The changing dynamics of state-society relations in the Fifth Republic

West European Politics

Volumn 22, Issue 4, 1999, Pages 141-165

  Schmidt, Vivien A ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

NATIONAL POLITICS; POLITICAL SYSTEM; STATE-LOCAL RELATIONS;

FRANCE;

EID: 0033511217     PISSN: 01402382     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01402389908425337     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Vivien A. Schmidt, From State to Market? The Transformation of French Business and Government (NY: CUP 1996) Ch.1; John T.S. Keeler, 'Patterns of Policymaking in the French Fifth Republic: Strong Governments, Cycles of Reform and Political Malaise', in Linda Miller and Michael Smith (eds.) Ideas and Ideals: Essays on Politics in Honor of Stanley Hoffmann, (Boulder, CO: Westview 1993); Stanley Hoffmann, 'The French Constitution of 1958: The Final Text and its Prospects', American Political Science Review 53/2 (1959) pp.332-57.
2. 1. Vivien A. Schmidt, From State to Market? The Transformation of French Business and Government (NY: CUP 1996) Ch.1; John T.S. Keeler, 'Patterns of Policymaking in the French Fifth Republic: Strong Governments, Cycles of Reform and Political Malaise', in Linda Miller and Michael Smith (eds.) Ideas and Ideals: Essays on Politics in Honor of Stanley Hoffmann, (Boulder, CO: Westview 1993); Stanley Hoffmann, 'The French Constitution of 1958: The Final Text and its Prospects', American Political Science Review 53/2 (1959) pp.332-57.
3. 1. Vivien A. Schmidt, From State to Market? The Transformation of French Business and Government (NY: CUP 1996) Ch.1; John T.S. Keeler, 'Patterns of Policymaking in the French Fifth Republic: Strong Governments, Cycles of Reform and Political Malaise', in Linda Miller and Michael Smith (eds.) Ideas and Ideals: Essays on Politics in Honor of Stanley Hoffmann, (Boulder, CO: Westview 1993); Stanley Hoffmann, 'The French Constitution of 1958: The Final Text and its Prospects', American Political Science Review 53/2 (1959) pp.332-57.
4. Schmidt (note 1) Chs 1, 2; John Zysman, Political Strategies for Industrial Order: State, Market, and Industry in France (Berkeley: Univ. of California Press 1977); David Wilsford, 'Tactical Advantages versus Administrative Heterogeneity: The Strengths and the Limits of the French State', Comparative Political Studies 21/1 (1988) pp.126-68; Jack Hayward, 'Mobilising Private Interests in the Service of Public Ambitions: The Salient Element of the Dual Policy Style', in Jeremy Richardson (ed.) Policy Styles in Western Europe (London: Allen & Unwin 1982) pp.111-40; Peter Hall, Governing the Economy: The Politics of State Intervention in Britain and France (Cambridge: Polity Press 1986) pp.165-6.
5. Schmidt (note 1) Chs 1, 2; John Zysman, Political Strategies for Industrial Order: State, Market, and Industry in France (Berkeley: Univ. of California Press 1977); David Wilsford, 'Tactical Advantages versus Administrative Heterogeneity: The Strengths and the Limits of the French State', Comparative Political Studies 21/1 (1988) pp.126-68; Jack Hayward, 'Mobilising Private Interests in the Service of Public Ambitions: The Salient Element of the Dual Policy Style', in Jeremy Richardson (ed.) Policy Styles in Western Europe (London: Allen & Unwin 1982) pp.111-40; Peter Hall, Governing the Economy: The Politics of State Intervention in Britain and France (Cambridge: Polity Press 1986) pp.165-6.
6. Schmidt (note 1) Chs 1, 2; John Zysman, Political Strategies for Industrial Order: State, Market, and Industry in France (Berkeley: Univ. of California Press 1977); David Wilsford, 'Tactical Advantages versus Administrative Heterogeneity: The Strengths and the Limits of the French State', Comparative Political Studies 21/1 (1988) pp.126-68; Jack Hayward, 'Mobilising Private Interests in the Service of Public Ambitions: The Salient Element of the Dual Policy Style', in Jeremy Richardson (ed.) Policy Styles in Western Europe (London: Allen & Unwin 1982) pp.111-40; Peter Hall, Governing the Economy: The Politics of State Intervention in Britain and France (Cambridge: Polity Press 1986) pp.165-6.
7. Schmidt (note 1) Chs 1, 2; John Zysman, Political Strategies for Industrial Order: State, Market, and Industry in France (Berkeley: Univ. of California Press 1977); David Wilsford, 'Tactical Advantages versus Administrative Heterogeneity: The Strengths and the Limits of the French State', Comparative Political Studies 21/1 (1988) pp.126-68; Jack Hayward, 'Mobilising Private Interests in the Service of Public Ambitions: The Salient Element of the Dual Policy Style', in Jeremy Richardson (ed.) Policy Styles in Western Europe (London: Allen & Unwin 1982) pp.111-40; Peter Hall, Governing the Economy: The Politics of State Intervention in Britain and France (Cambridge: Polity Press 1986) pp.165-6.
