Can biological activity be maintained at ultra-high dilution? An overview of homeopathy, evidence, and Bayesian philosophy

Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine

Volumn 4, Issue 1, 1998, Pages 49-76

  Vallance, Aaron K ^a,b  

^a ROYAL FREE HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^b NONE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANIMAL; BAYES THEOREM; EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE; HOMEOPATHY; HUMAN; PHILOSOPHY; REVIEW;

ANIMALS; BAYES THEOREM; EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE; HOMEOPATHY; HUMANS; PHILOSOPHY, MEDICAL;

EID: 0032018504     PISSN: 10755535     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1089/acm.1998.4.1-49     Document Type: Review

References (149)

1. Aïssa J, Jurgens P, Litime MH, Behar I, Benveniste J. Electronic transmission of the cholinergic signal (abstract). FASEB J 1995;9:A683.
2. Aïssa J, Litime MH, Attias E, Allal A, Benveniste J. Transfer of molecular signals via electronic circuitry (abstract). FASEB J 1993a;7:A602.
3. Aïssa J, Litime MH, Attias E, Benveniste J. Molecular signalling at high dilution or by means of electronic circuitry (abstract). J Immunol 1993b;150:146A.
4. Anagnostatos GS 1994 Small water clusters (clathrates) in the preparation process of homoeopathy. In Endler PC, Schulte J (eds) Ultra High Dilution Physiology and Physics. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, p 121-128.
5. Anagnostatos GS, Vithoulkas G, Garzonis P, Tavouxoglou C. A working hypothesis for homeopathic microdiluted remedies. Berlin J Res Homeopathy 1991; 1(3):141-147.
6. Anonymous. Riding the coat-tails of homoeopathy. FDA Consumer, March 1985.
7. Anonymous. Quadruple-blind. Lancet 1989;22:914.
8. Anonymous. Reilly's challenge. Lancet 1994;344:1585.
9. Anthony HM, Kirk JA, Madsen KE, Mason M, Templeman GH. E and EAC rosetting lymphocytes in patients with carcinoma of bronchus. Clin Exp Immunol 1975;20:29-40, 41-54.
10. Aulagnier G. Action d'un traitement homéopathique sur la reprise du transit post opératoire. Homéopathie 1985;6:42-45.
11. Baker R, Smith C. Comment on the paper: Growth of yeast cultures as in vitro model for investigating homoeopathic remedies. Br Homoeopathic J 1985;74:93-96.
12. Beauvais F, Bidet B, Descours B, Hieblot C, Burtin C, Benveniste J. Regulation of human basophil activation. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1991;87(5):1020-1028.
13. Bellavite P, Signorini A (eds) 1995 Homeopathy - A Frontier in Medical Science. North Atlantic Books, Berkeley, California.
14. Benveniste J. Platelet-activating factor, a new mediator of anaphylaxis and immune complex deposition from rabbit and human basophils. Nature 1974;249:581-582.
15. Benveniste J. The human basophil degranulation test as in vitro method for diagnosis of allergies. Clin Allergy 1981;11:1-11.
16. Benveniste J. Dr. Jacques Benveniste replies. Nature 1988a;334:291.
17. Benveniste J. Benveniste on the Benveniste affair. Nature 1988b;335:759.
18. Benveniste J. Letter from Professor Benveniste. Comp Med Res 1988c;3(1):86-87.
19. Benveniste J, Arnoux B, Hadji L. Highly dilute antigen increases coronary flow of isolated heart from immunized guinea pigs (abstract). FASEB J 1992;6:A1610.
20. Benveniste J, Davenas E, Ducot B, Cornillet B, Poitevin B, Spira A. L'agitation de solutions hautement diluees n'induit pas d'activité biologique specifique. CR Acad Sci Paris 1991;312(II):461-466.
21. Benveniste J, Ducot C, Spira A. Letter. Nature 1994a;370: 322.
22. Benveniste J, Aïssa J, Litime MH, Tsangaris G.Th, Thomas Y. Transfer of the molecular signal by electronic amplification (abstract). FASEB J 1994b;8:A398.
