Diffusion theory in biology: A relic of mechanistic materialism

Journal of the History of Biology

Volumn 33, Issue 1, 2000, Pages 71-111

  Agutter, Paul S ^a   Malone, P Colm ^b   Wheatley, Denys N ^c  

^a EDINBURGH NAPIER UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b MacRobert Building ^*  (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF ABERDEEN   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

19th century physiology; Diffusion theory; Fick; Mechanistic materialism; Metabolic organization; Oxygen secretion

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BIOLOGY; DIFFUSION; HISTORY; PHILOSOPHY;

BIOLOGY; DIFFUSION; HISTORY, 19TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 20TH CENTURY; PHILOSOPHY, MEDICAL;

MAMMALIA;

EID: 0034102689     PISSN: 00225010     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/A:1004745516972     Document Type: Article

References (149)

1. Agutter, Paul S. 1991. Between Nucleus and Cytoplasm. London: Chapman and Hall.
2. _ 1994. "Models of Solid-State Transport: Messenger RNA Movement from Nucleus to Cytoplasm." Cell Biology International 18: 849-858.
3. _ 1994. "Intracellular Solute Movements: a Problem-Orientated Lecture for Final Year Undergraduates." Biochemical Education 22: 32-35.
4. Agutter, Paul S. and Taylor, Philip L. 1996. The Meaning of Nucleocytoplasmic Transport. Austin, Texas: R. G. Landes Co. pp. 21-52.
5. Agutter, Paul S. and Wheatley, Denys N. 1999. "Random Walks and Cell Size." BioEssays (in press).
6. _ 1999. "Foundations in Biology: On the Problem of 'Purpose' in Biology in Relation to our Acceptance of the Darwinian Theory of Natural Selection." Foundations of Science 4: 3-23.
7. Agutter, Paul S., Malone P. Colm and Wheatley, Denys N. 1995. "Intracellular Transport Mechanisms: A Critique of Diffusion Theory." Journal of Theoretical Biology 176: 261-272.
8. Alberts, Bruce, Bray, Dennis, Lewis, Julian, Raff, Martin, Roberts, Keith and Watson, James. 1998. Molecular Biology of the Cell. 2nd Edition. New York: Garland.
9. Allen, Garland E. 1967. "J. S. Haldane: The Development of the Idea of Control Mechanisms in Respiration." Journal of the History of Medicine 22: 392.
10. _ 1978. Life Science in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11. Balcar, J. O., Sansum, W. D. and Woodyatt, T. T. 1919. "Fever and the Water Reserve of the Body." Archives of Internal Medicine 24: 116-128.
12. Barcroft, Joseph, Binger, C. A., Bock, A. V., Doggart, J. H., Forbes, H. S., Harrop, G., Meakins J. C. and Redfield, A. C. 1923. "Observations on the Effect of High Altitude on the Physiological Processes of he Human Body Carried out in Peruvian Andes, Chiefly Cerro de Pasco." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal society, Series B 211: 351-480.
13. Barcroft, Joseph, Cooke, A., Hartridge, H., Parsons, T. R. and Parsons, W. 1920. "The Flow of Oxygen through the Pulmonary Epithelium." Journal of Physiology 53: 450-472.
14. Berg, Howard C. 1993. Random Walks in Biology. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
15. Best, Charles H. and Taylor, N. B. 1955. The Physiological Basis of Medical Practice, 6th Edition. London: Balliere Tindall and Cox. pp. 365ff.
16. Bigwood, E. J. 1930. "The Distribution of Ions in Gels." Transactions of the Faraday Society 26: 704-719.
17. Bohr, Christian. 1891. "Sur la respiration pulmonaire." Skandinavisches Archiv für Physiologie 2: 236-268.
18. _ 1893. "Gas-secretion into the Air-bladder of Fishes." Journal of Physiology 5: 494-500.
19. _ 1904. "Karlheinz Hasselbach and August Krogh, Über einen in Biologischer Beziehung Wichtigen Einfluss, de die Kohlensaurespannug des Blutes auf dessen Sauerstoffbindung ubt." Skandinavisches Archiv für Physiologie 16: 402-412.
20. _ 1909. "Über die Spezifische Tagigkeit der Lungen bei der Respiratorischen Gasaufnahme und ihr Verhalten zu der durch die Alveolarwand Stattfindenden Gas-diffusion." Skandinavisches Archiv für Physiologie 22: 221-280.
