Metazoan phylogenies: Falling into place or falling to pieces? A palaeontological perspective

Current Opinion in Genetics and Development

Volumn 8, Issue 6, 1998, Pages 662-667

  Morris, Simon Conway ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EMBRYO; METAZOON; MOLECULAR EVOLUTION; NONHUMAN; PHYLOGENY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW;

METAZOA;

EID: 0031737687     PISSN: 0959437X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0959-437X(98)80034-8     Document Type: Article

References (53)

1. Lanzavecchia G, Valvassori R, Candia Carnevali MD. Body Cavities: Function and Phylogeny, Collana UZI Select Symp Monogr. 8:1995;1-280.
2. Minelli A. Symposium on metamerism. Ital J Zool. 65:1998;1-84.
3. Ehlers U, Sopott-Ehlers B. Xenotuberbella bocki: organization and phylogenetic position as sistertaxon of the Bilateria. Verh Deutsch Zool Ges. 90:1997;168.
4. Noren M, Jondelius U. Xenoturbella's molluscan relatives. Nature. 390:1997;31-32.
5. Israelsson O. ... and molluscan embryogenesis. Nature. 390:1997;32.
6. Funch P, Kristensen RM. Cycliophora is a new phylum with afinities to Entoprocta and Ectoprocta. Nature. 378:1995;711-714.
7. Conway Morris S. A new phylum from the lobster's lips. Nature. 378:1995;661-662.
8. Winnepenninckx BMH, Backeljau T, Kristensen RM. Relations of the new phylum Cycliphora. Nature. 393:1998;636-637.
9. Halanych KM, Bacheller JD, Aguinaldo AMA, Liva SM, Hillis DM, Lake JA. Evidence from 18S ribosomal DNA that the lophophorates are protostome animals. Science. 267:1995;1641-1643.
10. Cohen BL, Stark S, Gawthrop AB, Burke ME, Thayer CW. Comparison of articulate brachiopod nuclear and mitochondrial gene trees leads to a clade-based redefinition of protostomes (Protostomozoa) and deuterostomes (Deuterostomozoa). Proc R Soc Lond. 265:1998;475-482.
11. Lüter C, Bartolomaeus T. The phylogenetic position of Brachiopoda - a comparison of morphological and molecular data. of special interest Zool Scripta. 26:1997;245-253 Deserves a sympathetic reading as whole-organism zoologists grapple with the revolutionary insights from molecular data.
12. Aguinaldo AMA, Turbeville JM, Linford LS, Rivera MC, Garey JR, Raff RA, Lake JA. Evidence for a clade of nematodes, arthropods and other moulting animals. Nature. 387:1997;489-492.
13. Dzik J, Krumbiegel G. The oldest 'onychophoran' Xenusion: a link connecting phyla? Lethaia. 22:1989;169-182.
14. Wills MA. Cambrian and recent disparity: the picture from priapulids. of special interest Paleobiology. 24:1998;177-199 A brave attempt to grapple with the elusive concept of disparity via the medium of a data matrix of characters states. Perhaps there is a totality of morphospace that can be so pinned-down, if not described, but questions remain: is a minor character, for example "looped gut", really to be taken seriously? And what of convergence, or redundancy of data whereby two or more characters march step-in-step?
15. Conway Morris S. The culticular structure of the 495-Myr-old type species of the fossil worm Palaeoscolex, P. piscatorum (?Priapulida). Zool J Linn Soc. 119:1997;69-82.
16. Budd GE. Stem group arthropods from the Lower Cambrian Sirius Passet fauna of North Greenland. Fortey RA, Thomas RH. Arthropod Relationships. 55:1997;125-138 Chapman & Hall, London. Syst Ass Spec Vol.
17. Narbonne GM, Saylor BZ, Grotzinger JP. The youngest Ediacaran fossils from southern Africa. J Paleont. 71:1997;953-967.
18. Seilacher A. Vendobionta and Psammocorallia: lost constructions of Precambrian evolution. J Geol Soc Lond. 149:1992;607-613.
19. Gehling JG, Rigby JK. Long expected sponges from the Neoproterozoic Ediacara fauna of South Australia. J Paleontol. 70:1996;185-195.
20. Fedonkin MA, Waggoner BM. The late Precambrian Kimberella is a mollusc-like bilaterian organism. of special interest Nature. 388:1997;869-871 A radical reinterpretation, because until now Kimberella had been interpreted as a cubozoan onidarian, represented today by the fearsome box-jellies. Now the animal is interpreted as a sort of naked slug, with crawling foot and a curiously crenulated margin. It is a little odd, perhaps, that the crawling activities of Kimberella are not recorded as trace fossils. Any surface trails it did make would have a very small chance of being preserved, or alternatively Kimberella may have glided over cohesive sediment leaving little trace of its passage.
