SCOPUS 정보 검색 플랫폼

Volumn 19, Issue 5-6, 2001, Pages 611-636

'Fairness and reasonableness of the child's decision:' A proposed legal standard for children's participation in medical decision making

(2) Tomkins, Alan J b Doyon, Theresa a

a MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY (United States)

b NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANTIRETROVIRUS AGENT; NUCLEOSIDE ANALOG; ZIDOVUDINE;

ACQUIRED IMMUNE DEFICIENCY SYNDROME; ARTICLE; BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE; CHILD; CHILD CARE; CHILD PARENT RELATION; COGNITION; EXPERIENCE; FEMALE; HUMAN; HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS INFECTION; HUMAN RIGHTS; ILLNESS BEHAVIOR; LEGAL ASPECT; MAJOR CLINICAL STUDY; MALE; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MEDICAL ETHICS; RISK BENEFIT ANALYSIS; SOCIAL ASPECT; WELLBEING;

LEGAL APPROACH; PROFESSIONAL PATIENT RELATIONSHIP;

AGE FACTORS; ANTIRETROVIRAL THERAPY, HIGHLY ACTIVE; CHILD; CHILD ADVOCACY; COGNITION; HIV INFECTIONS; HUMANS; LEGAL GUARDIANS; MALE; MENTAL COMPETENCY; PARENTS; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; PATIENT RIGHTS; TREATMENT REFUSAL; UNITED STATES;

EID: 0035705978 PISSN: 07353936 EISSN: None Source Type: Journal
DOI: 10.1002/bsl.461 Document Type: Article

Times cited : (16)

References (151)

1
- 21544474087
- Note: Protecting the rights and interests of competent minors in litigated medical treatment disputes
- (1996) 64 Fordham L. Rev. , vol.2075 , pp. 2090
- Hawkins, S.D.¹

2
- 0008202979
- Are children competent to make decisions about their own deaths?
- (1995) 13 Behav. Sci. & L. , vol.27 , pp. 29
- Evans, J.L.¹

3
- 0008240801
- In re Nikolas E., 1998 Me. 243; 1998 Me. LEXIS 264 (1998)

4
- 0003604669
- (1992) Pediatric And Adolescent AIDS: Research Findings From The Social Sciences
- Henggeler, S.W.¹

5
- 0008158860
- note

6
- 0008240802
- note

7
- 0008159753
- Law court upholds ruling in HIV case
- Friday, November 20
- (1998) The Bangor Daily News

8
- 0008236781
- Maine high court hears appeal for HIV-infected child
- Wednesday, November 4
- (1998) Press Herald

9
- 0008236299
- (NBC television broadcast, January 25) at 14
- (1999) NBC News Dateline: Valerie's Choice

10
- 0008161183
- Child and Family Services and Child Protection Act, 22 M.R.S.A. § 4003 (1992), amended by P.L. 1997, ch. 715, § B-4 (effective June 30, 1998)

11
- 0008238682
- In re Nikolas E., supra note 3, at 20

12
- 0008162072
- Id. at 18

13
- 0008158862
- Id. at 20-21

14
- 0008240803
- note

15
- 0003717948
- (1998) Social Science in Law: Cases and Materials (4th edn)
- Monahan, J.¹ Walker, L.²

16
- 0023305060
- Medical compliance and coping with cystic phybrosis
- (1987) 28 J. Child Psychol. & Allied Disciplines , vol.311
- Czajkowski, D.R.¹ Koocher, G.²

17
- 0008159755
- Children's participation in treatmemt planning
- (1981) 12 Professional Psychol. , vol.246
- Melton, G.B.¹

18
- 84882597378
- Abandoning children to their autonomy: The United Nations convention on the rights of the child
- (1996) 37 Harv. Int'l. L. J. , vol.449
- Hafen, B.C.¹ Hafen, J.O.²

19
- 0011368479
- Chapter 7
- (1998) Children's Rights in the United States: In Search of a National Policy
- Walker, N.E.¹

20
- 0008204168
- Id.

