A multi-method evaluation of journals in the decision and management sciences by US academics

Omega

Volumn 28, Issue 1, 2000, Pages 17-36

  Donohue, Joan M ^a   Fox, Jeremy B ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA   (United States)

^b APPALACHIAN STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Business and management studies; Citation analysis; Journal quality

Indexed keywords

EID: 0034135008     PISSN: 03050483     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0305-0483(99)00024-9     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Amoako-Gyampah K, Meredith JR. The operations management research agenda: An update. Journal of Operations Management 1989;8:250-62.
2. Andrews WT, McKenzie PB. Leading accounting departments revisited. Accounting Review 1978;53:135-8.
3. Barman S, Tersine RJ, Buckley MR. An empirical assessment of the perceived relevance and quality of POM-related journals by academicians. Journal of Operations Management 1991;10:194-211.
4. Beattie VA, Ryan RJ. Performance indices and related measures of journal reputation in accounting. British Accounting Review 1989;21:267-78.
5. Barnett V, Lewis T. Outliers in Statistical Data. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1974.
6. Beilock RP, Polopolous LC, Correal M. Ranking of agricultural economics departments by citations. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 1986;68:595-604.
7. Billings BB, Viksnins GJ. The relative quality of economic journals: An alternative rating system. Western Economic Journal 1972;10:467-9.
8. Blalock HM. Measurement in the Social Sciences: Theories and Strategies. Chicago: Aldine Publishing, 1974.
9. Brinn T, Jones MJ, Pendelbury M. UK accountants' perceptions of research journal quality. Accounting and Business Research 1996;26:265-78.
10. Broad WJ. The publishing game: Getting more for less. Science 1981;211:1137-9.
11. Brown LD, Gardner JC. Using citation analysis to assess the impact of journals and articles on Contemporary Accounting Research (CAR). Journal of Accounting Research 1985;23:84-109.
12. Brown LD, Huefner RS. The familiarity with and perceived quality of accounting journals: Views of senior accounting faculty in leading US MBA programs. Contemporary Accounting Research 1994;11:223-50.
13. Buffa ES. Research in operations management. Journal of Operations Management 1980;1:8-14.
14. Bush WC, Hamelman PW, Staaf RJ. A quality index for economic journals. Review of Economics and Statistics 1974;56:123-5.
15. Cabell DWE. Cabell's Directory of Publishing Opportunities in Accounting, Economics, and Finance. Beaumont, TX: Cabell Publishing Company, 1994.
16. Cabell DWE. Cabell's Directory of Publishing Opportunities in Management and Marketing. Beaumont, TX: Cabell Publishing Company, 1994.
17. Carr HH. Is using computer-based questionnaires better than using paper? Journal of Systems Management 1991;42(9):18, 37.
18. Chase RB. A classification and evaluation of research in operations management. Journal of Operations Management 1980;1:1-7.
19. Coe RK, Weinstock I. Evaluating the finance journals: The department chairperson's perspective. Journal of Financial Research 1983;6:345-9.
20. Coe RK, Weinstock I. Evaluating journal publications of marketing professors: A second look. Journal of Marketing Education 1983;5:37-42.
21. Coe RK, Weinstock I. Evaluating the management journals: A second look. Academy of Management Journal 1984;27:660-6.
22. Culnan MJ. Mapping the intellectual structure of MIS, 1980-1985: A co-citation analysis. MIS Quarterly 1987;11:341-53.
23. Diamond Jr AM. The money value of citations to single-authored and multiple-authored articles. Scientometrics 1985;8:815-20.
24. Diamond Jr AM. What is a citation worth? Journal of Human Resources 1986;21:201-25.
25. Doke ER, Luke RH. Perceived quality of CIS/MIS journals among faculty: Publishing hierarchies. Journal of Computer Information Systems 1987;27:30-3.
26. Doyle JR, Arthurs AJ. Judging the quality of research in business schools: The UK as a case study. Omega 1995;33:257-70.
27. Doyle JR, Arthurs AJ, Green RH, Mcauly L, Pitt MR, Bottomley PA, Evans W. The judge, the model of the judge, and the model of the judged as judge: Analyses of the UK 1992 research assessment exercise data for business and management studies. Omega 1996;24:13-28.
