Risking ethical insolvency: A survey of trends in criminal DNA databanking

Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics

Volumn 28, Issue 3, 2000, Pages 209-221

  Kimmelman, Jonathan ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BIOMEDICAL TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT; CANADA; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CONFIDENTIALITY; CRIMINAL LAW; DNA FINGERPRINTING; GENETICS AND REPRODUCTION; GOVERNMENT; GOVERNMENT REGULATION; HUMAN; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; JUVENILE DELINQUENCY; LEGAL APPROACH; LEGAL ASPECT; MEDICAL ETHICS; NUCLEIC ACID DATABASE; STATISTICS; UNITED KINGDOM; UNITED STATES;

GENETICS AND REPRODUCTION; LEGAL APPROACH;

CANADA; CONFIDENTIALITY; CRIMINAL LAW; DATABASES, NUCLEIC ACID; DNA FINGERPRINTING; ENGLAND; ETHICS, MEDICAL; GOVERNMENT REGULATION; HUMANS; INTERNATIONALITY; JUVENILE DELINQUENCY; STATE GOVERNMENT; TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT, BIOMEDICAL; UNITED STATES;

EID: 0034278483     PISSN: 10731105     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2000.tb00661.x     Document Type: Review

References (79)

1. B. Herber and K. Herold, "DNA Typing of Human Dandruff," Journal of Forensic Science, 43 (1998): 648-656.
2. R.A.H. Van Oorschot and M.K. Jones, "DNA Fingerprints from Fingerprints." Nature, 387 (1997): 767.
3. M.N. Hochmeister, et al., "PCR-based Typing of DNA Extracted from Cigarette Butts," International Journal of Legal Medicine, 104 (1991): 229-233; D. Sweet and D. Hildebrand, "Saliva from Cheese Bite Yields DNA Profile of Burglar: A Case Report," International Journal of Legal Medicine, 112 (1999): 201-3; and D.J. Walsh, et al., "Isolation of Deoxyribonucleic Acid (DNA) from Saliva and Forensic Science Samples Containing Saliva," Journal of Forensic Science, 37 (1992): 387-395.
4. M.N. Hochmeister, et al., "PCR-based Typing of DNA Extracted from Cigarette Butts," International Journal of Legal Medicine, 104 (1991): 229-233; D. Sweet and D. Hildebrand, "Saliva from Cheese Bite Yields DNA Profile of Burglar: A Case Report," International Journal of Legal Medicine, 112 (1999): 201-3; and D.J. Walsh, et al., "Isolation of Deoxyribonucleic Acid (DNA) from Saliva and Forensic Science Samples Containing Saliva," Journal of Forensic Science, 37 (1992): 387-395.
5. M.N. Hochmeister, et al., "PCR-based Typing of DNA Extracted from Cigarette Butts," International Journal of Legal Medicine, 104 (1991): 229-233; D. Sweet and D. Hildebrand, "Saliva from Cheese Bite Yields DNA Profile of Burglar: A Case Report," International Journal of Legal Medicine, 112 (1999): 201-3; and D.J. Walsh, et al., "Isolation of Deoxyribonucleic Acid (DNA) from Saliva and Forensic Science Samples Containing Saliva," Journal of Forensic Science, 37 (1992): 387-395.
6. G.J. Annas, L.H. Glantz, and P.A. Roche, "The Genetic Privacy Act and Commentary," (Boston: Boston University School of Public Health, 1995): at 90.
7. J.E. McEwen and P.R. Reilly, "A Review of State Legislation on DNA Forensic Data Banking," American Journal of Human Genetics, 54 (1994): 941-958; and J.E. McEwen, "DNA Data Banks," in M.A. Rothstein, ed., Genetic Secrets: Protecting Privacy and Confidentiality in the Genetic Era (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997): 231-251.
8. J.E. McEwen and P.R. Reilly, "A Review of State Legislation on DNA Forensic Data Banking," American Journal of Human Genetics, 54 (1994): 941-958; and J.E. McEwen, "DNA Data Banks," in M.A. Rothstein, ed., Genetic Secrets: Protecting Privacy and Confidentiality in the Genetic Era (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997): 231-251.
9. All US federal and state statute citations discussed in this text are shown in Table 1.
10. G.M. Doot, "The Secrets of the Genome Revealed: Threats to Genetic Privacy," Wayne Law Review, 37 (1991): 1615-1645; N.L. Wilker, et al., "DNA Data Banking and the Public Interest," in Paul R. Billings, ed., DNA on Trial: Genetic Identification and Criminal Justice (Plainview: Cold Spring Harbor Press, 1992): 141-149; and G.J. Annas, "Privacy Rules for DNA Databanks: Protecting Coded 'Future Diaries'," JAMA, 270 (1993): 2346-2350.
