The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality inventory and chronic pain: A conceptual analysis of a long-standing but complicated relationship

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 20, Issue 5, 2000, Pages 533-559

  Vendrig, Alexander A ^a  

^a Rug AdviesCentra Nederland   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Assessment; Chronic pain; MMPI 2; Personality

Indexed keywords

BACKACHE; CHRONIC PAIN; FACTORIAL ANALYSIS; HUMAN; MENTAL DISEASE; MODEL; OUTCOMES RESEARCH; PERSONALITY; PREDICTION; RATING SCALE; REVIEW; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 0034114312     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0272-7358(00)00053-2     Document Type: Article

References (125)

1. Adams K.M., Heilbronn M., Silk S.D., Reider E., Blumer D.P. Use of the MMPI with patients who report chronic pain. Psychological Reports. 48:1981;855-866.
2. Akerlind I., Hornquist J.O., Bjurulf P. Psychological factors in the long-term prognosis of chronic low back pain patients. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 48:1992;596-605.
3. Alexander F. Psychosomatic medicine. Its principles and application:1952;Allan and Unwin, London.
4. Armentrout D.P., Moore J.E., Parker J.C., Hewett J.E., Feltz C. Pain-patient subgroups. The psychological dimensions of pain Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 5:1982;201-211.
5. Barnes D., Gatchel R.J., Mayer T.G., Barnett J. Changes in MMPI profile levels of chronic low back pain patients following successful treatment. Journal of Spinal Disorders. 3:1990;353-355.
6. Beals R.K., Hickman N.W. Industrial injuries of the back and extremities. Comprehensive evaluation, an aid in prognosis and management: A study of 180 patients Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. 54:1972;1593-1611.
7. Ben-Porath Y.S., Butcher J.N. The comparability of the MMPI and MMPI-2 scales and profiles. Psychological Assessment. 1:1989;345-347.
8. Bigos S.J., Battié M.C., Spengler D.M., Fisher L.D., Fordyce W.E., Hansson T.H., Nachemson A.L., Wortley M.D. A prospective study of work perceptions and psychosocial factors affecting the report of back injury. Spine. 16:1991;1-6.
9. Blumetti A.E., Modesti L.M. Psychological predictors of success or failure of surgical intervention for intractable back pain. Bonica J.J., Albe-Fessard D.G. Advances in pain research and therapy. 1976;323-325 Raven Press, New York.
10. Bombardier C.H., Divine G.W., Jordan J.S., Brooks W.B., Neelon F.A. Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) cluster groups among chronically ill patients. Relationship to illness adjustment and treatment outcome Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 16:1993;467-484.
11. Bradley L.A., Prokop C.K., Margolis R., Gentry W.D. Multivariate analyses of the MMPI profiles of low back pain patients. Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 1:1978;253-272.
12. Bradley L.A., Van der Heide L.H. Pain-related correlates of MMPI profile subgroups among back pain patients. Health Psychology. 3:1984;157-174.
13. Butcher J.N. MMPI-2 in psychological treatment. 1990;Oxford University Press, Oxford, England.
14. Butcher J.N. Letter to MMPI'ers. News and Profiles. 6:1995;1.
15. Butcher J.N. International adaptations of the MMPI. Research and clinical applications:1996;University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN.
16. Butcher J.N., Dahlstrom W.G., Graham J.R., Tellegen A., Kaemmer B. MMPI-2. An administrative and interpretive guide:1989;University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN.
17. Caldwell L.A., Chase C. Diagnosing and treatment of personality factors in chronic low back pain. Clinical Orthopedics and Related Research. 129:1977;141-149.
18. Calsyn D.A., Louks J., Freeman C.W. The use of the MMPI with chronic low back pain patients with a mixed diagnosis. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 32:1976;532-536.
19. Chapman S.L., Brena S.F. Learned helplessness and responses to nerve blocks in chronic low back pain patients. Pain. 14:1982;355-364.
20. Chapman S.L., Pemberton J.S. Prediction of treatment outcome from clinically derived MMPI clusters in rehabilitation for chronic low back pain. Clinical Journal of Pain. 10:1994;267-276.
21. Costello R.M., Hulsey T.L., Schoenfeld L.S., Ramamurthy S. P-a-i-n. A four-cluster mmpi typology for chronic pain Pain. 30:1987;199-209.
22. Deardorff W.W., Chino A.F., Scott D.W. Characteristics of chronic pain patients. Factor analysis of the MMPI-2 Pain. 54:1993;153-158.