28. Doyle JR, Arthurs AJ, Mcauly L, Osborne PG. Citation as effortful voting: A reply to Jones, Brinn and Pendelbury. Omega 1996;24:603-6.
29. Dyckman TR, Zeff SA. Two decades of the journal of accounting research. Journal of Accounting Research 1984;22:225-97.
30. Ederington LH. Aspects of the production of significant financial research. Journal of Finance 1979;34:777-86.
31. Eom SB. Decision support systems research: Reference disciplines and a cumulative tradition. Omega 1995;23:511-23.
32. Extejt MM, Smith JE. The behavioral sciences and management: An evaluation of relevant journals. Journal of Management 1990;16:539-51.
33. Feingold A. Assessment of journals in social science psychology. American Psychologist 1989;36:961-4.
34. Ferguson W. An evaluation of journals that publish business logistics articles. Transportation Journal 1983;23:69-72.
35. Garfield E. Citation analysis as a tool in journal evaluation. Science 1972;178:471-9.
36. Gillenson ML, Stutz JD. Academic issues in MIS: Journals and books. MIS Quarterly 1991;15:447-52.
37. Goh CH, Holsapple CW, Johnson LE, Tanner J. An empirical assessment of influences on POM research. Omega 1996;24:337-45.
38. Grover V, Segars AH, Simon SJ. An assessment of institutional research productivity in MIS. Data Base 1992;23(1):5-9.
39. Gupta UG. Using citation analysis to explore the intellectual base, knowledge dissemination, and research impact of interfaces (1970-1992). Interfaces 1997;27:85-101.
40. Hamilton S, Ives BI. The journal communication system for MIS research. Data Base 1983;14(3):3-14.
41. Hawkins RG, Ritter LS, Walter I. What economists think of their journals. Journal of Political Economy 1973;81:1017-32.
42. Holsapple CW, Johnson LE, Manakyan H, Tanner J. Business computing system research: Structuring the field. Omega 1994;22:69-81.
43. Howard TP. Attitude measurement: Some further considerations. The Accounting Review 1981;56:613-21.
44. Howard TP, Nikolai LA. Attitude measurement and perceptions of accounting faculty publication outlets. Accounting Review 1983;58:765-76.
45. Jones MJ, Brinn T, Pendelbury M. Judging the quality of research in business schools: A comment from accounting. Omega 1996;24:597-602.
46. Jones MJ, Brinn T, Pendelbury M. Judging evaluation methodologies: A balanced response. Omega 1996;24:607-12.
47. Kawasaki JL, Raven MR. Computer-administered surveys in extension. Journal of Extension 1995;33 Research No. 3.
48. Kiesler S, Sproull LS. Response effects in the electronic survey. Public Opinion Quarterly 1986;50:402-13.
49. Klemkosky RC, Tuttle DL. The institutional source and concentration of financial research. Journal of Finance 1977;32:901-7.
50. Koong KS, Weistroffer HR. Faculty usage of management information systems journals. Journal of Computer Information Systems 1989;29(3):1-4.
51. Koulack D, Keselman HJ. Ratings of psychology journals by members of the American Psychological Association. American Psychologist 1975;30:1049-53.
52. Lending D, Wetherbe JC. Update on MIS research: A profile of leading journals and US universities. Data Base 1992;23(3):5-11.
53. Liebowitz SK, Palmer JP. Assessing the relative impacts of economics journals. Journal of Economic Literature 1984;22:77-88.
54. Lodge M. Magnitude Scaling, Quantitative Measurement of Opinions. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications, 1981.
55. Luke RH, Doke ER. Marketing journal hierarchies: Faculty perceptions, 1986-87. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 1987;15:74-8.
56. MacMillan IC, Stern I. Delineating a forum for business policy scholars. Strategic Management Journal 1987;8:183-6.
57. Malhotra MK, Kher HV. Institutional research productivity in production and operations management. Journal of Operations Management 1996;14:55-77.
58. Medoff MH. The ranking of economists. Journal of Economic Education 1989;20:405-15.
59. Miller TR, Dodge HR. Rating professional journals by teachers of management. Improving College and University Teaching 1979;27:102-3.
60. Mitchell G. Judging research quality and journals: A call for debate. Omega 1996;24:613.
