Privatizing water, producing scarcity: The Yorkshire drought of 1995

Economic Geography

Volumn 76, Issue 1, 2000, Pages 4-27

  Bakker, Karen J ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Discourse analysis; Drought; Privatization; Regulation theory; Water management; Yorkshire

Indexed keywords

DROUGHT; PRIVATIZATION; REGULATORY APPROACH; WATER SUPPLY;

ENGLAND(WEST YORKSHIRE); UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 0034053202     PISSN: 00130095     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1944-8287.2000.tb00131.x     Document Type: Article

References (142)

1. Aglietta, M. 1979. A theory of capitalist regulation: The US experience. London: New Left Books.
2. Allan, J. A., and Karshenas, M. A. 1996. Managing environmental capital: The case of water in Israel, Jordan, the West Bank and Gaza, 1947-1995. In Water, peace and the Middle East: Negotiating resources in the Jordan basin, ed. J. A. Allan, 75-119. Oxford: Tauris Academic Publishers.
3. Altvater, E. 1989. Ecological and economic modalities of time and space. Capitalism, Nature, Socialism 3:59-71.
4. _. 1993. The future of the market: An essay on the regulation of money and nature after the collapse of "actually-existing socialism." London: Verso.
5. Amin, A., ed. 1994. Post-Fordism: A reader. Oxford: Blackwell.
6. Armstrong, M.; Cowan, S.; and Vickers, J. 1994. Regulatory reform: Economic analysis and the British experience. Cambridge: MIT Press.
7. Arnell, N. W.; Jenkins, A.; and George, D. G. 1994. The implications of climate change for the National Rivers Authority. NRA Research and Development: Report, No. 12. Bristol: National Rivers Authority.
8. Averch, H., and Johnson, L. 1962. Behaviour of the firm under regulatory constraints. American Economic Review 52:1052-69.
9. Bakker, K. 1999a. Privatizing water. Ph.D. diss., School of Geography, Oxford University.
10. _. 1999b. Deconstructing discourses of drought. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 24:367-78.
11. Barkas, E., and Walker, C. 1996. Yorkshire Water faces £150m kill for drought. Yorkshire: Post, 29 February.
12. Boulton, L. 1996. Yorkshire Water in £70m drought fight. Financial Times, 27 April, 4.
13. Boyer, R. 1990. The Regulation School: A critical introduction. New York: Columbia University Press.
14. Brenner, R., and Click, M. 1991. The regulation approach: Theory and history. New Left Review 188:45-120.
15. Buckley, C. 1996. Yorkshire Water counts the cost of supply hitches. The Times, 29 February.
16. Buller, H. 1996. Privatization and Europeanization: The changing context of water supply in Britain and France. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 39:461-82.
17. Bunyan, N. 1995. Drought firm plans second £50m pipeline. Yorkshire Post, 15 December.
18. Burke, T. 1996. Lifebuoy men, Lux women: Commodification, consumption and cleanliness in modern Zimbabwe. London: Duke University Press.
19. Castree, N. 1995. The nature of produced nature: Materiality and knowledge construction in Marxism, Antipode 27:12-48.
20. _. 1997. Nature, economy and the cultural politics of theory: The "War against the Seals" in the Bering Sea, 1870-1911. Geoforum 28:1-20.
21. Castree, N., and Braun, B. 1998. The construction of nature and the nature of construction. In Remaking reality: Nature at the millennium, ed. B. Braun and N. Castree, 3-42. London: Routledge.
22. Clark, G. 1988. Stylized facts and close dialogue: Methodology in economic geography. Annals of the, Association of American Geographers 88:73-87.
23. _. 1992a. Commentary - "real" regulation. Environment and Planning A 24:613-14.
24. _. 1992b. "Real" regulation - the administrative state. Environment and Planning A 24:615-27.
