The Malthus-Ricardo correspondence: Sequential structure, argumentative patterns, and rationality

Journal of Pragmatics

Volumn 31, Issue 9, 1999, Pages 1129-1172

  Dascal, Marcelo ^a   Cremaschi, Sergio ^b  

^a TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY   (Israel)

^b UNIVERSITY OF EASTERN PIEDMONT   (Italy)

Author keywords

Argumentation; Controversy; Dialectics; Dialogue; History of economics; Pragma rhetorical analysis; Rationality; Scientific correspondence

Indexed keywords

EID: 0033196057     PISSN: 03782166     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/s0378-2166(99)00026-0     Document Type: Article

References (57)

1. Arnauld, Antoine and Pierre Nicole, 1683. La Logique ou l'art de Penser. Fifth Edition. [Reprinted with an introd. by Louis Marin, 1970. Paris Flammarion].
2. Attardo, Salvatore, 1997. Competition and cooperation: Beyond Gricean pragmatics. Pragmatics and Cognition 5 (1): 19-48.
3. Burnyeat, Miles F., 1984. The sceptic in his place and time. In: R. Rorty, J.B. Schneewind and Q. Skinner, eds., Philosophy in History, 225-254. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
4. Cremaschi, Sergio, 1984. Il Sistema della Richezza. Milano: Angeli.
5. Cremaschi, Sergio, 1988a. Metafore, modelli, linguaggio scientifico: Il dibattito postempirista. In: V. Melchiorre, ed., Simbolo e Conoscenza, 31-102. Milan: Vita e Pensiero.
6. Cremaschi, Sergio, 1988b. Remarks on scientific metaphors. In: M.L. Dalla Chiara and M.C. Galavotti, eds., Atti del Congresso: Temi e Prospettive della Logica e Filosofia della Scienza, Vol. II, 114-116. Bologna: CLUEB.
7. Cremaschi, Sergio, 1989. Adam Smith: Skeptical Newtonianism, Disenchanted Republicanism, and the Birth of Social Science. In: M. Dascal, ed., Routledge.
8. Cremaschi, Sergio and Marcelo, Dascal, 1996. Malthus and Ricardo on economic methodology. History of Political Economy 28 (3): 475-511.
9. Cremaschi, Sergio and Marcelo Dascal, 1998. Persuasion and argument in the Malthus-Ricardo correspondence. Research in the History of Economic Thought and Methodology 16: 1-63.
10. Cremaschi, Sergio and Marcelo Dascal, forthcoming. Malthus and Ricardo: Two styles for economic theory. Science in Context.
11. Dascal, Marcelo, 1983. Pragmatics and the Philosophy of Mind, vol. 1. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
12. Dascal, Marcelo, 1985. The relevance of misunderstanding. In: M. Dascal, ed., Dialogue: An Interdisciplinary Approach, 441-460. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
13. Dascal, Marcelo, 1989. Controversies as quasi-dialogues. In: E. Weigand and F. Hundsnurscher, ed., Dialoganalyse II, I: 147-159. Tübingen: Niemeyer.
14. Dascal, Marcelo, 1990a. The controversy about ideas and the idea of controversy. In: F. Gil., ed., Controvérsias Científicas e Filosóficas, 61-100. Lisboa: Editora Fragmentos.
15. Dascal, Marcelo, 1990b. La arrogancia de la razón. Isegoría 2: 75-103.
16. Dascal, Marcelo, 1992. On the pragmatic structure of conversation. In: (On) Searle on Conversation: Compiled and Introduced by H. Parret and J. Verschueren, 35-56. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
17. Dascal, Marcelo, 1995. Epistemología, controversias y pragmática. Isegoría 12: 8-43.
18. Dascal, Marcelo, 1996a. La balanza de la razón. In: O. Nudler, ed., La Racionalidad: Su Poder y sus Límites, 363-381. Buenos Aires: Paidós.
19. Dascal, Marcelo, 1996b. The beyond enterprise. In: J. Stewart, ed., Beyond the Symbol Model: Reflections on the Representational Nature of Language, 303-334. Albany, NY: Suny Press.
20. Dascal, Marcelo, 1998. Types of polemics and types of polemical moves. In: S. Čmejrková, J. Hoffmanova, O. Mulerova, and J. Svetla, eds., Dialoganalyse VI (Proceedings of the 6th Conference, Prague 1996), Teil 1, 15-33. Tubingen: Niemeyer.
21. Dascal, Marcelo, Forthcoming. Some questions about misunderstanding. Journal of Pragmatics.
22. Dascal, Marcelo and Alan Gross. Forthcoming. The marriage between pragmatics and rhetoric. Philosophy and Rhetoric.
23. Dascal, Marcelo and Tamar Katriel. 1977. Between semantics and pragmatics: The two types of 'but' -Hebrew 'aval' and 'ela'. Theoretical Linguistics 4: 143-172.
24. Dorfman, Robert, 1989. Thomas Robert Malthus and David Ricardo. Journal of Economic Perspectives 3(3): 153-164.
25. van Eemeren, Frans H. and Rob Grootendorst, 1984. Speech Acts in Argumentative Discussions. Dordrecht: Foris.