21. Brown, Robert. 1828. "A Brief Account of Microscopical Observation Made in the Months of June, July and August, 1827, on the Particles Contained in the Pollen of Plants; and on the General Existence of Active Molecules in Organic and Inorganic Bodies." A privately printed pamphlet.
22. Brush, S. G. 1967. "Foundations of Statistical Mechanics, 1845-1915." Archive for the History of the Exact Sciences 4: 145-183.
23. Burdon-Sanderson, John and Ludwig, Carl Friedrich Wilhelm. 1895-1896. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 59: 1-8.
24. Burton, E. F. 1930. Colloid Science Applied to Biology. London: Faraday Society, p. 677.
25. Cannon, Walter B. 1932. The Wisdom of the Body. New York.
26. Cardwell, D. S. L. (ed.). 1968. John Dalton and the Progress of Science. Manchester: University Press.
27. Cater, Douglas B. and Silver, Ian A. 1961. "Microelectrodes and Electrodes used in Biology." In: Reference Electrodes, ed. J. G. Ives and G. J. Janz, p. 512. New York: Academic Press.
28. Chambers, Robert. 1940. The Micromanipulation of Living Cells, In The Cell and Protoplasm, ed. F. R. Moulton, pp. 49-67. Washington, D. C.: AAAS Publication 14.
29. Clegg James S. and Wheatley, Denys N. 1991. "Intracellular Organization: Evolutionary Origins and Possible Consequences to Metabolic Rate Control in Vertebrates." American Zoologist 3: 504-513.
30. Collander R. and Barlund, H. 1933. Acta Botanicae Fenniae 2: 1-48.
31. Cornforth, M. 1968. Materialism and the Dialectical Method. New York: Doubleday.
32. Cranefield, Paul F. 1957. "The Organic Physics of 1847 and the Biophysics of Today." Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 12: 407-423.
33. Crank, John. 1975. The Mathematics of Diffusion. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
34. Dalton, John. 1808. A New System of Chemical Philosophy, Part I, Manchester: Unlisted Publisher.
35. Danielli, James F. and Davson, Hugh. 1935. "A Contribution to the Theory of Permeability of Thin Films." Journal of Cellular and Comparative Physiology 5: 495-508.
36. Davson, Hugh and Danielli, James F. 1940. The Permeability of Natural Membranes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p. 53.
37. Driesch, Hans. 1914. History and Theory of Vitalisms. Tr. London: London University Press.
38. Desmond, A. 1987. "Artisan Resistance and Evolution in Britain, 1819-1848." Osiris 3: 77-110.
39. _ 1989. "Lamarckism and Democracy; Corporations, Corruptions and Comparative Anatomy in the 1830s." In: History, Humanity and Evolution, ed. J. R. Moore. New York: Cambridge University Press.
40. Donnan, Francis G. 1911. "The Theory of Membrane Equilibrium in the Presence of a Non-Dialyzable Electrolyte." Zeitschrift für Elektrochemische, Halle 17: 572-581.
41. _ 1927. "Concerning the Applicability of Thermodynamics to the Phenomena of Life." Journal of General Physiology 8: 685-688.
42. Du Bois-Reymond, Emil. 1848. Untersuchungen über thierische Elektricität. Berlin: G. Reimer. The preface of this work contains a clear statement of the underlying philosophy of the new experimental physiology, which seems to have made a particularly profound impression on Fick.
43. Douglas, Charles G., Haldane, John S., Henderson Y and Schneider, E. C. 1913. "Physiological Observations made on Pike's Peak, Colorado, with Specific Reference to Adaptation to Low Barometric Pressure." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 203 B: 185-318.
44. Durbin, Paul T. 1988. Dictionary of Concepts in the Philosophy of Science. New York: Greenwood Press.
45. Dutrochet, René-J-H. 1827. "Recherches sur L-endosmose et sur les Phénomènes Particuliers aux Corps Vivants." Annales de Chimie et de Physique 35: 411-437.
46. _ 1827. "Nouvelles Observations sur L'endosmose et L'exosmose, et sur la Cause de ce Double Phénomène." Annales de Chimie et de Physique 35: 393-400.
47. Einstein, Albert. 1905. "Von der molekulärkinetischen Theorie der Wärme gefordete Bewegung von in ruhenden Flüssigkeiten suspendierten Teilchen." Annalen der Physike 17: 549-554.
48. _ 1908. "Der Theorie der Brownschen Bewegung." Zeitschrift fur Elektrochemie 14: 235-239.
49. Encyclopedia Britannica. 15th Edition. 1973-4. Volume 2: p. 1130.