25. Clarke, S. 1988. Overaccumulatian, class struggle and the regulation approach. Capital and Class 38:59-92.
26. Cocklin, C. and Blunden, D. 1998. Sustainability, water resources, and regulation. Geoforum 29:51-58.
27. Darier, E., ed. 1999. Discourses of the environment. Oxford: Blackwell.
28. Day, D. 1987. An Australian perspective on drought and water management objectives for regional development. Water Resources Development 3:267-83.
29. Department of the Environment. 1996a. Water resources and supply: Agenda for action. London: The Stationery Office.
30. _. 1996b. Review of the potential effects of climate change in the United Kingdom. London: HMSO.
31. De Vroey, M. 1984. A regulation approach interpretation of the contemporary crisis. Capital and Class 23:454-56.
32. Downing, T., and Bakker, K. 2000. Drought discourse and vulnerability. In Drought Hazards and disasters: A series of definitive major works, ed. D. A. Wilhite. London: Routledge, in press.
33. Dracup, S. 1973. Water supply in Great Britain: A brief history in six parts. British Water Supply, January-June.
34. Drummond, I., and Marsden, T. K. 1995. Regulating sustainable development. Global Environmental Change 5:51-64.
35. Dunford, M. 1990. Theories of regulation. Society and Space 8:297-321.
36. Eagleton, T. 1991. Ideology. London: Verso.
37. Emel, J. 1990. Resource instrumentalism, privatization, and commodification. Urban Geography 11:527-47.
38. Emel, J., and Brooks, E. 1988. Changes in form and function of property rights institutions under threatened resource scarcity. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 78:241-52.
39. Emel, J., and Roberts, R. 1995. Institutional form and its effect on environmental change: The case of groundwater in the Southern High Plains. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 85:664-83.
40. Emel J.; Roberts, R.; and Sauri, D. 1992. Ideology, property, and groundwater resources. Political Geography 11:37-54.
41. Environment Agency. 1996a. Review of water Company plans to safeguard summer water supplies: Environment Agency report to the Secretary of State for the Envinmnient. Fourth report of a series. Bristol: Environment Agency.
42. _. 1996b. Interim report on the environmental imparts of the drought on Yorkshire's rivers: April 1995-April 1996. Leeds: Environment Agency.
43. Ernst, J. 1994. Whose utility? The social impact of public utility privatization and regulation in Britain. Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
44. Farrar, C. 1996. Yorkshire Water stuns customers with its latest letter: Because we've been so efficient, here's a cheque for £10. Yorkshire Post, 16 September.
45. Ferner, A., and Colling, T. 1993. Privatization of the British utilities: Regulation, decentralization and industrial relations. In The political economy of privatization, ed. T. Clarke and C. Pitelis, 125-41. London: Routledge.
46. Firms hit by water shortages . . . should move. 1995. Yorkshire Post, 29 August.
47. Foster, C. D. 1992. Privatization, public ownership and the regulation of natural monopoly. Oxford: Blackwell.
48. Gandy, M. 1997. The making of a regulatory crisis: Restructuring New Yorks water supply. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 22:338-58.
49. Gibbs, D. 1996. Integrating sustainable development and economic restructuring: A role for regulation theory? Geoforum 27:1-10.
50. Gibson-Graham, J-K. 1996. The end of capitalism (as we knew it): A feminist critique of political economy, Oxford: Blackwell.
51. Gill, A. 1995. Digging a watery grave. Yorkshire Post, 6 September.
52. Graham, S. 1997. Liberalized utilities, new technologies, and urban social polarization - the UK experience. European Urban and Regional Studies 4:135-50.
53. Graham, S., and Marvin, S. 1995. More than ducts and wires: Post-Fordism, cities and utility networks. In Managing cities: The new urban context, ed. P. Healey, S. Cameron, S. Davodi, S. Graham, and A. Madani-Pour, 160-80. London: John Wiley & Sons.
54. Hajer, M. A. 1995. The politics of environmental discourse: Ecological modernization and the policy process. Oxford: Clarendon.
