Involuntary circumcision: The legal issues

BJU International, Supplement

Volumn 83, Issue 1, 1999, Pages 63-73

  Van Howe, R S ^a,b   Svoboda, J S ^b   Dwyer, J G ^b   Price, C P ^a  

^a MARSHFIELD CLINIC   (United States)

^b NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CHILD ABUSE; CIRCUMCISION; HUMAN; HUMAN RIGHTS; INFORMED CONSENT; MALE; MEDICAL ETHICS; MEDICOLEGAL ASPECT; NEWBORN; PARENTAL BEHAVIOR; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; UNITED KINGDOM; UNITED STATES;

LEGAL APPROACH; PROFESSIONAL PATIENT RELATIONSHIP;

ATTITUDE; CHILD; CHILD ABUSE; CHILD ADVOCACY; CIRCUMCISION, MALE; GREAT BRITAIN; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; MALE; RELIGION AND MEDICINE; UNITED STATES;

EID: 0033029094     PISSN: 14655101     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (148)

1. Taylor JR, Lockwood AP, Taylor AJ, The prepuce: specialized mucosa of the penis and its loss to circumcision. Br J Urol 1996; 77: 291-5
2. Cold CJ, Taylor JR. The prepuce. BJU Int 1999; 83 (Suppl 1): 34-44
3. Price C. Male circumcision: an ethical and legal affront. Bull Med Ethics 1997; 128: 13-9. [URL http: //www.cirp.org/CIRP/library/legal/price/]
4. Dwyer JG. The children we abandon: religious exemptions to child welfare and education laws as denials of equal protection to children of religious objectors. N C Law Rev 1996; 74: 1321-478
5. Svoboda JS. Routine infant male circumcision: examining the human rights and constitutional issues. In Denniston GC, Milos MF, eds. Sexual Mutilations: a Human Tragedy. New York: Plenum Press, 1997: 205-15
6. Chessler AJ. Justifying the unjustifiable: rite or wrong. Buffalo Law Rev 1997; 45: 555-613
7. Richards D. Male circumcision: medical or ritual? J Law Med 1996; 3: 371-6
8. Brigman WE. Circumcision as child abuse: the legal and constitutional issues. J Fam Law 1985; 23: 337-57
9. Bonner CA, Kinane MJ. Circumcision: the legal and constitutional issues. The Truth Seeker 1989; July/ August: S1-4
10. Strong C. What is the 'inviolability of persons?' In Medicine Unbound: the Human Body and the Limits of Medical Intervention.
11. Etchells E, Sharpe G, Walsh P, Williams JR, Singer PA. Bioethics for clinicians: 1. Consent. Can Med Assoc J 1996; 155: 177-80
12. Dwyer JG. Parents' religion and children's welfare: debunking the doctrine of parents' right. California Law Rev 1994; 82: 1371-447
13. Re vs Quinlan. 355 A2d 647 (NJ) 1976
14. Feinberg J. The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law: Harm to Others. New York: Oxford University Press 1984
15. Riddick W. Parents and life prospects. In O'Neill O, Riddick W, eds. Having Children: Philosophical and Legal Reflections on Parenthood. New York: Oxford University Press 1979: 25
16. Harrison C, Kenny NP, Sidarous M, Rowell M. Bioethics for clinicians: 9. Involving children in medical decisions. Can Med Assoc J 1997; 156: 825-8
17. S v S, W, v Official Solicitor 3 All ER. 402. 1970
18. Committee on Bioethics. Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice. Pediatrics 1995; 95: 314-7
19. Valeric N v Valeric N. 707 P 2d 760, 219 Cal Rptr 3871985
20. Wisconsin v Yoder. 406 US 205 1972
21. Little v Little. 576 SW2d 493 1979
22. In Re Richardson. 284 So2d 185 1973
23. The Children Act 1989. London: HMSO 1989
24. Neuberger J. The role of research ethics committees in the United Kingdom. In Ethics and Health Care. London: King's Fund Institute 1992
25. Department of Health. Local Research Ethics Committees. London: DoH:HSG 1991 (91)5