23. Benveniste J, Jurgens P, Aïssa J. Digital recording/transmission of the cholinergic signal. Joint meeting of American Society of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology/American Society of Investigative Pathology/The American Association of Immunology, New Orleans, June 2-6, 1996.
24. Berezin AA. Isotopical positional correlations as a possible model for Benveniste experiments. Medical Hypotheses 1990;31:43-45.
25. Berezin AA 1994 Ultra high dilution effect and isotopic self-organisation. In Endler PC, Schulte J (eds) Ultra High Dilution Physiology and Physics. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, p. 137-169.
26. Bignamini M, Bertoli A, Consolandi AM, Dovera N, Saruggia M, Taino S, Tubertini A. Controlled double-blind trial with Baryta carbonica 15CH versus placebo in a group of hypertensive subjects confined to bed in two old people's homes. Br Homoeopathic J 1987;76: 114-119.
27. Bonini S, Adriani E, Balsano F. Letter. Nature 1988;334: 559.
28. 3 on the growth of oat coleoptiles. Berlin J Res Homeopathy 1991;1:275-278.
29. Bouchayer F. Alternative Medicines: A general approach to the French situation. Comp Med Res 1990;4(2):4-8.
30. Boyd WE. The action of microdoses of mercuric chloride on diastase. Br Homoeopathic J 1942;32:106-111.
31. Boyd WE. Biochemical and biological evidence of the activity of high potencies. Br Homoeopathic J 1954;44: 6-44.
32. Brigo B, Serpelloni G. Homeopathic treatment of migraines: A randomized double-blind controlled study of sixty cases. Berlin J Res Homeopathy 1991;1(2):98-106.
33. Cal JC, Larue F, Dorian C, Guillemain J, Dorfman P, Cambar J. 1988 Chronobiological approach of mercury-induced toxicity and of the protective effect of high dilutions of mercury against mercury-induced nephro-toxicity. In Guillouzo A (ed) Liver Cells and Drugs. John Libby Eurotext, Ltd., Colloque/Jiuseriu, pp. 481-485.
34. Callens E, Debiane H, Santias MC, Ruff F. Effects of highly diluted beta2-adrenergic agonists on isolated guinea pig trachea. Br Homoeopathic J 1993;82:123.
35. Cazin JC, Cazin M, Gaborit JL, Chaoui A, Boiron J, Belon P, Cherruault Y, Papapanayotou C. A study of the effect of decimal and centesimal dilutions of arsenic on the retention and mobilization of arsenic in the rat. Hum Toxicol 1987;6:315-320.
36. Cazin JC, Cazin M, Chaoui A, Belon P 1991 Influence of several physical factors on the activity of ultra low doses. In Doutremepuich C (ed) Ultra Low Doses. Taylor & Francis, London, pp. 69-80.
37. Chalmers AF 1992 What is this Thing Called Science? Open University Press, Milton Keynes, UK.
38. Cherruault Y, Guillez A, Sainte-Laudy J, Belon P. Etude mathematique et statistique des effets de dilutions successives de chlorhydrate d'histamine sur la reactivite des basophiles humains. Bio-Sciences 1989;7:63-72.
39. Chevrel JP, Saglier J, Destable MD. Reprise du transit intestinal en chirurgie digestive. Presse Med 1984;13: 883.
40. Collins HM 1985 Changing Order: Replication and Induction in Scientific Practice. Sage Publishing, London.
41. Danchin A. Letter. Nature 1988;334:286.
42. Davenas E, Beauvais F, Amara J, Oberbaum M, Robinzon B, Miadonna A, Tedeschi A, Pomeranz B, Fortner P, Belon P, Sainte-Laudy J, Poitevin B, Benveniste J. Human basophil degranulation triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE. Nature 1988;333:816-818.
43. Day C. Control of stillbirth in pigs using homoeopathy. Vet Rec 1984;114(9):216.
44. Day C. Clinical trials in bovine mastitis. Br Homoeopathic J 1986;75:11-14.
45. Del Guidice E 1994 Is the "memory of water" a physical impossibility? In Endler PC, Schulte J (eds) Ultra High Dilution Physiology and Physics. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.