21
- 0008160021
- See, e.g., Hafen & Hafen, supra note 17

22
- 0008202245
- Custody of a minor
- (1978) 375 Mass. , vol.733

23
- 0008160874
- Hafen & Hafen, supra note 17 at 461

24
- 0008162224
- Walker et al., supra note 18

25
- 0008159613
- The smallest democracy
- (1998) 2 Fam. Futures , vol.4 , pp. 4
- Melton, G.B.¹

26
- 0008268867
- Parents and children
- (1998) 2 Fam. Futures , vol.10 , pp. 12
- Melton, G.B.¹

27
- 0008268868
- G.A. Res. 44/25, U.N. Doc. A/Res/44/25 (1989) [hereinafter CRC]

28
- 0008200680
- (1995) Facts About the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child

29
- 0008160022
- note

30
- 0008202246
- note

31
- 0008161184
- CRC, supra note 26, at Article 3

32
- 0008160875
- Id. at Article 6

33
- 0008275902
- Id. at Article 12

34
- 0008236301
- Id. at Article 13

35
- 0001796396
- Competency to consent to treatment: The distinction between assent and objection
- (1991) 28 Houston L. Rev. , vol.15
- Winick, B.J.¹

36
- 0023083471
- The mental health rationale for policies fostering minors' autonomy
- (1987) 10 Internat'l. J. L. & Psychiatry , vol.111
- Tremper, C.¹ Kelly, M.P.²

37
- 0022360725
- Adolescents' competency to make informed consent birth control and pregnancy decisions: An interface for psychology and the law
- (1985) 3 Behavioral Sciences & L. , vol.309
- Carter, P.I.¹ St. Lawrence, J.S.²

38
- 0027478298
- Treatment adherence difficulties among children with cancer: The role of parenting style
- (1993) 18 J. Ped. Psychol. , vol.47
- Manne, S.L.¹

39
- 84929168301
- Medical decision making for and by children: Tensions between parents, state, and child
- (1994) 2 U. Ill. L. Rev. , vol.311 , pp. 314
- Wadlington, W.¹

40
- 0008202248
- Id.

41
- 0008202980
- Id.

42
- 0008160712
- See e.g., In re Tuttendario, 21 Pa. D. 561 (Q.S. Phila. 1912) (cited in Wadlington, supra note 37, at 315)

43
- 0008162073
- 321 U.S. 158 (1944)

44
- 0008197420
- Id. at 170

45
- 0008204170
- Wadlington, supra note 37, at 318

46
- 0008202981
- 317 N.Y.S.2d 641, 654 (N.Y. 1972)

47
- 0008240805
- Wadlington, supra note 37, at 316

48
- 0008242923
- note

49
- 0008240806
- note

50
- 0008243324
- 405 U.S. 645, 651 (1972)

51
- 0008199729
- Id. at 651

52
- 0008200172
- In re Conroy, 486 A.2d 1209, 1229 (N.J. 1976)

53
- 0008242226
- See, e.g., In re Quinlan, 355 A.2d 647 (N.J. 1976)

54
- 0008239769
- 445 S.2d 365 (Fla. 1984)

55
- 0008204172
- Chapsky v. Wood, 26 Kan. 650 (1881)

56
- 0008242925
- In re Nikolas E., supra note 3

57
- 0008202982
- CRC, supra note 26

58
- 0008240808
- Advancing the rights of children and adolescents to be altruistic: Bone marrow donation by Minors
- (1994) 9 J.L. & Health , vol.213 , pp. 224-225
- Robbennolt, J.K.¹

59
- 0030223803
- The ultimate test of autonomy: Should minors have a right to make decisions regarding life-sustaining treatment?
- (1996) 49 Rutgers L. Rev. , vol.1 , pp. 20
- Rosato, J.L.¹

60
- 0008236783
- Id.

