Battered women and bad science: The limited validity and utility of battered woman syndrome

Psychiatry, Psychology and Law

Volumn 6, Issue 1, 1999, Pages 23-49

  McMahon, Marilyn ^a  

^a LA TROBE UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

AUSTRALIA; BATTERED WOMAN; CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY; COURT; FORENSIC MEDICINE; HUMAN; REVIEW; SYNDROME;

EID: 0032703260     PISSN: 13218719     EISSN: 19341687     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/13218719909524946     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. American Psychiatric Association. (1994). The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders – Fourth Edition. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.
2. American Psychiatric Association. (1987). The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders – Third Edition (Revised). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.
3. Anson, O., and Sagy, S. (1995). Marital violence: Comparing women in violent and nonviolent unions. Human Relations, 48, (3), 285–305
4. Ball, P and Wyman, E. (1977–78). Battered wives and powerlessness: What can counsellors do? Victimology, 2, 545–552.
5. Blowers, A., and Bjerregaard, B.(1996). The admissibility of expen testimony on the battered woman syndrome in homicide cases. Journal of Psychiatry and Law, 22. (4), 527–560.
6. Bricker, D. (1993). Fatal defense: An analysis of battered woman’s syndrome expert testimony for gay men and lesbians who kill abusive partners. Brooklyn Laiv Review, 58, 1379–1437.
7. Brodie, J. (1996). ‘All youse three will be dead in the morning’: The Kontinnen case. In Greenwood, K. (Ed.). The Thing She Loves: Why Women Kill. St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin.
8. Brown, H. (1997). Beyond Battered Woman Syndrome: Reforming the Law ofSelfDefonce to Achieve Justice for Women Who Kill. Unpublished M.A thesis, Monash University.
9. Browne, A. (1988). When Battered Women Kill. NY: Free Press.
10. CofFee, C.L. (1986). Note: A trend emerges: A state survey on the admissibility of expert testimony concerning the battered woman syndrome. Journal of Family Law, 25, 373–396.
11. Comack, E.(1987) Women defendants and the ‘battered wife syndrome’: A plea for the sociological imagination. Crown Counsel’s Review, 5, (12), 6–16.
12. Crocker, P. (1985). The meaning of equality for battered women who kill men in self-defense. Harvard Women’s Law Journal, 8, 121–153.
13. Coughlin, A. (1994). Excusing women, California Law Review, 82, 1–89.
14. Dershowitz, A. (1994). The Abuse Excuse: And Other Cop-Outs, Sob Stories, and Evasions of Responsibility. NY: Little Brown ‖ Co.
15. Dobash, R.E. and Dobash, R.P. (1992). Women, Violence and Social Change. NY: Roudedge.
16. Dodge, M. and Greene, E. (1991). Juror and expert conceptions of battered women. Violence and Victims, 6, (4), 271–282.
17. Douglas, M. (1987). The battered woman syndrome. In Sonkin, D.J. (Ed.) Domestic Violence On Trial NY: Springer.
18. Downs, D.A. (1997). More than Victims: Battered Women, the Syndrome Society and the Law. Chicago: Univ. Chicago Press.
19. Duncan, K.L (1996). Lies, damned lies and statistics? Psychological syndrome evidence in the courtroom after Daubert. Indiana Law Journal 7, (3), 53.
20. Dutton, M.A. and Goodman, L.A. (1994). Posttraumatic stress disorder among battered women: Analysis of legal implications. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 12, 215–234.
21. Dutton, D., and Painter, S.(1993).The battered woman syndrome: Effects of severity and inter-mittency of abuse. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 63, (4) 614–622.
22. Easteal, P. (1996). Till death us do part. In Greenwood, K. (Ed.). The Thing She Loves: Why Women Kill. St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin.
23. Easteal, P., Hughes, K. and Easter, J. (1993). Battered women and duress. Alternative Law Journal 18, (3), 139–140.
24. Ewing, C. (1987). Battered women who kill: Psychological self defense as legal justification. Lexington, MA-eath.
25. Ewing, C, and Aubry, M. (1987). Battered women and public opinion: Some realities about the myths. Journal of Family Violence, 2, (3), 257–264.