46. Del Giudice E, Preparata G, Vitiello G. Water as a free electric dipole laser. Phys Rev Lett 1988;61:1085-1088.
47. Demangeat JC, Demangeat C, Gries P, Poitevin B, Constantinesco A. Modifications des temps de relaxation RMN a 4MHZ des protons du solvant dans les tres hautes dilutions salines de silice/lactose. J Med Nucl Biophy 1992;16:135-145.
48. D'Souza MF, Emanuel MB, Gregg J, Charlton J, Gold-schmidt J. A method for evaluating therapy for hay fever. Clin Allergy 1983;13:329-335.
49. Edwards W, Lindman H, Savage LJ. Bayesian statistical inference for psychological research. Psychol Rev 1963;70:193-242.
50. Egido J, Sanchez-Crespo M, Garcia-Sanchez M, Hernando L, Benveniste J. In vitro basophil degranulation in drug-suspected acute renal failure. Lancet 1977;ii:712-713.
51. Endler PC, Pongratz W, van Wijk R, Kastberger G, Haidvogl M. Effects of highly diluted succussed thyroxine on metamorphosis of highland frogs. Berlin J Res Homeopathy 1991a;1(3):151-160.
52. Endler PC, Pongratz W, Kastberger G, Wiegant FAC. Haidvogel M. Climbing activity in frogs and the effect of highly diluted succussed thyroxine. Br Homoeopathic J 1991b;80:194-200.
53. Endler PC, Pongratz W, van Wijk R, Wiegant FAC, Waltl K, Gehrer M, Hilgers H 1994a A zoological example on ultra high dilution research. Energetic coupling between the dilution and the organism in a model of amphibia. In Endler PC, Schulte J (eds) Ultra High Dilution Physiology and Physics. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, p. 39-68.
54. Endler PC, Pongratz W, Kastberger G, Wiegant FAC, Schulte J. The effect of highly diluted agitated thyroxine on the climbing activity of frogs. Vet Hum Toxicol 1994b;36:56-59.
55. Endler PC, Pongratz W, Smith CW, Schulte J. Non-molecular information transfer from thyroxine to frogs with regard to homoeopathic toxicology. Vet Hum Toxicol 1995;37:259-260.
56. Endler PC, Schulte J (eds) 1994 Ultra High Dilution Physiology and Physics. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.
57. Escribano MJ. Letter Nature 1988;334:376.
58. European Community Homoeopathic Medicines Research Advisory Group #1. Overview of data from homoeopathic medicine trials. Preliminary report on the efficacy of homoeopathic intervention over nothing or a placebo. Draft 1.1 June 1996.
59. Ferley JP, Zmirou D, D'Adhemar D, Balducci F. A controlled evaluation of a homoeopathic preparation in the treatment of influenza-like syndromes. Br J Clin Pharmacol 1989;27:329-335.
60. Feyerabend PK 1975 Against Method: Outline of an Anarchistic theory of Knowledge. New Left Books, London.
61. Fierz W. Letter. Nature 1988;334:286.
62. Fisher P, House I, Belon P, Turner P. The influence of homeopathic remedy Plumbum metallicum on the excretion kinetics of lead in rats. Hum Toxicol 1987;6: 321-324.
63. Fisher P, Ward A. Complementary medicine in Europe. Br Med J 1994;309:107-111.
64. Freedman L. Bayesian statistical methods - a natural way to assess clinical evidence. Br Med J 1996;313:569-570.
65. Gagnon R. Letter. Lancet 1995;345:252.
66. Gilks WR, Clayton DG, Spiogelhalter DJ, Best NG, McNeil AJ, Sharples LD, Kirby AJ. Modelling complexity: Applications of Gibbs sampling in medicine (with discussion). J R Stat Soc Ser B 1993;5:39-102.
67. Glick JL. Letter Nature 1988;334:376.
68. Goldbeck-Wood S, Dorozynski A, Gunnar Lie L, Yamauchi M, Zinn C, Josefson D, Ingram M. Complementary medicine is booming world-wide. Br Med J 1996;313:131-133.