26. Queensland Law Reform Commission. Research Paper: Circumcision of Male Infants. Brisbane, Australia: QLRC 1993
27. Universal Declaration of Human Rights. GA Rese 217 A, UN GAOR, 3rd Session, Suppl. 51, at 73, UN Doc A/810 1948
28. Convention on the Rights of the Child. UN GA resolution 44/25, November 201989
29. Declaration of the Rights of the Child. UN GA resolution 1 386 [XIV]. November 20 1959 Principle 9
30. Alderson P. European charter of children's rights. Bull Med Ethics 1993; 124: 13-5
31. Bravery v Bravery. 1 WLR 116 1954
32. Re Z (a minor) (freedom of publication).
33. Gillick v West Norfolk, Wisbech Area Health Authority 3 All ER. 402 1985
34. Delany L, Month S, Savulescu J, Browett P, Palmer S. Altruism by proxy: volunteering children for bone marrow donation. Br Med J 1996; 312: 240-3
35. Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation 156 CLR. 41 1984
36. Secretary, Dept. of Health and Community Services v JWB and SMB, 175 CLR 218 1992 [Marion's Case]
37. Wallerstein E. Circumcision: An American Health Fallacy New York: Springer Publishing Co. 1980
38. American Academy of Pediatrics Section on Urology. Timing of elective surgery on (he genitalia of male children with particular reference to the risks, benefits, and psychological effects of surgery and anesthesia. Pediatrics 1996; 97: 590-4
39. To T, Agha M, Dick PT, Feldman W. A cohort study on male neonatal circumcision and the subsequent risk of urinary tract infection. Paediatr Child Health 1997; 2; 55A
40. Gee WF, Anscli JS. Neonatal circumcision: a ten-year overview: with comparison of the Gomco clamp and the Plastibell device. Pediatrics 1976; 58: 824-7
41. Moreno CA, Realini JP. Infant circumcision in an outpatient setting. Tex Med 1989; 85: 37-40
42. Wiswell TE, Tencer HL., Welch CA, Chamberlain JL. Circumcision in children beyond the neonalal period. Pediatrics 1993; 92: 791-3
43. Walfisch S, Ben Zion YZ, Gurman G. [Circumcision of new immigrants]. Harefuah 1994; 126: 176
44. Frank JD. Circumcision, meatotomy and meatoplasty. In Spitz L, Coran AG, eds. Pediatric Surgery, 5th edn. London: Chapman & Hall Medical, 1995: 738-44
45. Howard CR, Howard FM, Weitzman ML. Acetaminophen analgesia in neonalal circumcision: the effect on pain. Pediatrics 1994; 93: 641-6
46. Stang HJ, Gunnar MR, Snellman L, Condon LM. Kestenbaum R. Local anesthesia for neonatal circumcision. Effects on distress and cortisol response. JAMA 1988; 259: 1507-11
47. Puthoff TD, Visconti JA, Tschampel MM. Use of EMLA prior to circumcision. Ann Pharmacotherapy 1996; 30: 1327-30
48. Taddio A, Stevens B, Craig K et al. Efficacy and safety of lidocaine-prilocaine cream for pain during circumcision. N Engl J Med 1997; 336: 1197-20
49. Lander J, Brady-Fryer B, Metcalfe JB, Nazarali S, Muttitt S. Comparison of ring block, dorsal penile nerve block, and topical anesthesia for neonalal circumcision. JAMA 1997; 278: 2157-62
50. Van Howe RS. Anesthesia for neonatal circumcision: who benefits? J Pre Perinatal Psychol Health 1997; 12: 3-18
51. Re Jane. 94 FLR 1 1988
52. Ciesielski-Carlucci C, Milliken N, Cohen NTL Determinant of decision making for circumcision. Camb Q Healthcare Ethics 1996; 5: 228-36
53. Stein MT, Marx M, Taggart SL, Bass RA. Routine neonalal circumcision: The gap between contemporary policy and practice. J Fam Pract 1982; 15: 47-53
54. Lovell JE, Cox J. Maternal attitudes toward circumcision. J Fam Pract 1979; 9: 811-3
55. Christensen-Szalanski JJ, Boyce WT, Harrell H, Gardner MM. Circumcision and informed consent. Is more information always better? Med Care 1987; 25: 856-67
