Comparison of human, primate, and canine femora: Implications for biomaterials testing in total hip replacement

Journal of Biomedical Materials Research

Volumn 40, Issue 3, 1998, Pages 475-489

  Kuo, Tony Y ^a   Skedros, John G ^a   Bloebaum, Roy D ^a  

^a VETERANS AFFAIRS MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

Author keywords

Chimpanzee femur; Femur morphology; Greyhound femur; Human femur; Total hip replacement

Indexed keywords

BIOMECHANICS; BONE; MORPHOLOGY;

TOTAL HIP REPLACEMENT;

HIP PROSTHESES;

BIOMATERIAL;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; ANIMAL TISSUE; ARTICLE; BIOCOMPATIBILITY; BIOMECHANICS; CHIMPANZEE; DOG; FEMALE; FEMUR; HUMAN; HUMAN TISSUE; MALE; NONHUMAN; TOTAL HIP PROSTHESIS;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; AGED, 80 AND OVER; ANIMALS; ARTHROPLASTY, REPLACEMENT, HIP; DOGS; FEMALE; FEMUR; HUMANS; MALE; MATERIALS TESTING; MIDDLE AGED; PAN TROGLODYTES; SPECIES SPECIFICITY;

EID: 0032486508     PISSN: 00219304     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/(SICI)1097-4636(19980605)40:3<475::AID-JBM19>3.0.CO;2-I     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. G. Bergmann, J. Siraky, and A. Rohlmann, "A comparison of hip joint forces in sheep, dog and man," J. Biomech., 17, 907-921 (1984).
2. F. Eitel, F. Klapp, W. Jacobson, and L. Schweiberer, "Bone regeneration in animals and in man. A contribution to understanding the relative value of animal experiments to human pathophysiology," Arch. Orthop. Traumat. Surg., 99, 59-64 (1981).
3. D. R. Sumner, T. C Devlin, D. Winkelman, and T. M. Turner, "The geometry of the adult canine proximal femur," J. Orthop. Res., 8, 671-677 (1990).
4. V. K. Goel, H. Drinker, M. M. Panjabi, and A. Strongwater, "Selection of an animal model for implant fixation studies: Anatomical aspects," Yale J. Biol. Med., 55, 113-122 (1982).
5. R. L. Anemone, "The functional anatomy of the hip and thigh in primates," in Postcranial Adaptation in Nonhuman Primates, D. L. Gebo (ed.), Northern Illinois University Press, Dekalb, 1993, pp. 150-174.
6. B. A. Sigmon and D. L. Farslow, "The primate hindlimb," in Comparative Primate Biology, Vol. 1, Systematics, Evolution, and Anatomy, D. R. Swindler and J. Erwin (eds.), Alan R. Liss, Inc., New York, 1986, pp. 671-718.
7. A. H. Schultz. "The skeleton of the chimpanzee," in Anatomy, Behavior, and Diseases of Chimpanzees, G. H. Bourne (ed.), S. Karger, New York, 1969, pp. 50-101.
8. T. Kimura, "Hindlimb dominance during primate high-speed locomotion," Primates, 33, 465-476 (1992).
9. D. Schmitt and S. G. Larson, "Heel contact as a function of substrate type and speed in primates," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 96, 39-50 (1995).
10. S. Kondo, ed., Primate Morphophysiology, Locomotor Analyses and Human Bipedalism, University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 1985.
11. C. O. Lovejoy, "A biomechanical review of the locomotor diversity of early hominids," in Early Hominids of Africa, C. J. Jolly (ed.), Gerald Duckworth & Co., Ltd., London, 1978, pp. 403-429.
12. E. A. Bowles, D. S. Weaver, F. W. Telewski, A. H. Wakefield, M. J. Jaffe, and L. C. Miller, "Bone measurement by enhanced contrast image analysis: Ovariectomized and intact Macaca fascicularis as a model for human postmenopausal osteoporosis," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 67, 99-103 (1985).
13. C. J. DeRousseau, "Aging in the musculoskeletal system of Rhesus monkeys. III: Bone loss," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 68, 157-167 (1985).