26. Faigman, C. (1986). The battered woman syndrome and self-defense: A legal and empirical dissent. Virginia Law Review, 72, 619–647.
27. Faigman, C. (1995). The labyrinth of scientific evidence. Hastings Law Journal 46.
28. Faigman, C, and Wright, A. (1997). The battered woman syndrome in the age of science. Arizona Law Review, 39, 67–115.
29. Freckelton, I. (1992). Battered woman syndrome. Alternative Law Journal, 17, 39–41.
30. Freckelton, I. (1997). Judicial pedagogy and expert evidence on victims’ responses to trauma. Psychiatry, Psychology and Law, 4, (1), 79–86.
31. Freckelton, I. (1994). When plight makes right – the Forensic abuse syndrome. Criminal Law Journal, 18, (1), 29–49.
32. Freckelton, I. (1993). Novel psychological evidence. In Freckelton, I. And Selby, H. (Eds). Expert Evidence. Sydney: Law Book Company, (vol.l, part 9).
33. Gesino, J., Smith, H., and Keckich, W. (1982). The battered woman grows old. Clinical Gerontologist, 1, 59–67.
34. Gleason, W.J. (1993).Mental disorders in battered women: An empirical study. Violence and Victims, 8, (1), 53–68
35. Goodman-Delahunty, J. (1997). Forensic psychological expertise in the wake of Daubert. Law and Human Behavior, 21, (2), 121–140.
36. Goodyear-Smith, .(1997). Re battered woman syndrome. NZLJ, 436–438.
37. Greenwood, K. (Ed.). The Thing She Loves: Why Women Kill. St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin.
38. Hancock, L. (1997). Aboriginality and lawyering: Problems for aboriginal defendants in partner homicide cases. In Cook, S. and Bessant J. (eds.), Women’s Encounters with Violence. Thousand Oaks, CA, USA: Sage.
39. Hilberman, E. and Munson, K. (1977–78). Sixty battered women. Victimology, 2, 460–470.
40. Hinchcliffe, S. and Lloyd, D. (1996). Provocative behaviour: Should battered women who kill be given special treatment in law? http:/www.informinc.co.uk/LM/LM86/LM86_Taboos.html
41. Ho, R. and Venus, M. (1995) Reactions to a battered woman who kills her abusive spouse:’An attribu-tional analysis. Australian Journal of Psychology, 47, (3), 153–159.
42. Jacobson, N., Gottman, J.M., Gortncr, E., Berns, S, and Shortt, J. (1996). Psychological factors in the longitudinal course of battering: When do couples split up? When does the abuse decrease? Violence and Victims, 11, 371–392.
43. Kissane, K. (1998, September 5). Kiss or kill? The Age (Saturday Extra), 1, 6.
44. Kuhl, A. (1984). Personality traits of abused women: Masochism myth refuted. Victimology, 9, 450–463.
45. Kuhl, A. (1986). Implications of justifiable homicide verdicts for battered women. Response, 9, 6–10.
46. Leader-Elliott, I. (1993). Battered but not beaten: Women who kill in self defence. Sydney Law Review, 15, 403–460.
47. Levit, H. (1985). The battered woman. American Journal of Forensic Psychology, 3, 9–14.
48. Levit, H.(1991).Battered women: Syndrome versus self-defense. American Journal of Forensic Psychology, 9, (1) 29–35.
49. Maguigan, H. (1991). Battered women and selfdefense: Myths and misconceptions in current reform proposals. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 140, 379.
50. McCarthy, T. (1994). Battered woman syndrome. Australian Feminist Law Journal, 4, 141–151.
51. McDonald, P.L. (1989). Helping with the termination of an assaultive relationship. In Pressman, B. (Ed.) Intervening with Assulted Women. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlboum.
52. McHugh, M.C. (1993). Studying battered women and batterers: feminist perspectives on methodology. In Hansen, M. and Harway, M. (Eds.) Battering and Family Therapy. London: Sage.
53. Morse, S. (1990). The misbegotten marriage of soft psychology and bad law. Law and Human Behavior, 14, (6), 593–618.
54. Murphy, S. (1992). Assisting the jury in understanding victimisation: Expert psychological testimony on battered woman syndrome and rape trauma syndrome. Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems, 25 276–310.
55. Nicolson, D. and Sanghvi, R. (1993). Battered women and provocation: The implications of R v Ahluwalia. Crim.LR. 728–738.
56. O’Donovan, K. (1991). Defences for battered women who kill. Journal of Law and Society, 18, (2), 219–240.
57. O’Donovan, K. (1993). Law’s knowledge: The judge, the expert, the battered woman and her syndrome. Journal of Law and Society, 20, (4), 427–437.
