Faculty evaluation in Departments of Family Medicine: Do our universities measure up?

Medical Education

Volumn 32, Issue 6, 1998, Pages 597-606

  Green, Michael E ^a   Ellis, Connie L ^b   Frémont, Pierre ^c   Batty, Helen ^d  

^a QUEEN S UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY   (Canada)

^c LAVAL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^d UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

Author keywords

Canada; Clinical competence; Evaluation studies; Faculty medicine, standards; Family practice, education; Medline

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CANADA; COMPETENCE; EVALUATION AND FOLLOW UP; FAMILY MEDICINE; MEDICAL EDUCATION; PEER REVIEW; QUALITY CONTROL; TEACHING; UNIVERSITY; VIDEORECORDING;

CANADA; CLINICAL COMPETENCE; EDUCATIONAL MEASUREMENT; EVALUATION STUDIES; FACULTY, MEDICAL; FAMILY PRACTICE;

EID: 0031735220     PISSN: 03080110     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1046/j.1365-2923.1998.00242.x     Document Type: Article

References (56)

1. Albanese M A, Schuldt S S, Case D E & Brown D (1991) The validity of lecturer ratings by students and trained observers. Academic Medicine 66, 26-8.
2. Bardes C L & Hayes J G (1995) Are the teachers teaching? Measuring the educational activities of clinical faculty. Academic Medicine 70, 111-4.
3. Brickely M R, Prytherch I M, Kay E J & Shepard J P (1995) A new method of assessment of clinical teaching: ROC analysis. Medical Education 29, 150-3.
4. Buchanan R et al. (1974) Preliminary Report of the Faculty Professional Growth Committee. ERIC Document 116 738, St Louis Junior College District.
5. Carey R M, Wheby M S & Reynolds R E (1993) Evaluating faculty clinical excellence in the academic health sciences center. Academic Medicine 68, 813-7.
6. Cashin W E (1983) Concerns about using student ratings in community colleges. New Directions for Community Colleges 11, 57-65.
7. Cohen A (1974) Evaluation of faculty. Community College Review 2, 12-21.
8. Colyle B A (1994) Faculty evaluation in the scholarly domain: conceptions for academic planning. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Theraputics 17, 398-403.
9. DeWitt T G, Goldberg R L & Roberts K B (1993) Developing community faculty. American Journal of the Disabled Child 147, 49-53.
10. Donnelly M B & Woolliscroft J O (1989) Evaluation of clinical instructors by third-year medical students. Academic Medicine 64, 159-64.
11. Fallon S M, Croen L G & Shelov S P (1987) Teachers' and students' ratings of clinical teaching and teachers' opinions on use of student evaluations. Journal of Medical Education 62, 435-8.
12. Gjerde C L & Coble R J (1982) Resident and faculty perceptions of effective clinical teaching in family practice. Journal of Family Practice 14, 323-7.
13. Guyatt G H, Nishikawa J, Willan A, McIlra W, Cook D, Gibson J, Kerrigan A & Neville A (1993) A measurement process for evaluating clinical teachers in internal medicine. Canadian Medical Association Journal 149, 1097-102.
14. Hartman S L & Nelson M S (1992) What we say and what we do: self-reported teaching behavior versus performances in written simulations among medical school faculty. Academic Medicine 67, 522-7.
15. Hitchcock M A, Lamkin B D, Mygdal W K, Clarke C & O'Connor-Clarke S (1986) Affective changes in faculty development fellows in family medicine. Journal of Medical Education 61, 394-403.
16. Hitchcock M A, Stritter F T & Bland C J (1993) Faculty development in the health professions: conclusions and recommendations. Medical Teacher 14, 295-309.
17. Holloway R L, Bland C J, Schmitz C G & Withington AM (1988) An advanced research seminar series for family medicine faculty members. Family Medicine 20, 338-42.
18. Hulsmeyer B S & Bowling A K (1986) Evaluating colleagues' classroom teaching effectiveness. Nurse Educator 11, 19-23.
19. Irby D M & Rakestraw P (1981) Evaluating clinical teaching in medicine. Journal of Medical Education 56, 181-6.
20. Irby D M, Gillmore G M & Ramsey P G (1987) Factors affecting rating of clinical teachers by medical students and residents. Journal of Medical Education 62, 1-7.
21. Irby D M (1978) Clinical teacher effectiveness in medicine. Journal of Medical Education 53, 808-15.
22. Irby D M (1983a) Evaluating instruction in medical education. Journal of Medical Education 58, 844-9.
23. Irby D M (1983b) Peer review of teaching in medicine. Journal of Medical Education 58, 457-61.
24. Jackson M & MacInnes I (1984) Promotion and tenure in family practice in US medical schools. Journals of Family Practice 18, 435-9.
25. Jacobs M B (1993) Faculty status for clinician-educators: guidelines for evaluation and promotion. Academic Medicine 68, 126-8.