11. G.M. Doot, "The Secrets of the Genome Revealed: Threats to Genetic Privacy," Wayne Law Review, 37 (1991): 1615-1645; N.L. Wilker, et al., "DNA Data Banking and the Public Interest," in Paul R. Billings, ed., DNA on Trial: Genetic Identification and Criminal Justice (Plainview: Cold Spring Harbor Press, 1992): 141-149; and G.J. Annas, "Privacy Rules for DNA Databanks: Protecting Coded 'Future Diaries'," JAMA, 270 (1993): 2346-2350.
12. G.M. Doot, "The Secrets of the Genome Revealed: Threats to Genetic Privacy," Wayne Law Review, 37 (1991): 1615-1645; N.L. Wilker, et al., "DNA Data Banking and the Public Interest," in Paul R. Billings, ed., DNA on Trial: Genetic Identification and Criminal Justice (Plainview: Cold Spring Harbor Press, 1992): 141-149; and G.J. Annas, "Privacy Rules for DNA Databanks: Protecting Coded 'Future Diaries'," JAMA, 270 (1993): 2346-2350.
13. A.J. Beck and B.E. Shipley, "Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 1983," U.S. Department of Justice, (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, April 1989): at 7.
14. A. Goldman, "Unabomber Case Files Trace Trail that Led to Kaczynski," Los Angeles Times, June 14, 1996, at 1.
15. N. Wade, "F.B.I. Set to Open its DNA Database for Fighting Crime," New York Times, Oct. 12, 1998, at A1; and G. Gugliotta, "A Rush to DNA Sampling: Vital Police Tool? Affront to Liberty? Both?", Washington Post, July 7, 1999, at A1.
16. N. Wade, "F.B.I. Set to Open its DNA Database for Fighting Crime," New York Times, Oct. 12, 1998, at A1; and G. Gugliotta, "A Rush to DNA Sampling: Vital Police Tool? Affront to Liberty? Both?", Washington Post, July 7, 1999, at A1.
17. M. Pezzella, "FBI DNA Dragnet to Track Fugitives in 50 States," Biotechnology Newswatch, Oct. 19, 1998, at 1.
18. For reviews of recent developments in the juvenile justice system, see J.M. Chaikin, "Changing Laws and Policies Governing Juvenile Justice Records," in National Conference on Juvenile Justice Records: Appropriate Criminal and Noncriminal Justice Uses, (Washington, D.C., Bureau of Justice Statistics, US Department of Justice, 1997): 11-14; and I.M. Schwartz, "Will the Juvenile Court System Survive?", American Academy of Political and Social Science, 564 (1999): 8-9 and essays that follow.
19. For reviews of recent developments in the juvenile justice system, see J.M. Chaikin, "Changing Laws and Policies Governing Juvenile Justice Records," in National Conference on Juvenile Justice Records: Appropriate Criminal and Noncriminal Justice Uses, (Washington, D.C., Bureau of Justice Statistics, US Department of Justice, 1997): 11-14; and I.M. Schwartz, "Will the Juvenile Court System Survive?", American Academy of Political and Social Science, 564 (1999): 8-9 and essays that follow.
20. T. Callaghan, Testimony, National Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence Conference, Washington, D.C., National Institute of Justice: Sept. 26-27, 1999; and National Research Council, Commission on Life Sciences, Board of Biology, DNA Technology in Forensic Science, (Washington, D.C.: National Acadamy Press, 1992), at 120.
21. T. Callaghan, Testimony, National Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence Conference, Washington, D.C., National Institute of Justice: Sept. 26-27, 1999; and National Research Council, Commission on Life Sciences, Board of Biology, DNA Technology in Forensic Science, (Washington, D.C.: National Acadamy Press, 1992), at 120.
22. See McEwen, 1997, supra note 5; and K. Kipnis, "DNA Banking in the Military: An Ethical Analysis," in R.F. Weir, ed., Stored Tissue Samples: Ethical, Legal, and Public Policy Implications, (Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1998): 329-344.