61. Moore LJ, Taylor III BW. A study of institutional publications in business-related academic journals 1972-78. Quarterly Review of Economics and Business 1980;20:87-97.
62. Moore WJ. The relative quality of economics journals: A suggested rating system. Western Economic Journal 1972;10:156-69.
63. Morrison J, George JF. Exploring the software engineering component in MIS research. Communications of the ACM 1995;38:80-91.
64. Niemi Jr AW. Institutional contributions to the leading finance journals, 1975 through 1986: A note. Journal of Finance 1987;42:1389-97.
65. Niemi Jr AW. Research productivity of american business schools, 1975-85. Review of Business and Economics Research 1988;23:1-17.
66. Nord JH, Nord GD. MIS research: Journal status assessment and analysis. Information and Management 1995;29:29-42.
67. Omar MH, Goodwin JS. An investigation of the decision support systems literature. Interfaces 1991;13:18-23.
68. Ormerod RJ. An observation on publication habits based on the analysis of MS/OR journals. Omega 1997;25:599-603.
69. Ormerod RJ, Kiossis I. OR/MS publications: Extension of the analysis of US flagship journals to the United Kingdom. Operations Research 1997;45:178-87.
70. Outreville JF, Malouin JL. What are the major journals that members of ARIA read? Journal of Risk and Insurance 1985;52:721-33.
71. Petry G, Settle J. A comprehensive analysis of worldwide scholarly productivity in selected US business journals. Quarterly Review of Economics and Business 1988;28:88-104.
72. Reisman A. On alternative strategies for doing research in the management and social sciences. IEEE Transactions Engineering Management 1988;35:215-21.
73. Reisman A, Kirschnick F. Research strategies used by OR/MS workers as shown by an analysis of papers in flagship journals. Operations Research 1995;43:731-40.
74. Rosenfeld P, Booth-Kewley S, Edwards JE. Computer-administered surveys in organizational settings: Alternatives, advantages, and applications. American Behavioral Scientist 1993;36:485-511.
75. Rothkopf MH. Which universities contribute to the practice literature? The first Interfaces ranking. Interfaces 1996;26:16-21.
76. Rotton J, Levett M, Foos P. Citation impact, rejection rates, and journal value. American Psychologist 1993;40:911-2.
77. Saladin BA. Operations management research: Where should we publish? Operations Management Review 1985;3(4):3-9.
78. Science Citation Index. Philadelphia, PA: Institute for Scientific Information, 1996.
79. Serials Directory: An International Reference Book. Birmingham, AL: EBSCO Publishing, 1996.
80. Sharplin AD, Mabry RH. The relative importance of journals used in management research: An alternative ranking. Human Relations 1985;38:139-49.
81. Skeels JW, Taylor RA. The relative quality of economics journals: An alternative rating system. Western Economic Journal 1972;10:470-3.
82. Social Science Citation Index. Philadelphia, PA: Institute for Scientific Information, 1996.
83. Sproull LS. Using electronic mail for data collection in organizational research. Academy of Management Journal 1986;29:159-69.
84. Stahl MJ, Leap TL, Wei ZZ. Publication in leading management journals as a measure of institutional research productivity. Academy of Management Journal 1988;31:707-20.
85. Staudte RG, Sheather SJ. Robust Estimation and Testing. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1990.
86. Thach L. Using electronic mail to conduct survey research. Educational Technology 1995;35(2):27-31.
87. Vellenga DB, Allen BJ, Riley CD. Analysis of author affiliation for publications in transportation and logistics academic journals. Transportation Journal 1981;21:44-53.
88. Walstrom KA, Hardgrave BC, Wilson RL. Forums for management information systems scholars. Communications of the ACM 1995;38:93-107.
89. Weber RP, Stevenson WC. Evaluations of accounting journal and department quality. Accounting Review 1981;56:596-612.
90. White MJ, White KG. Citation analysis of psychology journals. American Psychologist 1977;32:301-5.
91. Williams WW. Institutional propensities to publish in academic journals of business administration: 1979-1984. Quarterly Review of Economics and Business 1987;27:77-94.
92. Young ST, Baird BC, Pullman ME. POM research productivity in US business schools. Journal of Operations Management 1996;14:41-53.