8. See Schmidt (note 1) Chs 1, 2.
9. Frank L. Wilson, 'French Interest Group Politics: Pluralist or Neo-Corporatist?', American Political Science Review 77/4 (1983) pp.895-910; John T. S. Keeler, 'Situating France on the Pluralism-Corporatism Continuum. A Critique of and an Alternative to the Wilson Perspective', Comparative Politics 17/2 (Jan. 1985) pp.229-49; Schmidt (note 1) Ch.1.
10. Frank L. Wilson, 'French Interest Group Politics: Pluralist or Neo-Corporatist?', American Political Science Review 77/4 (1983) pp.895-910; John T. S. Keeler, 'Situating France on the Pluralism-Corporatism Continuum. A Critique of and an Alternative to the Wilson Perspective', Comparative Politics 17/2 (Jan. 1985) pp.229-49; Schmidt (note 1) Ch.1.
11. Wilsford (note 2) pp.152-6: Charles Tilly, From Mobilization to Revolution (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall 1978).
12. Schmidt (note 1) Ch.2.
13. John T.S. Keeler, The Politics of Neo-corporatism in France (Oxford: OUP 1987).
14. John Ambler, 'Neocorporatism and the Politics of French Education', West European Politics 8/3 (July 1985) pp.23-42.
15. Vivien A. Schmidt, Democratizing France. The political and administrative history of decentralization (Cambridge, CUP 1990).
16. Ezra N. Suleiman, Private Power and Centralisation in France: The Notaires and the State (Princeton UP 1987).
17. Denis Olivennes and Nicolas Baverez, L'impuissance publique (Paris: Calmann-Lévy 1989); Michel Crozier, État modeste, État moderne. Stratégie pour un autre changement (Paris: Fayard 1987).
18. Denis Olivennes and Nicolas Baverez, L'impuissance publique (Paris: Calmann-Lévy 1989); Michel Crozier, État modeste, État moderne. Stratégie pour un autre changement (Paris: Fayard 1987).
19. François Dupuy and Jean-Claude Thoenig, L'administration en miettes (Paris: Fayard 1987).
20. Vivien A. Schmidt, 'European Integration and Democracy: The Differences among Member States', Journal of European Public Policy 4/1 (1997) pp.128-45.
21. Ezra N. Suleiman, Politics, Power and Bureaucracy in France (Princeton UP 1974) pp.137-54; Jean-Louis Quermonne, L'appareil administratif de l'État (Paris: Seuil 1991).
22. Ezra N. Suleiman, Politics, Power and Bureaucracy in France (Princeton UP 1974) pp.137-54; Jean-Louis Quermonne, L'appareil administratif de l'État (Paris: Seuil 1991).
23. Schmidt (note 13); Vivien A. Schmidt, 'National Patterns of Governance under Siege: The Impact of European Integration', in Beate Kohler-Koch (ed.) The Transformation of Governance in the European Union (London: Routledge 1999).
24. Vivien A. Schmidt, 'Business, the State, and the End of Dirigisme', in John T.S. Keeler and Martin A. Schain (eds.) Chirac's Challenge: Liberalization, Europeanization, and Malaise in France (NY: St Martin's Press 1996) pp.105-42.
25. See the essay by Emmanuel Négrier in this volume; and Schmidt (note 9).
26. Schmidt (note 9).
27. Hall (note 2); Schmidt (note 1) Chs 3, 9.
28. Andrew Shonfield, Modern Capitalism: The Changing Balance of Public and Private Power (Oxford: OUP 1965) pp.126, 145; Hall (note 2) pp.152-5; Schmidt (note 1) Ch.9.
29. Suzanne Berger, 'Lame Ducks and National Champions: Industrial Policy in the Fifth Republic', in William G. Andrews and Stanley Hoffmann (eds.) The Impact of the Fifth Republican France (Albany: SUNY Press 1981) pp.160-78; Elie Cohen, L'État brancardier, Politiques du déclin industriel (1974-1984) (Paris: Calmann-Lévy 1989).
30. Suzanne Berger, 'Lame Ducks and National Champions: Industrial Policy in the Fifth Republic', in William G. Andrews and Stanley Hoffmann (eds.) The Impact of the Fifth Republican France (Albany: SUNY Press 1981) pp.160-78; Elie Cohen, L'État brancardier, Politiques du déclin industriel (1974-1984) (Paris: Calmann-Lévy 1989).