23. Dzioba R.B., Doxey N.C. A prospective investigation into the orthopaedic and psychological predictors of outcome of first lumbar surgery following industrial injury. Spine. 9:1984;614-623.
24. Engel G.L. 'Psychogenic' pain and the pain-prone patient. American Journal of Medicine. 26:1959;899-918.
25. Etscheidt M., Steger H., Braverman B. Multidimensional Pain Inventory profile classification and psychopathology. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 51:1995;29-36.
26. Finn S.E. Using the MMPI-2 as a therapeutic intervention. 1996;University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN.
27. Fordyce W.E. Behavioral methods for chronic pain and illness. 1976;C.V. Mosby, St. Louis, MO.
28. Fordyce W.E., Brena S.F., Holcomb R.J., De Lateur B.J., Loeser J.D. Relationship of patient semantic pain descriptions to physician diagnostic judgments, activity level measures and MMPI. Pain. 5:1978;293-303.
29. Fordyce W.E., Bigos S.J., Battié M.C., Fisher L.D. MMPI Scale 3 as a predictor of back injury reports. What does it tell us? Clinical Journal of Pain. 8:1992;222-226.
30. Freeman C.W., Calsyn D.A., Louks J.L. The use of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory with low back pain patients. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 32:1976;294-298.
31. Garron D.C., Leavitt F. Chronic low back pain and depression. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 39:1983;486-493.
32. Gatchel R.J. Early development of physical and mental deconditioning in painful spinal disorders. Mayer T.G., Mooney V., Gatchel R.J. Contemporary conservative care for painful spinal disorders. 1991;64-81 Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia.
33. Gatchel R.J. Psychological disorders and chronic pain. Gatchel R.J., Turk D.C. Psychological approaches to pain management. A practitioner's handbook:1996;33-52 The Guilford Press, New York.
34. Gatchel R.J., Mayer T.G., Capra P., Diamond P., Barnett J. Quantification of lumbar functioning. Part 6. The use of psychological measures in guiding physical functional restoration Spine. 11:1986;36-42.
35. Gatchel R.J., Polatin P.B., Kinney R.K. Predicting outcome of chronic back pain using clinical predictors of psychopathology. A prospective analysis Health Psychology. 14:1995;415-420.
36. Gatchel R.J., Polatin P.B., Mayer T.G. The dominant role of psychosocial risk factors in the development of chronic low back pain disability. Spine. 20:1995;2702-2709.
37. Gentry W.D., Shows W.D., Thomas M. Chronic low back pain. A psychological profile Psychosomatics. 151:1974;174-177.
38. Graham J.R. MMPI-2. Assessing personality and psychopathology. 1993;Oxford University Press, Oxford, England.
39. Graham J.R., Timbrook R.E., Ben-Porath Y.S., Butcher J.N. Code-type congruence between MMPI and MMPI-2. Separating fact from artifact Journal of Personality Assessment. 57:1991;205-215.
40. Gough H.E. Diagnostic patterns on the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 2:1946;23-37.
41. Guck T.P., Meilman P.W., Skultety F.M., Poloni L.D. Pain-patient Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) subgroups. Evaluation of long-term treatment outcome Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 111:1988;159-169.
42. Hanssen F.R., Biering-Sorensen F.B., Schroll M.S. Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory profiles in persons with or without low back pain. A 20-year follow-up study Spine. 20:1995;2716-2720.
43. Hanvik L.J. MMPI profiles in patients with low-back pain. Journal of Consulting Psychology. 15:1951;350-353.
44. Henrichs T.F. MMPI profiles of chronic pain patients. Some methodological considerations that concern clusters and descriptors Journal of Clinical Psychology. 43:1987;650-660.
45. Herron L.D., Pheasant H.C. Changes in MMPI profiles after low-back surgery. Spine. 7:1982;591-597.
46. Herron L.D., Turner J. Patient selection for lumbar laminectomy and discectomy with revised objective rating system. Clinical Orthopedics and Related Research. 199:1985;145-152.
47. Herron L.D., Turner J., Clancy S., Weiner P. The differential utility of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory. A predictor of outcome in lumbar laminectomy for disc herniation versus spinal stenosis Spine. 11:1986;847-850.
48. Herron L.D., Turner J., Weiner P. A comparison of the Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory and the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory as predictors of successful treatment by lumbar laminectomy. Clinical Orthopedics and Related Sciences. 203:1986;232-238.