14. D. R. Sumner, M. E. Morbeck, and J. J. Lobick, "Apparent age-related bone loss among adult female Gombe chimpanzees," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 79, 225-234 (1989).
15. C. S. Carlson, R. F. Loeser, M. J. Jayo, D. S. Weaver, M. R. Adams, and C. P. Jerome, "Osteoarthritis in Cynomolgus macaques: A primate model of naturally occurring disease," J. Orthop. Res., 12, 331-339 (1994).
16. C. P. Jerome, C. S. Carlson, T. C. Register, F. T. Bain, M. J. Jayo, D. S. Weaver, and M. R. Adams, "Bone functional changes in intact, ovariectomized, and ovariectomized, hormone-supplemented adult Cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicutaris) evaluated by serum markers and dynamic histomorphometry," J. Bone Miner. Res., 9, 527-540 (1994).
17. F. W. Rhinelander, C. L. Nelson, R. D. Stewart, and C. L. Stewart, "Experimental reaming of the proximal femur and acrylic cement implantation. Vascular and histologic effects," Clin. Orthop., 141, 74-89 (1979).
18. R. D. Bloebaum, D. T. Ota, J. G. Skedros, and J. P. Mantas, "Comparison of human and canine external femoral morphologies in the context of total hip replacement," J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 27, 1149-1159 (1993).
19. C. B. Ruff, "Structural changes in the lower limb bones with aging at Pecos Pueblo," Ph.D. Thesis, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia (1981).
20. C. B. Ruff and W. C. Hayes, "Cross-sectional geometry of Pecos Pueblo femora and tibiae - a biomechanical investigation: I. Method and general patterns of variation," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 60, 359-381 (1983).
21. C. B. Ruff and W. C. Hayes, "Cross-sectional geometry of Pecos Pueblo femora and tibiae - a biomechanical investigation: II. Sex, age, and side differences," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 60, 383-400 (1983).
22. C. B. Ruff and W. C. Hayes, "Subperiosteal expansion and cortical remodeling of the human femur and tibia with aging," Science, 217, 945-948 (1982).
23. C. B. Ruff and W. C. Hayes, "Sex differences in age-related remodeling of the femur and tibia," J. Orthop. Res., 6, 886-896 (1988).
24. R. Poss, P. Staehlin, and M. Larson, "Femoral expansion in total hip arthroplasty," J. Arthroplasty, 2, 259-264 (1987).
25. E. D. Simmons, Jr., K. P. H. Pritzker, and M. D. Grynpas, "Age-related changes in the human femoral cortex," J. Orthop. Res., 9, 155-167 (1991).
26. M. F. Ericksen, "Aging changes in the medullary cavity of the proximal femur in American blacks and whites," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 51, 563-570 (1979).
27. R. W. Smith, Jr. and R. R. Walker, "Femoral expansion in aging women: Implications for osteoporosis and fractures," Science, 145, 156-157 (1964).
28. C. J. Grobbelaar, "The baboon as an experimental animal in joint replacement," J. Bone Joint Surg., 63B, 471 (1981).
29. D. M. Doran, "Comparative locomotor behavior of chimpanzees and Bonobos: The influence of morphology on locomotion," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 91, 83-98 (1993).
30. M. J. Adrian, W. E. Roy, and P. V. Karpovich, "Normal gait of the dog: An electrogoniometric study," Am. J. Vet. Res., 27, 90-95 (1966).
31. A. K. Hedley, I. C. Clarke, S. C. Kozinn, I. Coster, T. Gruen, and H. C. Amstutz, "Porous ingrowth fixation of the femoral component in a canine surface replacement of the hip," Clin. Orthop., 163, 300-311 (1982).
32. T. M. Turner, D. R. Sumner, R. M. Urban, D. P. Rivero, and J. O. Galante, "A comparative study of porous coatings in a weight-bearing total hip-arthroplasty model," J. Bone Joint, Surg., 68A, 1396-1409 (1986).
