QSAR for Boiling Points of "Small" Sulfides. Are the "High-Quality Structure-Property-Activity Regressions" the Real High Quality QSAR Models?

Journal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences

Volumn 41, Issue 4, 2001, Pages 1022-1027

  Zefirov, N S ^a   Palyulin, V A ^a  

^a MOSCOW STATE UNIVERSITY   (Russian Federation)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE;

BOILING POINTS;

COMPUTER SIMULATION; HYDROCARBONS; HYDROPHOBICITY; REGRESSION ANALYSIS; STRUCTURE (COMPOSITION);

SULFUR COMPOUNDS;

EID: 0035412809     PISSN: 00952338     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1021/ci0001637     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. Hansch, C.; Leo, A. Exploring QSAR. Fundamentals and Applications in Chemistry and Biology, American Chemical Society: Washington DC, 1995.
2. Kubinyi, H. QSAR: Hansen Analysis and Related Approaches; Mannhold, R., Krogsgaard-Larsen, R. Timmerman, H., Eds.; VCH: Weinheim, Germany, 1993.
3. Silipo, C. QSAR: Rational Approaches to the Design of Bioactive Compounds; Silipo, C., Victoria, A., Eds.; Pharmacochemistry Library; Timmerman, H., Eds.; Elsevier: 1991; Vol. 16.
4. Gordeeva, E. V.; Molchanova, M. S.; Zefirov, N. S. General Methodology and Computer Program for the Exhaustive Restoring of Chemical Structures by Molecular Connectivity Indexes. Solution of the Inverse Problem in QSAR/QSPR. Tetrahedron Comput. Methodol. 1999, 3, 389-415.
5. Skvortsova, M. I.; Baskin, I. I.; Slovokhotova, O. I.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Inverse Problem in QSAR/QSPR Studies for the Case of Topological Indices Characterizing Molecular Shape (Kier Indices), J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1993, 33, 630-634.
6. Zefirov, N. S.; Palyulin, V. A.; Radchenko, E. V. Problem of generation of structures with predetermined properties. Solution of inverse QSAR problem for Balaban's centric index (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 316, 921-924 (Chem. Abstr. 115, 48463).
7. Zefirov, N. S.; Palyulin, V. A.; Radchenko, E. V. Problem of generation of structures with predetermined properties. Solution of inverse QSAR problem for Balaban's centric index (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 316, 921-924 (Chem. Abstr. 115, 48463).
8. Skvortsova, M. I.; Baskin, I. I.; Slovokhotova, O. I.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Inverse Problem in QSAR Studies for the Case of Equations, Containing any Topological Indices (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1996, 346, 497-500 (Chem. Abstr. 125, 166953).
9. Skvortsova, M. I.; Baskin, I. I.; Slovokhotova, O. I.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Inverse Problem in QSAR Studies for the Case of Equations, Containing any Topological Indices (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1996, 346, 497-500 (Chem. Abstr. 125, 166953).
10. Skvortsova, M. I.; Slovokhotova, O. I.; Baskin, I. I.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Inverse Problem in QSAR Studies for the Case of Informational Topological Indices (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1997, 357, 72-74 (Chem. Abstr. 128, 216988).
11. Skvortsova, M. I.; Slovokhotova, O. I.; Baskin, I. I.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Inverse Problem in QSAR Studies for the Case of Informational Topological Indices (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1997, 357, 72-74 (Chem. Abstr. 128, 216988).
12. Hosoya, H.; Gotoh, M.; Murakami, M.; Ikeda, S. Topological Index and Thermodynamical Properties. 5. How Can We Explain the Topological Dependency of Thermodynamic Properties of Alkanes with Topology of Graphs? J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1999, 39, 192-196.
13. See, however, excellent discussion for QSAR of boiling points of structurally extended set of saturated hydrocarbons in ref 11.
14. Rücker, G.; Rücker, C. On Topological Indices, Boiling Points, and Cycloalkanes. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1999, 39, 788-802.
15. Randié, M.; Basak, S. Construction of High-Quality Structure-Property-Activity Regression: The Boiling Points of Sulfides. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 2000, 40, 899-905.
16. Balaban, A. T.; Kier, L. B.; Joshi, N. Correlation between Chemical Structure and Normal Boiling Points of Acyclic Ethers, Peroxides, Acetals, and Their Sulfur Analogues. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1992, 32, 237-244.
17. 12 is incorrect, and we have used the structure of 1-ethylpropyl methyl sulfide (entry 75, Table 2, ref 13). However the calculated values for connectivity indices are correct.
18. Antipin, I. S.; Arslanov, N. A.; Palyulin, V. A.; Konovalov, A. I.; Zefirov, N. S. Solvation Topological Index. Topological Description of Dispersion Interactions (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. SSSR 1991, 316, 925-927 (Chem. Abstr. 115, 91390).
