Community-based planning as a source of political change: The transit equity movement of los angeles' bus riders union

Journal of the American Planning Association

Volumn 68, Issue 2, 2002, Pages 165-178

  Grengs, Joe ^a  

^a Department of Obstetrics Gynecology   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION; GRASSROOTS LEVEL; LOCAL PARTICIPATION; PUBLIC TRANSPORT; TRANSPORTATION PLANNING;

UNITED STATES;

EID: 0036284782     PISSN: 01944363     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01944360208976263     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. Adler, S., 1986. The dynamics of transit innovation in Los Angeles. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 4 (3):321–335.
2. Adler, S., 1987. Why BART but no LART? The political economy of rail rapid transit planning in the Los Angeles and San Francisco metropolitan areas, 1945–1957. Planning Perspectives, 2:149–174.
3. Altshuler, A., 1965. The city planning process:A political analysis, Ithaca, NY:Cornell University Press.
4. Altshuler, A., Womack, J. P., and Pucher, J. R., 1979. The urban transportation system:Politics and policy innovation, Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
5. Arnstein, S. R., 1969. A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 25 (4):216–224.
6. Barrett, P., and Rose, M. H., 1999. The politics of transportation statistics in the American city, 1900–1990. Journal of Urban History, 25 (3):405–433.
7. Baum, H. S., 1983. Politics and ambivalence in planners' practice. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 3 (1):13–22.
8. Baum, H. S., 1996. “ Practicing planning in a political world ”. In Explorations in planning theory, Edited by:Mandelbaum, S. J., Mazza, L., and Burchell, R. W., 365–382. New Brunswick, NJ:Center for Urban Policy Research.
9. Beauregard, R. A., 1995. Edge critics. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 14 (2):163–166.
10. Black, A., 1990. The Chicago area transportation study:A case study of rational planning. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 10 (1):27–37.
11. Black, A., 1995. Urban mass transportation planning, New York:McGraw-Hill.
12. Bolan, R. S., 2000. The four faces of planning theory:Theory choice and practitioner action. Paper presented at the annual conference of the Associated Collegiate Schools of Planning. November2000, Atlanta, Georgia.
13. Brown, J., Spring, 1998. Race, class, gender, and public transportation planning:Lessons from the Bus Riders Union lawsuit. Critical Planning,:3–20.
14. Bryson, J. M., 1995. Strategic planning for public and nonprofit organizations, San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
15. Bundy, E., 2000. Why rail?. Open Spaces Quarterly, 3 (2) [Online]. Available
16. Burrington, S. H., and Heart, B., 1998. City routes, city rights:Building livable neighborhoods and environmental justice by fixing transportation, Boston:Conservation Law Foundation.
17. Chin, R., and Benne, K. D., 1976. “ General strategies for effecting change in human systems ”. In The planning of change, Edited by:Bennis, W., 32–57. New York:Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
18. Clavel, P., 1986. The progressive city, New Brunswick, NJ:Rutgers University Press.
19. Clavel, P., 1994. The evolution of advocacy planning. Journal of the American Planning Association, 60 (2):146–149.
20. Committee for a Better North Philadelphia v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority, Civ. 88–1275, U.S. Dist. LEXIS 10895 (E.D. Pa. August 14, 1990)
21. Davis, M., September 18, 1995. Runaway train crushes buses. The Nation,:270–274.
22. del Barco, M., April 5 1997. April 5, Bus union. All Things Considered National Public Radio, Transcript #97040502–216 [Online]. Available:Lexis Academic Universe:
23. Dittmar, H., 1995. A broader context for transportation planning:Not just an end in itself. Journal of the American Planning Association, 61 (1):7–13.
24. Eisinger, P. K., 1973. The conditions of protest behavior in American cities. American Political Science Review, 67:11–28.
25. Environmental Systems Research, Inc. 2001. ArcData online, U.S. Bureau of the Census, redistricting census 2000 TIGER/line files [On-line]. Available:
26. Evans, S. M., and Boyte, H. C., 1986. Free spaces:The sources of democratic change in America, New York:Harper and Row.
27. 1994. Executive Order No. 12898, 59 C.F.R. 7,629
28. Fielding, G. J., 1995. “ Transit in American cities ”. In The geography of urban transportation, Edited by:Hanson, S., 287–304. New York:Guildford Press.
29. Flyvbjerg, B., 1998. Rationality and power, Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
30. Forester, J., 1989. Planning in the face of power, Berkeley:University of California Press.
31. Friedmann, J., 1998a. Planning theory revisited. European Planning Studies, 6 (3):245–253.
32. Friedmann, J., 1998b. “ The new political economy of planning:The rise of civil society ”. In Cities for citizens, Edited by:Douglass, M., and Friedmann, J., 19–35. Chichester, UK:John Wiley & Sons.