33. J. D. Bobyn, R. M. Pilliar, A. G. Binnington, and J. A. Szivek, "The effect of proximally and fully porous-coated canine hip stem design on bone modeling," J. Orthop. Res., 5, 393-408 (1987).
34. D. R. Sumner, T. M. Turner, R. M. Urban, and J. O. Galante, "Long-term femoral remodelling as a function of the presence, type and location of the porous coating in cementless THA," Trans. Orthop. Res. Soc., 13, 310 (1988).
35. P. Chen, T. M. Turner, H. Ronnigen, J. Galante, R. Urban, and W. Rostoker, "A canine cementless total hip prosthesis model," Clin. Orthop., 176, 24-33 (1983).
36. P. E. Greis, J. D. Kang, V. Silvaggio, and H. E. Rubash, "A long-term study on defect filling and bone ingrowth using a canine fiber metal total hip model," Clin. Orthop., 274, 47-59 (1992).
37. S. P. Arnoczky and P. A. Torzilli, "Biomechanical analysis of forces acting about the canine hip," Am. J. Vet. Res., 42, 1581-1585 (1981).
38. R. Grelsamer, H. Alexander, M. Fruchtman, J. Kowalski, and D. Shetty, "Three-dimensional analysis of canine hip forces," Trans. Orthop. Res. Soc., 14, 224 (1989).
39. V. T. Inman, "Functional aspects of the abductor muscles of the hip," J. Bone Joint Surg., 29, 607-619 (1947).
40. R. D. Crowninshield, R. C. Johnston, J. G. Andrews, and R. A. Brand, "A biomechanical investigation of the human hip," J. Biomech., 11, 75-85 (1978).
41. R. D. McLeish and J. Chamley, "Abduction forces in the one-legged stance," J. Biomech., 3, 191-209 (1970).
42. E. F. Rybicki, F. A. Simonen, and E. B. Weis, Jr., "On the mathematical analysis of stress in the human femur," J. Biomech., 5, 203-215 (1972).
43. G. Bergmann, F. Graichen, and A. Rohlmann, "Hip joint loading during walking and running, measured in two patients," J. Biomech., 26, 969-990 (1993).
44. N. Rydell, "Forces acting in the femoral head-prosthesis," Acta Orthop. Scand., 37, Suppl. 88, 1-132 (1966).
45. N. Rydell, "Biomechanics of the hip-joint," Clin. Orthop., 92, 6-15 (1973).
46. A. Page, T. P. Harrigan, C. Allen, M. Jasty, R. W. Mann, and W. H. Harris, "Analysis of the canine gait using bone pins, bilateral force plates and rigid segment motion analysis system," Trans. Orthop. Res. Soc., 13, 544 (1988).
47. S. C. Budsberg, M. C. Verstraete, and R. W. Soutas-Little, "Force plate analysis of the walking gait in healthy dogs," Am. J. Vet. Res., 48, 915-918 (1987).
48. J. K. Roush and R. M. McLaughlin, Jr., "Effects of subject stance time and velocity on ground reaction forces in clinically normal greyhounds at the walk," Am. J. Vet. Res., 55, 1672-1676 (1994).
49. T. Kimura, "Bipedal and quadrupedal walking of primates: Comparative dynamics," in Primate Morphophysiology, Locomotor Analyses and Human Bipedalism, S. Kondo (ed.), University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 1985, pp. 81-104.
50. H. Ishida, H. Kumakura, and S. Kondo "Primate bipedalism and quadrupedalism: Comparative electromyography," in Primate Morphophysiology, Locomotor Analyses and Human Bipedalism, S. Kondo (ed.), University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 1985, pp. 59-79.
51. K. Ogata and E. M. Goldsand, "A simple biplanar method of measuring femoral anteversion and neck-shaft angle," J. Bone Joint Surg., 61A, 846-851 (1979).
52. P. M. Montavon, R. B. Hohn, M. L. Olmstead, and R. L. Rudy, "Inclination and anteversion angles of the femoral head and neck in the dog. Evaluation of a standard method of measurement," Vet. Surg., 14, 277-282 (1985).
53. N. A. Walensky, "A study of anterior femoral curvature in man," Anal. Rec., 151, 559-570 (1965).