49. Jensen, M. P. (1996). Enhancing motivation to change in pain treatment. In R. J. Gatchel & D. C. Turk (Eds.), Psychological approaches to pain management: A practitioner's handbook. New York: The Guilford Press.
50. Keefe F.J., Block A.R., Williams R.B., Surwit R.S. Behavioral treatment of chronic low back pain. Clinical outcome and individual differences in pain relief Pain. 11:1981;221-231.
51. Keller L.S., Butcher N.J. Assessment of chronic pain patients with the MMPI-2. 1991;University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN.
52. Kerns R.D., Turk D.C., Rudy T.E. The West Haven-Yale Multidimensional Pain Inventory (WHYMPI). Pain. 23:1985;345-356.
53. Kinder B.N., Curtiss G., Kalichman S. Anxiety and anger as predictors of MMPI elevations in chronic pain patients. Journal of Personality Assessment. 50:1986;651-661.
54. Kline P. Personality. The psychometric view:1993;Routledge, London.
55. Klump K., Butcher J.N. Psychological tests in treatment planning. Butcher J.N. Personality assessment in managed health care. Using the MMPI-2 in treatment planning:1997;93-130 Oxford University Press, Oxford, England.
56. Kuhn T. The structure of scientific revolutions. 1962;The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
57. Lacroix J.M., Powell J., Lloyd G.J., Doxey N.C., Mitson G.L., Aldam C.F. Low-back pain. Factors of value in predicting outcome Spine. 15:1990;495-499.
58. Lakatos I. Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. Lakatos I., Musgrave A. Criticism and the growth of knowledge. 1970;22-63 Cambridge University Press, London.
59. Leavitt F. The value of the MMPI conversion 'V' in the assessment of psychogenic pain. Journal of Psychosomatic Research. 29:1985;125-131.
60. Leavitt F., Garron D.C. Rorschach and pain characteristics of patients with low back pain and "Conversion V" MMPI profiles. Journal of Personality Assessment. 46:1982;18-25.
61. Leavitt F., Garron D.C., McNeill T.W., Whisler W.W. Organic status, psychological disturbance and pain report characteristics in low back pain patients on compensation. Spine. 7:1982;398-402.
62. Leonard S., Dorfman W. The role of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory in the assessment of sexual dysfunctions. A review Clinical Psychology Review. 16:1996;317-335.
63. Long C.J. The relationship between surgical outcome and MMPI profiles in chronic pain patients. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 37:1981;744-749.
64. Louks J.L., Freeman C.W., Calsyn D.A. Personality organization as an aspect of back pain in a medical setting. Journal of Personality Assessment. 42:1978;152-158.
65. Love A.W., Peck C.L. The MMPI and psychological factors in chronic low back pain. A review Pain. 28:1987;1-12.
66. Main C.J. The Modified Somatic Perception Questionnaire (MSPQ). Journal of Psychosomatic Research. 27:1983;503-514.
67. Main C.J., Wood P.L., Hollis S., Spanswick C., Waddell G. The distress and risk assessment method. A simple patient classification to identify distress and evaluate the risk of poor outcome Spine. 17:1992;42-52.
68. Maruta T., Goldman S., Chan C.W., Ilstrup D.M., Kunselman A.R., Colligan R.C. Waddell's nonorganic signs and Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory profiles in patients with low back pain. Spine. 22:1997;72-75.
69. McCreary C. Empirically derived MMPI profile clusters and characteristics of low back pain patients. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 53:1985;558-560.
70. McCreary C., Naliboff B., Cohen M. A comparison of clinically and empirically derived MMPI subgroups in low back pain patients. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 45:1989;560-570.
71. McCreary C., Turner J., Dawson E. Differences between functional and organic low back pain patients. Pain. 4:1977;73-78.
72. McCreary C., Turner J., Dawson E. The MMPI as a predictor of response to conservative treatment for low back pain. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 35:1979;278-284.
73. McGill J.C., Lawlis G.F., Selby D., Mooney V., McCoy C.E. The relationship of Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) profile clusters to pain behaviors. Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 6:1983;77-92.
74. McGrath R.E., O'Malley W.B. The assessment of denial and physical complaints. The validity of the Hy scale and associated MMPI signs Journal of Clinical Psychology. 42:1986;754-760.
75. McMahon M.J., Gatchel R.J., Polatin P.B., Mayer T.G. Early childhood abuse in chronic spinal disorder patients. A major barrier to treatment success Spine. 22:1997;2408-2415.
