On some fundamental flaws in present aeroacoustic theory

Journal of Sound and Vibration

Volumn 232, Issue 4, 2000, Pages 719-782

  Fedorchenko, A T ^a  

^a MOSCOW INSTITUTE OF PHYSICS AND TECHNOLOGY   (Russian Federation)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ACOUSTIC WAVE PROPAGATION; MATHEMATICAL MODELS; ACOUSTIC GENERATORS; AERODYNAMICS;

AEROACOUSTIC THEORY; ACOUSTIC ANALOGY; ACOUSTIC EQUATION; AERO-ACOUSTIC THEORY; AEROACOUSTIC PHENOMENA; AERODYNAMIC SOUND; COMPLEX PROBLEMS; CRITICAL ANALYSIS; FLOW VARIABLE; INVISCID GAS; SOUND GENERATION; SOURCE TERMS; THEORETICAL APPROACH; THEORETICAL MODELS; TIME AVERAGING;

AERODYNAMICS; AEROACOUSTICS;

EID: 0033732847     PISSN: 0022460X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1006/jsvi.1999.2767     Document Type: Article

References (124)

1. RAYLEIGH J. W. S. Theory of Sound. 1977;Macmillan, New York.
2. D. I. BLOKHINTSEV, 1946, Acoustics of a Nonhomogeneous Moving Medium.
3. TAM C. K. W. Computational aeroacoustics: issue and methods. AIAA Journal. 33:1995;1778-1796.
4. LILLEY G. M., ZHANG X., RONA A. Progress in computational aeroacoustics in predicting the noise radiated from turbulent flows. International Journal of Acoustics and Vibration. 2:1997;3-10.
5. POWELL A. Why do vortices generate sound? ASME Journal of Vibration and Acoustics. 117:1995;252-260.
6. WAN MENG, LELE S. K., MOIN P. Computation of quadrupole noise using acoustic analogy. AIAA Journal. 34:1996;2247-2254.
7. COLONIUS T., LELE S. K., MOIN P. Sound generation in a mixing layer. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 330:1997;375-410.
8. RIBNER H. S. Effects of jet flow on jet noise via an extension to the Lighthill model. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 321:1996;1-24.
9. S. Y. LIN, Y. F. CHEN, S. C. SHIH, 1997, AIAA Paper 97-0023, Numerical study of MUSCL schemes for computational aeroacoustics.
10. LIGHTHILL J. Some aspects of the aeroacoustics of high-speed jets. Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics. 6:1994;261-280.
11. WELLS V. I., RENAUT R. A. Computing aerodynamically generated noise. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics. 29:1997;161-199.
12. G. RAMAN, D. K. MCLAUGHLIN, 1999, AIAA Paper 99-1915, Highlights of aeroacoustics research in the U.S. - 1998.
13. D. P. LOCKARD, 1999, 10th Thermal and Fluids Analysis Workshop, Huntsville, Alabama, USA, An over view of computational aeroacoustic modeling at NASA Langley.
14. BRENTNER K. S., LYRINTSIS A. S., KOUTSAVDIS E. K. Comparison of computational aeroacoustic prediction methods for transonic rotor noise. Journal of Aircraft. 34:1997;531-538.
15. GAUNAURD G. C., EISLER T. J. Classical electrodynamics and acoustics: sound radiation by moving monopoles. ASME Journal of Vibration and Acoustics. 119:1997;271-290.
16. FFOWCS-WILLIAMS J. E. Aeroacoustics. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 190:1996;387-398.
17. DELFS J., HELLER H. Aeroacoustic research in Europe - 1996 highlights: a summary of last year's activities in the six CEAS countries. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 204:1997;609-622.
18. BASTIN F., LAFON P., CANDEL S. Computation of jet noise due to coherent structures: the plane jet case. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 335:1997;261-304.
19. EKATERINARIS J. A. Upwind scheme for acoustic disturbances generated by low-speed flows. AIAA Journal. 35:1997;1448-1455.
20. GALLMAN J. M., SCHULTZ K.-J., SPIEGEL P., BURLEY C. L. Effect of wake structure on blade-vortex interaction phenomena: acoustic prediction and validation. Journal of Aircraft. 35:1998;267-273.
21. OZYORUK Y., LONG I. N. A new efficient algorithm for computatinal aeroacoustics on parallel processors. Journal of Computational Physics. 125:1996;135-149.
22. HOLSTE F. An equivalent source method for calculation of the sound radiated from aircraft engines. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 203:1997;667-695.
23. SIMING M., MAHALINGAM S. Direct numerical simulation of acoustic/shear flow interactions in two-dimensional ducts. AIAA Journal. 34:1996;237-243.
24. MAJUMDAR S. L., PEAKE N. Noise generation by the interaction between ingestal turbulence and a rotating fan. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 359:1997;181-216.
25. MORRIS P. J., LONG L. N., BANGALORE A., WANG Q. A parallel three-dimensional computational aeroacoustic method using nonlinear disturbance equations. Journal of Computational Physics. 133:1997;56-74.
26. FISHER M. J., PRESTON G. A., BRYCE W. D. A modelling of the noise from simple coaxial jets. Pts I, II. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 209:1998;385-417.
27. RAHIER G., DEBRIEUX Y. Blade-vortex interaction noise prediction using a rotor wake roll-up model. Journal of Aircraft. 34:1997;522-530.