54. B. M. Gilbert, "Anterior femoral curvature: Its probable basis and utility as a criterion of racial assessment," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 45, 601-604 (1976).
55. C. B. Ruff, E. Trinkaus, A. Walker, and C. S. Larsen, "Postcranial robusticity in Homo. I: Temporal trends and mechanical interpretation," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 91, 21-53 (1993).
56. C. B. Ruff, "Allometry between length and cross-sectional dimensions of the femur and tibia in Homo sapiens sapiens," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 65, 347-358 (1984).
57. A. L. Zihlman, M. E. Morbeck, and J. Goodall, "Skeletal biology and individual life history of Gombe chimpanzees," J. Zool., Lond., 221, 37-61 (1990).
58. G. van Wagenen, "Menopause in a subhuman primate," Anat. Rec., 166, 392 (1970).
59. E. S. Watts, "Adolescent growth and development of monkeys, apes and humans," in Nonhuman Primate Models for Human Growth and Development. Monographs in Primatology, Vol. 6, E.S. Watts (ed.), Alan R. Liss, Inc., New York, 1985, pp. 41-65.
60. W. R. Sanford and C. R. Green, The Greyhound, Crestwood House, New York, 1989.
61. J. P. Collier, M. B. Mayor, J. C. Chae, V. A. Surprenant, H. P. Surprenant, and L. A. Dauphinais, "Macroscopic and microscopic evidence of prosthetic fixation with porous-coated materials," Clin. Orthop., 235, 173-180 (1988).
62. P. C. Noble, J. W. Alexander, L. J. Lindahl, D. T. Yew, W. M. Granberry, and H. S. Tullos, "The anatomic basis of femoral component design," Clin. Orthop., 235, 148-165 (1988).
63. A. Page, M. Jasty, C. Bragdon, K. Ito, and W. H. Harris, "Alterations in femoral and acetabular bone strains immediately following cementless total hip arthroplasty: An in vitro canine study," J. Orthop. Res., 9, 738-748 (1991).
64. F. T. Hoaglund and W. D. Low, "Anatomy of the femoral neck and head with comparative data from Caucasians and Hong Kong Chinese," Clin. Orthop., 152, 10-16 (1980).
65. J. M. Clark, M. A. R. Freeman, and D. Witham, "The relationship of neck orientation to the shape of the proximal femur," J. Arthroplasty, 2, 99-109 (1987).
66. P. J. Rubin, P. F. Leyvraz, J. M. Aubaniac, J. N. Argenson, P. Esteve, and B. DeRoguin, "The morphology of the proximal femur. A three-dimensional radiographic analysis," J. Bone Joint Surg., 74B, 28-32 (1992).
67. C. Ruff, "Structural allometry of the femur and tibia in Hominoidea and Macaca," Folia Primatol., 48, 9-49 (1987).
68. E. Trinkaus, S. E. Churchill, and C. B. Ruff, "Postcranial robusticity in Homo. II: Humeral bilateral asymmetry and bone plasticity," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 93, 1-34 (1994).
69. C. B. Ruff, A. Walker, and E. Trinkaus, "Postcranial robusticity in Homo. III: Ontogeny," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 93, 1-34 (1994).
70. R. Huiskes, H. Weinans, and B. van Rietbergen, "The relationship between stress shielding and bone resorption around total hip stems and the effects of flexible materials," Clin. Orthop., 274, 124-134 (1992).
71. W. H. Harris, "Will stress shielding limit the longevity of cemented femoral components of total hip replacement?," Clin. Orthop., 274, 120-123 (1992).
72. W. H. Harris, A. L. Schiller, J. Scholler, R. A. Freiberg, and R. Scott, "Extensive localized bone resorption in the femur following total hip replacement," J. Bone Joint Surg., 58A, 612-617 (1976).
73. J. D. Bobyn, E. S. Mortimer, A. H. Glassman, C. A. Engh, J. E. Miller, and C. E. Brooks, "Producing and avoiding stress shielding. Laboratory and clinical observations of noncemented total hip arthroplasty," Clin. Orthop., 274, 79-96 (1992).
