Learning to bridge the gap between science-based decision support and the practice of farming: Evolution in paradigms of model-based research and intervention from design to dialogue

Australian Journal of Agricultural Research

Volumn 52, Issue 5, 2001, Pages 549-571

  McCown, R L ^a  

^a CSIRO   (Australia)

Author keywords

Action research; DSS; Systems

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE; AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH; DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM; LAND MANAGEMENT;

EID: 0035018045     PISSN: 00049409     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1071/AR00119     Document Type: Review

References (111)

1. Ackoff RL (1973) Science in the systems age: beyond IE, OR, and MS. Operations Research 21, 661-671.
2. Ackoff RL (1979 (The future of operational research is past. In 'Critical systems thinking: directed readings'. (Eds RL Flood, MC Jackson) pp. 41-58. (John Wiley and Sons: Chichester)
3. Ackoff RL, Emery FE (1972) 'On purposeful systems.' (Tavistock Publications: London)
4. Agnew NM, Ford KM, Hayes PJ (1997) Expertise in context: personally constructed, socially selected, and reality-relevant. In 'Expertise in context: human and machine'. (Eds PJ Feltovich, KM Ford, RR Hoffman) pp. 219-244. (AAA Press/MIT Press: Menlo Park, CA)
5. Agrawal RC, Heady EO (1972) 'Operations research methods for agricultural decisions.' (Iowa State University Press: Ames, IA)
6. Alavi M, Henderson JC (1981) Evolutionary strategy for implementing a decision support system. Management Science 27, 1309-1323.
7. Argyris C, Putnam R, Smith DM (1985) 'Action science.' (Jossey-Bass: San Francisco, CA)
8. Argyris C, Schon DA (1974) 'Theory in practice: increasing professional effectiveness.' (Jossey-Bass Pubs: San Francisco, CA)
9. Ascough JC, Deer-Ascough LA (1994) Integrating evaluation into decision support system development. American Society of Agricultural-Engineers Paper No. 943029, American Society of Agricultural Engineers (ASAE), St Joseph.
10. Barrett JR, Nearing MA (1998) Humanization of decision support using information from simulations. In 'Agricultural systems modeling and simulation'. (Eds RM Peart, RB Curry) pp. 1-18. (Marcel Dekker: New York)
11. Bennett D, Bowden JW, Sewell PL (1975) Implementation of a fertilizer decision model in farm advisory services. In 'Models for modern management: better decisions through operations research. Proceedings of the 2nd National Conference of the Australian Society for Operations Research'. Sydney.
12. Berg M (1997) 'Rationalizing medical work: decision-support techniques and medical practices.' (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
13. Bernstein RJ (1985) 'Habermas and modernity.' (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
14. Blaikie N (1993) 'Approaches to social enquiry.' (Blackwell: Cambridge)
15. Brocklesby J (1997) Becoming multimethodology literate: an assessment of the cognitive difficulties of working across paradigms. In 'Multimethodology'. (Eds J Mingers, A Gill) pp. 189-216. (John Wiley and Sons: Chichester)
16. Busch L, Lacy WB (1986) 'The agricultural scientific enterprise: a system in transition.' (Westview Press: Boulder, CO)
17. Case HCM, Williams DB (1957) 'Fifty years of farm management.' (University of Illinois Press: Urbana, IL)
18. Caws P (1988) 'Structuralism: a philosophy for the human sciences.' (Humanities Press International: Atlantic Highlands, NJ)
19. Checkland PB (1981) 'Systems thinking, systems practice.' (John Wiley and Sons: Chichester)
20. Checkland PB (1983) OR and the systems movement: mapping and conflicts. Journal of the Operational Research Society 34, 661-675.
21. Checkland PB, Scholes J (1990) 'Soft systems methodology and action.' (John Wiley and Sons: Chichester)
22. Churchman CW (1964) Managerial acceptance of scientific recommendations. California Management Review 7, 31-39.
23. Churchman CW, Ackoff RL, Arnoff EL (1957) 'Introduction to operations research.' (John Wiley and Sons: New York)
24. Clancey WJ (1997) 'Situated cognition: on human knowledge and computer representations.' (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)
25. Collins HM (1990) 'Artificial experts: social knowledge and intelligent machines.' (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
26. Collins HM, Kusch M (1998) 'The shape of actions: what humans and machines can do.' (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