28. SHIH S. H., HIXON D. R., MANKBADI R. R. Zonal approach for prediction of jet noise. Journal of Propulsion and Power. 13:1997;745-752.
29. S. K. LELE, 1997, AIAA Paper 97-0018, Computational aeroacoustics.
30. C. K. W. TAM, 1997, AIAA Paper 97-1774, Advances in numerical boundary conditions for computational aeroacoustics.
31. E. J. AVITAL, N. D. SANDMAN, K. H. LUO, R. E. MUSAFIR, 1998, AIAA Paper 98-2263, Calculation of basic radiation by direct numerical simulation of an axisymmetric jet.
32. P. W. TENPAS, S. B. SCHWALMAN, R. K. AGARVAL, 1998, AIAA Paper 98-2221, Development of a high order compact algorithm for aeroacoustics employing PML absorbing boundaries.
33. I. M. A. AL-QUADI, J. N. SCOTT, 1998, AIAA Paper 98-2265, A numerical investigation of the influence of jet lip geometry on mixing.
34. RIENSTRA S. W. Sound transmission in slowly varying circular and annual lined ducts with flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 380:1999;279-296.
35. DOAK P. E. On the free field point-impulse response of total enthalpy waves. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;3643-3650.
36. GOLDSTEIN M. E. Some recent developments in jet noise modeling. Programme and Abstracts of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;31.
37. DOWLING A. P. Thermoacoustic instability. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;3277-3292.
38. MOHRING W., OBERMEIER F. Vorticity - the voice of flows. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;3617-3626.
39. LILLEY G. M. On the refraction of aerodynamic noise. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;3581-3588.
40. GLEGG S. A. L. Recent advances in aeroacoustics: the influence of computational fluid dynamics. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;43-58.
41. MITCHELL B. E., LELE S. K., MOIN P. Direct computation of the sound generated by vortex pairing in an axisymmetric jet. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 383:1999;113-142.
42. JUVE D., BAILLY C. Numerical simulation of aerodynamic noise. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;3627-3630.
43. INOUE O., HATTORI Y. Sound generation by shock-vortex interaction. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 380:1999;81-116.
44. C. SEROR, P. SAGAUT, C. BAILLY, D. JUVE, 1999, AIAA Paper 99-1976, Subgrid scale contribution to noise production in decaying isotropic turbulence.
45. LIGHTHILL M. J. On sound generated aerodynamically. Part I. General theory. Proceedings of the Royal Society, London A. 211:1952;564-587.
46. LIGHTHILL M. J. On sound generated aerodynamically. Part II. Turbulence as a source of sound. Proceedings of the Royal Society, London A. 222:1954;1-32.
47. RIBNER H. S. New theory of jet noise generation, directionality, and spectra. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 31:1959;245-246.
48. PHILLIPS O. M. On the generation of sound by supersonic turbulent shear flows. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 9:1960;1-28.
49. POWELL A. Theory of vortex sound. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 36:1964;177-195.
50. HOWE M. S. Contribution to the theory of aerodynamic sound, with application to excess jet noise and the theory of the flute. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 71:1975;625-673.
51. MÖHRING W. On vortex sound at low Mach number. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 85:1978;685-691.
52. FFOWCS-WILLIAMS J. E., HAWKINGS D. L. Sound generation by turbulence and surfaces in arbitrary motion. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A. 264:1969;321-342.
53. FARASSAT F., MYERS M. K. Extension of Kirchhoff's formula to radiation from moving surfaces. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 123:1988;451-461.
54. PILON A. R., LIRINTZIS A. Development of an improved Kirchhoff method for jet aeroacoustics. AIAA Journal. 36:1998;783-790.
55. LYRINTZIS A. S. Review: the use of Kirchhoff's method in computational aeroacoustics. Journal of Fluids Engineering. 116:1994;665-675.
56. FARASSAT F., MYERS M. K. The Kirchhoff's formula for a supersonically moving surface. Proceedings of the 1st Joint CEAS/AIAA Aeroacoustic Conference (AIAA 16th Aeroacoustic Conference). 1:1995;455-461.
57. DIFRANCESANTONIO P. A new boundary integral formulation for the prediction of sound radiation. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 202:1997;491-509.
58. BRENTNER K. S., FARASSAT F. Analytical comparisons of the acoustic analogy and Kirchhoff formulation for moving surfaces. AIAA Journal. 36:1998;1379-1387.
59. CROCKER M. J. The end of science? International Journal of Acoustics and Vibration. 3:1998;3.
60. FEDORCHENKO A. T. New approach to the theory of aerodynamic sound. Proceedings of the 5th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Adelaide, Australia. 1997;591-598.
61. FEDORCHENKO A. T. On the nonlinear theory of aerodynamic sound sources. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR. 344:1995;48-51.
