENTATION; SKIN PROTECTION; SOLAR RADIATION; SUN EXPOSURE; TOPICAL TREATMENT; ULTRAVIOLET A RADIATION; ULTRAVIOLET B RADIATION;

CHEMISTRY, PHARMACEUTICAL; DOSE-RESPONSE RELATIONSHIP, RADIATION; HUMANS; SKIN; SUNBURN; SUNSCREENING AGENTS; ULTRAVIOLET RAYS;

EID: 0037526217     PISSN: 11671122     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (48)

1. Ross P M, Carter D M. Cutaneous DNA damage and repair. In "Physiology, Biochemistry and Molecular Biology of the Skin". (Goldsmith L.A. Ed.) 2nd ed. Oxford University Press, New-York, 1991: 410-51.
2. Sarasin A. The molecular pathways of ultraviolet-induced carcinogenesis. Mut Res 1999; 428: 5-10.
3. LeVee G J, Oberhelman L, Anderson T, Koren H, Cooper KD. UVA II exposure of human skin results in decreased immunization capacity, increased induction of tolerance and a unique pattern of epidermal antigen-presenting cell alteration. Photochem Photobiol 1997; 65: 622-9.
4. Damian D, Barnetson R, Halliday G. Low-dose UVA and UVB hove different time courses for suppression of contact hypersensitivity to a recall antigen in humans. J Invest Dermatol 1999; 112: 939-44.
5. Lavker R M, Gerberick G F, Veres D A, Irwin C J, Kaidbey K H. Cumulative effects from repetitive exposures to suberythemal doses of UVB and UVA in human skin. J Am Acad Dermatol 1995; 32: 53-62.
6. Kligman L, Akin F J, Kligman A M. The contributions of UVA and UVB to connective tissue damage in hairless mice. J Invest Dermatol 1985; 84: 272-6.
7. Drobetsky E A, Turcotte J, Châteauneuf A. A role for ultravialet A in solar mutogenesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1995; 92: 2350-4.
8. Robert C, Muel B, Benoit A Dubertret L, Sarasin A, Stary A. Cell survival and shuttle vector mutagenesis induced by ultraviolet A and ultraviolet B radiation in a human cell line. J Invest Dermatol 1996; 106: 721-8.
9. Naylor M F, Farmer K C. The case for sunscreens. A review of their use in preventing actinic damage and neoplasia. Arch Dermatol 1997; 133: 1146-54.
10. Rosen CF. In sunscreen photobiology: molecular, cellular, and physiological ospects. F. Gasporro ED. Springer-Verlag and Landes Bioscience. Chap 4, 1997; 63-68.
11. COLIPA. Sun protection factor test method. Brussels: The European Cosmetic Toiletry and Perfumery Association. 21, 1994.
12. Lowe N J, Meyers D P, Wieder J M et al. Low doses of repetitive ultraviolet A induce morphologic changes in human skin. J Invest Dermatol 1995; 105: 739-43.
13. Seite S, Moyal D, Richard S et al. Mexoryl® SX: a broad spectrum absorption UVA filter protects human skin from the effects of repeated suberythemal doses of UVA. J. Photochem Photobiol B:Biolog 1998; 44: 69-76.
14. Kelly D A, Young A R, McGregor J M, Seed P T, Potten C S, Walker S L. Sensitivity to sunburn is associated with susceptibility to ultraviolet radiation-induced suppression of cutaneous cell-mediated immunity. J Exp Med 2000; 191: 561-6.
15. Roberts L K, Learnb D B. Sunscreen SPF values and immune protection levels are equivalent when tests are conducted by appropriate methods. In: Sunscreen photobiology: molecular, cellular and physiological aspects., F. Gasparro, Ed. Landes Bio-sciences, Austin, TX, 1997: 127-55.
16. Ullrich S E, Kim T-H, Ananthaswamy H N, Kripke M. Sunscreen effects on UV-incluced immune suppression. J Invest Dermatol Symposium Proceedings 1999; 4: 65-9.
17. Hochberg M, Enk C. Partial protection against epidermal IL-10 transcription and Langerhans cell depletion by sunscreen ofter exposure of human skin to UVB. Photochem Photobiol 1999; 70: 766-72.
18. Kligman L, Zheng P. The protective effect of a broad-spectrum sunscreen against UVA radiation in hairless mice: a histologic and ultrastructural assessment. J Soc Cosmet Chem 1994; 45: 21-3.
19. Kligmon L, Agin P P, Sayre R M. Brood-spectrum sunscreens with UVA I and UVA II absorbers provide increased protection against solar-simulating radiation-induced dermal damage in hairless mice. J Soc Cosmet Chem 1996; 47: 129-55.
20. Rosentein B, Phelps R, Weistock M et al. p53 Mutations in basal cell carcinomas arising in routine users of sunscreens. Photochem Photobiol 1999; 70: 798-806.
21. Bernerd F, Asselineau D. Successive alteration and recovery of epidermal differentiation and morphogenesis after specific UVB-damages in skin reconstructed in vitro. Dev Biol 1997; 183: 123-38.
22. Bernerd F, Asselineau D. UVA exposure of human skin reconstructed in vitro induces apoptosis of dermal fibroblasts: subsequent connective tissue repair and implications in photoaging. Cell Death and Differentiation 1998; 5: 792-802.
23. Bernerd F, Vioux C, Asselineau D. Evaluation of the protective effect of sunscreens on in vitro reconstructed human skin exposed to UVB or UVA irradiation. Photochem Photobiol 2000; 71: 314-20.