27. Cooke P (1994) Farmers give research wish list. Farming Ahead 26, 3.
28. Coulson RN, Saunders MC (1987) Computer-assisted decision-making as applied to entomology. Annual Review of Entomologyl 32, 415-437.
29. Dando MR, Bennett PG (1981) A Kuhnian crisis in management science? Journal of the Operational Research Society 32, 91-103.
30. Dent JB (1994) The human response: enabling technologies for land use and resource management. In 'Proceedings of the 5th International Congress for Computer Technology in Agriculture'. Churchill College, University of Cambridge and the Royal International Agricultural Exhibition, National Agricultural Centre, Stoneleigh Park, Warwickshire. pp. 40-45. (Royal Agricultural Society of England, National Agricultural Centre: Kenilworth)
31. Dent JB, Anderson JR (1971) Systems, management, and agriculture. In 'Systems analysis in agricultural management'. (Eds JB Dent, JR Anderson) pp. 3-14. (JohnWiley and Sons: Sydney)
32. Dillon JL (1979) An evaluation of the state of affairs in farm management. South African Journal of Agricultural Economics 1, 7-13.
33. Dillon JL (1992) 'The farm as a purposeful system.' Miscellaneous Publication No. 10. Department of Agricultural Economics and Business Management (University of New England: Armidale, NSW)
34. Donnelly JR, Moore AD, Freer M (1997) GRAZPLAN: Decision Support Systems for Australian Grazing Enterprises-I. Overview of the GRAZPLAN Project and a Description of the MetAccess and LambAlive DSS. Agricultural Systems 54, 57-76.
35. Doyle, CJ (1990) Application of systems theory to farm planning and control: modelling resource allocation. In: 'Systems theory applied to agriculture and the food chain'. (Eds JGW Jones, PR Street) pp. 89-112. (Elsevier Applied Science: London)
36. Dreyfus HL (1994) 'What computers still can't do: a critique of artificial reason.' (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
37. Dreyfus HL (1991) 'Being-in-the-world: a commentary on Heidegger's Being and Time, Division I.' (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
38. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Ethics: Varieties of Consequentialism. Britannica© CD 2000, 1994-1998. (Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc.)
39. Frost FM (2000) Value orientations: impact and implications in the extension of complex farming systems. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 511-518.
40. Gibbons M, Limoges C, Nowotny H, Schwartzman S, Scott P, Trow M (1994) 'The new production of knowledge: the dynamics of science and research in contemporary societies.' (Sage: London)
41. Heady EO, Diesslin HG, Jensen HR, Johnson GL (1958) 'Agricultural adjustment problems in a growing economy.' (Iowa State College Press: Ames, IA)
42. Hoag DL, Ascough JC, Frasier WM (1999) Farm computer adoption in the Great Plains. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 31, 57-67.
43. Habermas, J (1984) 'The theory of communicative action. Volume I: Reason and the rationalization of society.' (Beacon Press: Boston, MA)
44. Hochman Z, Courts JA, Carberry PS, McCown RL (2000) The FARMSCAPE experience: Simulations aid participative learning in risky farming systems in Australia. In 'Cow up a tree: learning and knowing processes for change in agriculture. Case studies from industrialised countries'. (Eds M Cerf, D Gibbon, B Hubert, R Ison, J Jiggins, MS Paine, J Proost, N Roling) pp. 175-188. (INRA Editions: Versailles).
45. Hodges HF, Whisler FD, Bridges SM, Reddy KR (1998) Simulation in crop management: GOSSYM/COMAX. In 'Agricultural systems modeling and simulation'. (Eds RM Peart, RB Curry) pp. 235-281. (Marcel Dekker: New York)
46. Hofman G, Salomez J (2000) Nitrogen and water - decision support systems. In 'Management of nitrogen and water in potato production'. (Eds AJ Haverkort, DKL Mackerron) pp. 219-261. (Wageningen Press: Wageningen)
47. Howard RA (1963) The practicality gap Management Science. Management Science 14, 503-507
48. Hutton RF (1965) Operations research techniques in farm management: survey and appraisal. Journal of Farm Economics 47, 1400-1414.
49. Ison R, Russell D (2000) 'Agricultural extension and rural development: breaking out of traditions.' (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)
50. Jantsch E (1972) 'Technological planning and social futures.' (Cassell/ Associated Business Programmes: London)