55. Hassan, J. 1995. The impact of EU environmental policy on water industry reform. European Environment 5:45-51.
56. Hassan, J. and Taylor, P. 1996. The politics of water in early and mid-Victorian Britain. Discussion Paper in Economics and Economic History 96-01. Manchester: Manchester Metropolitan University.
57. Haughton, G. 1998. Private profits-pubfic drought: The creation of a crisis in water management for West Yorkshire. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 23:419-33.
58. Hay, C. 1995. Re-stating the problem of regulation and re-regulating the local state. Economy and Society 24:387-407.
59. Helm, D. and Yarrow, G. 1988. The assessment: The regulation of utilities. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 4:i-xxxi.
60. Hughes, S. 1996. Report for the Yorkshire Wildlife Trust on the independent commission of inquiry into water supply in Yorkshire. York: Yorkshire Wildlife Trust
61. Hunt, L., and Lynk, E. 1995. Privatization and efficiency in the UK water industry: An empirical analysis, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 57:371-88.
62. Jessop, B. 1990. Regulation theories in retrospect and prospect. Economy and Society 19:153-216.
63. _. 1992. Fordism and post-Fordism: A critical reformulation. In Pathways to industrialization and regional development, ed. M. Storper and A. Scott, 46-69. London: Routledge.
64. _. 1995. The regulation approach, governance, and post-Fordism. Economy and Society 24:307-33.
65. Lascelles, D., and Martinson, J. 1996. Yorkshire Water hit by £40m revenue penalty: Price curb agreed as regulator attacks "serious failures." Financial Times, 22 June, 4.
66. Latour, B. 1993. We have never been modern. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
67. Lazenby, P. 1995. Water stocks continue to fall as cut-offs loom. Yorkshire Post, 21 September.
68. _. 1996. Water watchdog anger as profits hit £162m. Yorkshire Post, 1 June, 5.
69. Letza, S., and Smallman, C. 1996. Is water thicker than blood? Overcoming the conspiracy of profit over social responsibility in privatized utilities. In Public and private sector: Partnerships working for change, ed. L. Montanheir, G. Rebelo, and E. Rebelo, 289-303. Sheffield: Pavic Publications.
70. Lipietz, A. 1987. Mirages and miracles: The crisis of global Fordism. London: New Left Books.
71. _. 1988. Reflections on a tale: The Marxist foundations of the concepts of regulation and accumulation. Studies in Political Economy 26:7-36.
72. _. 1992. Towards a new economic order. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
73. Litfin, K. 1994. Ozone discourses: Science and politics in global environmental cooperation. New York: Columbia University Press.
74. MacGuire, F. 1996. The environmental threats of the Kielder Transfer Scheme. FOE Briefing Sheet. London: Friends of the Earth.
75. Maloney. W., and Richardson, J. 1994. Water policy-making in England and Wales: Policy communities under pressure? Environmental Politics 3:110-38.
76. _. 1995. Managing policy change in Britain: The politics of water Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
77. Marden, P. 1992. "Real" regulation reconsidered. Environment and Planning A 24:751-67.
78. Marsh, T. I995. Drought returns to the United Kingdom. Drought Network News 7:5-6.
79. _. 1996. The 1995 UK drought - A signal of climatic instability? Proceeding of the Institution of Civil Engineers: Water, Marine and Energy 118:189-95.
80. Marsh, T., and Turton, P. S. 1996. The 1995 drought - A water resources perspective. Weather (February): 47-53.
81. Martin, S., and Parker, D. 1997. Privatization: The conceptual framework. In The impact of privatization: Ownership and corporate performance in the UK, ed. S. Martin and D. Parker, 1-30. London: Routledge.
82. Martinson, J. 1996a. Companies and finance: Yorkshire Water moves to restore its reputation. Financial Times, 6 June.
83. _. 1996b. Companies and finance: Yorkshire hopes tide has turned. Financial Times, 24 July.
84. _. 1996c. Companies and finance: Yorkshire chief faces grilling. Financial Times, 26 July.
85. _. 1996d. Companies and finance: Yorkshire still "very keen" to return value. Financial Times, 30 November, 30.
