Grammar. For writing? A critical review of empirical evidence

British Journal of Educational Studies

Volumn 49, Issue 4, 2001, Pages 411-427

  Wyse, Dominic ^a  

^a LIVERPOOL JOHN MOORES UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

English teaching; Grammar teaching; Literacy teaching

Indexed keywords

EID: 0035638391     PISSN: 00071005     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1467-8527.t01-1-00185     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. ABRAHAMSON, R. F. (1977) The Effects of Formal Grammar Instruction vs. the Effects of Sentence Combining Instruction on Student Writing: a collection of evaluative abstracts of pertinent research documents (Houston, University of Houston).
2. BATEMAN, D. and ZIDONIS, F. (1966) The Effect of a Study of Transformational Grammar on the Writing of Ninth and Tenth Graders: * no. 6 in a series of research reports sponsored by the NCTE Committee on Research (Champagne, Illinois, National Council of Teachers of English).
3. BAIN, R., FITZGERALD, B. and TAYLOR, M. (1992) Looking into Language: Classroom Approaches to Knowledge About Language (London, Hodder and Stoughton).
4. BEARD, R. (1999) National Literacy Strategy: Review of Research and other Related Evidence (London, DfEE).
5. BURGESS, T. (1998) Mouse and Grammar: connecting use and structure in English teaching. Changing English, 5 (2), 103-113.
6. CAJKLER, W. (1999) Misconceptions in the NLS: national literacy strategy or no linguistic sense? Use of English, 50, (3), 214-227.
7. CARTER, R. (Ed.) (1990) Knowledge about Language and the Curriculum (London, Hodder and Stoughton).
8. COMBS, W. E. (1977) Sentence-combining Practice: Do gains in judgements of writing "quality" persist. Journal of Educational Research, 70, 318-321.
9. COX, B. (1995) Cox on the Battle for the English Curriculum (London, Hodder and Stoughton).
10. CZERNIEWSKA, P. (1992) Learning about Writing (Oxford, Blackwell).
11. DAHL, K. L. and FARNAN, N. (1998) Children's Writing: Perspectives from Research. Delaware: International Reading Association; Chicago: National Reading Conference.
12. DEPARTMENT FOR EDUCATION AND EMPLOYMENT (1998) The National Literacy Strategy: Framework for Teaching (London, DfEE).
13. DEPARTMENT FOR EDUCATION AND EMPLOYMENT (DfEE) (2000) The National Literacy Strategy: Grammar for Writing (London, DfEE).
14. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE, WELSH OFFICE, DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION FOR NORTHERN IRELAND, ASSESSMENT OF PERFORMANCE UNIT/GORMAN, T. P., WHITE, J., BROOKS, G., MACLURE, M. AND KISPAL, A. (1988) Language Performance in Schools: Review of APU Language Monitoring 1979-1983 (London, HMSO).
15. ELLEY, W. B. (1994) Grammar Teaching and Language Skill. In R. ASHER (Ed.) The Encyclopaedia of Language and Linguistics (Oxford, Pergamon).
16. ELLEY, W. B., BARHAM, I. H., LAMB, H. AND WYLLIE, M. (1976) The Role of Grammar in a Secondary School English Curriculum. Research in the Teaching of English, 10, 5-21.
17. FITZ-GIBBON, C. T. (1999) OfSTED is Inaccurate and Damaging: how did we let it happen? FORUM, 41 (1), 14-17.
18. FRASER, I. S. and HUDSON, L. M. (1978) Twenty-one Kicks at the Grammar Horse: Close-up: grammar and composition. English Journal, 67 (9), 49-54.
19. GRAVES, D. H. (1983) Writing: Teachers and Children at Work (Portsmouth, NH, Heinemann Educational).
20. HALL, N. (1987) The Emergence of Literacy (Sevenoaks, Hodder and Stoughton).
21. HARRIS, R. J. (1962) An experimental inquiry into the functions and value of formal grammar in the teaching of English, with special reference to the teaching of correct written English to children aged twelve to fourteen. PhD thesis, University of London.
22. HARSTE, J. C., WOODWARD, V. A. and BURKE, C. L. (1984) Language Stories and Literacy Lessons (Portsmouth, N.H, Heinemann Educational Books).
23. HARTWELL, P. (1985) Grammar, Grammars, and the Teaching of Grammar. College English, 47, 105-127.
24. HAWKINS, E. (1992) Awareness of Language/Knowledge about Language in the Curriculum in England and Wales: an historical note on twenty years of curricular debate. Language Awareness, 1 (1), 5-17.
25. HER MAJESTY'S INSPECTORATE (1992) English: Key Stages 1, 2 and 3: A Report by H M Inspectorate on the Second Year, 1990-91 (London, Department of Education and Science).
26. HERRIMAN, M. (1994) Literacy and Metalinguistic Awareness. In R. ASHER (Ed.) The Encyclopaedia of Language and Linguistics (Oxford, Pergamon).
27. HILLOCKS, G. Jr. (1984) What Works in Teaching Composition: A Meta-analysis of Experimental Treatment Studies. American Journal of Education, 93 (1), 133-170.
28. HILLOCKS, G. Jr. (1986) Research on Written Composition: New Directions for Teaching (Urbana, Illinois, ERIC Clearinghouse on Reading and Communication Skills).
29. HILLOCKS, G., Jr, and SMITH, M. W. (1991) Grammar and Usage. In J. FLOOD, J. M. JENSEN, D. LAPP and J. R. SQUIRE (Eds) Handbook of Research on Teaching the English Language Arts (591-603) (New York, Macmillan). http://www.official-documents.co.uk/document/ofsted/ped/ped.htm