24. Reece B T, Deeds D, Rozen M. An in vitro method for screening sunscreen formulations for sun protection factor using a full-thickness skin model. J Soc Cosmet Chem 1992; 43: 307-12.
25. Augustin C, Collombel C, Damour O. Measurements of the protective effect of topicolly applied sunscreens using in vitro three-dimensional dermal and skin equivalents. Photochem Photobiol 1997; 66: 853-9.
26. Diffey B L. A method for broad spectrum classification of sunscreens. Int J Cosmet Sci 1994; 16: 47-52.
27. Moyal D, Chardon A, Kollias N. Determination of UVA protection factors using the persistent pigment darkening (PPD) as the end point. (Part 1) Calibration method Photodermatol Photoimmunol Photomed 2000; 16: 245-9.
28. Commission Internationale de l'Eclairage (CIE) (1998). Erythema reference action spectrum and standard erythema dose. Publ. CIE S 007/E, Vienna, Austria.(http://www.cie.co.at/cie/, Central Bureau, Kegelstrasse 27, 1030 Vienna, Austria).
29. Chardon A, Moyal D, Hourseau C. Persistent pigment darkening response as a method for evoluation of ultraviolet A protection assays in: Sunscreen Development, Evaluation and Regulatory aspects. N.Lowe, N. Shaath; M. Pathak Eds. Marcel Dekker Inc. New-York, Basel, Hong Kong 1997: 559-82.
30. Diffey B L, Robson J. A new substrate to measure sunscreen protection factors thoughout the ultraviolet spectrum. J Soc Cosmet Chem 1989; 40:127-33.
31. Asselineou D, Bernard B A, Bailly C, Darmon M. Epidermal morphogenesis and induction of 67kD keratin polypeptide by culture ot the liquid-air interface. Exp Cell Res 1985; 159: 536-9.
32. Roza L, de Gruijl F R, Bergen Henegouwen J P A et al. Detectian of photorepair of UV-induced thymine dimers in human epidermis by immunofluorescence microscopy. J Invest Dermatol 1991; 96: 903-7.
33. Pathak M A. Sunscreens: progress and perspectives on photo-protection of human skin against UVB and UVA rodiation. J Dermatol 1997; 23: 783-800.
34. Sayre R M, Cole C, Billhimer W, Stanfield J, Ley R. Spectral comparison of solar simulators and sunlight. Photodermotol Photoimmunol Photomed 1990; 7: 159-65.
35. Fourtanier A, Gueniche A, Compan D, Walker S, Young A R. Improved protection against solar-simulated radiation-induced immunosuppression by a sunscreen with enhanced ultraviolet A protection. J Invest Dermatol 2000; 114: 620-7.
36. Seite S, Moyal D, Verdier M P, Hourseau C, Fourtanier A. Accumulated p53 protein and UVA protection level of sunscreens. Photodermatol Photoimmunol Photomed 2000; 16: 3-9.
37. Marrot L Belaidi J P, Meunier J R, Perez P, Agapakis-Causse C. The human melanocyte as a particular target for UVA radiation and an end-point for photoprotection assessment. Photochem Photobiol 1999; 69: 686-93.
38. Gilchrest B A. Dermatoheliosis (Sun-induced aging). In « Skin and Aging Processes ». Gilchrest B A Ed., CRC Press, 1989: 97-116.
39. U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Tentative final monograph for sunscreen drug products for over-the-counter human use. Fed Reg 1993; 53 (90): 28194-302.
40. Freeman S E, Hacham H, Gange R W, Maytum D J, Sutherland J C, Sutherland B M. Wavelength dependence of pyrimidine dimer formation in DNA of human skin irrodiated in situ with ultraviolet light. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1989; 86: 5605-9.
41. Perdiz D, Grof P, Mezzina M, Nikaido O, Moustacchi E, Sage E. Distribution and repair of bipyrimidine photoproducts in solar UV-irradiated mammalian cells. J Biol Chem 2000; 275: 26732-42.
42. Woollons A, Kipp C, Young A R et al. The 0,8% ultraviolet B content of an ultraviolet A sunlamp induces 75% of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in human keratinocytes in vitro. Br J Dermatol 1999; 140: 1023-30.
43. Scharffetter K Wlaschek M, Hogg A et al. UVA irradiation induces collagenase in human dermal firoblasts in vitro and in vivo. Arch Dermatol Res 1991; 283: 506-11.
44. Brown D B, Peritz A E, Mitchell D L, Chiarello S, Uitto J, Gasparro F P. Common fluorescent sunlamps are an inappropriate substitute for sunlight. Photochem Photobiol 2000; 72: 340-4.
45. Gasparro F P, Brown D B. Photobiology 102: UV sources and dosimetry- the proper use and measurement of "photons as a reagent". J Invest Dermatol 2000; 114: 613-5.
46. Young A R, Sheehan J M, Chadwick C A, Potten C S. Protection by Ultraviolet A and B sunscreens against in situ dipyrimidine photolesions in human epidermis is comparable to protection against sunburn. J Invest Dermatol 2000; 115: 37-41.
47. Young A R, Chadwick C A, Harrison G I, Nikaido O, Ramsden J, Potten C S. The similarity of action spectra for thymine dimers in human epidermis and erythema suggests that DNA is the chromophore for erythema. J Invest Dermatol 1998; 111: 982-8.
48. Young A R. The sunburn cell. Photodermatol 1987; 4: 127-34.