51. Jantsch E (1975) 'Design for evolution.' (George Brazilian New York)
52. Jarvie IC (1972) 'Concepts and society.' (Routledge and Kegan Paul: London)
53. Jayaratna N (1986) Normative information model-based systems analysis and design (NIMSAD): a framework for understanding and evaluating methodologies. Journal of Applied Systems Analysis 13, 73-87.
54. Johnson GL (1962) Value problems in farm management. Journal of Agricultural Economics 14, 13-31.
55. Johnson M (1987) 'The body in the mind: the bodily basis of meaning, imagination, and reason.' (University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL)
56. Johnson DM, Erneling CE (1997) 'The future of the cognitive revolution.' (Oxford University Press: Oxford)
57. Jones P (1989) Agricultural applications of expert systems concepts. Agricultural Systems 31, 3-18.
58. Keating BA, McCown RL, Verburg K, Probert ME (1999) Advances in farming systems analyses. Presentation at the Third International Symposium on Systems Approaches for Agricultural Development (SAAD-III), Lima, Peru.
59. Keen PGW (1987) Decision support systems: the next decade. Decision Support Systems 3, 253-265.
60. Laszlo, E (1996) 'The systems view of the world: a holistic vision for our time.' (Hampton Press: Cresskill, NJ)
61. Lave J (1988) 'Cognition in practice: mind, mathematics and culture in everyday life.' (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)
62. Lave J, Wenger E (1991) 'Situated learning: legitimate peripheral participation.' (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)
63. Lloyd A (2000) Jimbour: Why modelling matters. Queensland Country Life July 13, 27.
64. Makeham JP, Bird JG (1969) 'Problems of change in Australian agriculture.' (University of New England: Armidale, NSW)
65. Malcolm LR (1990) Fifty years of farm management in Australia: survey and review. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics 58, 24-55.
66. Malcolm LR (2000) Farm management economic analysis: a few disciplines, a few perspectives, a few figurings, a few futures. Paper presented at the 44th Annual Conference of the Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society, University of Sydney.
67. Maxwell JA, Randall A (1989) Ecological economic modeling in a pluralistic, participatory society. Ecological Economics 1, 233-249.
68. McArthur DS (1980) Decision scientists, decision makers, and the gap. Interfaces 10, 110-113.
69. McCown RL, Carberry PS, Foale MA, Hochman Z, Courts JA, Dalgliesh NP (1998) The FARMSCAPE approach to farming systems research. In 'Proceedings of the 9th Australian Agronomy Conference'. Wagga Wagga, NSW. pp. 633-636.
70. Mingers J (1997) Mixing methods in practice: a transformation-competence perspective. In 'Multimethodology: the theory and practice of combining management science methodologies'. (Eds J Mingers, A Gill) pp. 1-28. (John Wiley and Sons: Chichester)
71. MODSS (1998) Multiple objective decision making for land, water, and environmental management. In 'Proceedings of the First International Conference on Multiple Objective Decision Support Systems MODSS for Land, Water and Environmental Management: Concepts, Approaches, and Applications/International Conference on Multiple Objective Decision Support Systems for Land Water and Environmental Management: Concepts, Approaches, and Applications'. (Lewis Publishers: Boca Raton, FL)
72. Naylor TH (1982) Decision support systems or whatever happened to MIS? Interfaces 12, 92-94.
73. Oquist P (1978) The epistemology of action research. Acta Sociologica 21, 143-163
74. Parker C (1999) Decision support systems: lessons from past failures. Farm Management 10, 273-289
75. Passioura JB (1996) Simulation models: science, snake oil, education or engineering? Agronomy Journal 88, 690-694.
76. Peacock WJ (1980) SIRATAC: management system for cotton. Agricultural Gazette 91, 7-10. (New South Wales Dept. of Agriculture)
77. Plant RE (1997) Implementation of cotton crop management expert systems: lessons from 10 years experience. AI Applications 11, 33-39.
78. Plant RE, Stone NS (1991 ) 'Knowledge-based systems in agriculture.' (McGraw Hill: New York)
79. Popper KR (1994) 'Knowledge and the body-mind problem.' (Routledge: New York)
80. Popper KR (1976) The logic of the social sciences. In 'The Positivist Dispute in German Sociology'. (Eds TW Adorno, H Albert, R Dahrendorf, J Habemas, H Pilot, KR Popper) pp. 87-104. (Heinemann: London)