23. V.W. Weedn, "Stored Biologic Specimens for Military Identification: The Department of Defense DNA Registry," in Weir, id. at 345-357.
24. See Callaghan, supra note 13.
25. B. Budowle and T.R. Moretti, "Forensics: Analysis of Short Tandem Repeat Loci by Multiplex PCR and Real Time Fluorescence Detection During Capillary Electrophoresis," in J.T. Epplen and T. Lubjuhn, eds., DNA Profiling and DNA Fingerprinting, (Boston: Birkhäuser Verlag, 1999): 101-115.
26. See McEwen, 1997, supra note 5; J. McEwen, "Storing Genes to Solve Crimes: Legal, Ethical, and Public Policy Considerations," in R.F. Weir, supra note 14, at 311-28; and P.R. Reilly and D.C. Page, "We're off to see the genome," Nature Genetics, 20, no. 9 (1998): 15-17.
27. See McEwen, 1997, supra note 5; J. McEwen, "Storing Genes to Solve Crimes: Legal, Ethical, and Public Policy Considerations," in R.F. Weir, supra note 14, at 311-28; and P.R. Reilly and D.C. Page, "We're off to see the genome," Nature Genetics, 20, no. 9 (1998): 15-17.
28. Anonymous, "Right to Privacy Protected by Massachusetts Decision," Biotechnology Newswatch, Sept. 7, 1998.
29. See supra note 13.
30. See supra note 4 at 66.
31. See id.
32. J.A. Phillips III, et al., "American College of Medical Genetics Statement on the Storage and Use of Genetic Materials," American Journal of Human Genetics, 57 (1995): 1499-1500.
33. See McEwen, 1994 supra note 4.
34. K. Lawson, "CrimTrac to Provide Speedy Suspect Identification," Canberra Times, July 22, 1999, at A1.
35. Anonymous, "China: Law Enforcement DNA Database Established," BBC World Wide Monitoring - Asia Pacific, Sept. 9, 1999.
36. C. Pascal, "La France se dote d'un fichier national d'empreintes genetiques," Le Monde, March 21, 2000.
37. Criminal Justice and Public Order Act, Part IV, 1994.
38. Criminal Code RSC 1985, Chapter C-46, s.487 et seq. (1996).
39. M. Benecke, "DNA Typing in Forensic Medicine and Criminal Investigations: A Current Survey," Naturwissenschaften, 84 (1997): 181-8; and E. Peerenboom, "Central Criminal DNA Database Created in Germany," Nature Biotechnology, 16 (1998): 510-11.
40. M. Benecke, "DNA Typing in Forensic Medicine and Criminal Investigations: A Current Survey," Naturwissenschaften, 84 (1997): 181-8; and E. Peerenboom, "Central Criminal DNA Database Created in Germany," Nature Biotechnology, 16 (1998): 510-11.
41. J. Morton, A Guide to the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act of 1994 (London: Butterworths, 1994): at 33-34.
42. J. Blair, "Police Chiefs Join in Call for More DNA Sampling," New York Times, Aug. 16, 1999, at B5.
43. D. Werrett, Testimony, National Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence Conference, Oak Brook, IL, National Institute of Justice, June 8, 1998.
44. Anonymous, "Fed: Mass DNA Screenings OK if Voluntary, says Williams," AAP Newsfeed, Apr. 16, 2000.
45. W.A.Thompson, "A Forensic Blood Bank? RCMP solve a murder by soliciting DNA samples, but have not returned them," British Columbia Report, Sept. 13, 1999, at 43.
46. See Peerenboom, supra note 30.
47. L. Fereday, Testimony, "Technology Development: DNA from Fingerprints," National Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence Conference, Boston, National Institute of Justice, July 25-26, 1999.
48. Criminal Code RSC 1985, Chapter C-46, s.487 et seq. (1996).
49. I thank an anonymous reviewer for bringing this point to my attention; see also David Boyd, Speech, Fifth Annual Conference on the Future of DNA: Implications for the Criminal Justice System. New York, National Institute of Justice, May 8, 2000, at 20.
50. C.J. DeFrances and G.W. Steadman, Prosecutions in State Courts, 1996, (Washington, D.C.: Bureau of Justice Statistics, 1998); J.W. Hicks and V. Weedn, "The Unrealized Potential of DNA Testing," in NIJ: Research in Action, (Washington, D.C.: National Institute of Justice, June, 1998); and supra note 33.
51. C.J. DeFrances and G.W. Steadman, Prosecutions in State Courts, 1996, (Washington, D.C.: Bureau of Justice Statistics, 1998); J.W. Hicks and V. Weedn, "The Unrealized Potential of DNA Testing," in NIJ: Research in Action, (Washington, D.C.: National Institute of Justice, June, 1998); and supra note 33.