61
- 0008202249
- Id. at 33 (footnotes omitted)

62
- 0008160025
- 133 Ill. 2d 98 (1989)

63
- 0030158875
- Minor rights and wrongs
- (1996) 24 J.L. Med. & Ethics , vol.127 , pp. 128
- Oberman, M.¹

64
- 0008197422
- Id. at 111

65
- 0008204174
- Id. at 128

66
- 0008161185
- Hafen & Hafen, supra note 17, at 465

67
- 0008160714
- Oberman, supra note 61, at 129 (citing In the Matter of Long Island Jewish Medical Center, 557 N.Y.S.2d 239 (1990)

68
- 0008160715
- Rosato, supra note 57, at 28

69
- 0008202983
- Id.

70
- 0008197585
- Id. at 29

71
- 0008162075
- The child's choice: An essential component in treatment decisions
- (1987) 15 Children's Health Care , vol.156 , pp. 158
- Erlen, J.A.¹

72
- 0008159615
- Id. at 158

73
- 0008160026
- Erlen, supra note 69, at 158
- (1958) Barbel Ihelder & Jean Piaget, The Growth of Logical Thinking

74
- 0008162225
- CRC, supra note 26

75
- 0008239770
- Id.

76
- 0008202984
- Id.

77
- 0008158865
- Minor's assent or dissent to medical treatment
- (1983) 102 J. Pediatrics , vol.169 , pp. 174
- Leiken, S.L.¹

78
- 0008200028
- See note 56 supra and accompanying text

79
- 0008162078
- In re Nikolas E., supra note 3

80
- 0008158866
- Walker et al., supra note 18, at 152

81
- 0008202985
- See Henggeler, supra note 4

82
- 0008242227
- Rosato, supra note 57

83
- 0008268872
- Id. at 90-92

84
- 0008239020
- See Henggeler, supra note 4

85
- 0008199731
- CRC, supra note 26

86
- 0008162079
- Rosato, supra note 57 at 49

87
- 0008200681
- CRC, supra note 26

88
- 0008158867
- Evans, supra note 2

89
- 0008197586
- Id. at 29

90
- 0008204176
- Id.

91
- 0008200682
- Id.

92
- 0002755303
- Involving children in decisions affecting their own welfare: Guidelines for professionals
- G.B. Melton et al. eds.
- (1983) Children's Competence to Consent , vol.235-260 , pp. 252
- Weithorn, L.A.¹

93
- 84984217483
- Competency for informed consent
- (1982) 5 Int'l J. L. and Psychiatry , vol.51 , pp. 53
- Tancredi, L.¹

94
- 0008268873
- See text supra at 11

95
- 0008242926
- Hafen & Hafen, supra note 17, at 464

96
- 0008202251
- Cardwell v. Bechtol, 724 S.W.2d 739, 745 (Tenn. 1987)

97
- 0008236304
- Melton, supra note 25, at 13

98
- 1542793853
- The child's evolving capacities
- Cynthia P. Cohen & Howard A. Davidson eds.
- (1990) Children's, Rights, in America: U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child Compared with United States Law , vol.19
- Garbarino, J.¹

99
- 0008242720
- Cardwell v. Bechtol, supra note 94

100
- 0008242721
- Id. at 838

101
- 0008200030
- Hafen & Hafen, supra note 17, at 465-66

102
- 0008239021
- note

103
- 0003364212
- The development of conceptual structures
- William Damon et al., eds.
- (1998) 2 Handbook of Child Psychology , vol.745 , pp. 757
- Case, R.¹

104
- 0026916479
- The role of the frontal lobes in the regulation of cognitive development
- (1992) 20 Brain and Cognition , vol.51
- Case, R.¹

105
- 0001746342
- A theory of cognitive development. The control and construction of hierarchies of skills
- Siegler, supra note 100
- (1980) 87 Psychological Review , vol.477
- Fischer, K.W.¹

106
- 0008199889
- Erlen, supra note 69

107
- 0020349163
- The competency of children and adolescents to make informed treatment decisions
- (1982) 53 Child Devel. , vol.1589
- Weithorn, L.A.¹ Campbell, S.B.²

108
- 0008160188
- Inhelder & Piaget, supra note 71, referred to these abilities as the stage of formal operations

109
- 0008158869
- Id.