31. Schmidt (note 1) Ch.8.
32. Hall (note 2) pp.169-71.
33. Jack Hayward, The State and the Market Economy: Industrial Patriotism and Economic Intervention in France (NY UP 1986).
34. Michel Bauer and Elie Cohen. 'Le politique, l'administratif, et l'exercice du pouvoir industriel', Sociologie du Travail 27 (1985) pp.324-7.
35. Daniel Derivry, 'The Managers of Public Enterprises in France', in Mattei Dogan (ed.) The Mandarins of Western Europe (NY: Wiley 1975) pp.217-18.
36. Stephen S. Cohen, 'Informed bewilderment: French economic strategy and the crisis', in idem and Peter A. Gourevitch (eds.) France in the Troubled World Economy (London: Butterworth 1982) pp.21-48; Lynne Krieger Mytelka, 'In Search of a Partner: The State and the Textile Industry in France', in Cohen and Gourevitch, ibid. pp.132-50; Elie Cohen and Michel Bauer, Les grandes manoeuvres industrielles (Paris: Belford 1985).
37. Stephen S. Cohen, 'Informed bewilderment: French economic strategy and the crisis', in idem and Peter A. Gourevitch (eds.) France in the Troubled World Economy (London: Butterworth 1982) pp.21-48; Lynne Krieger Mytelka, 'In Search of a Partner: The State and the Textile Industry in France', in Cohen and Gourevitch, ibid. pp.132-50; Elie Cohen and Michel Bauer, Les grandes manoeuvres industrielles (Paris: Belford 1985).
38. Stephen S. Cohen, 'Informed bewilderment: French economic strategy and the crisis', in idem and Peter A. Gourevitch (eds.) France in the Troubled World Economy (London: Butterworth 1982) pp.21-48; Lynne Krieger Mytelka, 'In Search of a Partner: The State and the Textile Industry in France', in Cohen and Gourevitch, ibid. pp.132-50; Elie Cohen and Michel Bauer, Les grandes manoeuvres industrielles (Paris: Belford 1985).
39. Jonah D. Levy, Tocqueville's Revenge: The Decline of Dirigisme and Evolution of France's Political Economy, PhD Dissertation in Political Science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (1993) pp.51-2.
40. Michel Bauer and Bénédicte Mourot, Les 200: Comment devient-on un grand patron? (Paris: Seuil 1987); Schmidt (note 1) Chs 11, 12.
41. Schmidt (note 1); Vivien A. Schmidt, 'The Decline of Traditional State Dirigisme in France: The Transformation of Political Economic Policies and Policymaking Processes', Governance 9/4 (1996) pp.375-405; Bauer and Cohen (note 25); Claude Durand, Michelle Durand and Monique VerVaeke, 'Dirigisme et libéralisme: l'État dans l'industrie', Sociologie du Travail 27 (1985); Jocelyne Barreau et al. (eds.) L'État entrepreneur: nationalisation, gestions du secteur public concurrentiel, construction européenne (1982-1993) (Paris: L'Harmattan 1990).
42. Schmidt (note 1); Vivien A. Schmidt, 'The Decline of Traditional State Dirigisme in France: The Transformation of Political Economic Policies and Policymaking Processes', Governance 9/4 (1996) pp.375-405; Bauer and Cohen (note 25); Claude Durand, Michelle Durand and Monique VerVaeke, 'Dirigisme et libéralisme: l'État dans l'industrie', Sociologie du Travail 27 (1985); Jocelyne Barreau et al. (eds.) L'État entrepreneur: nationalisation, gestions du secteur public concurrentiel, construction européenne (1982-1993) (Paris: L'Harmattan 1990).
43. Schmidt (note 1); Vivien A. Schmidt, 'The Decline of Traditional State Dirigisme in France: The Transformation of Political Economic Policies and Policymaking Processes', Governance 9/4 (1996) pp.375-405; Bauer and Cohen (note 25); Claude Durand, Michelle Durand and Monique VerVaeke, 'Dirigisme et libéralisme: l'État dans l'industrie', Sociologie du Travail 27 (1985); Jocelyne Barreau et al. (eds.) L'État entrepreneur: nationalisation, gestions du secteur public concurrentiel, construction européenne (1982-1993) (Paris: L'Harmattan 1990).
44. Schmidt (note 1) ch.4; Schmidt (note 30).
45. Vivien A. Schmidt, 'Running on Empty: The End of Dirigisme in French Economic Leadership', Modern and Contemporary France 5/2 (1997) pp.229-41; Schmidt (note 1) Chs 6, 13; Schmidt (note 30).
46. Schmidt (note 32).
47. Elie Cohen, Le colbertisme 'high tech': Économie des télécom et du grand projet (Paris: Pluriel 1992).
48. Schmidt (note 30).
49. Vivien A. Schmidt, 'Loosening the Ties that Bind: The Impact of European Integration on French Government and its Relationship to Business', Journal of Common Market Studies 34/2 (June 1996) pp.223-54.