56. Etchells E, Sharpe G, Dykeman MJ, Meslin EM, Peter A, Singer PA. Bioethics for clinicians: 4. Voluntariness. Can Med Assoc J 1996; 155: 1083-6
57. Kaplan GW. Circumcision - an overview. Curr Probl Pediatr 1977; 7: 1-33
58. Van Howe RS. Why does neonatal circumcision persist in the United States? In Denniston GC, Milos MF, eds. Sexual Mutilations: a Human Tragedy. New York: Plenum Press, 1997: 111-9
59. American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs. Code of Medical Ethics: Current Opinions with Annotations. Chicago, Illinois: American Medical Association 1997
60. Briggs A. Circumcision: What Every Parent Should Know, Earlysville, Virginia: Birth & Parenting Publications 1985
61. Hovsepian D. The pros & cons of routine circumcision. California Med 1951; 75: 360
62. Mason S. Obtaining informed consent for neonatal randomized controlled trials - an 'elaborate ritual'? Arch Dis Child 1997; 76: F143-5
63. Wiswell TE. Circumcision - an update. Curr Probl Pediatr 1992; 22: 424-31
64. Porter FL, Porges SW, Marshall RE. Newborn pain cries and vagitl tone: parallel changes in response to circumcision. Child Dev 1988; 59: 495-505
65. Porter FL, Miller RH, Marshall RE. Neonatal pain cries: effect of circumcision on acoustic features and perceived urgency. Child Dev 1986; 57: 790-802
66. Schrag D, Kuntz KM, Carber JE, Weeks JC. Decision analysis - effects of prophylactic mastectomy and oophrectomy on life expectancy among women with BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations. N Engl J Med 1997; 336: 1464-71
67. Parker SL, Tong T, Bolden S, Wingo PA. Cancer statistics, 1997. CA Cancer J Clin 1997; 47: 5-27
68. Ganiats TG, Humphrey JB, Taras HL, Kaplan RM. Routine neonatal circumcision: a cost-utility analysis. Med Decis Making 1991; 11: 282-93
69. Lawler FH, Bisonni RS. Holtgrave DR. Circumcision: a decision analysis of its medical value. Fam Med 1991; 23: 587-93
70. Chessarc JB. Circumcision: is the risk of urinary tract infection really the pivotal issue? Clin Pediatr Phila 1992; 31: 100-4
71. Cadman D, Gafni A, McNamce J. Newborn circumcision: an economic perspective. Can Med Assoc J 1984; 131: 1353-5
72. Haberfield L. The law and male circumcision in Australia: medical, legal, and cultural issues. Monash University Law Rev 1997; 23: 92-122
73. Lancaster J. Egyptian court overturns decree that banned female circumcision. The Washington Post 1997; June 25: A26 [Munir Fawzi, MD, a British-trained gynaecologist and professor at Cairo's Ain Shams University, defends the practice of female circumcision on both religious and medical grounds]
74. Lightfoot-Klein H. Similarities in attitudes and misconceptions about male and female sexual mutilations. In Denniston GC, Milos MF, eds, Sexual Mutilations: a Human Tragedy. New York: Plenum Press, 1997: 131-5
75. Haberfield L. Responding to 'Male circumcision: medical or ritual?'. J Law Med 1997; 4: 379-85
76. Cuckow PM, Rix G, Mouriquand PD. Preputial plasty: a good alternative to circumcision. J Pediatr Surg 1994; 29: 561-3
77. Anand KJS, Hickey PR. Pain and its effects in the human neonate and fetus. N Engl J Med 1987; 317: 1321-9
78. Garry T. Circumcision: a survey of fees and practices. OBG Management 1994; October: 34-6
79. 2 in term infants. Am J Dis Child 1980; 134: 676-8
80. Gunnar MR, Porter FL, Wolf CM, Rigatuso J, Larson MC. Neonatal stress reactivity: predictions to later emotional temperament. Child Dev 1995; 66: 1-13