69. Hadji L, Amoux B, Benveniste J. Effect of dilute histamine on coronary flow of guinea-pig isolated heart. Inhibition by a magnetic field. FASEB J 1991;5:A1583.
70. Hill C, Doyon F. Review of randomised trials of homoeopathy. Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique 1990;38: 139-147.
71. Hirst SJ, Hayes NA, Burridge J, Pearce FL, Foreman JC. Human basophil degranulation is not triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE. Nature 1993;366:525-527.
72. Ho MW, Popp FA, Warnke V (eds) 1994 Bioelectrodynamics and Biocommunication. World Scientific Publishing Co., Singapore.
73. Howson C, Urbach P (eds) 1989 Scientific Reasoning: The Bayesian Approach. Open Court Publishing, La Salle, Illinois.
74. Jacobs J, Jiménez M, Gloyd S, Carares FE, Gaitan MP, Crothers D. Homoeopathic treatment of acute childhood diarrhea: A randomized clinical trial in Nicaragua. Br Homoeopathic J 1993;82:83-86.
75. Jacobs J, Jiménez M, Gloyd S, Gale JL, Crothers D. Treatment of acute childhood diarrhea with homeopathic medicine: A randomized clinical trial in Nicaragua. Pediatrics 1994;93(5):719-725.
76. Jones R, Jenkins M. Plant responses to homoeopathic remedies. Br Homoeopathic J 1981;70:120-128.
77. Jones R, Jenkins M. Comparison of wheat and yeast as in vitro models for investigating homoeopathic medicines. Br Homoeopathic J 1983;72:143-147.
78. Khanna KK, Chandra S. Control of tomato fruit rot caused by Fusarium roseum with homoeopathic drugs. Indian Phytopathol 1976a;29:269-272.
79. Khanna KK, Chandra S. Effect of some homoeopathic drugs on the spore germination of four isolates of Alternaria alternata. Indian Phytopathol 1976b;29:195-197.
80. Khanna KK, Chandra S. Control of guava fruit rot caused by Pestalotia psidii with homoeopathic drugs. Plant Dis Rep 1977a;61:362-366.
81. Khanna KK, Chandra S. Control of leaf blight of wheat caused by Alternaria alternata with homoeopathic drugs. Indian Phytopathol 1977b;30:320-322.
82. Khanna KK, Chandra S. A homoeopathic drug controls mango fruit rot caused by Pestalotia mangiferae Henn. Experentia 1978;34:1167-1168.
83. Khuda-Bukhsh AR, Banik S. Assessment of cytogenetic damage in X-irradiated mice and its alteration by oral administration of potentized homeopathic drug. Ginseng D200. Berlin J Res Homeopathy 1991;1(4/5):254-263.
84. Khuda-Bukhsh AR, Maity S. Alterations of cytogenetic effects by oral administration of a homoeopathic drug, Ruta graveolens, in mice exposed to sub-lethal X-irradiation. Berlin J Res Homeopathy 1991;1(4/5): 264-274.
85. Kishore J. Homoeopathy: The Indian experience. World Health Forum 1983;4:105-107.
86. Kleijnen J, Knipschild P, ter Riet G. Clinical trials of homoeopathy. Br Med J 1991;302:316-323.
87. Kolisko E, Kolisko L 1978 Agriculture of Tomorrow, 2nd edition. Kolisko Archive Publications, Bournemouth.
88. Kollerstrom J. Basic scientific research into the "low-dose effect." Br Homoeopathic J 1982;71(2):41-47.
89. Kuhn T 1970 The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
90. Kuhn T 1977 The Essential Tension: Selected Studies in Scientific Tradition and Change. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
91. Lakatos I 1970 Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. In Lakatos I, Musgrave A (eds) Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
92. Lapp C, Wurmser L, Ney J. Mobilisation de l'arsenic fixé chez le cobaye, sous l'action de doses infinitesimales d'arseniate sodium. Therapie 1955;10:625-638.
93. Lawren B. The case of the ghost molecules? OMNI 1992;(June):51-52, 73-74.
94. Lewith G, Brown PK, Tyrell DAJ. Controlled study of the effects of a homeopathic dilution of influenza vaccine on antibody titres in man. Comp Med Res 1989; 3:22-24.