50. Cohen (note 34) pp.217-18.
51. Bauer and Mourot (note 29).
52. Schmidt (note 30).
53. See the essay by Emmanuel Négrier in this volume.
54. Hayward (note 24) p.63.
55. George Ross, 'Labor and the Left in Power: Commissions, Omissions, and Unintended Consequences', in Patrick McCarthy (ed.) The French Socialists in Power, 1981-1986 (NY: Greenwood Press 1987).
56. Mark Kesselman, 'The New Shape of French Industrial Relations: Ce n'est plus la même chose', in Paul Godt (ed.) Policymaking in France: From de Gaulle to Mitterrand (London: Pinter 1989); W. Rand Smith, Crisis in the French Labor Movement: A Grassroots Perspective (NY: St Martin's Press 1988).
57. Mark Kesselman, 'The New Shape of French Industrial Relations: Ce n'est plus la même chose', in Paul Godt (ed.) Policymaking in France: From de Gaulle to Mitterrand (London: Pinter 1989); W. Rand Smith, Crisis in the French Labor Movement: A Grassroots Perspective (NY: St Martin's Press 1988).
58. René Mouriaux, 'Trade Unions, Unemployment, and Regulation: 1962-1989', in James F. Hollifield and George Ross (eds.) Searching for the New France (NY: Routledge 1991) pp.175-6.
59. Mark Kesselman and Guy Groux (eds) 1968-1982: Le mouvement ouvrier français (Paris, Editions Ouvrières 1984); George Ross, 'The Perils of Politics: French Unions and the Crisis of the 1970s', in Peter Lange (ed.) Unions, Change and Crisis: French and Italian Union Strategy and the Political Economy, 1945-1980 (London: Allen & Unwin 1982)
60. Mark Kesselman and Guy Groux (eds) 1968-1982: Le mouvement ouvrier français (Paris, Editions Ouvrières 1984); George Ross, 'The Perils of Politics: French Unions and the Crisis of the 1970s', in Peter Lange (ed.) Unions, Change and Crisis: French and Italian Union Strategy and the Political Economy, 1945-1980 (London: Allen & Unwin 1982)
61. Mouriaux (note 44) pp.179-84.
62. Ibid. p.186.
63. Chris Howell, Regulating Labor: The State and Industrial Relations Reform in Postwar France (Princeton UP 1992).
64. Vivien A. Schmidt, 'Economic Policy, Political Discourse, and Democracy in France', French Politics and Society 15/2 (1997) pp.37-48.
65. Jonah D. Levy, 'The Crisis of Identity of Post-Dirigiste France', French Politics and Society 14/1 (1996).
66. Doug Imig and Sidney Tarrow, From Strike to Eurostrike: The Europeanisation of Social Movements and the Development of a Euro-Polity (Working Paper no. 97-10, Weatherhead Center for Int. Affairs, Harvard U. 1997).
67. Schmidt (note 49); Schmidt (note 36).
68. See Jean-Noël Jeanneney, Une histoire des medias: Des origines à nos jours (Paris: Seuil 1996).
69. Marie-José Guédon, Les autorités administratives indépendantes (Paris: LGDJ 1991); Fabrice Demarigny, 'Independent Administrative Authorities in France and the Case of the French Council for Competition', in Giandomenico Majone (ed.) Regulating Europe, (London and NY: Routledge 1996); H. Dumez and A. Jeunemaître, La concurrence en Europe: De nouvelles règles du jeu pour les entreprises (Paris: Seuil 1990).
70. Marie-José Guédon, Les autorités administratives indépendantes (Paris: LGDJ 1991); Fabrice Demarigny, 'Independent Administrative Authorities in France and the Case of the French Council for Competition', in Giandomenico Majone (ed.) Regulating Europe, (London and NY: Routledge 1996); H. Dumez and A. Jeunemaître, La concurrence en Europe: De nouvelles règles du jeu pour les entreprises (Paris: Seuil 1990).
71. Marie-José Guédon, Les autorités administratives indépendantes (Paris: LGDJ 1991); Fabrice Demarigny, 'Independent Administrative Authorities in France and the Case of the French Council for Competition', in Giandomenico Majone (ed.) Regulating Europe, (London and NY: Routledge 1996); H. Dumez and A. Jeunemaître, La concurrence en Europe: De nouvelles règles du jeu pour les entreprises (Paris: Seuil 1990).
72. Alain-Gérard Slama, 'L'État sans citoyens', Pouvoirs 84 (1998) pp.89-98.
73. 'Repenser l'État?', Revue Politique et Parlementaire 982 (1996).
74. See Le Monde, 7-8 July 1996.