110
- 0008162227
- Id.

111
- 0008162228
- Developmental competency
- (1986) 14 Bull. Am. Acad. Psychiatry and L. , vol.301 , pp. 305
- Billick, S.B.¹

112
- 0008236305
- Id. at 304-305

113
- 0008162083
- (1982) The Changing World of Legal Adolescence
- Zimring, F.E.¹

114
- 0008243326
- note

115
- 0000795363
- Children's attitudes toward their rights
- Eugeen Verhellen Ed.
- (1996) Monitoring Children's Rights , vol.241-250 , pp. 248
- Cherney, I.¹ Perry, N.W.²

116
- 0008162229
- Erlen, supra note 69

117
- 0018005206
- Minors' consent to treatment: A developmental perspective
- (1978) 9 Prof. Psychol. , vol.412
- Grisso, T.¹ Vierling, L.²

118
- 0008197423
- Id.

119
- 0008160882
- Id.

120
- 0008162230
- Weithorn & Campbell, supra note 104

121
- 0008268876
- Id. at 1595-96

122
- 0008204180
- In re Guardianship of Barry, supra note 52

123
- 0028772053
- Behind a boy's decision to forgo treatment
- June 13, at 12
- (1994) The New York Times

124
- 0008200684
- See text at 12-13

125
- 0025344001
- Consequences of empowering children to care for themselves
- (1990) 17 Pediatrician , vol.63
- Lewis, M.A.¹ Lewis, C.E.²

126
- 0008200173
- Id. at 65

127
- 0008202254
- Id.

128
- 0008243328
- Camp SuperKids' (sponsored annually by the American Lung Association of Nebraska)

129
- 0008239023
- Personal communication to the author

130
- 24444436419
- Irreversibility, nonfunctionality, and universality: Children's understanding of three components of a death concept
- John E. Schowalter et al. eds.
- (1987) Children and Death: Perspectives from Birth through Adolescence , vol.19-29 , pp. 23
- Speece, M.W.¹ Brent, S.B.²

131
- 0008197425
- Id.

132
- 0008242722
- NBC News Dateline, supra note 8

133
- 0008236786
- CRC, supra note 26

134
- 0008243329
- See 'Factors for the court to consider in implementing a 'fairness and reasonableness of the child's decision' standard: social fact and social framework as guiding principles' supra

135
- 0008242723
- See Walker et al., supra note 18 (distinguishing 'personhood' theory from 'protectionist' theory)

136
- 0008243330
- See Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, 393 U.S. 503, 511 (1969)

137
- 0008243331
- See text supra at 9

138
- 0008236306
- CRC, supra note 26

139
- 0008162232
- See text supra at 9

140
- 0008160716
- Monahan and Walker, supra, note 14

141
- 0008236307
- Id. at 174

142
- 0008162085
- Id. at 356

143
- 0008236787
- Id. at 345

144
- 0008200174
- Id. at 92

145
- 0008275905
- Id. at 346

146
- 0008200031
- Id. at 348

147
- 0008197426
- Id. at 349

148
- 0008159618
- Id.

149
- 0002102709
- Compliance research in pediatric and adolescent populations: Two decades of research
- Norman P. Krasnegor et al., eds.
- (1993) Developmental Aspects of Health Compliance Behavior , pp. 29-51
- Dunbar-Jacob, J.¹

150
- 0003887466
- (1996) Adaptation to Chronic Childhood Illness , vol.254
- Thompson Jr., R.J.¹ Gustafson, K.E.²

151
- 0008242229
- CRC, supra note 26

* 이 정보는 Elsevier사의 SCOPUS DB에서 KISTI가 분석하여 추출한 것입니다.