21. Conway Morris S, Peel JS. Articulated halkieriids from the Lower Cambrian of North Greenland and their role in early protostome evolution. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B. 347:1995;305-358.
22. Lacalli TC. The nature and origin of deuterostomes: some unresolved issues. Invert Biol. 116:1997;363-370.
23. Boore JL, Lavrov DV, Brown WM. Gene translocation links insects and crustaceans. Nature. 392:1998;667-668.
24. Conway Morris S. The evolution of diversity in ancient ecosystems: a review. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B. 353:1998;327-345.
25. Cooper A, Fortey R. Evolutionary explosions and the phylogenetic fuse. Trends Ecol Evol. 13:1998;151-156.
26. Conway Morris S. The Crucible of Creation: the Burgess Shale and the Rise of Animals. 1998;Oxford University Press, Oxford.
27. Wray GA, Levinton JS, Shapiro LH. Molecular evidence for deep Pre-Cambrian divergences among metazoan phyla. Science. 274:1996;568-573.
28. Fortey RA, Briggs DEG, Wills MA. The Cambrian 'explosion' recalibrated. of special interest Bioessays. 19:1997;429-434 A paper worth looking at - but for all the wrong reasons. Special pleading, an elastic concept of the meiofauna, and a credulous attitude to molecular clocks undermine confidence in the conclusions drawn.
29. Conway Morris S. Early metazoan evolution: reconciling paleontology and molecular biology. Amer Zool. 1998;. in press.
30. Walossek D, Müller KJ. Cambrian 'Orsten'-type arthropods and the phylogeny of Crustacea. Fortey RA, Thomas RH. Arthropod relationships. 55:1997;139-153 Chapman & Hall, London. Syst Ass Spec Vol.
31. Balavoine G, Doutte A. One or three Cambrian radiations? Science. 280:1998;397-398.
32. Turner PN. Rotifer look-alikes: two species of Colurella are ciliated protozoans. Invert Biol. 114:1995;202-204.
33. Peterson KJ, Cameron RA, Davidson EH. Set-aside cells in a maximal indirect development: evolutionary and developmental significance. of special interest Bioessays. 19:1997;623-631 A paper which has attracted wide attention. The focus of the argument is on the so-called 'set-aside' cells that can be identified in many ciliated larvae, and from which the adult emerges as a result of a catastrophic metamorphosis and during which time the remainder of the larva is either consumed or discarded. The authors argue that it was the 'invention' of these 'set-aside' cells that ushered in the prospect of large adult animals, an event which is recorded as the Cambrian 'explosion'. There are, however, some difficulties. In particular, it presupposes the planktrophic larval type to be primitive, which is now contested[34,35], rather than being rampantly polyphyletic and convergent [29].
34. Haszprunar G, Salvini-Plawen LV, Rieger RM. Larval planktotrophy - a primitive trait in the Bilateria? Acta Zool (Stockh). 76:1995;141-154.
35. McHugh D, Rouse GW. Life history evolution of marine invertebrates: new views from phylogenetic systematics. Trends Ecol Evol. 13:1998;182-186.
36. Bengtson S, Yue Z. Fossilized metazoan embryos from the earliest Cambrian. of special interest Science. 277:1997;1645-1648 An important paper that reveals an entirely unexpected set of insights into ancient life. In one case, an effectively complete ontogeny from pre-hatched embryos to adult cnidarian can be traced. In the other, the embryo is probably protostomian and conceivably represents an halkieriid [37]. It is a pity that some of the wider implications of these discoveries [29,37] were not addressed in this initial announcement. In particular the documentation of direct development hints that the planktotrophic stage seen in many metazoans is not a primitive condition.
37. Conway Morris S. Eggs and embryos from the Cambrian. Bioessays. 20:1998;676-682.
38. Xiao S, Zhang Y, Knoll AH. Three-dimensional preservation of algae and animal embryos in a Neoproterozoic phosphorite. of special interest Nature. 391:1998;553-558 Although greeted with great excitement, it is important to note that the cleavage patterns of these embryos are rather unusual, at least in comparison with most known metazoans. Also puzzling, and perhaps to be remedied by further collecting, is the absence of embryos beyond the 16 cell stage. Are these embryos really metazoan? Even if they are, it must be remembered that the age of these fossils is Ediacaran (Figure 2), from which geological interval animals are already documented.