86. McDowell, L. 1991. Valid games? A response to Erica Schoenberger. Professional Geographer 44:212-15.
87. Melville, A. 1994. Power, strategy and games: Economic regulation of a privatized utility. Public Administration 72:385-408.
88. Millward, R. 1989. Privatization in historical perspective: The UK water industry. In Money, trade and payments Essays in honour of D.J. Coppock, ed. D. Cobham, R. Harrington, and G. Zis, 188-209. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
89. Moulaert, F., and Swyngedouw, E. 1989. A regulation approach to the geography of flexible production systems. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 7:327-45.
90. Murray, P. 1993. The neceessity of money: How Hegel helped Marx surpass Ricardo's theory of value. In Marx's, method in capital, ed. F. Moseley, 37-62. Atlantic Highlands, N.J.: Humanities Press.
91. National Rivers Authority (NRA). 1994a. Water Nature's precious resource. Bristol: NRA.
92. _. 1994b. Regional water resources strategy: Northumbria and Yorkshire. Leeds: NRA.
93. _. 1995a. Saving water: The NRA's approach to water conservation and demand management. Bristol: NRA.
94. _. 1995b. The drought of 1995: A report to the Secretary of State for the Environment. Bristol: NRA.
95. _. 1995c. Measures to safeguard public water supplies: A second report to the Secretary of State for the Environment on the drought of 1995. Bristol: NRA.
96. _. 1996a. Refill prospects: A third report to the Secretary of State, for the Environment on the drought of 1995/96. Bristol: NRA.
97. _ 1996b. Review of water company plans to safeguard water supplies. Bristol: NRA.
98. Nevarez, L. 1996. Just wait until there's a drought: Mediating environmental crises for urban growth. Antipode 28:246-72.
99. Nixon, J. S. 1995. Yorkshire Water Services Ltd: Applications for emergency draught orders. London: Department of the Environment.
100. Nöel, A. 1987. Accumulation, regulation and social change: An essay on French political economy. International Organisation 41:303-33.
101. O'Connell-Davidson, J. 1993. Privatization and employment relations: The case of the water industry. London: Mansell.
102. Office of Water Services (OfWat). 1995. Compensation for customers: A consultation paper on the issues raised by the 1995 drought. Birmingham: OfWat.
103. _. 1996a. Report on conclusions from OfWat's enquiry into the performance of Yorkshire Water Services Ltd. Birmingham: OfWat.
104. _ 1996b. Compensation for customers: Review of the Guaranteed Standards scheme. Birmingham: OfWat.
105. _. 1996c. Customer benefits, investments and dividends: Letter to managing directors of all water and sewerage companies and water only companies. Birmingham: OfWat.
106. _. 1997. 1996-97 Report on leakage and water efficiency. Birmingham: OfWat.
107. Ogden, S., and Glaister, K. 1996. The cautious monopolists - Strategies of Britain's privatized water companies. Long Range Planning 29:663-74.
108. Oxford Economic Research Associates. 1997. Water resources demand. OXERA Briefing Paper 6/97. Oxford; OXERA.
109. Peck, J., and Tickell, A. 1994. Searching for a new institutional fix: The after-Fordist crisis and global-local disorder. In Post-Fordism: A reader, ed. A. Amin, 280-315. Oxford: Blackwell.
110. Peet, R., and Watts, M. 1993. Introduction: Development theory and environment in an age of market truimphalism. Economic Geography 69:227-53.
111. Penning-Rowsell, E. C., and Parker, D. J. 1983. The changing economic and political character of water planning in Britain. Progress in Resource Management and Environmental Planning 4:169-99.
112. Rees, J. 1989. Water privatization. Department of Geography Research Papers London: London School of Economics.
113. 1996. The drought of 1995: The customers' perspective in Bradford. Research study conducted on behalf of the Office of Water Services. Solihull: Research by Design.
114. Richardson. J.; Maloney, W.; and Rudig, W. 1992. The dynamics of policy change, lobbying and water privatization. Public Administration 70:157-75.