81. Popper KR (1972) 'Objective knowledge: an evolutionary approach.' (Clarendon Press: Oxford)
82. Redman DA (1991) Sir Karl Popper's philosophy of the social sciences: a disjointed whole. In 'Economics and the philosophy of science'. pp. 103-141. (Oxford University Press: New York)
83. Roling NG, Jiggins J (1998) The ecological knowledge system. In 'Facilitating sustainable agriculture: participatory learning and adaptive management in times of environmental uncertainty'. (Eds NG Roling, MAE Wagemakers) pp. 283-311. (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)
84. Roling NG (1988) 'Extension science: information systems in agricultural development.' (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)
85. Ryle G (1949) 'The concept of mind.' (Penguin Books: New York)
86. Savage LJ (1972) 'The foundations of statistics.' (Dover Publications: New York)
87. Schon DA (1983) 'The reflective practitioner: how professionals think in action.' (Basic Books: New York)
88. Searle J (1995) 'The construction of social reality.' (Free Press: New York)
89. Searle JR (1984) 'Minds, brains, and science.' (Harvard University Press: MA)
90. Searle JR (1998) 'Mind, language, and society: philosophy in the real world.' (Basic Books: New York)
91. Sellars W (1963) Philosophy and the scientific image of man. In 'Science, perception, and reality'. (Routledge and Kegan Paul: London)
92. Silver EA, Vidai VV, de Warra D (1980) A tutorial on heuristic methods European Journal of Operational Research 5, 153-162.
93. Simon HA (1979) From substantive to procedural rationality. In 'Philosophy and economic theory'. (Eds F Hahn, M Hollis) pp. 65-86.(Oxford University Press: Oxford)
94. Simon HA (1996) 'The sciences of the artificial.' 3rd edn (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
95. Sorensen JT, Kristensen ES (1992) Systemic modelling: a research methodology in livestock farming. In 'Global appraisal of livestock farming systems and study on their organizational levels: concept, methodology and results'. Commission of European Communities. pp. 45-57.
96. Sprague RH (1980) A framework for the development of decision support systems. Management Information Systems Quarterly, 1-26.
97. Sprague RH, Watson HJ (1996) 'Decision support for management.' (Prentice-Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ)
98. Stabell CB (1987) Decision support systems: alternative perspectives and schools. Decision Support Systems 3, 243-251.
99. Stich Stephen (1991) 'From folk psychology to cognitive science: the case against belief.' (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)
100. Suchman LA (1987) 'Plans and situated action: the problem of human-machine interaction.' (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)
101. Taylor HC (1919) 'Agricultural economics.' (Macmillan: New York)
102. Taylor HC, Taylor AD (1952) 'The story of agricultural economics in the United States, 1840-1932.' (Iowa Sate College Press: Ames, IA)
103. Trist E (1981) 'The evolution of socio-technical systems: a conceptual framework and action research program.' (Ontario Ministry of Labour: Toronto)
104. Turner S (1994) 'The social theory of practice: tradition, tacit knowledge, and presuppositions.' (Polity Press: Oxford)
105. Ulrich W (1983) 'Critical heuristics of social planning.' (Wiley and Sons: New York)
106. Vaile M (1999) Moving forward in natural resource management. 'Fenner Conference - Visions of Future Landscapes'. Canberra, May 1999.
107. van Keulen H, Penning de Vries WT (1993) Farming under uncertainty: terminology and techniques. International Crop Science I, 139-143.
108. Webster JPG (1990) Reflections on the economics of decision support systems. In 'Integrated decision support systems in agriculture-successful practical applications. Proceedings of the 3rd International Congress for Computer Technology'. Frankfurt aM-Bad Soden, 1990. (Ed. F Kuhlmann).
109. Weizenbaum J (1976) 'Computer power and human reasoning: from judgement to calculation.' (W H Freeman and Co: San Francisco)
110. Winograd T (1973) A procedural model of language understanding. In 'Computer models of thought and language'. (Eds RC Shank, KM Colby) p. 191. (WH Freeman: San Francisco)
111. Winograd T, Flores F (1986) 'Understanding computers and cognition: a new foundation for design.' (Ablex: Norwood)