50. Fick, Adolf E. 1855. "Über Diffusion." Annalen der Physike, Leipzig 94: 59-86.
51. _ 1904. Gesammelte Schriften (writings collected posthumously), Vol. 1. Würzburg: Stahel.
52. _ 1856. Medizinische Physik. Zürich: Kapelmann.
53. _ 1869. "Die Geschwindigkeitskurve in der Arterie des Lebender Menschen, Untersuch Physiol." Zürischer Hochschule 1: 51-69.
54. Fisher, Albert. 1899. Fixierung, Farbung und Bau des Protoplasmas. Jena: Fischer Verlag.
55. Fourier, Jean-Baptiste. 1828. Theorie Analytique de la Chaleur. Oeuvres: Paris. Translated by Freeman A. 1878. The Analytical Theory of Heat. London: Cambridge University Press.
56. Fourier, Jean-Baptiste. 1828. Theorie Analytique de la Chaleur. Oeuvres: Paris. Translated by Freeman A. 1878. The Analytical Theory of Heat. London: Cambridge University Press.
57. Fulton, John F. 1931. Physiology. New York: Hoeber.
58. Gasking, E. 1970. The Rise of Experimental Biology. New York: Random House.
59. Gortner, R. A. 1929. "The Role of Water in Living Organisms." In: Outlines of Biochemistry. New York: Wiley.
60. Graham, Thomas. 1833. "On the Law of Diffusion of Gases." Philosophical Magazine 2: 175-204.
61. _ 1850. "On the Diffusion of Liquids." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 140: 1-46.
62. Gregory, Frederick. 1977. Scientific Materialism: Nineteenth Century Germany. Lancaster: Reidel.
63. Haldane John S. and Priestley, J. G. 1905. "The Regulation of the Lung Ventilation." Journal of Physiology 32: 225-266.
64. _ 1935. Respiration, 2nd Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press, p. 251.
65. Haldane John S. and Smith, J. L. 1896. "The Oxygen Tension of Arterial Blood." Journal of Physiology 20: 497-517.
66. _ 1897. "The Absorption of Oxygen by the Lungs." Journal of Physiology 22: 231-258.
67. Haldane, John S., Kellas A. S. and Kennaway, E. L. 1919. "Experiments on Acclimatisation to Reduced Atmospheric Pressure." Journal of Physiology 53: 181-206.
68. Hall, Thomas S. 1969. Ideas of Life and Matter, Chicago: University of Illinois Press, pp. 245-251.
69. Halling, Paul J. 1989. "Do the Laws of Chemistry Apply to Living Cells?" Trends in Biochemical Sciences 14: 317-318.
70. Hardy, William B. 1900. "On the Structure of Cell Protoplasm." Journal of Physiology 24: 158-210.
71. _ 1912. "The General Theory of Colloidal Solutions." Proceedings of the Royal Society. Series A 86: 601-610.
72. Harrington, Anne. 1996. Re-enchanted Science: Holism in German Cultures from Wilhelm II to Hitler. Princeton New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
73. Hasenohrl, F. (ed.). 1909. Ludwig Boltzmanns Wissenschaftliche Abhandlungen (3 Volumes), Leipzig: University Press.
74. Hill, Archibald V. 1930. "A Thermal Method of Measuring the Vapour Pressure of an Aqueous Solution." Proceedings of the Royal Society (Lond.) Series A 127: 9-22.
75. _ 1930. Colloid Science Applied to Biology. London: The Faraday Society, p. 672.
76. _ 1956. "Why Biophysics?" Science 124: 1233-1237.
77. Hoofd, L. 1992. "Updating the Krogh Model - Assumptions and Extension." In: Oxygen Transport in Biological Systems, ed. S. Egginton and H. F. Ross, pp. 197-229. Society for Experimental Biology Seminar Series 51. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
78. Hudson, J. A. and Cater, Douglas B. 1964. "An Analysis of Factors Affecting Tissue Oxygen Tension." Proceedings of the Royal Society (Lond.) Series B 161: 247-258.
79. Jacobson, K. and Dietrich, C. 1999. "Looking at Lipid Rafts?" Trends in Cell Biology 9: 87-91.
80. Jacyna, L. S. 1983. "Immanence or Transcendence; Theories of Life and Organization in Britain, 1790-1835." Isis 14: 311-329.
81. Joseph D. D. and Preziosi, L. 1989. "Heat Waves." Review of Modern Physics 61: 41-53.
82. Krogh, August. 1910. "On the Mechanism of Gas-Exchange in the Lungs." Skandinavisches Archiv für Physiologie 23: 248-278.
83. _ 1919. "The Rate of Diffusion of Gases through Animal Tissues." Journal of Physiology 52: 391-408.
84. Krogh, Marie. 1914/5. "The Diffusion of Gases through the Lungs of Man." Journal of Physiology 49: 271-296.
