Shift-share analysis: Further examination of models for the description of economic change

Socio-Economic Planning Sciences

Volumn 34, Issue 3, 2000, Pages 177-198

  Knudsen, Daniel C ^a  

^a INDIANA UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

ANOVA; Economic change; Information theory; Shift share

Indexed keywords

ECONOMIC ANALYSIS; PLANNING METHOD; REGIONAL ECONOMY; SHIFT-SHARE ANALYSIS;

EID: 0034124159     PISSN: 00380121     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0038-0121(99)00016-6     Document Type: Article

References (68)

1. Glickman N.J., Glasmeier A. The international economy and the American South. Rodwin L., Sazanami H. Deindustrialization and regional transformation: the experience of the United States. 1989;60-80 Unwin Hyman, Boston.
2. Harrison B., Kluver J. Reassessing the Massachusetts miracle. Environment and Planning A. 21:1989;771-801.
3. Markusen A.R., Carlson V. Deindustrialization in the American Midwest: causes and responses. Rodwin L., Sazanami H. Deindustrialization and regional transformation: the experience of the United States. 1989;29-59 Unwin Hyman, Boston.
4. Huff D., Sherr L. Measure for determining differential growth rates of markets. Journal of Market Geography. 4:1967;391-395.
5. Plane D.A. The geographic components of change in a migration system. Geographical Analysis. 19:1987;283-299.
6. Plane D.A., Rogerson P. U.S. migration pattern responses to the oil glut and recession of the early 1980s: an application of shift-share and causative matrix techniques. Congdon P., Batey P. Advances in regional demography. 1989;386-414 Belhaven Press, London.
7. Barff R.A., Knight P.L. III. The role of federal military spending in the timing of the New England employment turnaround. Papers of the Regional Science Association. 65:1988;151-166.
8. Casler S.D. A theoretical context for shift and share analysis. Regional Studies. 23:1989;43-48.
9. Barff R.A., Knight P.L. III. Dynamic shift-share analysis. Growth and Change. 19:1988;1-10.
10. Houston D.B. The shift and share analysis of regional growth: a critique. Southern Economic Journal. 33:1967;577-581.
11. Richardson H.W. The state of regional economics: a survey article. International Regional Science Review. 3:1978;1-48.
12. Buck T.W. Shift-share analysis: a guide to regional policy? Regional Studies. 4:1970;445-450.
13. Holden D.R., Swales J.K., Nairn A.G.M. The repeated application of shift-share: a structural explanation of regional growth? Environment and Planning A. 19:1987;1233-1250.
14. Stillwell F.J.B. Further thoughts on the shift and share approach. Regional Studies. 4:1970;451-458.
15. Hellman D.A. Shift-share models as predictive tools. Growth and Change. 7:1976;3-8.
16. Kurre J.A., Weller B.R. Forecasting the local economy, using time-series and shift-share techniques. Environment and Planning A. 21:1989;753-770.
17. Stevens B.H., Moore C.L. A critical review of the shift-share as a forecasting technique. Journal of Regional Science. 20:1980;419-437.
18. Rigby D.L., Anderson W.P. Employment change, growth and productivity in Canadian manufacturing: an extension and application of shift-share analysis. Canadian Journal of Regional Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences Regionales. 26:1993;69-88.
19. Haynes K.E., Dinc M. Productivity change in manufacturing regions: a multifactor/shift-share approach. Growth and Change. 28:1997;150-170.
20. Creamer D.B. Industrial location and natural resources. 1943;US Natural Resources Planning Board, Washington, DC.
21. Dunn E.S. Jr. A statistical and analytical technique for regional analysis. Papers of the Regional Science Association. 6:1960;97-112.
22. Perloff H.S., et al. Regions, resources and economic growth. 1960;Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
23. Arcelus F.J. An extension of shift-share analysis. Growth and Change. 15:1984;3-8.
24. Esteban-Marquillas J.M. Shift- and share-analysis revisited. Regional and Urban Economics. 2:1972;249-261.
25. Thirlwall A.P. A measure of the proper distribution of industry. Oxford Economic Papers. 19:1967;46-58.
26. Brown H.J. Shift-share projections of regional growth: An empirical test. Journal of Regional Science. 9:1969;1-18.
27. Browne L.E. The impact of industry mix on New England's economic growth since 1950. New England Economic Indicators. April:1977;33.
28. Fothergill S., Gudgin G. In defense of shift-share. Urban Studies. 16:1979;309-319.
29. Jackson G., et al. Regional diversity: growth in the United States, 1960-1990. 1981;Auburn House, Boston.
30. Lever W.F. The inner-city employment problem in Great Britian, 1952-76: a shift-share approach. Rees J., et al. Industrial location and regional systems. 1981;Bergin, New York.
31. Berzeg K. The empirical content of shift-share analysis. Journal of Regional Science. 18:1978;463-469.