95. Lilford RJ, Braunholtz D. The statistical basis of public policy: A paradigm shift is overdue. Br Med J 1996; 313:603-607.
96. Linde K, Jonas WB, Melchart D, Worku F, Wagner H, Eitel F. Critical review and meta-analysis of serially agitated dilutions in experimental toxicology. Hum Exp Toxicol 1994;13:481-492.
97. Linde K, Clausius N, Ramirez G, Melchart D, Eitel F, Hedges LV, Jonas W. Are the clinical effects on homoeopathy placebo effects? A meta-analysis of placebo-controlled trials. Lancet 1997;350:834-843.
98. Litime MH, Aissa J, Benveniste J. Antigen signaling at high dilution (abstract) FASEB J 1993;7:A602.
99. Lo S-Y. Anomalous state of ice. Modern Physics Letters 1996;B10:909-919.
100. E structures. Modern Physics Letters 1996;B10:921-930.
101. Maddox J. Waves caused by extreme dilution. Nature 1988a;335:760-763.
102. Maddox J. Letter. Science 1988b;241:1585-1586.
103. Maddox J, Randi J, Stewart WW. "High dilution" experiments a delusion. Nature 1988;334:287-290.
104. Matsumoto J. Molecular mechanism of biological responses to homoeopathic medicines. Medical Hypotheses 1995;45:292-296.
105. Mayaux MJ, Guihard-Moscato ML, Schwartz D, Benveniste J, Coquin Y, Crapanne JB, Poitevin B, Rodary M, Chevrel JP, Mollet M. Controlled clinical trial of homoeopathy in postoperative ileus. Lancet 1988;1: 528-529.
106. Metzger H, Dreskin SC. Letter. Nature 1988;334:375.
107. Ovelgonne JH, Bol AWJM, Hop WCJ, van Wijk R. Mechanical agitation of very dilute antiserum against IgE has no effect on basophil staining properties. Experentia 1992;48:504-508.
108. Pelikan W, Unger G. The activity of potentized substances. Experiments on plant growth and statistical evaluation. Br Homoeopathic J 1971;60:233-266.
109. Petit C, Belon P, Got R. Effect of homoeopathic dilutions on subcellular enzymatic activity. Hum Toxicol 1989; 8:125-129.
110. Pigani P. Jacques Benveniste: la "memoire de l'eau" 2. Psychologie 1997;January:60.
111. Pirotzky E, Hieblot C, Benveniste J, Laurent J, Lagrue G, Noirot C. Basophil sensitisation in idiopathic nephrotic syndrome. Lancet 1982;1:358-361.
112. Poitevin B, Aubin M, Benveniste J. Approach to a quantitative analysis of the effect of Apis mellifica on the in vitro human basophil degranulation. J Innov Tech Biol Med 1986;7:64-68.
113. Poitevin B, Davenas E, Benveniste J. In vitro immunological degranulation of human basophils is modulated by Lung histamine and Apis mellifica. Br J Clin Pharmacol 1988;25:439-444.
114. Pool R. More squabbling over unbelievable result. Science 1988;241:658.
115. Popp FA. Some elements of homoeopathy. Br Homoeopathic J 1990;79:161-166.
116. Popper KR 1959 The Logic of Scientific Discovery. Hutchinson and Co., London.
117. Reilly DT, Taylor MA. Potent placebo or potency? A proposed study model with initial findings using homoeopathically prepared pollens in hay fever. Br Homoeopathic J 1985;74:65-75.
118. Reilly DT, Taylor MA. Letter. Lancet 1995;345:252.
119. Reilly DT, Taylor MA, Beattie NGM, Campbell JH, McSharry C, Aitchison TC, Carter R, Stevenson RD. Is evidence for homoeopathy reproducible? Lancet 1994;344: 1601-1606.
120. Reilly DT, Taylor MA, McSharry C, Aitchison T. Is homoeopathy a placebo response? Controlled trial of homoeopathic potency, with pollen in hayfever as model. Lancet 1986;ii:881-886.