26. Fraser, Bruce, 1994. No Conversation Without Misrepresentation. In: Parret, ed., 1994, 143-153.
27. Granger, Gilles-Gaston, 1968. Essai d'une Philosophie du Style. Paris: Colin.
28. Granger, Gilles-Gaston, 1985. Discussing and convincing: An approach towards a pragmatical study of the language of science. In: M. Dascal, ed., Dialogue: An Interdisciplinary Approach, pp. 339-351. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
29. Guo, Yueguo, 1994. Pragmatics and Rhetoric: A Collaborative Approach to Conversation. In: Parret, ed., 1994, 173-195.
30. Keynes, John Maynard, [1972] 1933. Thomas Robert Malthus. In: Essays in Biography, 71-108. Cambridge: Macmillan.
31. Khalil, Elias L., 1992. Fox, hedgehog, and owl: Three temperaments in economic discourse. Methodus 4(1): 101-109.
32. Lakatos, Imre, 1970. Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. In: I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave, eds., Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, 91-196. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
33. Malthus, Thomas Robert, 1986. The Works of Thomas Robert Malthus, 8 vols. Edited by E.A. Wrigley and D. Souden. London: Pickering.
34. Malthus, Thomas Robert, [1986] 1814. Observations on the effects of the Corn Laws. In: Malthus, 1986, VII: 87-109.
35. Malthus, Thomas Robert, [1986] 1815. An inquiry into the nature and progress of rent. In: Malthus, 1986, VII.
36. Malthus, Thomas Robert, [1986] 1823. The measure of value. In: Malthus, 1986, VII.
37. Malthus, Thomas Robert, [1986] 1827. Definitions in political economy. In: Malthus, 1986. VIII.
38. Malthus, Thomas Robert, [1989] 1803. An essay on the principle of population. The Version Published in 1803, with the Variora of 1806, 1807, 1817 and 1826, 2 vols. Edited by P. James. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press for the Royal Economic Society.
39. Malthus, Thomas Robert, [1989] 1820, 1836. Principles of political economy. Variorum Edition Edited by J. Pullen. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press for the Royal Economic Society.
40. Mill, James, [1965] 1808. Commerce Defended. New York: Kelley.
41. Paley, William, [1786] 1785. The Principles of Moral and Political Philosophy. London: Faulder.
42. Paley, William, [1970] 1802. Natural Theology, or: Evidences of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity, Collected from the Appearances of Nature. Westmead: Gregg.
43. Parrel, Herman, ed., 1994. Pretending to Communicate. Berlin: De Gruyter.
44. Pepper, Stephen. 1935. The root metaphor theory of metaphysics. Journal of Philosophy 32: 365-374.
45. Popper, Karl, [1981] 1975. The rationality of scientific revolutions. In: I. Hacking, ed., Scientific Revolutions, 80-106. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
46. Pullen, John. 1989. Introduction to the variorum edition. In: Malthus, 1989 [1820, 1836].
47. Ricardo, David, 1951-1973. The Works and Correspondence, 11 vols. Edited by P. Sraffa with the collaboration of M.H. Dobb. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
48. Ricardo, David, [1951] 1817, 1821. On the principles of political economy and taxation. In: Ricardo, 1951-1973, I.
49. Ricardo, David, [1951] 1928. Notes on Mr Malthus. In: Ricardo, 1951-1973, Vol. II.
50. Ricardo, David, 1952. Absolute value and exchangeable value. In: Ricardo, 1951-1973, IV: 361-412.
51. Ricardo, David, 1992. Notes on Malthus' 'Measure of Value'. Edited by P.L. Porta. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
52. Schopenhauer, Arthur, [1985] 1864. Die kunst, recht zu behalten, in 38 kunstgriffen dargestellt. In: Der Handschriftliche Nachlass, 5 Vols., III: 669-695. Edited by A. Hübscher. München: Deutscher Taschenbuch-Verlag.
53. Smith, Adam, [1976] 1776. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, 2 vols. Edited by R. H. Campbell, A.S. Skinner and W.B. Todd. Oxford: Clarendon.
54. Spence, William, 1807. Britain Independent of Commerce. London: Cadell and Davies.
55. Stewart, Dugald, [1814] 1792. Elements of the Philosophy of the Human Mind, Vol. II. Edinburgh: Constable.
56. Walton, Douglas N., 1998. The New Dialectic: Conversational Contexts of Argument. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
57. Walton, Douglas N., 1995. A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.