85. Krutch, J. Wood. 1950. The Best of Two Worlds. New York: Sloane Press.
86. Kruyt, H. R. and Overbeek, J. Th. G. 1962. An Introduction of Physical Chemistry for Biologists and Medical Students with Special Reference to Colloid Chemistry. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
87. Kuhn, Thomas S. 1962. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. New York: Columbia University Press.
88. LeFanu, W. R. 1946. John Hunter: a List of his Books. London: Routledge.
89. Lodish, Harvey, Baltimore, David, Berk, Arnold, Zipursky, S. Lawrence, Matsudaira, P. and Darnell, James. 1995. Molecular Cell Biology, 3rd Edition. New York: Scientific American Books.
90. Loeb, Jacques. 1912. The Mechanistic Conception of Life. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press (reprinted 1964).
91. Lombard, W. P. 1916. "The Life and Work of Carl Ludwig." Science 44: 363-375.
92. Longmuir, lain S. 1987. "Adaptation to Hypoxia." In: Oxygen Transport to Tissues IX: Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology, ed. I. A. Silver and A. Silver, pp. 252-276.
93. Ludwig, Carl F. W. 1852 and 1856. Lehrbuch der Physiologie des Menschen (2 Volumes), Heidelberg: University Press.
94. Maddox, John. 1989. "Heat Conduction is a Can of Worms." Nature 338: 373.
95. Malone, P. Colm. 1981. "Cell, Membrane and Diffusion: An Essay in Bio-Theory." Medical Hypotheses 7: 1477-1488.
96. _ 1981. "Concerning the Oxygenation of Tissues and Cells." Medical Hypotheses 7: 1489-1502.
97. Malone P. Colm and Wheatley, Denys N. 1991. "Diffusion: A Bigger Can of Worms." Nature 349: 373.
98. Mandelbaum, M. 1971. History, Man and Reason: Study of Nineteenth Century Thought, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press.
99. Mendelsohn, E. 1965. "Physical Models and Physiological Concepts: Explanation in Nineteenth Century Biology." British Journal of the History of Biology 2: 201-209.
100. Merz, J. T. 1964. A History of European Thought in the Nineteenth Century. New York: Macmillan.
101. Munson R. (ed.) 1970. New York: Random House, pp. 19-32. (But see also Beckner, M. Organismic Biology, pp. 54-62).
102. Munson R. (ed.) 1970. New York: Random House, pp. 19-32. (But see also Beckner, M. Organismic Biology, pp. 54-62).
103. Nagel, Ernst. 1970. "Mechanistic Explanation and Organismic Biology." Man and Nature.
104. Nernst, H. W. 1888. "Zur Kinetic der in Losung Befindlichen Korper I: Theorie der Diffusion." Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie 2: 613-637.
105. Nernst H. W. and Barratt, J. O. W. 1904. "Elektrische Nervenreizung durch Wechelstrome." Zeitschrift für Elektrochemie 10: 664-668.
106. Nernst H. W. and Ostwald, F. Wilhelm. 1889. "Über freie lonen." Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie? 3: 120-130.
107. Niven, Sir W. D. (ed.). 1890. The Scientific Papers of James Clerk Maxwell (2 Volumes), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
108. Nussbaum, M. 1873. "Fortgezetzte Untersuchungen en uber Athmung der Lungen." Pflugers Archive 7: 296-300.
109. Olmsted, J. M. D. 1938. Claude Bernard: Physiologist. New York: Academic Press.
110. Ostwald, F. Wilhelm. 1904. "The Faraday Lecture." Journal of the Chemical Society 85: 506-522.
111. _ 1909. Grundriss der Allgemeinen Chemie. Leipzig; Engelman. Translated by W.W. Taylor. 1912. Under the title: Outlines of General Chemistry. London: MacMillan.
112. _ 1909. Grundriss der Allgemeinen Chemie. Leipzig; Engelman. Translated by W.W. Taylor. 1912. Under the title: Outlines of General Chemistry. London: MacMillan.
113. Overton, Charles E. 1899. "Über die Allgemeinen Osmotischen Eigenschaften der Zelle, ihre vermutlichen Ursachen und ihre Bedeutung für die Physiologie." Vierteljahrsschrift der Naturforschenden Gesellschaft in Zürich 44: 88-135.
114. Paine, Philip L. 1984. "Diffusive and Non-diffusive Proteins in vivo. Journal of Cell Biology 99: 188s-195s.
115. Perrin, Jean. 1909. "Mouvement Brownien et Realité Moleculaire." Annales de Chimie et de Physique 118: 1-114.