76. Melzack R., Wall P.D. Pain mechanisms. A new theory Science. 50:1965;971-979.
77. Millon T. The nature of personality. Millon T. Disorders of personality. 1981;3-23 John Wiley & Sons, New York.
78. Naliboff B.D., McCreary C.P., McArthur D.L., Cohen M.J., Gottlieb H.J. MMPI changes following behavioral treatment of chronic low back pain. Pain. 35:1988;271-277.
79. Norton, J. C. (1990). Compensation and litigation in disabled pain patients. In Miller, T. W. (Ed.), Chronic pain: Clinical issues in health care management (pp. 110-148). Madison, CT. International University Press.
80. Novy D.M., Nelson D.V., Berry L., Averill P.M. What does the Beck Depression Inventory measure in chronic pain? A reappraisal. Pain. 61:1995;261-270.
81. Oostdam E.M., Duivenvoorden H.J., Pondaag W. Predictive value of some psychological tests on the outcome of surgical intervention in low back pain patients. Journal of Psychosomatic Research. 25:1981;227-235.
82. Ornduff S.R., Brennan A.F., Barrett C.L. The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) hysteria (hy) scale. Scoring bodily concern and psychological denial subscales in chronic pain patients Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 11:1988;131-146.
83. Pheasant H.C., Gilbert D., Gildfarb J., Herron L. The MMPI as a predictor of outcome in low-back surgery. Spine. 4:1979;78-84.
84. Pichot P., Perse J., Lekeous M.O., Dureau J.L., Perez C.I., Rychewaert A. La personalite des subjects presentant des douleurs dorsales fonchonnelles valeur de l'inventaire multiphasique de personalite du minnesota. Revue de Psychologie Applique. 22:1972;145-172.
85. Pilowsky I., Spence N. Manual for the Illness Behavior Questionnaire (IBQ). 3rd ed:1994;University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia.
86. Polatin P.B., Kinney R.K., Gatchel R.J., Lillo E., Mayer T.G. Psychiatric illness and chronic low-back pain. The mind and the spine - which goes first? Spine. 18:1993;66-71.
87. Pollack D.R., Grainey T.F. A comparison of MMPI profiles for state and private disability insurance applicants. Journal of Personality Assessment. 48:1984;121-125.
88. Pope M.H., Rosen J.C., Wilder D.G., Frymoyer J.W. The relation between biomechanical and psychological factors in patients with low back pain. Spine. 5:1980;173-177.
89. Prokop C.K. Hysteria scale elevations in low back pain patients. A risk factor for misdiagnosis? Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 54:1986;558-562.
90. Riley J.L., Robinson M.E., Geisser M.E., Wittmer V.T. Multivariate cluster analysis of the MMPI-2 in chronic low-back pain patients. Clinical Journal of Pain. 9:1993;248-252.
91. Riley J.L., Robinson M.E., Geisser M.E., Wittmer V.T., Smith A.G. Relationship between MMPI-2 cluster profiles and surgical outcome in low-back pain patients. Journal of Spinal Disorders. 8:1995;213-219.
92. Roberts A.H., Reinhardt L. The behavioral management of chronic pain. Long-term follow-up with comparison groups Pain. 8:1980;151-162.
93. Rook J.C., Pesch R.N., Keeler E.C. Chronic pain and the questionable use of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory. Archives of Physical Rehabilitation Medicine. 62:1981;373-376.
94. Rosen J.C., Frymoyer J.W., Clements J.H. A further look at the validity of the MMPI with low back patients. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 36:1980;994-1000.
95. Rosen J.C., Grubman J.A., Bevins T., Frymoyer J.W. Musculoskeletal status and disability of MMPI profile subgroups among patients with low back pain. Health Psychology. 6:1987;581-598.
96. Schmidt J.P., Wallace R.W. Factor analysis of the MMPI profiles of low back pain patients. Journal of Personality Assessment. 46:1982;366-369.
97. Sherman R.A., Camfield M.R., Arena J.G. The effect of presence or absence of low back pain on the MMPI's conversion V. Military Psychology. 7:1995;29-38.
98. Snyder D.K. Assessing chronic pain with the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI). Miller T.W. Chronic pain. Clinical issues in health care management:1990;215-257 International University Press, Madison, CT.