19. Antipin, I. S.; Arslanov, N. A.; Palyulin, V. A.; Konovalov, A. I.; Zefirov, N. S. Solvation Topological Index. Topological Description of Dispersion Interactions (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. SSSR 1991, 316, 925-927 (Chem. Abstr. 115, 91390).
20. Antipin, I. S.; Arslanov, N. A.; Palyulin, V. A.; Konovalov, A. I.; Zefirov, N. S. Prognosis of Enthalpy of Nonspecific Solvation of Organic Nonelectrolytes (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 331, 173-176(Chem. Abstr. 120, 133743).
21. Antipin, I. S.; Arslanov, N. A.; Palyulin, V. A.; Konovalov, A. I.; Zefirov, N. S. Prognosis of Enthalpy of Nonspecific Solvation of Organic Nonelectrolytes (Russ.). Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 331, 173-176(Chem. Abstr. 120, 133743).
22. Barysz, M.; Jashari, G.; Lall, R. S.; Srivastava, V. K.; Trinajstic, N. On the Distance Matrix of Molecules Containing Heteroatoms. In Applications of Chemical Topology and Graph Theory; King, R. B., Ed.; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1983; pp 222-227.
23. Balaban, A. T. Chemical Graphs. 48. Topological Index J for Heteroatom-Containing Molecules Taking into Account Periodicities of Element Properties. Math. Chem. (MATCH) 1986, 21, 115-122.
24. Ivanciuc, O.; Ivanciuc, T.; Cabrol-Bass, D.; Balaban, A. T. Comparison of Weighting Schemes for Molecular Graph Descriptors: Application in Quantitative Structure - Retention Relationship Models for Alkylphenols in Gas-Liquid Chromalography. J. Chem. Inf. Comput, Sci. 2000, 40, 732-743.
25. Ivanciuc, O.; Ivanciuc, T.; Balaban, A. T. Design of Topological Indices. Part 10. Parameters Bused on Electronegativity and Covulent Radius for the Computation of Molecular Graph Descriptors for Heteroatom-Containing Molecules. J. Chem. Inf. Comput, Sci. 1998. 38, 395-401,
26. 22-28 which calculates several hundreds of different descriptors,
27. Pivina, T. S.; Sukhachev, D. V.; Maslova, L. K.; Shlyapochnikov, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Studies of Correlations for Structure-thermal Stability Parameters of Nitro Compounds Based on the QSPR Approach. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 330, 468-472 (Chem. Abstr. 120, 54070).
28. Pivina, T. S.; Sukhachev, D. V.; Maslova, L. K.; Shlyapochnikov, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Studies of Correlations for Structure-thermal Stability Parameters of Nitro Compounds Based on the QSPR Approach. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 330, 468-472 (Chem. Abstr. 120, 54070).
29. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Shlyapochnikov, V. A.; Petrov, E. A.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Study of Quantitative Structureimpact Sensitivity Relations for Organic Polynitrocompounds. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 328, 188-189 (Chem. Abstr. 118. 257697).
30. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Shlyapochnikov, V. A.; Petrov, E. A.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Study of Quantitative Structureimpact Sensitivity Relations for Organic Polynitrocompounds. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1993, 328, 188-189 (Chem. Abstr. 118. 257697).
31. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Zhokhova, N. I.; Zefirov, N. S.; Zeman, S. QSPR Approach to Calculating the Rate Constants of Homolysis of Nitro Compounds in Different Aggregation States. I. Gas State. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1995, 1653-1656(Chem. Abstr. 124, 260218).
32. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Zhokhova, N. I.; Zefirov, N. S.; Zeman, S. QSPR Approach to Calculating the Rate Constants of Homolysis of Nitro Compounds in Different Aggregation States. I. Gas State. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1995, 1653-1656(Chem. Abstr. 124, 260218).
33. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Zhokhova, N. I.; Zefirov, N. S.; Zeman, S. QSPR Approach to Calculating the Rate Constants of Homolysis of Nitro Compounds in Different Aggregation States. 2. Liquid Stale, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1995, 1657-1660 (Chem. Abstr. 124, 260219).
34. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Zhokhova, N. I.; Zefirov, N. S.; Zeman, S. QSPR Approach to Calculating the Rate Constants of Homolysis of Nitro Compounds in Different Aggregation States. 2. Liquid Stale, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1995, 1657-1660 (Chem. Abstr. 124, 260219).
35. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Zhokhova, N. I.; Zefirov, N. S.; Zeman, S. QSPR Approach to Calculating the Rate Constants of Homolysis of Nitro Compounds in Different Aggregation States. 3. Solid State. Izv. Akad, Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1995. 1661-1665 (Chem. Abstr. 124, 260220).