52. See supra note 8 at 6.
53. See id.
54. See McEwen, 1997 supra note 5; and M. Hibbert, "DNA Databanks: Law Enforcement's Greatest Surveillance Tool?", Wake Forest Law Review, 34 (1999): at 782-786. (Hibbert 1999; McEwen 1997)
55. See Hibbert, id.
56. B. Lambert, "Guiliani Backs DNA Testing of Newborns for ID," New York Times, Dec. 17, 1998, at B4; and M. Smith, Remarks, "Legal Issues Working Group Report: Constitutional Analysis of Arrestee DNA Sampling," National Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence Conference, Washington, D.C., National Institute of Justice, July 26-27, 1999.
57. B. Lambert, "Guiliani Backs DNA Testing of Newborns for ID," New York Times, Dec. 17, 1998, at B4; and M. Smith, Remarks, "Legal Issues Working Group Report: Constitutional Analysis of Arrestee DNA Sampling," National Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence Conference, Washington, D.C., National Institute of Justice, July 26-27, 1999.
58. Davis v. Mississippi, 394 U.S. 721 (S. Ct. 1969).
59. Thom v. New York Stock Exchange, 306 F.Supp. 1002, (S.D.N.Y 1969).
60. J.D Woodward, "Biometric Scanning, Law and Policy: Identifying the Concerns - Drafting the Biometric Blueprint," University of Pittsburgh Law Review, 59, no.3 (1997): 97-152.
61. Perkey v. Department of Motor Vehicles, 721 P.2d 50, 55-56 (Cal. 1986).
62. C. Fried, "Privacy," Yale Law Journal, 77 (1968): 475-93.
63. See id. at 486.
64. M. Sjerps and A.D. Kloosterman, "On the Consequences of DNA Profile Mismatches for Close Relatives of an Excluded Suspect," International Journal of Legal Medicine, 112 (1999): 176-180.
65. J. Sterngold, "Investigation into Police is Broadened in Los Angeles," New York Times, Feb. 24, 2000, at A12.
66. H.N. Snyder and M. Sickmund, "Juvenile Offenders and Victims: 1999 National Report," National Center for Juvenile Justice, (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1999).
67. F. Butterfield, "Racial Disparities Seen as Pervasive in Juvenile Justice," New York Times, April 26, 2000, at A1; and M. Males and D. Macallair, "The Color of Justice: An Analysis of Juvenile-Adult Court Transfers in California," (San Francisco: Justice Policy Institute, 2000).
68. F. Butterfield, "Racial Disparities Seen as Pervasive in Juvenile Justice," New York Times, April 26, 2000, at A1; and M. Males and D. Macallair, "The Color of Justice: An Analysis of Juvenile-Adult Court Transfers in California," (San Francisco: Justice Policy Institute, 2000).
69. T.P. Bonczar and A.J. Beck, "Lifetime Likelihood of Going to State or Federal Prison," U.S. Department of Justice, (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1997): at 1.
70. J.F. Merz, and P. Sankar, "DNA Banking: An Empirical Study of a Proposed Consent Form," in Weir, supra note 14 at 198-235.
71. Bureau of Justice Statistics, "Correctional Populations in the US, 1996," Department of Justice (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, April, 1999), at Table 1.28.
72. Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 113 S.Ct. 2786 (1993).
73. See National Academy of Sciences, supra note 13, at 120.
74. L. Trischitta, "As DNA Use Rises, So Do Concerns," The Times Union, March 3, 2000, at A1; and Callaghan, supra note 13.
75. P. Belgrader, at al., "Rapid PCR for Identity Testing Using a Battery-Powered Miniature Thermal Cycler," Journal of Forensic Science, 43, (1998): 315-19.
76. J.M. Butler, at al., "Rapid Analysis of the Short Tandem Repeat HUMTHO1 by Capillary Electrophoresis," Biotechniques, 17, (1994): 1062-70.
77. R. Radtkey, et al., "Rapid, high fidelity analysis of simple sequene repeats on an electronically active DNA microchip," Nucleic Acids Research, 28, no. 7, (2000): e17i-vi.
78. See supra note 17.
79. D.E. Rosenblum, "Seeking Answers, Census is Stirring Privacy Questions," New York Times, April 1, 2000, at A1.