99. Sorensen L.V., Mors O. Presentation of a new MMPI scale to predict outcome after first lumbar discectomy. Pain. 34:1988;191-194.
100. Sternbach R.A. Pain patients. Traits and treatment:1974;Academic Press, New York.
101. Sternbach R.A., Timmermans G. Personality changes associated with reduction of pain. Pain. 1:1975;177-181.
102. Sternbach R.A., Wolf S.R., Murphy R.W., Akeson W.H. Aspects of chronic low back pain. Psychosomatics. 14:1973;52-56. a.
103. Sternbach R.A., Wolf S.R., Murphy R.W., Akeson W.H. Traits of pain patients. The low back 'loser.' Psychosomatics. 14:1973;226-229. b.
104. Swimmer G.I., Robinson M.E., Geisser M.E. Relationship of MMPI cluster type, pain coping strategy, and treatment outcome. Clinical Journal of Pain. 8:1992;131-137.
105. Towne W.S., Tsushima W.T. The use of the low back and dorsal scales in the identification of functional low back patients. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 34:1978;88-91.
106. Trief P.M., Yuan H.A. The use of the MMPI in a chronic back pain rehabilitation program. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 39:1983;46-53.
107. Troup J.D., Foreman T.K., Baxter C.E., Brown D. The perception of back pain and the role of psychophysical tests of lifting capacity. Spine. 12:1987;645-657.
108. Tsushima W.T., Towne W.S. Clinical limitations of the low back scale. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 35:1979;306-308.
109. Turk D.C. Biopsychosocial perspective on chronic pain. Gatchel R.J., Turk D.C. Psychological approaches to pain management. A practitioner's handbook:1996;3-32 The Guilford Press, New York.
110. Turk D.C., Rudy T.E., Kubinski J.A., Zaki H.S., Greco C.M. Dysfunctional patients with temporomandibular disorders. Evaluating the efficacy of a tailored treatment protocol Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 64:1996;139-146.
111. Turk D.C., Rudy T.E., Sorkin B. Neglected topics in chronic pain treatment outcome studies. Determination of success Pain. 53:1993;3-16.
112. Turner J.A., Herron L., Weiner P. Utility of the MMPI pain index in predicting outcome after lumbar surgery. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 42:1986;764-769.
113. Turner J.A., McCreary C. Short forms of the MMPI with back pain patients. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 46:1978;354-355.
114. Uomoto J.M., Turner J.A., Herron L.D. Use of the MMPI and MCMI in predicting outcome of lumbar laminectomy. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 44:1988;191-197.
115. Vallfors B. Acute, subacute and chronic low back pain. Clinical symptoms, absenteeism and working environment Scandinavian Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine Supplement 11. 1-98:1985.
116. Vendrig A.A. Comment on 'Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory profiles in persons with and without low back pain. A 20-year follow-up study' Spine. 21:1996;1939-1940.
117. Vendrig A.A. Prognostic factors and treatment-related changes associated with return to work in the multimodal treatment of chronic back pain. Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 22:1999;217-232.
118. Vendrig A.A., de Mey H.R., Derksen J.J.L., van Akkerveeken P.F. Assessment of chronic back pain patient characteristics using factor analysis of the MMPI-2. Which dimensions are actually assessed? Pain. 76:1998;179-188.
119. Waddell G., McCulloch J.A., Kummel E., Venner R.M. Nonorganic physical signs in low-back pain. Spine. 5:1980;117-125.
120. Waring E.M., Weisz G.M., Bailey S.I. Predictive factors in the treatment of low back pain by surgical intervention. Bonica J.J., Albe-Fessard D.G. Advances in pain research and therapy. 1976;939-942 Raven Press, New York.
121. Watkins R.G., O'Brien J.P., Draugelis R., Jones D. Comparisons of preoperative and postoperative MMPI data in chronic back patients. Spine. 11:1986;385-390.
122. Watson D. Neurotic tendencies among chronic pain patients. An MMPI item analysis Pain. 14:1982;365-385.
123. Wilfling F.J., Klonoff H., Kokan P. Psychological, demographic and orthopedic factors associated with prediction of outcome of spinal fusion. Clinical Orthopedics and Related Research. 90:1973;153-160.
124. Williams A.C., Richardson P.H. What does the BDI measure in chronic pain? Pain. 55:1993;259-266.
125. Wiltse L.L., Rocchio P.D. Preoperative psychological tests as predictors of success of chemonucleolysis in the treatment of the low-back syndrome. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. 57:1975;478-483.