74. T. A. Gruen, G. M. McNeice, and H. C. Amstutz, " 'Modes of failure' of cemented stem-type femoral components. A radiographic analysis of loosening," Clin. Orthop., 141, 17-27 (1979).
75. R. D. Beckenbaugh and D. M. Ilstrup, "Total hip arthroplasty. A review of three hundred and thirty-three cases with long follow-up," J. Bone Joint Surg., 60A, 306-313 (1978).
76. R. N. Stauffer, "Ten-year follow-up study of total hip replacement. With particular reference to roentgenographic loosening of the components," J. Bone Joint Surg., 64A, 983-990 (1982).
77. C. J. Sutherland, A. H. Wilde, L. S. Borden, and K. E. Marks, "A ten-year follow-up of one hundred consecutive Müller curvedstem total hip-replacement arthroplasties," J. Bone Joint Surg., 64A, 970-982 (1982).
78. L. Neumann, K. G. Freund, and K. H. Sorensen, "Total hip arthroplasty with the Charnley prosthesis in patients fifty-five years old and less," J. Bone Joint Surg., 78A, 73-79 (1996).
79. I. W. Brown and P. A. Ring, "Osteolytic changes in the upper femoral shaft following porous-coated hip replacement," J. Bone Joint Surg., 67B, 218-221 (1985).
80. C. A. Engh, J. D. Bobyn, and A. H. Glassman, "Porous-coated hip replacement. The factors governing bone ingrowth, stress shielding, and clinical results," J. Bone Joint Surg., 69B, 45-55 (1987).
81. J. Hua and P. S. Walker, "Relative motion of hip stems under load," J. Bone Joint Surg., 76A, 95-103 (1994).
82. M. Jasty, C. R. Bragdon, S. Schutzer, H. Rubash, T. Haire, and W. H. Harris, "Bone ingrowth into porous-coated canine total hip replacements. Quantification by backscattered scanning electron microscopy and image analysis," Scan. Microsc., 3, 1051-1057 (1989).
83. T. D. Stewart, "Anterior femoral curvature: Its utility for race identification," Hum. Biol. 34, 49-62 (1962).
84. C. B. Ruff, "Biomechanics of the hip and birth in early Homo," Am. J. Phys. Anthropol, 98, 527-574 (1995).
85. J. Charnley, Low Friction Arthroplasty of the Hip, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1979.
86. A. C. Merchant, "Hip abductor muscle force. An experimental study of the influence of hip position with particular reference to rotation," J. Bone Joint Surg., 47A, 462-476 (1965).
87. S. L. Delp, A. V. Komattu, and R. L. Wixson, "Superior displacement of the hip in total joint replacement: Effects of prosthetic neck length, neck-stem angle, and anteversion angle on the moment-generating capacity of the muscles," J. Orthop. Res., 12, 860-870 (1994).
88. P. B. Chang, B. H. Robie, D. L. Bartel, and S. I. Backus, "Effects of anteversion and neck length on hip contact force and moment of contact force on the proximal femur," Trans. Orthop. Res. Soc., 22, 287 (1997).
89. B. Steinberg and W. H. Harris, "The 'offset' problem in total hip arthroplasty," Contemp. Orthop., 24, 556-562 (1992).
90. P. A. Ruwe, J. R. Gage, M. B. Ozonoff, and P. A. DeLuca, "Clinical determination of femoral anteversion. A comparison with established techniques," J. Bone Joint Surg., 74A, 820-830 (1992).
91. J. Wolff, The Law of Bone Remodelling (Das gesetz der transformation der knochen), P. Maquet and R. Furlong (trans., 1986), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1892.
92. C. B. Ruff, W. W. Scott, and A. Y. Liu, "Articular and diaphyseal remodeling of the proximal femur with changes in body mass in adults," Am J. Phys. Anthropol., 86, 397-413 (1991).
93. J. E. A. Bertram and A. A. Biewener, "Bone curvature: Sacrificing strength for load predictability?," J. Theor. Biol, 131, 75-92 (1988).