62. FEDORCHENKO A. T. New nonlinear theory of aerodynamic sound sources. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Copenhagen, Denmark. 1999;1967-1974.
63. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Models of permeable boundaries for nonstationary problems of computational gas dynamics. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR. 260:1981;826-830.
64. FEDORCHENKO A. T. A method for the numerical investigation of unsteady flows of viscous gas in ducts. Zhurnal Vychislitelnoy Matematiki i Matematicheskoy Fiziki. 21:1981;1215-1232.
65. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Nonlinear models of sound-absorbing boundary sections of the computational domain in a duct. Akusticheskiy Zhurnal. 30:1984;827-833.
66. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Computational models of the interaction of vortices with the penetrable boundary of a region of subsonic flow. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR. 273:1983;66-70.
67. FEDORCHENKO A. T. On vortex outflow through the permeable boundary of the computational domain of non-stationary subsonic flow. Zhurnal Vychislitelnoy Matematiki i Matematicheskoy Fiziki. 26:1986;114-129.
68. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Problems of the numerical modelling of unsteady spatial viscous gas flows in nozzles. Zhurnal Vychislitelnoy Matematiki i Matematicheskoy Fiziki. 22:1982;178-196.
69. O. REYNOLDS 1894, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A, 186, 123, I, On the dynamic theory of incompressible viscous fluids and the determination of the criterion.
70. LAMB H. Hydrodynamics. 1932;Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
71. TAYLOR G. I. Statistical theory of turbulence. Proceedings of the Royal Society London A. 151:1935;421-478.
72. GOLDSTEIN M. E. Aeroacoustics. 1976;McGraw-Hill, New York.
73. BLAKE W. K. Mechanics of Flow-Induced Sound and Vibration. 1986;Academic Press, New York.
74. DURST F., MELLING A., WHITELAW J. H. Low Reynolds number flow over a plane symmetric sudden expansion. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 64:1974;111-128.
75. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Evolution of subsonic flow instability in a viscous gas in a suddenly expanded flat channel. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR. 296:1987;1315-1319.
76. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Numerical investigation of unsteady subsonic flow of viscous gas in the plane channel with sudden expansion. Izvestiya Akademii Nauk SSSR, Mekhanika Zhidkosti i Gaza. 4:1988;32-41.
77. NAYFEH A. H., KAISER J. E., TELIONIS D. P. Acoustics of aircraft engine-duct systems. AIAA Journal. 13:1975;130-153.
78. EVERSMAN W. Theoretical model for duct acoustic propagation and radiation. Habbard H. H. Aeroacoustics of Flight Vehicles: Theory and Practice. Vol. 2: Noise Control. 1991;101-164.
79. PRIDMORE-BROWN D. C. Sound propagation in a fluid flowing through an attenuating duct. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 4:1958;393-406.
80. V. V. GOLUBEV, H. M. ATASSI, 1997, AIAA Paper 97-1695, Acoustic-vorticity modes in an annular duct with mean vortical swirling flow.
81. TAM C. K. W., AURIAULT L. Mean flow refraction effects on sound radiated from localized sources in a jet. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 370:1998;149-174.
82. TAM C.K.W., AURIAULT L. 1998 Journal of Fluid Mechanics 371, 1-20. The wave modes in an annular duct with mean vortical swirling flow.
83. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Action of small-scale turbulence on the development of coherent structures in a mixing layer. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR. 302:1988;1327-1332.
84. DOAK P. E. Analysis of internally generated sound in continuous materials: 3. The momentum potential field description of fluctuating fluid motion as a basis for a unified theory of internally generated sound. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 26:1973;91-120.
85. DOAK P. E. Momentum potential theory of energy flux carried by momentum fluctuations. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 131:1989;67-90.
86. FEDORCHENKO A. T. A model of unsteady subsonic flow with acoustics excluded. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 334:1997;135-155.
87. MILNE-THOMSON L. M. Theoretical Hydrodynamics. 1960;Macmillan, New York.
88. FEDORCHENKO A. T. On the theory of generation and propagation of sound in an unsteady flow. Akusticheskiy Zhurnal. 34:1988;1109-1115.
89. LIGHTHILL M. J. Waves in Fluids. 1978;Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
90. DOWLING A. P., FFOWCS-WILLIAMS J. E. Sound and Sources of Sound. 1983;Ellis Horwood, Chickester.
91. CRIGHTON D. G., DOWLING A. P., FFOWCS-WILLIAMS J. E., HECKL M., LEPPINGTON F. G. Modern Methods in Analytical Acoustics. 1992;Springer-verlag, Berlin.