26. Jeffers J M & Guthrie D W (1988) Self assessment via videotaping to maximize teaching effectiveness. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing 19, 223-6.
27. Jones R F & Froom J D (1994) Faculty and administration views of problems in faculty evaluation. Academic Medicine 69, 476-83.
28. Keig L & Waggoner M D (1995) Collaborative Peer Review: the Role of Faculty in Improving College Teaching. ERIC Document 378 924.
29. Lancaster C J, Ross G R & Smith I K (1988) Survey of practices in evaluating teaching in U.S. medical schools, 1978 and 1986. Journal of Medical Education 63, 912-4.
30. Lewis B S & Pace W D (1990) Qualitative and quantitative methods for the assessment of clinical preceptors. Family Medicine 22, 356-60.
31. Lindemann J C, Beecher A C, Morzinski J A & Simpson D E (1995) Translating family medicine's educational expertise into academic success. Family Medicine 27, 306-9.
32. Magill M K, McClure C & Commerford K (1986) A system for evaluating teaching in the ambulatory setting. Family Medicine 18, 173-4.
33. Martin J A & Carey R M (1990) The student-initiated, faculty-assisted system of evaluation of clinical teaching at the university of Virginia. Academic Medicine 66, 773-5.
34. McAvoy P A & Fraser R C (1990) Teaching the teachers at Leicester: the general practice approach. Medical Teacher 12, 33-9.
35. McGaghie W C, Frey J J, Stritter F T & Shahady E (1981) A multi-component program to increase family physicians' faculty skills. Journal of Medical Education 56, 803-11.
36. McHugh P R (1994) A "letter of experience" about faculty promotion in medical schools. Academic Medicine 69, 877-81.
37. Metcalfe D H & Matharu M (1995) Students' perception of good and bad teaching: report of a critical incident study. Medical Education 29, 193-7.
38. Neal J E (1988) Faculty Evaluation: Its Purposes and Effectiveness. ERIC Document 308 800 ERIC Digest, School of Education, George Washington University.
39. Rainey M A, Hekelman F P, Galazka S S & Kolb D A (1993) The executive skills profile: a method for assessing development needs among family medicine faculty. Family Medicine 25, 100-3.
40. Ramsbottom-Lucier M T, Gillmore G M, Irby D M & Ramsey P G (1994) Evaluation of clinical teaching by general internal medicine faculty in outpatient and inpatient settings. Academic Medicine 69, 152-4.
41. Ramsey P G, Gillmore G M & Irby D M (1988) Evaluating clinical teaching in the medicine clerkship: relationship of instructor experience and training setting to ratings of teaching effectiveness. Journal of General Internal Medicine 3, 351-5.
42. Rifkin T (1995) The Status and Scope of Faculty Evaluation. ERIC Document 385 315 ERIC Digest, School of Education, George Washington University.
43. Rosendaal G M A (1995) Implementing an evaluation system for clinical teaching. Medical Teacher 17, 315-20.
44. Rost K, Gordon G H and the SGIM Task Force on the Medical Interview (1989) The teacher simulation exercise: changes in physician teaching emphasis and strategy. Journal of General Internal Medicine 4, 121-6.
45. Rothman A I, Poldre P & Cohen R (1989) Evaluating clincal teachers for promotion. Academic Medicine 64, 774-5.
46. Schofield T P C & Hasler J (1984a) Approval of trainers and training practices in the Oxford region: criteria. British Medical Journal 288, 538-40.
47. Schofield T P C & Hasler J (1984b) Approval of trainers and training practices in the Oxford region: assessment. British Medical Journal 288, 612-4.
48. Schofield T P C & Hasler J (1984c) Approval of trainers and training practices in the Oxford region: evaluation. British Medical Journal 288, 688-9.
49. Skeff K M (1983) Evaluation of a method for improving the teaching performance of attending physicians. American Journal of Medicine 75, 465-70.
50. Squires B P (1993) Evaluating Clinical Teachers. Canadian Medical Association Journal 149, 1085.
51. Steinert Y (1993) Faculty development in Family medicine: a reassessment. Canadian Family Physician 39, 1917-22.
52. Stritter F T & Baker R M (1982) Resident preferences for the clinical teaching of ambulatory care. Journal of Medical Education 57, 33-41.
53. Stuart M R, Orzano A J & Eidus R (1980) Preceptor development in residency training through a faculty facilitator. Journal of Family Practice 11, 591-5.
54. Ward-Griffen C W & Brown B (1992) Evaluation of teaching: a review of the literature. Journal of Advanced Nursing; 17, 1408-14.
55. Wilkerson L, Armstrong E & Lesky L (1990) Faculty development for ambulatory teaching. Journal of General Internal Medicine 5(Suppl.), s44-s53.
56. Winter M G & Kestner S G (1990) Peer evaluation of teaching effectiveness. Journal of Dentist Education 54, 626-9.