30. HUDSON, R. Grammar Teaching and Writing Skills: the research evidence [online] Department of Phonetics and Linguistics, UCL, Gower Street, London. [Cited August 2000] Available from: http://www.phon.ucl.ac.uk/home/dick/writing.htm
31. MASON, M. and MASON, B. (1997) Breakthrough to Learning: Linguistics in the service of mainstream education University of Central England (UCE) Faculty of Education Papers: Issues in Education Series, 2 (Birmingham, UCE).
32. MASON, M., MASON, R. and QUAYLE, T. (1992) Illuminating English: how explicit language teaching improved public examination results in a comprehensive school. Educational Studies, 18, 341-53.
33. MATZEN, R. N. Jr. and others [information as given in secondary source] (1995) The role of traditional grammar instruction in the teaching of writing: a selected, annotated bibliography. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the conference on college composition and communication. March 23-25 (Washington DC).
34. McCAULEY, W. J. (1947) The Difficulty of Grammar. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 17, 153-162.
35. McQUADE, F. (1980) Examining a Grammar Course: The Rationale and the Result. English Journal, 69, 26-30.
36. MELLON, J. C. (1969) Transformational Sentence Combining: A Method for Enhancing the Development of Syntactic Fluency in English Composition: No. 10 in a series of research reports sponsored by the NCTE Committee on Research. (Urbana, Illinois, National Council of Teachers of English).
37. MITCHELL, R., BRUMFIT, C. and HOOPER, J. (1994) 'Knowledge about Language': policy, rationales and practices. Research Papers in Education, 9 (2), 183-205.
38. MORENBERG, M., DAIKER, D. and KEREK, A. (1978) Sentence Combining at the College Level: An experimental study. Research in the Teaching of English, 12, 245-256.
39. MORTIMORE, P. and GOLDSTEIN, H. (1996) The Teaching of Reading in 45 Inner London Primary Schools: A critical examination of OFSTED research (London, Institute of Education, University of London).
40. O'HARE, F. (1973) Sentence Combining: Improving Student Writing without Formal Grammar Instruction. No. 15 in a series of research reports sponsored by the NCTE Committee on Research (Urbana, National Council of Teachers of English).
41. OFFICE FOR STANDARDS IN EDUCATION (1995) English: A review of inspection findings 1993/94 (London, HMSO).
42. OFFICE FOR STANDARDS IN EDUCATION. A Review of Primary Schools, 1994-1998. [online] August 1999. [cited 11-7-00] Available from: http://www.official-documents.co.uk/document/ofsted/ped/ped.htm
43. POULSON, L., RADNOR, H. and TURNER-BISSETT, R. (1996) From Policy to Practice: Language Education, English Teaching and Curriculum Reform in Secondary Schools in England. Language and Education, 10 (1), 33-46.
44. QUALIFICATIONS AND CURRICULUM AUTHORITY (1998a) Standards at Key Stage 2: English, Mathematics and Science: Report on the 1997 National Curriculum Assessments for 11-year-olds (London, SCAA).
45. QUALIFICATIONS AND CURRICULUM AUTHORITY (1998b) Standards at Key Stage 2: English, Mathematics and Science: Report on the 1998 National Curriculum Assessments for 11-year-olds (London, SCAA).
46. QUALIFICATIONS AND CURRICULUM AUTHORITY (1998c) Key Stage 2: English Tests Mark Schemes: 1998 (London, SCAA).
47. QUALIFICATIONS AND CURRICULUM AUTHORITY (1998d) The Grammar Papers: Perspectives on the teaching of grammar in the national curriculum (London, QCA).
48. QUALIFICATIONS AND CURRICULUM AUTHORITY (1999) Key Stage 2: English Tests Mark Schemes: 1999 (London, SCAA).
49. QUALIFICATIONS AND CURRICULUM AUTHORITY (2000a) Standards at Key Stage 2: English, Mathematics and Science: Report on the 1999 National Curriculum Assessments for 11-year-olds (London, SCAA).
50. QUALIFICATIONS AND CURRICULUM AUTHORITY (2000b) Key Stage 2: English Tests Mark Schemes: 2000 (London, SCAA).
51. SCHOOL CURRICULUM AND ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY (1995) Report on the 1995 Key Stage 2 Tests and Tasks in English, Mathematics and Science (London, SCAA).
52. SCHOOL CURRICULUM AND ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY (1996) Key Stage 2 Tests 1996: English Mark Schemes (London, SCAA).
53. SCHOOL CURRICULUM AND ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY (1997) Key Stage 2: English Tests Mark Schemes: 1997 (London, SCAA).
54. TOMLINSON, D. (1994) Errors in the Research into the Effectiveness of Grammar Teaching. English in Education, 28 (1), 20-26.
55. TORDOIR, A. C. and HILDO, W. (1979) Het grammatica-onderwijs in Nederland: een researchoversicht betreffende de effecten van grammatica-onderwijs en een verslag van een onderzoek naar de praktijk van dit onderwijs in nederland. 's-gravenhage: staatsuitgeverij.
56. WALMSLEY, J. (1984) The Uselessness of Formal Grammar'? Committee for Linguistics in Education: Working Paper No. 2 (London, University of London, Department of Phonetics and Linguistics).
57. WEAVER, C. (1996) Teaching Grammar in Context (Portsmouth, NH, Heinemann).
58. WYSE, D. (1998) Primary Writing (Buckingham, Open University Press).
59. WYSE, D. (2000) Phonics: The Whole Story?: A critical review of empirical evidence. Educational Studies, 26 (3), 355-364.
60. WYSE, D. and JONES, R. (2001) Teaching English, Language and Literacy (London, RoutledgeFalmer).