33. Frug, G. E., 1980. The city as a legal concept. Harvard Law Review, 93 (6):1057–1154.
34. Giuliano, G., and Small, K., 1991. Subcenters in the Los Angeles region. Regional Science and Urban Economics, 21:163–182.
35. Grengs, J., 2001. Does public transit counteract the segregation of carless households? Measuring spatial patterns of accessibility with GIS. Transportation Research Record, 1753:3–10.
36. Heskin, A. D., 1991. The struggle for community, Boulder, CO:Westview Press.
37. Holston, J., 1998. “ Spaces of insurgent citizenship ”. In Making the invisible visible:A multicultural planning history, Edited by:Sandercock, L., 37–56. Berkeley:University of California Press.
38. Howard, C., Lipsky, M., and Marshall, D. R., 1994. “ Citizen participation in urban politics:Rise and routinization ”. In Big city politics, governance, and fiscal constraints, Edited by:Peterson, G. E., 153–199. Washington, DC:Urban Institute Press.
39. Innes, J. E., and Gruber, J., 1999. Planning strategies in conflict:The case of regional transportation planning in the Bay Area. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association of European Schools of Planning. July1999, Bergen, Norway.
40. Jackson, B. O., and Preston, M. B., 1994. “ Race and ethnicity in Los Angeles politics ”. In Big city politics, governance, and fiscal constraints, Edited by:Peterson, G. E., 85–101. Washington, DC:Urban Institute Press.
41. Kelley, R. D. G., February 5, 1996. Freedom riders (The sequel). The Nation,:18–22.
42. Khisty, C. J., and Leleur, S., 1997. Citizen participation through communicative action:Towards a new framework and synthesis. Journal of Advanced Transportation, 31 (2):119–137.
43. King, M. L., Jr. 1958. Stride toward freedom:The Montgomery story, New York:Harper.
44. King, M. L., Jr. 1963. Letter from Birmingham city jail, Philadelphia:American Friends Service Committee.
45. Kleidman, R., and Rochon, T. R., 1997. “ Dilemmas of organization in peace campaigns ”. In Coalitions and political movements:Lessons from the nuclear freeze, Edited by:Rochon, T., and Meyer, D., 47–60. Boulder, CO:Lynne Rienner.
46. Krumholz, N., and Forester, J., 1990. Making equity planning work, Philadelphia:Temple University Press.
47. Krumholz, N., and Clavel, P., eds. 1994. Reinventing cities:Equity planners tell their stories, Philadelphia:Temple University Press.
48. Labor/Community Strategy Center. 1997. Labor/Community Strategy Center National School for Strategic Organizing, [Brochure], Los Angeles:Author.
49. Labor/Community Strategy Center. 1998. Labor/Community Strategy Center update, [Brochure], Los Angeles:Author.
50. Labor/Community Strategy Center v. L.A. County Metropolitan Transportation Authority, No. 2:94-cv-05936 TJH (U.S. District Court August 31, 1994)
51. Leavitt, J., 1994. Planning in an age of rebellion:Guidelines to activist research and applied planning. Planning Theory, 10–11:111–129.
52. Lewis Mumford Center for Comparative Urban and Regional Research. 2001. Metropolitan racial and ethnic change, Census, 2000 [On-line]. Available:
53. Mann, E., 1996. A new vision for urban transportation, Los Angeles:Labor/Community Strategy Center.
54. Mann, E., 1997. “ Confronting transit racism in Los Angeles ”. In Just transportation, Edited by:Bullard, R. D., and Johnson, G. S., 68–83. Gabriola Island, BC:New Society Publishers.
55. Mann, E., and Mathis, C., 1997. Civil rights consent decree? Legal tactics for left strategy. Ahora Now, 4:1–11.
56. Markman, J. D., June 25, 1996. Study contends that MTA based 20-year transit plan on faulty data. Los Angeles Times,:B1
57. Markman, J. D., and Simon, R., December 5, 1996. Transportation post:Who would want it?. Los Angeles Times,:A1
58. Marris, P., 1994. Advocacy planning as a bridge between the professional and the political. Journal of the American Planning Association, 60 (2):143–146.
59. McAdam, D., 1982. Political process and the development of Black insurgency 1930–1970, Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
60. McAdam, D., 1995. “ ‘Initiator’ and ‘spin-off’ movements:Diffusion processes in protest cycles ”. In Repertoires and cycles of collective action, Edited by:Traugott, M., 217–239. Durham, NC:Duke University Press.
61. McAdam, D., McCarthy, J. D., and Zald, M. N., 1996. “ Opportunities, mobilizing structures, and framing processes:Towards a synthetic, comparative perspective on social movements ”. In Comparative perspectives on social movements, Edited by:McAdam, D., McCarthy, J. D., and Zald, M. N., 1–20. Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
62. McAdam, D., Tarrow, S., and Tilly, C., 1997. “ Toward an integrated perspective on social movements and revolution ”. In Comparative politics:Rationality, culture, and structure, Edited by:Lichbach, M. I., and Zuckerman, A. S., 142–173. Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
63. McAdam, D., Tarrow, S., and Tilly, C., 2001. Dynamics of contention, Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