81. Gunnar MR, Fisch RO, Korsvik S, Donhowc JM. The effects of circumcision on serum cortisol and behavior. Psychoneuroendocrinology 1981; 6: 269-75
82. Gunnar MR, Fisch RO. Malone S. The effects of a pacifying stimulus on behavioral and adrenocortical responses to circumcision in the newborn. J Am Acad Child Psychiatry 1984; 23: 34-8
83. Gunnar MR, Malone S, Vance G, Fisch RO. Coping with aversivc stimulation in the neonatal period: quiet sleep and plasma cortisol levels during recovery from circumcision. Child Dev 1985; 56: 824-34
84. Talbert LM, Kraybill EN, Potter HD. Adrenal cortical response to circumcision in the neonate. Obstet Gynecol 1976; 48: 208-10
85. Goldman R. Circumcision: The Hidden Trauma: How an American Cultural Practice Affects Infants and Ultimately Us All. Boston: Vanguard Publications 1997
86. NIH Consensus Development Conference, Infantile Apnea, Home Monitoring. Rockville MD. US Public Health Service. 4. US Dept of Health and Human Services, NIH publication 87-29051986
87. Van Howe RS, Cold CJ. Local anesthesia for infants undergoing circumcision. JAMA 1998; 279: 1170
88. Emde RN, Harmon RJ, Metcalf D, Koenig KL, Wagonfeld S. Stress and neonatal sleep. Psychosom Med 1971; 33:491-7
89. Anders TF, Chalemian RJ. The effects of circumcision on sleep-wake stales in human neonates. Psychosom Med 1974; 36: 174-9
90. Marshall RE, Porter FL, Rogers AG, Moore J, Anderson B, Boxerman SB. Circumcision. II. Effects upon mother-infant interaction. Early Hum Dev 1982; 7: 367-74
91. Dixon S, Snyder J. Holve R, Bromberger P. Behavioral effects of circumcision with and without anesthesia. J Dev Behav Peds 1984; 5: 246-50
92. Laumann EO, Masi CM, Zuckerman EW. Circumcision in the United States: prevalence, prophylactic effects, and sexual practice. JAMA 1997; 277: 1052-7
93. Van Howe RS, Cold CJ. Advantages and disadvantages of neonatal circumcision. JAMA 1997; 278: 203
94. Convention Against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. UN GA resolution 39/46, December 10 1984 Article 1
95. Reynolds v United States. 98 US 145 1878
96. Jehovah's Witnesses v King County Hospital. 278 F 1968 (Supplement 488); (WD Wash 1967) aff'd 390 US 598
97. Adelaide Company of Jehovah's Witnesses Inc, v Commonwealth 67 CLR. 116 1943
98. Employment Division v Smith 494 US. 872 1990
99. Minersville School District Board of Education v Gobitis, 310 US 586 1940
100. Boerne, no. 95-2074 US LEXTS 4035 1997
101. McGowan v Maryland 336 US. 420 1961
102. Two Guys from Harrison-Allentown, Inc, v McGinley 366 US. 582 1961
103. Braunfeld v Brown 366 US. 599 1961
104. Gallagher v Crown Kosher Mkt. 366 ITS 617 1961
105. International Covenant of Civil and Political Rights, UNGA, resolution 2200 A, [XXI]. December 16 1966
106. Prince v Massachusetts 321 US. 158 1944
107. Costello-Roberts v UK. ECHRR 112 1993
108. State v Miskimens 490 NE. 2d 931 1984
109. Blackwelder v Safnauer, 689 F (Suppl. 106), 128 (NDNY 1988). Appeal Dismissed 866 F 2d; 548 (2d Cir) 1989
110. Etchells E, Sharpe G, Walsh P. Consent for circumcision. Can Med Assoc J 1997; 156: 18
111. Etchells E, Sharpe G, Burgess MM, Singer PA. Bioethics for clinicians: 2. Disclosure. Can Med Assoc J 1996; 155: 387-91
112. Neil M, Lazar NM, Greiner GG, Robertson G, Singer PA. Bioethics for clinicians: 5. Substitute decision-making. Can Med Assoc J 1996; 155: 1435-7
113. Haberfield E. Informed consent and male circumcision. Presented to Australasian Law Teachers Association Conference, Sydney, NSW, Australia, October 3 1997
114. Garkawe S. The impact of the doctrine of cultural relativism on the Australian legal system. E Law -Murdoch University Electronic J Law 1995; 2: 29-38