58. Reddy, P., Knowles, A., Mulvaney, J., McMahon, M, and Freckelton, I. (1997). Attributions about domestic violence: A study of community attitudes. Psychiatry, Psychology and Law, 4, (2), 125–146.
59. Regeher, C. (1995). Battered woman syndrome. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 40, (3), 130–135.
60. Rittenmayer, S. (1981). Of battered wives, self-defense and double standards of justice. Journal of Criminal Justice, 9, (5), 389–396.
61. Rogers, N. (1996). To save her life: Gender, justice and battered women who kill. In Greenwood, K. (Ed.). The Thing She Loves: Why Women Kill. St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin.
62. Rosewater, L. (1987). The clinical and courtroom application of battered women’s personality assessments. In Sonkin, D.J. (Ed). Domestic Violence on Trial NY: Springer.
63. Schopp, R.F., Sturgis, B.J., and Sullivan, M. (1994). Battered woman syndrome, expert testimony, and the distinction between justification and excuse. University of Illinois Law Review, 1994, 45–113.
64. Schuller, R. (1992).The impact of battered woman syndrome evidence on jury decision processes. Law and Human Behavior, 16, (6), 597–620
65. Schuller, R., and Hastings, P. (1996). Trials of battered women who kill: The impact of alternative forms of expert evidence. Law and Human Behavior, 20, (2) 167–187
66. Schuller, R., Smith, V., and Olson, J. (1994).Jurors’ decisions in trials of battered women who kill: The role of prior beliefs and expert testimony. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 24, (4) 316–337
67. Schuller, R. and Vidmar, N. (1992). Battered woman syndrome evidence in the courtroom: A review of the literature. Law and Human Behaviour, 16, 273–291.
68. Sheehy, E., Stubbs, J. and Tolmie, J. (1992). Defending battered women on’ trial: The battered woman syndrome and its limitations. Criminal Law Journal, 16, 369.
69. Simone, C. (1997). “Killer man was a battered wife’: The application of battered woman syndrome to homosexual defendants, The Queen v McEwen. Sydney Law Review, 19, 230–239.
70. Spiers, M. (1998). Which chicks are the liars? An undemocratic universe – chaos, lies, representation and the law. http://unvw.iq.com.au/-dtehhutt/oj/ojchaoslLhtm
71. Stubbs, J. and Tolmie, J. (1995). Race, gender and the battered woman syndrome: An Australia case study. CJWL, 8, 122–158.
72. Thyfault, R., Bennet, C., and Hirschorn, R. (1987). Battered women in court: Jury and trial consultants and expert witnesses. In Sonkin, D. (Ed.), Domestic Violence on Trial. N.Y.: Springer.
73. Walus-Wigle, J and Meloy, J. (1988). Battered woman syndrome as a criminal defence. Journal of Psychiatry and Law, 16, (3), 389–404.
74. Walker, L. (1996). Assessment of abusive spousal relationships, in Kaslow, F.W. (Ed.) Handbook of Relational Diagnosis and Dysfunctional Family Patterns. NY: Wiley.
75. Walker, L. (1977–78). Battered women and learned helplessness. Victimology, 2.
76. Walker, L.E. (1984a). Battered women, psychology and public policy. American Psychologist, 39, 1178–1182.
77. Walker, L. (1992). Battered woman syndrome and selfdefense. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy, 6, 321–334.
78. Walker, L. (1993). Legal self-defense for battered women. In Hansen, M. and Harway, M. (Eds.) Battering and Family Therapy. London: Sage.
79. Walker, L. (1991). Post-traumatic stress disorder in women: Diagnosis and treatment of battered woman syndrome. Special Issue: Psychotherapy with victims. Psychotherapy; 28, (1) 21–29
80. Walker, L. (1989). Psychology and violent women. American Psychologist, 44, (4), 695–702.
81. Walker, L. (1989). Terrijying Love. New York: Harper Perennial.
82. Walker, L. (1984b). The Battered Woman Syndrome. New York: Springer.
83. Walker, L. (1995). Understanding battered woman syndrome. Trial, 31, (2), 30.
84. Walker, L. (1983). Victimology and the psychological perspectives of battered women. Victimology, 8, 82–104.
85. Walker, L. (1983). Who are the battered women? Victimology, 8, 82–104
86. Walker, L., Thyfault, R., and Browne, A. (1982). Beyond the juror’s ken: Battered women. Vermont Law Review, 7, 1–14.
87. Yeo, S. (1992).Hickey: A case note. Criminal Law Journal.
88. Zdenkowski, G. (1992, October 6). Killing to survive. The Bulletin, 18.