36. Sukhachev, D. V.; Pivina, T. S.; Zhokhova, N. I.; Zefirov, N. S.; Zeman, S. QSPR Approach to Calculating the Rate Constants of Homolysis of Nitro Compounds in Different Aggregation States. 3. Solid State. Izv. Akad, Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1995. 1661-1665 (Chem. Abstr. 124, 260220).
37. Petelin, D. E.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Topological Indexes Based on Weights of the Molecular Graph Vertexes for QSAR and QSPR Studies. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1992, 324, 1019-1022 (Chem. Abstr. 118, 38223).
38. Petelin, D. E.; Palyulin, V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. Topological Indexes Based on Weights of the Molecular Graph Vertexes for QSAR and QSPR Studies. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1992, 324, 1019-1022 (Chem. Abstr. 118, 38223).
39. Zefirov, N. S.; Petelin, D. E.; Palyulin, V. A.; McFarland, J. W. Quantitative Relationship between the Structure of 2-Substituted 1,2,4- Triazine-3,5(2H,4H)-diones and their Anticoccidial Activity. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1992, 327, 504-508 (Chem. Abstr. 118, 182798).
40. Zefirov, N. S.; Petelin, D. E.; Palyulin, V. A.; McFarland, J. W. Quantitative Relationship between the Structure of 2-Substituted 1,2,4- Triazine-3,5(2H,4H)-diones and their Anticoccidial Activity. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. 1992, 327, 504-508 (Chem. Abstr. 118, 182798).
41. Hosoya, H. Topological Index. A Newly Proposed Quantity Characterizing the Topological Nature of Structural Isomers of Saturated Hydrocarbons. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1971, 44, 2332-2339,
42. Wiener, H. Structural Determination of Paraffin Boiling Points. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1947, 69, 17-20.
43. Tratch, S. S.; Stankevitch, M. I.; Zefirov, N. S. Combinatorial Models and Algorithms in Chemistry. The Expanded Wiener Number - a Novel Topological Index. J. Comput. Chem. 1990, 11, 899-908.
44. Randić, M. On Characterization of Molecular Branching. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1975, 97, 6609-6615,
45. 12 M. Randić (personal communication) clarified that Table 1 is based, in fact, on n = 19 but not on 21 compounds, because two compounds, l und 20, were eliminated as outliers.
46. One has to be careful in recalculating the generalized flexible connectivity indices using Table 4. ref 12. because the formulas of the entries 4, 9, 14, 15, 19. and 21 contain misprints.
47. Molchanova, M. S.; Shcherbukhin, V. V.; Zefirov, N. S. Computer Generation of Molecular Structures by SMOG Program. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1996. 36, 888-899.
48. Molchanova, M. S.; Zefirov, N. S. Irredundant Generation of Isomeric Molecular Structures with some Known Fragments. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1998, 38, 8-22.
49. Golovnya, R. V., Garbuzov, V. G.; Misharina, T.A. Gas-chromatografic Characteristic of Sulfur Containing Compounds. 3, n-Alkyl-iso-alkyl Sulfides (Russ.). Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1978, 387-397.
50. 12 also demonstrates a better correlation for nonlinear (quadratic) regression. Better correlation for logarithmic scale was even discussed in ref 39, and this point probably needs more careful investigation,
51. Liu, S.; Cao, C.; Li, Z. Approach to Estimation and Prediction for Normal Boiling Point (NBP) of Alkanes Based on a Novel Molecular Distance-Edge (MDE) Vector. λ. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1998, 38, 387-394.
52. Golovnya, R. V.; Misharina, T. A.; Gurbuiov, V. G. Gas-chromatografic Characteristic of Sulfur Containing Compounds. 6. Diiso-Alifatic sulfides (Russ.). Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR (Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR) 1979, 1029-1032.
53. 12
54. Clarification of a meaning of connectivity indices sec ref 43; index range see ref 44,
55. Kier, L. B.; Hall, L. H. Intermolecular Accessibility; The Meaning of Molecular Connectivity. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 2000, 40, 792- 795.
56. Gutman, I.; Araujo, O.; Morales, D. A. Bounds for the Randić Connectivity Index. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 2000, 40, 593-598.
57. Stankevich, I. V.; Stankevich, M. I.; Zefirov, N. S.Topological indices in organic chemistry (Russ.). Usp. Khim. (Russ. Chem. Rev.) 1988. 57, 337-366 (Chem. Abstr. 125, 166953).
58. Stankevich, I. V.; Stankevich, M. I.; Zefirov, N. S.Topological indices in organic chemistry (Russ.). Usp. Khim. (Russ. Chem. Rev.) 1988. 57, 337-366 (Chem. Abstr. 125, 166953).
59. We mean a general case; the number of extra variables depends on a number of atom types.
60. Baskin, I. I.; Palyulin. V. A.; Zefirov, N. S. A Neural Device for Searching Direct Correlations between Structures and Properties of Chemical Compounds. J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1997, 37, 715-721.