64. Meyer, D. S., and Rochon, T. R., 1997. “ Toward a coalitional theory of social and political movements ”. In Coalitions and political movements:Lessons from the nuclear freeze, Edited by:Rochon, T. R., and Meyer, D. S., 237–268. Boulder, CO:Lynne Rienner.
65. Moore, J. E., II. September 7, 1994. Shift the spending to buses. Los Angeles Times,:B7
66. Moore, J. E., II and Rubin, T. A., December 13, 1996. Admit rail plan is dead and move on. Los Angeles Times,:B9
67. NAACP Legal Defense Fund. 1996a. Labor/Community Strategy Center v. L.A. County Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Plaintiffs' revised statement of contentions of fact and law [On-line]. Available:, see hyperlink “Download Case Related Documents.
68. NAACP Legal Defense Fund. 1996b. Labor/Community Strategy Center v. L.A. County Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Consent decree [On-line]. Available:, see hyperlink “Download Case Related Documents.
69. New York Urban League v. State of New York. Civ. 9001 (RPP), 905 F. Supp. 1266, U.S. Dist. LEXIS 16684 (S.D.N.Y. November 8, 1995)
70. Oliver, M. L., and Johnson, J. H., Jr. 1984. Inter-ethnic conflict in an urban ghetto:The case of Blacks and Latinos in Los Angeles. Social Movements, Conflict and Change, 6:57–94.
71. Putnam, R. D., 1994. Making democracy work:Civic traditions in modern Italy, Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
72. Rabin, J. L., June 21, 1998. MTA borrowing puts the agency $7 billion in debt. Los Angeles Times,:A22
73. Rabin, J. L., November 19, 2000. Riders walk out of MTA hearing on bus lines. Los Angeles Times,:B1
74. Richmond, J. E. D., 1998. The mythical conception of rail transit in Los Angeles. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 15 (4):294–320.
75. Rooney, B., June 8 1996. Los Angeles Bus Riders Union suing for fair share June 8, ABC World News (Transcript #623–6) [Online]. Available:Lexis Academic Universe:
76. Rubin, T., 1993. A look at the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Los Angeles:Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
77. Sandercock, L., 1998. Towards cosmopolis, Chichester, UK:John Wiley and Sons.
78. Snow, D. A., Rochford, E. B., Jr., Worden, S. K., and Benford, R. D., 1986. Frame alignment processes, micromobilization, and movement participation. American Sociological Review, 51:464–481.
79. Solin, L., 1997. Professional practice manual, Chicago:American Planning Association.
80. Sonenshein, R. J., 1993. Politics in black and white:Race and power in Los Angeles, Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
81. Staggenborg, S., 1986. Coalition work in the pro-choice movement:Organizational and environmental opportunities and obstacles. Social Problems, 33 (5):374–390.
82. Sterngold, J., September 25, 1999. Improve bus service and soon, blunt judge tells Los Angeles. New York Times,:A11
83. Tarrow, S., 1994. Power in movement:Social movements, collective action, and politics, Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
84. Taylor, B. D., 1995. Public perceptions, fiscal realities, and freeway planning:The California case. Journal of the American Planning Association, 61 (1):43–56.
85. Taylor, B. D., and Garrett, M., 1998. Equity planning in the 90s:A case study of the Los Angeles MTA. Paper presented at the annual conference of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning. October1998, Pasadena, CA.
86. Taylor, B. D., Wachs, M., Luhrsen, K., Lem, L. L., Kim, E., and Mauch, M., 1995. Variations in fare payment and public subsidy by race and ethnicity:An examination of the Los Angeles Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Los Angeles:University of California. Working paper
87. Tilly, C., 1978. From mobilization to revolution, Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley.
88. U.S. Census Bureau. 1992. 1990 census of population and housing, summary tape file 1A [On-line]. Available:
89. U.S. Department of Transportation. 1993. Journey-to-work trends in the United States and its major metropolitan areas, 1960–1990, Washington, DC:Author.
90. U.S. Department of Transportation. 2001. National transportation atlas databases 2001, CD-ROM, BTS-01–04, Washington, DC:Bureau of Transportation Statistics.
91. U.S. General Accounting Office. 1996a. Los Angeles Red Line:Financing decisions could affect this and other Los Angeles County rail capital projects, Washington, DC:Author.
92. U.S. General Accounting Office. 1996b. Urban transportation:Metropolitan planning organizations' efforts to meet federal planning requirements, Washington, DC:Author.
93. Wachs, M., 1986. Technique versus advocacy in forecasting:A study of rail rapid transit. Urban Resources, 4 (1):23–30.
94. Wachs, M., 1993. Learning from Los Angeles:Transport, urban form, and air quality. Transportation, 20:329–354.
95. Wachs, M., 1996. Martin Wachs takes on the MTA. Los Angeles Magazine, 41 (1):18
96. Whitt, J. A., 1979. Toward a class-dialectical model of power:An empirical assessment of three competing models of political power. American Sociological Review, 44:81–100.