115. Roberts. R. S., and Emel, J. 1992. Uneven development and the tragedy of the commons: Competing images for nature-society analysis. Economic Geography 68:249-71.
116. Rofe, B. H., and Hampson, E. 1995a. Yorkshire Water drought orders 1995: Independent assessment report. London Department of the Environment.
117. _. 1995b. Yorkshire Water drought orders 1995: Second assessment report. London: Department of the Environment.
118. Saunders, P., and Harris, C. 1994. Privatization and popular capitalism. Philadelphia: Open University Press.
119. Schoenberger, E. 1991a. The corporate interview as a research method in economic geography. Professional Geographer 43:180-89.
120. _. 1991b. Self-criticism and self-awareness in research: A reply to Linda McDowell. Professional Geographer 44:215-18.
121. Schramm. E., and Kluge, T. 1994. The German water crisis: A socio-ecological view. Capitalism, Nature, Socialism 5:99-113.
122. Shaoul, J. 1997. A critical financial analysis of the performance of privatized industry: The case of the UK water industry. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 8:479-505.
123. Smith, N. 1984. Uneven development. Oxford: Basil Biackwell.
124. _. 1996. The production of nature. In future natural, ed. G. Robertson, M. Mash, L. Tichner, J. Bird, B. Curtis, and T. Putnam, 15-54. London: Routledge.
125. Solway, J. S. 1994. Drought as a "revelatory crisis"; An exploration of shifting entitlements and hierarchies in the Kalahari, Botswana. Development and Change 25:471-95.
126. Swyngedouw, E. 1997. Power, nature and the city. The conquest of water and the political ecology of urbanization in Guayaquil, Ecuador: 1880-1990. Environment and Planning A 29:311-32.
127. Tickell, A., and Peck, J. 1992. Accumulation, regulation and the geographies of post-Fordism: Missing links in regulationist research. Progress in Human Geography 16:190-218.
128. _. 1995. Social regulation after Fordism: Regulation theory, neo-liberalism and the global-local nexus. Economy and Society 24:357-86.
129. Uff, J. 1996. Water supply in Yorkshire: Report of the independent commission of inquiry. Leeds: Yorkshire Water Services.
130. U.K. House of Commons Environment Committee. 1996. Water conservation and supply: Interim report. London: HMSO.
131. UK Water Industry Research/National Rivers Authority (UKWIR/NRA). 1995. Demand forecasting methodology - Main report, London: UK Water Industry Research.
132. Vickers, J., and Yarrow, G. 1988. Privatization: An economic analysis. London: MIT Press.
133. Ward, N. 1996. Surfers, sewage and the new politics of pollution. Area 28:331-38.
134. Water Services Association. 1997. Water: Meeting the Challenge: The vision of the Water and Sewerage Companies of England and Wales. London: WSA.
135. WaterWatch. 1996. Submission of evidence to the House of Commons Environment Select Committee inquiry into water conservation and supply. Rotherham: WaterWatch.
136. West, B., and Smith, P. 1996. Drought, discourse and Durkheim - A research note. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology 32:93-102.
137. Wynne, B. 1994. Scientific knowledge and the global environment. In Social theory and the global environment, ed. M. Redclift and T. Benton, 169-89. London: Routledge.
138. Yorkshire Water. 1995. Annual report and accounts. Leeds: Yorkshire Water plc.
139. _. 1997. Establishing the economic level of leakage. Leeds: Yorkshire Water plc.
140. Yorkshire Wildlife Trust. 1996. Yorkshire Wildlife Trust objection to the River Hull drought permit application by Yorkshire Water Services Ltd. York: Yorkshire Wildlife Trust.
141. Zimmerer, K. 1993. Soil erosion and social (dis)courses in Cochabamba, Bolivia: Perceiving the nature of environmental degradation. Economic Geography 69:312-28.
142. _. 1994. Human geography and the "new ecology": The prospect and promise of integration. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 84:108-25.