92. COURANT R. Partial Differential Equations. 1962;Plenum, New York.
93. PETERS M. C. A. M. Aeroacoustic Surces in Internal Flows. 1993;Eindhoven University Publ.
94. BATCHELOR G. K. An Introduction to Fluid Dynamics. 1967;Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
95. CROW S. C. Aerodynamic sound emission as a singular perturbation problem. Studies in Applied Mathematics. 49:1970;21-44.
96. DOAK P. E. Fundamentals of aerodynamic sound theory and flow duct acoustics. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 28:1973;527-561.
97. CRIGHTON D. G. Acoustics as a branch of fluid mechanics. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 106:1981;261-298.
98. FARASSAT F. Prediction of advanced propeller noise in the time domain. AIAA Journal. 24:1986;578-584.
99. AMIET R. K. Thickness noise of a propeller and its relation to the blade sweep. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 192:1988;535-560.
100. Wells W. L., Han A. Geometrical and numerical considerations in computing advanced-propeller noise. Journal of Aircraft. 30:1993;365-371.
101. OBERMEIER F. On a new representation of aerodynamic source distribution. Acustica. 42:1979;56-71.
102. KAMBE T. Acoustic emission by vortex motion. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 173:1986;643-666.
103. LILLEY G. M. The radiated noise from isotropic turbulence with application to the theory of jet noise. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 190:1996;463-476.
104. CROCKER M. J. Recent developments in acoustics and vibration. Proceedings of 5th International Congress on Sound and Vibration, Adelaide, Australia. 1997;29-58.
105. DOAK P. E. Fluctuating total enthalpy as the basic generalized acoustic field. Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics. 10:1998;115-133.
106. MÖHRING W. On energy, group velocity and small damping of sound waves in ducts with shear flow. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 29:1973;93-101.
107. CANDEL S. M. Acoustic conservation principles and an application to plane and modal propagation in nozzles and diffusers. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 41:1975;207-232.
108. PIERCE A. D. Acoustics: An Introduction to its Physical Principles and Applications. 1989;American Institute of Physics, New York.
109. LAUFER J., YEN T.-C. Noise generation by a low-Mach-number jet. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 134:1983;1-31.
110. TANG S. K., KO N. W. M. Sound generation by a vortex ring collision. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 98:1995;3418-3427.
111. RIU K. W., LEE D. J. Sound radiation from elliptic vortex rings: evolution and interaction. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 200:1997;281-301.
112. MÜLLER E. A. Flow-acoustics. Proceedings of the 14th IUTAM Congress, Delft, Netherlands, 1976. 1977.
113. TAM C. K. W. Supersonic jet noise. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics. 27:1995;17-43.
114. PEAKE N., CRIGHTON D. G. Lighthill quadrupole radiation in supersonic propeller acoustics. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 223:1991;363-382.
115. HIGDON R. L. Absorbing boundary conditions for difference approximations to the multi-dimensional wave equation. Mathematics of Computation. 47:1986;437-459.
116. RUDY D. H., STRIKWERDA J. C. A non-reflecting outflow boundary condition for subsonic Navier-Stokes calculations. Journal of Computational Physics. 36:1980;55-70.
117. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Reflection of a plane sound wave from a permeable surface in the presence of a normal gas flow. Akusticheskiy Zhurnal. 35:1989;951-953.
118. POINSOT T. J., LELE S. K. Boundary conditions for direct simulations of compressible viscous flows. Journal of Computational Physics. 101:1992;104-129.
119. GILES M. B. Non-reflecting boundary conditions for Euler equation calculations. AIAA Journal. 28:1990;2050-2058.
120. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Numerical investigation of some MHD-flows of viscous gas in the rectangular cavity. Izvestiya Akademii Nauk SSSR, Mekhanika Zhidkosti i Gaza. 5:1975;27-33.
121. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Numerical investigation of acoustic resonance in a rectangular cavity with the flow of viscous gas. Akusticheskiy Zhurnal. 24:1978;751-759.
122. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Method of calculation of two-dimensional non-stationary flows of a viscous gas in nozzles. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR. 251:1980;578-582.
123. FEDORCHENKO A. T. Generation of nonlinear waves in a supersonic flow by volume heat-release sources. Akusticheskiy Zhurnal. 32:1986;230-237.
124. FFOWCS-WILLIAMS J. E. Computing the sources of sound. Lau R. L., Lee D., Robison A. R. Computational Acoustics. 1:1993;9-17 Holland, Amsterdam.