121. Rothwell PM. Letter. Lancet 1995;345:251.
122. Rubik B. Report on the status of research on homoeopathy with recommendations for future research. Br Homoeopathic J 1989;78:86-96.
123. Sainte-Laudy J, Sambucy JL, Belon P 1991 Biological activity of ultra low doses: Effect of Ultra low doses of histamine on human basophil degranulation triggered by D. Pteronyssinus extract. In Doutremepuich C (ed) Ultra Low Doses. Taylor & Francis, London, pp. 127-138.
124. Sainte-Laudy J, Belon P. Inhibition of human basophil activation by high dilutions of histamine. Agents Actions 1993;38:C245-C247.
125. Sampson W, London W. Analysis of homeopathic treatment of childhood diarrhea. Pediatrics 1995;96(5): 961-964.
126. Savage RH, Roe PF. A double blind trial to assess the benefit of Arnica montana in acute stroke illness. Br Homoeopathic J 1977;66:207-220.
127. Schiff M 1995 The Memory of Water. Thorsons, London.
128. Schofield AM. Experimental research in homoeopathy - A critical review. Br Homoeopathic J 1984a;73:161-180.
129. Schofield AM. Experimental research in homoeopathy - A critical review (conclusion). Br Homoeopathic J 1984b;73:211-226.
130. Seagrave JC. Letter. Nature 1988;334:559.
131. Senekowitsch F, Endler PC, Pongratz W, Smith CW. Hormone effects by CD record/replay (abstract). FASEB J 1995;9:A392.
132. Shakib F. Letter. Nature 1988;335:664.
133. Smith CW 1994 Electromagnetic and magnetic vector potential bio-information and water. In Endler PC, Schulte J (eds) Ultra High Dilution Physiology and Physics. Kluwer Academic Publications, Dordrecht, pp. 187-201.
134. Snell K. Letter. Nature 1988;334:559.
135. Stalker DF. Evidence and alternative medicine. Mt Sinai J Med. 1995;62(2):132-143.
136. Steffen W. Growth of yeast cultures as in vitro model for investigating homoeopathic medicines. Br Homoeopathic J 1984;73:198-210.
137. Sukul NC, Bala SK, Bhattacharyya B. Prolonged cataleptogenic effects of potentized homoeopathic drugs. Psychopharmacology 1986;89:338-339.
138. Sukul NC, Bhattacharyya B, Bala SK. Differentiation of potencies of Agaricus muscaris by experimental catalepsy. Br Homoeopathic J 1987;76(3):122-125.
139. Suslick K. Letter. Nature 1988;334:375-376.
140. Taylor MA. Results of the homoeopathic immunotherapy trial in perennial rhinitis. In Blackie Symposium notes, Blackie Symposium, London, December 1995.
141. Thomas Y, Schiff M, Litime MH, Belkadi L, Benveniste J. Direct transmission to cells of a molecular signal (phorbol myristate acetate, PMA) via an electronic device (abstract) FASEB J 1995;9:A227.
142. Tsong TY. Deciphering the language of cells. Trendes Biochem Sci 1989;14:89-92.
143. Vallance AK, Jobst KA. Letter. Lancet 1998;351:366.
144. Vandenbroucke JP. Homoeopathy trials: Going nowhere. Lancet 1997;350:824.
145. Weingartner O. NMR-Features that relate to homoeopathic sulphur potencies. Berlin J Res Homeopathy 1990;1:61-68.
146. Wharton R, Lewith G. Complementary medicine and the GP. Br Med J 1986;292:1498-1500.
147. Widakowich J. Facts and a postulate on the mode of action of potentiated remedies. Med Hypotheses 1996;47:15-17.
148. Williamson AV, Mackie WL, Crawford WJ, Rennie B. A study using Sepia 200c given prophylactically postpartum to prevent anoestrus problems in the dairy cow. Br Homoeopathic J 1991;80:149-156.
149. Yeung Laiwah ACY, Patel KR, Seenan AK, Galloway E, McCulloch W. Evaluation of the human basophil degranulation test using the commercially available Basokit as a test of immediate type hypersensitivity in hayfever suffers. Clin Allergy 1984;14:571-579.