115. Poulter D. English Law and Ethnic Minority Customs. London: Butterworths 1986
116. Poulter D. Ethnic minority customs, English law and human rights. ICLQ 1987; 36: 589
117. Queensland Law Reform Commission. Consent to Medical Treatment of Young People. WP 44. Brisbane, Australia: QLRC 1993
118. Bliss DP, Healy PJ, Waldhausen JHT. Necrotizing fasciitis after Plastibell circumcision. J Pediatr 1997; 13: 459-62
119. Sherman J, Borer JG, Horowitz M, Glassberg KI. Circumcision: successful glanular reconstruction and survival following traumatic amputation. J Urol 1996; 156: 842-4
120. Woodside JR. Necrotizing fasciitis after neonatal circumcision. Am J Bis Child 1980; 134: 301-2
121. Sotolongo JR Jr, Hoffman S, Gribetz ME. Penile denudation injuries after circumcision. J Urol 1985; 133: 102-3
122. Scurlock JM. Pemberton PJ. Neonatal meningitis and circumcision. Med J Aust 1977; 1: 332-4
123. Jee LD, Millar AJ. Ruptured bladder following circumcision using the Plastibell device. Br J Urol 1990; 65: 216-7
124. Connelly KP, Shropshire LC, Salzberg A. Gastric rupture associated with prolonged crying in a newborn undergoing circumcision. Clin Pediatr Phila 1992; 3: 560-1
125. Taddio A, Goldbach M, Ipp M, Stevens B, Koren G. Effect of neonatal circumcision on pain responses during vaccination in boys. Lancet 1995; 345: 291-2
126. Taddio A, Katz J, Ilersich AL, Koren G. Effect of neonatal circumcision on pain response during subsequent routine vaccination. Lancet 1997; 349: 599-603
127. Cansever G. Psychological effects of circumcision. Br J Med Psychol 1965; 38: 321-31
128. Hammond T. Long-term consequences of neonatal circumcision: a preliminary poll of circumcised men. In Dcnnislon GC, Milos MF, eds, Sexual Mutilations: a Human Tragedy. New York: Plenum Press, 1997: 125-9
129. Mississippi University for Women v Hogan 458 US. 7181982
130. Craig v Boren 429 US. 190 1976
131. Baer Z. Circumcision: are baby boys entitled to the same protection as baby girls regarding genital mutilation? In Denniston GC, Milos MF, eds, Sexual Mutilations: a Human Tragedy. New York: Plenum Press, 1997: 197-203
132. Califano v Westcott 443 US. 76 1979
133. Tussman tenBroek. The equal protection of the laws. California Law Rev 1949; 37: 341
134. Regina v Brown 1 AC, 212 1994
135. Regina v Adesanya. The Times 1974; July 16-17
136. Williams G. Consent and public policy. Crim Law Rev 1962: 155-6
137. Brazier M. Medicine, Patients and the Law. Harmondsworth: Penguin 1992
138. Kirkey S. Circumcising baby boys 'criminal assault': ethicist says society must consider ban. Ottawa Citizen 1997; October 17: 1
139. Collins v Wilcock 1 WLR. 1172 1984
140. Wolfenden Report on Homosexual Offences. Cmnd 247 Chapter 2, paragraph 13 1957
141. Kuhn TS. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. 2nd edn. Chicago: University of Chicago Press 1970
142. Weiss GN. Prophylactic neonatal surgery and infectious diseases. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1997; 16: 727-34
143. Schoen EJ. Benefits of newborn circumcision: is Europe ignoring medical evidence? Arch Dis Child 1997; 77: 258-60
144. Wiswell TE. Circumcision circumspection. N Engl J Med 1997; 336: 1244-5
145. Morey AF, Foley HT, McLeod DG, Pendergrass TL. Malpractice claims for urogenital injuries. J Urol 1988; 140: 1475-8
146. Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee 1 WLR. 582 1957
147. Dunne v National Maternity Hospital ICRM. 735 1989
148. Rogers v Whilakcr 175 CLR. 479 1992