39. Li C-W, Chan J-Y, Hua T-E. Precambrian sponges with cellular structures. Science. 279:1998;879-882.
40. Li WH. So, what about the molecular clock hypothesis. Curr Opin Genet Dev. 3:1993;896-901.
41. Ayala FJ. Vagaries of the molecular clock. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 94:1997;7776-7783.
42. Ayala FJ, Rzhetsky A, Ayala FJ. Origin of the metazoan phyla: molecular clocks confirm paleontological estimates. of special interest Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 95:1998;606-611 A highly effective demolition of the molecular clock hypothesis so far as it pertains to a divergence time for major groups of metazoans substantially before the known fossil record [25,27].
43. Kumar S, Hedges SB. A molecular timescale for vertebrate evolution. Nature. 392:1998;917-920.
44. of outstanding interest Cooper A, Penny D. Mass survival of birds across the Cretaceous Tertiary boundary: molecular evidence. of special interest Science. 275:1997;1109-1113 One couldn't ask for a clearer exposition of molecular-clock thinking in action. This paper resolutely turns its back on variations in substitution rates, especially during episodes of morphological divergence (and see [46]). The discrepancy with the fossil record is marked, the authors arguing that palaeontologists should now be on the look-out for a host of Cretaceous mammals, including rabbits, primates and aardvarks.
45. Bleiweiss R. Fossil gap analysis supports early Tertiary origin of trophically diverse avian orders. of special interest Geology. 26:1998;323-326 Having read [44], now turn to this paper. The conflict between the palaeon-tological data analyzed here and the strident claims made on behalf of the reliability of molecular clocks is out in the open.
46. Omland KE. Correlated rates of molecular and morphological evolution. of outstanding interest Evolution. 51:1997;1381-1393 A paper that questions some hallowed assumptions and, an importantly, argues that the micro-evolutionary neodarwinian framework is a potent way of bringing together population bottlenecks, founder effects and adaptive radiations in the context of accelerated substitution rates.
47. Clack JA. A new Early Carboniferous tetrapod with a mélange of crown-group characters. of special interest Nature. 394:1998;66-69 The latest epistle in a series of key papers showing the insights that the fossil record is now revealing into the assembly of vertebrate bodyplans. To be read in conjunction with [48].
48. Shubin N. Evolutionary cut and paste. of special interest Nature. 394:1998;12-13 A wonderfully succinct and hard-hitting commentary on [47], that economically poses some very uncomfortable questions to those wedded to the cladistic orthodoxy.
49. Grenier JK, Garber TL, Warren R, Whitington PM, Carroll S. Evolution of the entire arthropod Hox gene set predated the origin and radiation of the onychophoran/arthropod clade. of special interest Curr Biol. 7:1997;547-553 An important paper, showing that complex genetic architecture can be in place well before morphological divergence; but, in the end, will the Hox clusters be as informative about bodyplan construction as is presently thought [50]?
50. Averof M. Arthropod evolution: same Hox genes, different body plans. Curr Biol. 7:1997;R634-R636.
51. Lowe CJ, Wray GA. Radical alterations in the roles of homeobox genes during echinoderm evolution. of special interest Nature. 389:1997;718-721 The echinoderms, in terms of metazoan evolution much modified and highly derived from the ancestral state, have a set of peculiar bodyplans, and how it appears that classic regulatory genes such as distal-less and engrailed have been redeployed and recruited in all sorts of surprising ways.
52. Wu LH, Lengyel JA. Role of caudal in hindgut specification and gastrulation suggest homology between Drosophila aminoproctodeal invagination and vertebrate blastopore. Development. 125:1998;2433-2442.
53. Seilacher A, Bose PK, Pflüger F. Triploblastic animals more than 1 billion years ago: trace fossil evidence from India. Science. 282:1998;80-83.