32. Berzeg K. A note on statistical approaches to shift-share analysis. Journal of Regional Science. 24:1984;277-285.
33. Patterson M. A note on the formulation of a full-analogue regression model of the shift-share method. Journal of Regional Science. 31:1991;211-216.
34. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Establishment survey of employment, hours, and earnings. n.d. US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
35. Kullback S., Leibler R.A. On information and sufficiency. Annals of Mathematical Statistics. 22:1951;78-86.
36. Brockett P.L., Charnes A., Cooper W.W. M.D.I. Estimation via unconstrained convex programming. 1978;Center for Cybernetic Studies, Austin, TX.
37. Knudsen D.C. Exploring flow system change: U.S. rail freight flows, 1972-1981. Annals of the Association of American Geographers. 75:1985;539-551.
38. Fiacco A.V., McCormick G.P. Nonlinear programming: sequential unconstrained minimization techniques. 1968;Wiley, New York.
39. Phillips F.Y. A guide to MDI statistics for planning and management model-building. 1981;Institute for Constructive Capitalism, Austin.
40. Williams P.A., Fotheringham A.S. The calibration of spatial interaction models by maximum likelihood estimation with program SIMODEL. 1984;Indiana University, Department of Geography (Geographic Monograph Series), Bloomington, IN.
41. Wilson A.G. Entropy in urban and regional modelling. 1970;Pion, London.
42. Feinberg S.E. Analysis of cross-classified data. 1981;MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
43. Haynes K.E., Machunda Z.B. Considerations in extending shift-share analysis. Growth and Change. 18:1987;69-78.
44. Haynes K.E., Machunda Z.B. Decomposition of change in spatial employment concentration: an information-theoretic extension of shift-share analysis. Papers of the Regional Science Association. 65:1988;101-113.
45. Berry B.J.L., Schwind P.J. Information and entropy in migrant flows. Geographical Analysis. 1:1969;5-14.
46. Haynes K.E., Phillips F.Y. Constrained minimum discrimination information: a unifying tool for modeling spatial and individual choice behavior. Environment and Planning A. 14:1982;1341-1354.
47. Kullback S. Information and statistics. 1959;Wiley, New York.
48. Theil H., Gosh R. A comparison of shift-share and the RAS adjustment. Regional Science and Urban Economics. 10:1980;175-180.
49. Thomas R.W. Information statistics in geography. 1981;GeoAbstracts, Norwich.
50. Knudsen D.C. Generalizing Poisson regression: including a priori information using the method of offsets. The Professional Geographer. 44:1992;202-208.
51. Baxter M. Similarities in methods of estimating spatial interaction models. Geographical Analysis. 14:1982;267-272.
52. Baxter M. A note on the estimation of a nonlinear migration model using GLIM. Geographical Analysis. 16:1984;282-286.
53. Flowerdew R., Aitkin M. A method of fitting the gravity model based on the Poisson distribution. Journal of Regional Science. 22:1982;191-202.
54. Flowerdew R., Lovett A. Fitting constrained Poisson regression models to interurban migration flows. Geographical Analysis. 20:1988;297-307.
55. Flowerdew R., Lovett A. Compound and generalized Poisson models for interurban migration. Congdon P., Batey P. Advances in regional demography. 1989;246-256 Belhaven Press, London.
56. Gokhale D.V., Kullback S. The information in contingency tables. 1978;Marcel Dekker, New York.
57. Lovett A., Flowerdew R. Analysis of count data using Poisson regression. Professional Geographer. 41:1989;190-198.
58. Lovett A., Whyte I.D., Whyte K.A. Poisson regression analysis and migration fields: the example of the apprenticeship records of Edinburgh in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series. 10:1985;317-332.
59. McCullagh P., Nelder J.A. Generalized linear models. 1983;Chapman & Hall, London.
60. Knudsen D.C. Manufacturing employment change in the American Midwest, 1977-86. Environment and Planning A. 24:1992;1303-1316.
61. Knudsen D.C., Barff R. Shift-share as a linear model. Environment and Planning A. 23:1991;421-431.
62. Massey D.B., Meegan R. The anatomy of job loss: the how, why, and where of employment decline. 1982;Methuen, London, London.
63. Murgatroyd L., Urry J. The class and gender restructuring of the Lancaster economy, 1950-1980. Localities, class and gender. 1985;30-53 The Lancaster Regionalism Group, Pion, London.
64. Brewer G.D., deLeon P. The foundations of policy analysis. 1983;Dorsey Press, Homewood, IL.
65. Laswell H.D. A preview of policy sciences. 1971;Elsevier, New York.
66. Weimer D.L., Vining A.R. Policy analysis: concepts and practice. 1989;Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
67. Theil H., Sorooshian C. Components of the change in regional inequality. Economics Letters. 4:1979;191-193.
68. Pringle R.M., Raynor A.A. Generalised inverse matrices with applications to statistics. 1971;Hafner, New York.