116. Peters, Reiner. 1986. "Fluorescence Microphotolysis to Measure Nucleocytoplasmic Transport and Intracellular Mobility." Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 864: 305-359.
117. Peters, Sir Rudolph A. 1930. "Surface Structure in Cell Activity." Transactions of the Faraday Society 26: 797-807.
118. Polyani, Michael. 1968. "Life's Irreducible Structure." Science. 160: 1308-1312.
119. Porter, Keith R. 1984. "The Cytomatrix: A Short History of its Study." Journal of Cell Biology 99: 3s-12s.
120. Riese, W. 1943. "Claude Bernard in the Light of Modern Science." Bulletin of the History of Medicine 14: 281-294.
121. Robinson Robert A. and Stokes, Robert H. 1956. Electrolyte Solutions. London: Butterworths.
122. Rosenfeld, L. 198. In: Dictionary of Scientific Biography (Vol. I), ed. C.C. Gillespie. New York: Scribner.
123. Ruse, Michael. 1989. Philosophy of Biology. New York: Collier Macmillan.
124. Schenck, Franz. 1902. "Adolf Pick." Pflügers Archives 90: 313-361.
125. Sherrington, Charles S. 1906. Integrative Action of the Nervous System. New Haven, CO: Yale University Press.
126. Singer, Sydney G. and Nicolson, Garth L. 1972. "The Fluid Mosaic Model of the Structure of Cell Membranes." Science 175: 720-731.
127. Strassburg, Gusta. 1872. "Die Topographjie der Gasspannungen in thiereschen Organismus." Pflügers Archive 6: 65-96.
128. Temkin, Oswei. 1946. "Materialism in French and German Physiology of the Early Nineteenth Century." Bulletin of the History of Medicine 20: 322-327.
129. Thiele, J. 1968. ""Naturphilosophie" und "Monismus" um 1900." Philosophia Naturalis 10: 295-315.
130. Thompson, D'Arcy Wentworth. 1917. On Growth and Form. Cambridge: University Press, chapter 1.
131. Tyrrell, H. J. V. 1961. Diffusion and Heat Flow in Liquids. London: Butterworth.
132. Ussing, Hans H. 1949. "The Distinction by Means of Tracers between Active Transport and Diffusion." Acta Physiological Scandinavica 19: 43-56.
133. _ 1949. "Transport of Ions across Cellular Membranes." Physiological Reviews 29: 127-155.
134. Vogel, Steven. 1988. Life's Devices: The Physical World of Animals and Plants. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
135. Von Smoluchowski, Maryan. 1906. "Zur kinetischen Theorie der Brownschen Molekulärbewegung und der Suspensionen." Annalen der Physike 21: 756-780.
136. Warburg, Otto. 1912. "Über Beziehung zwischen Zellstruktur und Biochimischen Reaktionen." Pflügers Archives 145: 277-291.
137. Wax, N. (ed.). 1954. Selected Papers on Noise and Stochastic Processes. New York: Dover Press.
138. Wheatley, Denys N. 1985. "On the Possible Importance of an Intracellular Circulation." Life Sciences 36: 299-307.
139. _ 1993. "Diffusion Theory in Biology: its Validity and Relevance." Journal of Biological Education 27: 181-188.
140. _ 1999. "On the Vital Role of Fluid Movement in Organisms and Cells: A Brief Historical Account from Harvey to Coulson Extending the Hypothesis of Circulation." Medical Hypotheses 52: 275-284.
141. Wheatley Denys N. and Clegg, James S. 1994. "What Determines the Basal Metabolic Rate of Vertebrate Cells In Vivo?" BioSystems 32: 83-92.
142. Wheatley Denys N. and Malone, P. Colm. 1987. "Diffusion and Perfusion in the Living Cell: Implication for Metabolic Regulation and Organization." In: The Organization of the Cell Metabolism, ed. G. R. Welch and J. S. Clegg, pp. 171-173. NATO ARI Series 127.
143. _ 1993. "Heat Conductance, Diffusion Theory and Intracellular Metabolic Regulation." Biology of the Cell 79: 1-5.
144. Whitehead, Alfred North. 1926. Science and the Modern World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
145. Wiener, Norbert. 1948. Cybernetics. New York: Wiley.
146. _ 1964. Selected Papers No 2. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
147. Wilson, Leonard G. 1968. "Starling's Discovery of Osmotic Equilibrium in the Capillaries." Episteme 2: 3.
148. Wolffberg, Siegfreid. 1871. "Uber die Stannung der Blutgas in die Lungen capillaren." Pflügers Archive 4: 465-492.
149. Young, J. Zachary. 1951. In Doubt and Certainty in Science. The BBC Reith Lectures, 1950. Oxford: Oxford University Press.