A Response to Gru¨nbaum?s ?A Century of Psychoanalysis Critical Retrospect and Prospect? (and other texts): Requiem or Reveille?

International Forum of Psychoanalysis

Volumn 10, Issue 2, 2001, Pages 113-132

  Lothane, Zvi ^a  

^a NONE   (United States)

Author keywords

Dreams; Epistemology; Evidence; Freud; Freud bashing; Psychoanalytic method; Psychoanalytic theories; Sexuality

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; DREAM; HISTORY OF MEDICINE; PHILOSOPHY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PSYCHOANALYSIS; PSYCHOANALYTIC THEORY; PSYCHOTHERAPIST; SEXUALITY;

EID: 0034911428     PISSN: 0803706X     EISSN: 16512324     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/713797003     Document Type: Article

References (41)

1. Grünbaum A. A century of psychoanalysis: critical retrospect and prospect. In: Roth, MS, ed. Freud conflict and culture. In association with the Library of Congress. New York: Knopf, 1998
2. Freud S. The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud. London: Hogarth Press, 1953-1974, SE:24 volumes
3. Spence D. Narrative truth and historical truth. New York: Norton, 1982
4. Lothane Z. A new metapsycholog y-psychoanalysi s as story-making. International Forum for Psychoanalysis, 1984; 1:65-84. [Note: not the same as this journal]
5. Grünbaum A. The foundations of psychoanalysis: a philosophi-cal critique. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1985 paperback. Originally published by Guilford Press, 1984
6. Lothane Z. In defense of Schreber: soul murder and psychiatry. Hillsdale, NJ/London: The Analytic Press, 1992
7. Grünbaum A. Validation in the clinical theory of psychoanalysis: a study in the philosophy of psychoanalysis. Madison, CT: International Universities Press, 1993
8. Grünbaum A. Psychoanalyti c theory and therapy after 100 years, and its future. Geneva: Fondation Latsis Internationale, 1994
9. Grünbaum A. One hundred years of psychoanalyti c theory and therapy: retrospect and prospect. In: Carrier, M., & Machamer, P. eds, Mindscapes: philosophy, science and the mind. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press (University of Konstanz Press), 1997;323-360
10. Lothane Z. Psychoanalyti c method and the mischief of Freud bashers. Psychiatric Times, 1996; 13 (12):49-50
11. Lothane, Z. Open letter to Professor Crews. Bull Amer Soc Psychoanal Physicians, 1996; 46 (2): 69-71
12. Lothane Z. Review of M. Macmillan’s Freud Evaluated. The Completed Arc. Jour Amer Acad Psychoanal, 1994; 22:560-562
13. Lothane Z. The schism between Freud and Jung over Schreber: its implications for method and doctrine. Intemat Forum Psychoanalysis, 1997; 6(2):103-115
14. Lothane Z. Review of J. Farrell’s Freud’s Paranoid Quest. Jour Amer Psychoanal Ass, 1997; 45(4):1319-1323
15. Lothane Z. The feud between Freud and Ferenczi over love. Amer Jour Psychoanal, 1998; 58:21-39
16. Lothane Z. Freud and the interpersonal. Internat Forum Psychoanal, 1997; 6:175-184
17. Lothane, Z. El eterno Freud: el método frente al mito y la malicia de los detractores de Freud. Revista Españ Neuro-psiquiatria, 1998; 18(66):269-292
18. Lothane Z. The perennial Freud: method versus myth and the mischief of Freud bashers. Internat Forum Psychoanal, 1999; 8(3-4):151-171
19. Peirce C. Philosophical writings of Peirce. Buchler J, ed. New York: Dover Books, 1955
20. Grünbaum A. Meaning connections and causal connections in the theory of transference: why psychoanalysi s should NOT be a hermeneutic science. Paper presented at the 32nd Winter Meeting of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis, New York City, 1989
21. Lothane Z. The myth of narcissism. J European Psychoanal, 1995; 1:31-46
22. Borch-Jacobsen M. Remembering Anna O.: 100 Years of Psychoanalytic Mystification. London: Routledge. 1996
23. Nitzschke, B. Aufbruch nach Inner-Afrika. Gottingen: Vanden-hoeck & Ruprecht, 1998
24. Ellenberger H. The story of “Anna O.”: a critical review with new data. In: Beyond the unconscious, Micale, MS ed., Prince-ton: Princeton University Press, 1993
25. Hirschmüller A. The life and work of Josef Breuer. New York: New York University Press, 1989
26. Northrop FSC. The logic of the sciences and the humanities. New York: Meridian Books, 1959
27. Lothane, Z. Freud and the interpersonal. Internat Forum Psychoanal, 1997; 6:175-184
28. Grünbaum A. The role of the case study method in the foundations of psychoanalysis. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 18:623-658, 1988
29. Lothane Z. Review of Anthony Storr’s Feet of Clay, Saints, Sinners and Madmen. Psychoanal Books, 1998; 9:254-258
30. Grünbaum A. Critique of Freud’s neurobiological and psycho-analytic dream theories, in press, 1996
31. Grünbaum A. Freud’s 1900 compromise-model of wish-fulfill-ment in dreaming: an artifice of his discredited neurobiological model of dreaming, in press, 1996
32. Lothane Z. Reality, dream, and trauma. Contemporary Psychoanalysis; 1983; 19:423-443
33. Russell B. The analysis of mind. London: Allen & Unwin, 1921
34. Balter L, Lothane Z, & Spencer J. H. On the analyzing instrument, 1980; Psychoanal Quart, 49:474-504
35. Lothane Z. Listening with the third ear as an instrument in psychoanalysis, 1981; Psychoanal Rev, 68:487-503
36. Lothane Z. The psychopatholog y of hallucination s-a metho-dological analysis, 1982; Brit J Med Psychol, 55:335-348
37. Lothane Z. Teaching the psychoanalyti c method: procedure and process. In: Caligor, Bromberg and Meltzer, eds., Clinical Perspectives on the Supervision of Psychoanalysis and Psycho-therapy. New York: Plenum
38. Lothane Z. The analyzing instrument and reciprocal free association, 1994; J Clinical Psychoanal, 3:61-82
39. Lothane Z. Love, seduction and trauma; 1987; Psychoanalytical Review, 74:83-105
40. Shapiro AK. The placebo effect of treatment. Drug Therapy, December 1971
41. Lothane Z. Freud’s 1895 Project: from mind to brain and back again. In: Bilder RM, & LeFever FF, eds. Neuroscience of the Mind on the Centennial of Freud’s Project for a Scientific Psychology. Annals New York Acad Sciences, 1998; 843:43-65